Attractive or Unattractive - ASE?

OneCent

BeeMan

I have one that is currently in a Taco Bell napkin that looks similar to that one. It is a little darker.

kryptonitecomics

I voted neautral....not a dog but not a show stopper...I would say about average....maybe a touch above average since there is almost full coverage and these can get spotty at times.

Flatwoods

I agree with Shane. Not bad but not breathtaking either.
I'd leave it as is. After all you can get a white one anywhere.

Tootawl

Dip the SAE.
Notice I said SAE and not ASE!

rainbowroosie

Ugly

boucharda

This one was just left on my file cabinet (reverse is unchanged)

ambro51

Grandmas 100 year old silver hasnt toned that much.
Amazing how a six month old bullion coin can.

I vote (hmmm whats the kitco price on silver these days?).....no vote.

bfjohnson

Boucharda,
Not a fan of toning on coins but that looks nice. Anything out of ordinary going on where the coin was left?

CEOGBOSE

I don't find this one very attractive.

TommyB

also left in a cabinet for a few years.

boucharda

<< <i>Boucharda,
Not a fan of toning on coins but that looks nice. Anything out of ordinary going on where the coin was left? >>




Nothing.....Just a computer room

ProofCents

Dip it.

Halfhunter06

its alright, not too great, not horrible

Bossman88

I'm not a fan of toned Silver Eagles, sorry
New silver gotta be white and bright

Regards, Larry

DenverDave

I vote Natural and more interesting then a blast white example for sure...

It would be interesting to hear HRH's views on toned ASE's...

Same as the Peace Dollar Thread...?

al410

DenverDave >I do not normally care much for Toned eagles but the one in your reply is STUNNING!
al

ricko

Obviously requires dipping.. as do all the others. ASE's were meant to be bright, beautiful silver coins. Not tarnished, dirty, degenerated tokens. Cheers, RickO

drwstr123

Ms68:

pakasmom

The '86 in the post above is attractive to me. Looks like a slower natural progression.
The OP's coin doesn't appeal to me.

Gemineye

Save it for the upcoming Silver melt...!!!

DenverDave

Thanks Al, Ricko your killing me...

I found this one in the original goverment packaging, black cardboard with a plastic sleve...

I'll have to take better photos one day...

TomB

You left out "Negative, but do not dip".

telephoto1

<< <i>Thanks Al, Ricko your killing me...

I found this one in the original goverment packaging, black cardboard with a plastic sleve...

I'll have to take better photos one day...

>>



There is no "original packaging" for individual Unc ASEs; they came in a tube of 20. In 1987 there were 2 different tubes...clear with orange end caps (early '87), or the familiar white with green Treasury cap. That cardboard/plastic deal was/is an aftermarket holder of some sort.