Options
Is there anything wrong with selling an AT coin....
gecko109
Posts: 8,231 ✭
that you know to be AT because you conducted an AT experiment? As long as you clearly state that said coin is definitively artificially toned, because you did the toning yourself, is there some moral or legal obligation to NOT sell such a coin?
0
Comments
-Paul
<< <i>is there some moral or legal obligation to NOT sell such a coin? >>
I would definitely consult with a clergyman and an attorney before selling it.
<< <i>
<< <i>is there some moral or legal obligation to NOT sell such a coin? >>
I would definitely consult with a clergyman and an attorney before selling it. >>
I see you are making light of my question. Although there is a legal obligation to not sell a known counterfeit coin, I suppose as long as hobo nickels are sold for profit, perhaps intentionally altered coins of color are acceptable as well. Now lets focus on the moral aspect of this question.
bob
<< <i>As long as you state it is AT. However, will next next person down the line chose the path of honesty? >>
And this is EXACTLY why I asked this question.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>Should you sell a raw coin? The next person down the line may overgrade it. Same logic. >>
Perry, by that logic, is it ok then to sell a GREAT counterfeit $5 indian as long as you state it is counterfeit? Now we are wading into deeper legal/moral waters.
<< <i>
<< <i>Should you sell a raw coin? The next person down the line may overgrade it. Same logic. >>
Perry, by that logic, is it ok then to sell a GREAT counterfeit $5 indian as long as you state it is counterfeit? Now we are wading into deeper legal/moral waters. >>
Bad analogy. Counterfeit coins are illegal to own while AT coins are quite legal to own.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
But I will also add that I do not hold cleaners or doctors of coins in very high regard. JMO
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Should you sell a raw coin? The next person down the line may overgrade it. Same logic. >>
Perry, by that logic, is it ok then to sell a GREAT counterfeit $5 indian as long as you state it is counterfeit? Now we are wading into deeper legal/moral waters. >>
Bad analogy. Counterfeit coins are illegal to own while AT coins are quite legal to own. >>
Ok Perry, then try this one on for size. Take a Chinese replica bust dollar with the word copy stamped into it. Wear the coin down to a pleasing G6, just enough to obliterate any evidence of the "copy" stamp, and then sell it on ebay, and list it as a replica piece. How do you feel now?
<< <i>If a person conducts an AT experiment, I would like to think it is for an educational purpose. I am not certain what is achieved by selling the coin. Better it is donated for an educational purpose, (Mr, Brunners' new class comes to mind), where it will do much good and not risk questioning the intent of the original experimenter with thoughts of less than honorable reasons for the experiment. JMHO. Respectfully, John Curlis >>
Could an AT experiment that produced a beatiful piece of artwork on a coin be likened in any way to the carving of a buffalo nickel into a hobo nickel?
rainbowroosie April 1, 2003
Not at all. I have 3 Dansco's filled with ASE's, they are toning, that is the goal.
20 years from now I will sell them. They naturally toned in a Dansco for 20 plus years.
My intent is to tone, so I guess I'm morally wrong.
This subject hurts my head.
If you state the coin was AT'd, and the buyer is cool with it, sell it.
<< <i>No problem with me, just do like the chinese do and stamp AT into the coin!
bob
I thought the same exactly thing.
I toned a bunch of coins for educational purposes. I made AT vs NT displays for the coin club I was in. People asked me if I ever thought of selling them as AT coins and I said I was worried that they would end up on ebay being sold as NT coins. I did think of making sets showing the color progression and stamping AT into them, but it would be too much trouble.
<< <i>No problem with me, just do like the chinese do and stamp AT into the coin! >>
or photoshop it onto the pic.
60 years into this hobby and I'm still working on my Lincoln set!
Cheers, RickO
"La Vostra Nonna Ha Faccia Del Fungo"
I have no problem with you keeping it, but when you sell it and you are being honest about its toning origin and/or toning result, the next person who sells it may not be as forthcoming and sell it to an unsuspecting buyer at a premium. And then we have another AT out there in the general public causing wide spread panic and monetary loss. I agree either stamp AT so all will know in the future or just kept forever. having it circulate in the public domain will only haunt unknowledgeable collectors.
I completely disagree with this comment. This line of thinking....well, it's really nonsensical. There is no way a current owner of anything can control what the future owner does with that object. If the object is sold legally and the object itself is legal, then more power to the seller. AT coins are certainly legal and if a person likes the colors, then great. We are not here to protect every member of the hobby...or society as a whole. If an unsuspecting buyer buys an AT coin as NT, then that buyer needs to be better educated and his education begins with that coin. Protecting the stupid or uneducated from themselves is a nearly impossible endeavor.
K S
JJ
<< <i>Can we see a photo of the coin in question?
JJ >>
Here it is....suprised at all?
<< <i>
<< <i>Can we see a photo of the coin in question?
JJ >>
Here it is....suprised at all?
The toning is acceptable enough to be passed off as legitimate and probably be graded so. Looks like run-of-the-mill album toning.
Stuff like that is easy to do with Roosies and other small coins. Yet coins such as that tend to bring minimal premiums, so it doesn't really matter. If it was a silver dollar which you toned (which may I add, are exponentially harder to tone than dimes) it would be a different story.
<< <i>But if done on a seated dime GEN, this type of color would command probably a double price premium. >>
If done on a Seated Dime it would be obviously artificial.
Check out my current listings: https://ebay.com/sch/khunt/m.html?_ipg=200&_sop=12&_rdc=1
<< <i>
<< <i>But if done on a seated dime GEN, this type of color would command probably a double price premium. >>
If done on a Seated Dime it would be obviously artificial. >>
I'd guess there would be some debate.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>But if done on a seated dime GEN, this type of color would command probably a double price premium. >>
If done on a Seated Dime it would be obviously artificial. >>
I'd guess there would be some debate. >>
Seated Dimes don't tone like that.
No vomit of any kind was involved in making these coins.
<< <i>
<< <i>As long as you state it is AT. However, will next next person down the line chose the path of honesty? >>
And this is EXACTLY why I asked this question.
Therein lies the problem.
<< <i>Looks like the type of toning I would expect on a proof. >>
Sounds familar
That said, as long as it's sold with a sort of disclaimer I see no issue.
Though I'm curious if you could get it holdered for laughs
-D
-Aristotle
Dum loquimur fugerit invida aetas. Carpe diem quam minimum credula postero.
-Horace
The interesting problem when thinking of AT/NT in moral terms is the absence of a fine line between NT and AT. Instead there is a lot of overlap. We have respected experts pushing PCGS to accept colorful coins that COULD be NT but probably aren't, and PCGS pushing to reject colorful coins that are probably NT but COULD be AT.
As in life, if AT is a sin, there are degrees of sin and some sins that are "OK" (market acceptable), like violating posted speed limits.
I'm not very bright at times, in fact can be dumb as a post, but even I, starting out, learned pretty quick what AT looked like from noticing Ebay sellers who had a whole line-up of "MONSTER TONED!!!" coins that all looked more of less the same, usually like anodized aluminum.
But I have to fight off nausea and anger when I see a newbie biting on an AT not described as AT at way too high $$$'s, knowing we will probably lose another potential collector when he/she realizes he/she was taken for a ride. Rob
Questions about Ikes? Go to The IKE GROUP WEB SITE
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
I do have a problem if the next person sells it and touts it as original toning.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>As long as you state it is AT. However, will next next person down the line chose the path of honesty? >>
And this is EXACTLY why I asked this question.
Therein lies the problem.
Exactly. Why should one care what the next owner is going to do to or with it? If it would bother someone that the next owner might do something that he might not do, then the obvious thing is to keep it or destroy it. Thats like refusing to sell a coin to someone you know will crack it out and put it in an album.
Hell, I don't need to exercise.....I get enough just pushing my luck.
A couple of years later one of my proof Franklins had developed an ugly tobacco colored spot on it so remembering what I had been told, I decided to see if what I had been told was an old wives tale or not and removed in from the cello and stored it per his conversation with one caveat I needed to accelerate the process as I am reaching the sunset of my tour of duty here. Here is the result.