Can you guess the grade, Punk??? Pictures added, grades revealed, comments sought.

Well, can you, Punk?? Go ahead and make my day......................
Al H.
edit-----to add an additional picture for #2.












Al H.
edit-----to add an additional picture for #2.













0
Comments
MS63
PR63
AT
MS64
And, who ya callin' a punk??
PR63BN
PR64CAM
MS65
MS64
1870...ms63
1951 Frankie PR..66cam
SLQ..EF
Pilgrim Half..ms65
OK Al....kill me Now.....!!!!
edit...!!!
BTW, just to be sure, all the coins are encapsulated in major TPG holders and i'll post the encapsulated pictures for validation after more failed attempts at proving how well you can grade from, ah, skip it. i'm starting to sound like an old record that's got the needle stuck in a groove. hell, this is the age of the CD...........................
Yet none of the pieces would grade XF45 IMO.
I counted the bullets
#2 MS64
#3 PR63
#4 MS64
#5 MS63
Who you callin punk, Shirley?
64
65CAM
AT
66
.......................but still, no correct guesses by anyone on any of the coins(edits excluded).
<< <i>Your quote brings to mind a .45. >>
Thought it was a .44.
1883$ MS64
1870 Half MS65
1951 Half PR63CAM
SLQ - MS66
Pilgrim - MS67
You made my day, pardner.
I knew it would happen.
j935(?) pf64
Frank pf64 SLQ ms64
Pilgrim ms66
That pattern....
2. ditto
3. ditto
4. ditto
5. ditto
The SLQ is my fav.
Many members on this forum that now it cannot fit in my signature. Please ask for entire list.
A
A
A+
B
--Jerry
Proof 63
Proof 65
MS 63
MS 65
Garrow
guess a grade even close when looking at pics like that.
so why even bother.
<< <i>calling those pics "high quality" is laughable. of course one cannot
guess a grade even close when looking at pics like that.
so why even bother. >>
Matt, you may forward an apology to Mark Goodman at your earliest convenience.
<< <i>calling those pics "high quality" is laughable
Matt, you may forward an apology to Mark Goodman at your earliest convenience.
If Dr. Goodman all took those photos, I will print them out and eat them.
the 1883-s I thought was ms63
and the SLQ I thought was au58.
"“Those who sacrifice liberty for security/safety deserve neither.“(Benjamin Franklin)
"I only golf on days that end in 'Y'" (DE59)
https://www.smallcopperguy.com
i always felt that the coin was better than MS62 and assumed that PCGS was harsh due to the overall appearance of the tone. i felt that coin had spent time in an envelope and then in a folder or other type holder which resulted in the color's splotchiness. it is actually rather pleasing and the luster is very, very good. with many forum members seeing AU58/MS62 grades as cousins, i always wondered why this particular coin was in the MS62 holder when it clearly seemed to have the quality of a 63/64.