Options
Question on selling my type collection
In advance, sorry if this needs to be in another forum, but I was pretty sure it would get buried in the BST forum.
I have come to the decision that I would like to sell my certified type collection. It is not on par with the collections that normally get auctioned off by the likes of the bigger auction houses, but its not junk either. Low-lights would include a 1996-W Roosevelt in ANACS 65, a 1970-D Kennedy in ANACS 64 (doh), or a 1957-D Franklin in PCGS 65 FBL, and highlights would include a 1926-S Buffalo in PCGS 25, an 1860-O Seated dollar in ANACS 30, or an 1809 Bust Half in ANACS AU-50.
For context, the whole collection is about 42 coins, and listed in the Heritage "My Collection" is listed as worth about $7,000. A little over half are in ANACS (all old small white holders), the others are in PCGS or NGC. None are problem coins.
So, to my question... I would like to sell this as a collection, I'd rather not have to deal with trying to sell them individually although I might get more. I do not ebay (nor do I want to).
So, my options would seem to be:
1) To take them to a local dealer, but my experience with the only B&M near me has me expecting to get seriously low-balled. This is not an ‘emergency sale’ so I can afford to walk away from poor offers.
2) Try to sell them (as a collection) on the BST forum
3) Take a drive and take them in to Heritage (I live in Texas), but they might not purchase the lower end coins(?)
Any other options or ideas? Given my situation, are there any methods that would likely get me the best offers versus others?
Thanks very much for any advice or info.
I have come to the decision that I would like to sell my certified type collection. It is not on par with the collections that normally get auctioned off by the likes of the bigger auction houses, but its not junk either. Low-lights would include a 1996-W Roosevelt in ANACS 65, a 1970-D Kennedy in ANACS 64 (doh), or a 1957-D Franklin in PCGS 65 FBL, and highlights would include a 1926-S Buffalo in PCGS 25, an 1860-O Seated dollar in ANACS 30, or an 1809 Bust Half in ANACS AU-50.
For context, the whole collection is about 42 coins, and listed in the Heritage "My Collection" is listed as worth about $7,000. A little over half are in ANACS (all old small white holders), the others are in PCGS or NGC. None are problem coins.
So, to my question... I would like to sell this as a collection, I'd rather not have to deal with trying to sell them individually although I might get more. I do not ebay (nor do I want to).
So, my options would seem to be:
1) To take them to a local dealer, but my experience with the only B&M near me has me expecting to get seriously low-balled. This is not an ‘emergency sale’ so I can afford to walk away from poor offers.
2) Try to sell them (as a collection) on the BST forum
3) Take a drive and take them in to Heritage (I live in Texas), but they might not purchase the lower end coins(?)
Any other options or ideas? Given my situation, are there any methods that would likely get me the best offers versus others?
Thanks very much for any advice or info.
0
Comments
Most dealers will bend you over. Best bet would be individually on the BST, then coinzip (though, it appears there are few "auctions" there, so far, and most price things at a level they are comfortable with), then ebay.
You would likely sell quite a few on the BST.
I need a Seated Lib dollar, but need an economical one.
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
I feel that offering the set as a whole, where you have specific early coins like the Buffalo, Seated and Bust material and the modern coins will not get a strong offer from either group (early or modern buyers). Both sides will probably heavily discount one part of the lot for sure.
“We are only their care-takers,” he posed, “if we take good care of them, then centuries from now they may still be here … ”
Todd - BHNC #242
<< <i>It's an appropriate question in the right forum.
Most dealers will bend you over. Best bet would be individually on the BST, then coinzip (though, it appears there are few "auctions" there, so far, and most price things at a level they are comfortable with), then ebay.
You would likely sell quite a few on the BST.
I will agree, you will get more if sold individually. It takes more time but you will get more.
Stefanie
.
CoinsAreFun Toned Silver Eagle Proof Album
.
Gallery Mint Museum, Ron Landis& Joe Rust, The beginnings of the Golden Dollar
.
More CoinsAreFun Pictorials NGC FOR SALE