Update 2-5 Got Grades

tydye

Had pretty good luck in the past but this is my first submission in a while. Just wanted to run it past some board members in case you see something obvious that I missed. Thanks

2-5 Update. I ended up just submitting 16 of the 19 due to your suggestions. And 16/16 graded. I sent out 4 subs and have been getting them back in record speed due to the new shipping policy. Only bone I have with PCGS is on my indians. They need to establish a middle ground with respect to coins with some color. Seems like they went from far left to far right when it comes to color. I am quite sure they are original and not someone's experiment. Disappointed with my 2 silver washington quarters ( I thought 65s easy) The 2007 dime was graded becasue of die cracks that pretty much break it half. The Barber dime is heavily clashed. I owe my wife money on the large cent. It was the only one I thought would bag. Color looked off to me but my wife disagreed.

Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 15083719 6929 1843 $1 US XF45
2 1 15083720 6934 1847 $1 US XF45
3 1 15083721 6936 1849 $1 US XF40
Total Items: 3
Date Received: 1/8/2010
Date Shipped: N/A
Order Status: Shipped

Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 15060655 1908 1855 1C Upright 55 US MS63RB
2 1 15060656 2187 1894 1C US AU58BN
3 1 15060657 92187 1894/1894 1C US G06BN
4 1 15060658 2208 1901 1C US Genuine (91 - Questionable Color)
5 1 15060659 2217 1904 1C US Genuine (91 - Questionable Color)
6 1 15060660 2223 1906 1C US MS62BN
7 1 15060661 2229 1908 1C US Genuine (91 - Questionable Color)
8 1 15060662 4332 1843 H10C US AU50
9 1 15060663 4363 1856 H10C US XF40
10 1 15060664 4369 1858-O H10C US VF30
11 1 15060665 4379 1861 H10C US VF35
12 1 15060666 3985 1938-D/S 5C Buffalo US MS65
13 1 15060667 5844 1950-S 25C US MS64
14 1 15060668 5854 1953-S 25C US MS64
15 1 15060669 6100 1812 50C US XF45
16 1 15060670 6105 1814 50C US VF30
17 1 15060671 6113 1818 50C US VF25
17 2 15060672 6113 1818 50C US VF35
17 3 15060673 6113 1818 50C US VF35
18 1 15060674 6115 1818/7 50C Large 8 US F15
19 1 15060675 6119 1819/8 50C Large 9 US XF40
20 1 15060676 6126 1820/19 50C Curl Base 2 US F15
21 1 15060677 6128 1821 50C US VF25
22 1 15060678 6131 1823 50C US VF30
23 1 15060679 6138 1824 50C Over Various Dates US VF25
24 1 15060680 6143 1826 50C US XF40
25 1 15060681 6144 1827 50C Square Base 2 US XF40
26 1 15060682 6154 1829 50C US VF30
27 1 15060683 6160 1832 50C Small Letters US XF40
28 1 15060684 6163 1833 50C US XF45
29 1 15060685 7092 1879-S $1 US MS65
30 1 15060686 149521 2007-P 10C US MS66FB
31 1 15060687 5886 1970-D 25C US MS67
32 1 15060688 4796 1892 10C US AU55
33 1 15060689 3758 1889 3CN US XF40
Total Items: 35
Date Received: 1/8/2010
Date Shipped: N/A
Order Status: OK

Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 15083718 32074 1890-H 50C CANADA VF20
Total Items: 1
Date Received: 1/8/2010
Date Shipped: N/A
Order Status: Shipped


Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 15063335 416156 1817-FD Peso CHILE VF30
2 1 15063336 416157 1817-L 5 L ITL-SAR VF35
3 1 15063337 90342 1903 50C U.S. PHIL XF45
4 1 15063338 416158 1847-Mo RC 2 R MEXICO XF45
5 1 15063339 140601 1959 Crown BERMUDA MS67
6 1 15063340 552386 1838-C MS 8 R S. PERU XF40
Total Items: 6
Date Received: 1/8/2010
Date Shipped: N/A
Order Status: Shipped

SilverEagles92

I think the 1819 in the upper right corner might get bagged for cleaning.

Looks like a stunning group, though.

astrorat

Very nice selection. They should all do fine. The only ones, if I was forced to find coins that may have issues, would be the fourth coin from the left in row 2 (1832) and the third coin from the left in the fourth row (1829). The reverses look similar to a few that I have seen marked as "altered surfaces."

Nice coins ... you have a good eye for quality circulated pieces.

Lane

lava

I have seen worse get slabbed by PCGS, so I'll guess they all get slabbed.

You could always avoid the risk and sell them to a forum member.

tydye

I did dip 2 in acetone to remove some green pvc (the 19 and 32). I am 50/50 on the 19 as well but like the coin and need the overton. The coin is actually much darker than the photo shows but it was directly under the light. I agree on the 29 (looks like secondary toning - but no cleaning marks underneath). The 32 is actually on of my favorites of the bunch.

MikeInFL

I have concerns with the '12, '19, and '33 (and perhaps the '18). The rest look good to my eye.

mkman123

thats a stunning group!! Too bad those will be slabbed............a set like that would look great in 2x2s!!

sparky64

What an outstanding batch.
I can't offer an opinion on submitting but couldn't help comment on how good they look all together like that.
Good luck!

DoubleEagle59

looks good to me.

I predict 18 with grade.

One will somehow find its way into the 'genuine' slab.

DUIGUY

Dang Dude!

tydye

Thanks for the replys/advice. I added some better (hopefully anyway) of the ones pointed out as potential problems. I am leaning towards dropping three of them (hey grading fees aren't cheap) Maybe shoot for a sweet 16

kaz

Man, that is a nice looking group! I don't have anything to add otherwise, except to say that I like them better out of plastic, but good luck with the submission and I hope you will post the outcome as an addendum to this thread.

messydesk

They'll "genuine" one of them just to put you in your place. I'm going to guess the 1814 in the top row. NIce group of busties, though.

joebb21

1819 looks cleaned-

tightbudget

I once submitted an 1811 half that looked a lot like that 1814 and it got bagged by NGC. In an ideal situation, I'd say all of them should be graded, but my gut feeling tells me maybe one or two might end up in genuine holders.

lkeigwin

Are those the only pix you have? Any more? <jk>

Very nice. I hope you hit a home run. I do like the '32...it'll grade nicely, I bet.

Good luck! Tell us how it works out (LOL...like you wouldn't?).
Lance.

jdillane

Nice group! Tough to tell from images but I am skeptical the 1812 or the 1814 will grade @ PCGS.

pocketpiececommems

You can take very good pics

crypto79

<< <i>They'll "genuine" one of them just to put you in your place. I'm going to guess the 1814 in the top row. NIce group of busties, though. >>



100% with him on this one, A nice group no matter what PCGS says but I just can't see them all coming back with grades no matter what they look like.

tydye

grades in

SeaEagleCoins

Other than the few QC cents... I'd say you did real good... Congrats, my friend

tydye

The 3 QC really irk me. I paid for an opinion and I basically got a "I dont know"

stinkinlincoln

Great looking halfs!