1 1 11917345 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70 2 1 11917346 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
I'm happy with my results. At least the 70 is the lower POP.
1 1 11929621 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC 2 1 11929622 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR69
President, Racine Numismatic Society 2013-2014; Variety Resource Dimes; See 6/8/12 CDN for my article on Winged Liberty Dimes; Ebay
Got grades today: Not disappointed at all: Now I can sell the first to partially pay for the reverse proof.
1 1 11903298 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC 2 1 11903299 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
WOW.1675.00 Should have put a reserve on that, way too cheap ..Watching one last night and it sold for 2125 + 25 post...but think they are selling around 18-2000 for the most part.
<< <i>WOW.1675.00 Should have put a reserve on that, way too cheap ..Watching one last night and it sold for 2125 + 25 post...but think they are selling around 18-2000 for the most part. >>
To cheap???? Its an open market, multiple bids tells you that was all the market was willing to pay at that time. The mint screwed the flippers on this one. Way too many minted for the true demand. Same thing has been happening to the First Hags.
If you sent it in for grading and you sell it on ebay with paypal, you must get around $2300 just to break even.
<< <i>Man 69 sets are taking a real beating, and somebody got a great deal, overall looks like a $450 loss on a nicely presented listing...link >>
Or perhaps a BIN with a best offer. I know I am a small potatoes wannabe, but I can't see placing items like this on ebay for a straight auction in the current economic environment. You are practically asking to get your lunch handed to you. (Although some persons have done just fine on this very item in a straight auction. Fine being recouping the purchase price, grading fees. You are still losing if it is paid by paypal credit card.) JMHO.
"It's not that the Irish are cynical. It's simply that they have a wonderful lack of respect for everything and everybody." - Brendan Behan
Proud Participant in Operation "Stone Holey" August 7, 2008
<< <i>Man 69 sets are taking a real beating, and somebody got a great deal, overall looks like a $450 loss on a nicely presented listing...link >>
This should be a warning to eBay sellers. The above auction title did not have the year 2007 in it, as such it did not come up in my 2007 10th Anniversary Searches. I'm sure, I'm not alone. The seller has only himself to blame... some one got a great deal
"Bongo drive 1984 Lincoln that looks like old coin dug from ground."
<< <i>Man 69 sets are taking a real beating, and somebody got a great deal, overall looks like a $450 loss on a nicely presented listing...link >>
This should be a warning to eBay sellers. The above auction title did not have the year 2007 in it, as such it did not come up in my 2007 10th Anniversary Searches. I'm sure, I'm not alone. The seller has only himself to blame... some one got a great deal >>
Actually I've been using "Platinum 10th." A realization of 8% over melt might look attractive after a month or two.
I just sold my single 69DCAM/70 set to the local dealer for $2275, and was glad to get it. About half a dozen dealers at the Wilmington DE coin show, from several mid-Atlantic states, had exactly zero interest in any platinum -- 10th anny, 2006-W unc, whatever -- for anything more than 5 or 6% less than melt.
About half a dozen dealers at the Wilmington DE coin show, from several mid-Atlantic states, had exactly zero interest in any platinum -- 10th anny, 2006-W unc, whatever -- for anything more than 5 or 6% less than melt
not surprising-- platinum costs a lot, and is a specialty area; many dealers lack sufficient knowledge and/or liquidity.
If you decide to sell any 2006 ws for melt, let me know first!
Just for the record, I'm reporting my grades as well. One PR70DC, so I'm happy to have at least one. These will fit in my collection nicely.
1 1 11910439 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC 2 1 11910440 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR69
<< <i>About half a dozen dealers at the Wilmington DE coin show, from several mid-Atlantic states, had exactly zero interest in any platinum -- 10th anny, 2006-W unc, whatever -- for anything more than 5 or 6% less than melt
not surprising-- platinum costs a lot, and is a specialty area; many dealers lack sufficient knowledge and/or liquidity.
>>
It seems like it was the latter. Some of the comments were that they already had several sets, or that high melt prices were bringing everybody out of the woodwork selling their stuff; in any case demand was too low.
There was one instance where I finally found a dealer willing to look at a 2006 proof at melt levels -- "now you're speaking my language!" -- and a dealer at the next table piped up, "That's way too high. I dumped all my changing reverses at 10% under melt." After that incredible display of bad etiquette from someone who should know better, my possible buyer instantly put his guide book down and passed.
I do wholeheartedly agree that asking melt for an 06-W unc is too pessimistic.
More grades back today... Guess I got lucky that makes 5 out of 6 to be PR70's out of my two submissions
1 1 11900443 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC 1 2 11900444 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC 2 1 11900445 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70 2 2 11900446 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
1 1 11904045 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC 2 1 11904046 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
1 1 11904045 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC 2 1 11904046 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
Now what do I do?? >>
Get on your knees and thank the Lord you got a PR70 RP.
1 1 11904045 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC 2 1 11904046 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
Now what do I do?? >>
Get on your knees and thank the Lord you got a PR70 RP. >>
Seems the PR70 RP are not that hard from what I've seen. My brothers 2 set both came back 70's but the regular proofs are harder to get 70's on his were both 69's.
WOuld it be in my best interests to upgrade the PR69DCAM to a PR70DCAM? I believe there is a dealer that will take the 69 in trade for a 70. If the forum says no, then should I sell the set as is?
Comments
386/182 PR DCAM
254/310 RP PR69
1 1 11910077 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
2 1 11910078 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
Can't beat that!
<< <i>Got my grades today:
1 1 11910077 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
2 1 11910078 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
Can't beat that!
No wonder they call you BigBadChad!!!!!!!! Congrats!!!!
<< <i>Got my grades today:
1 1 11910077 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
2 1 11910078 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
Can't beat that!
You should thank us 69 ers for allowing yours to grade out at 70's!!
1 1 11917345 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 1 11917346 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
1 1 11929621 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
2 1 11929622 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR69
President, Racine Numismatic Society 2013-2014; Variety Resource Dimes; See 6/8/12 CDN for my article on Winged Liberty Dimes; Ebay
My grades just came back:
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 11925838 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
2 1 11925839 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
3 1 11925840 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
4 1 11925841 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR69
Total Items: 4
2 sets submitted, one full 70 set, so I'm reasonably happy
1 1 11903298 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
2 1 11903299 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
I knew it would happen.
President, Racine Numismatic Society 2013-2014; Variety Resource Dimes; See 6/8/12 CDN for my article on Winged Liberty Dimes; Ebay
Order #20154011 / Submission #9082837
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 11906813 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
2 1 11906814 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
Total Items: 2
Date Received: 1/9/2008
Date Shipped: N/A
Order Status: OK
==================================
Complete US-PHIL Coins for Sale, Circulation Strikes 1903-1945
<< <i>Got the grades today.
Order #20154011 / Submission #9082837
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 11906813 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
2 1 11906814 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
Total Items: 2
Date Received: 1/9/2008
Date Shipped: N/A
Order Status: OK >>
Good job!!! Now you should be able to get MOON Money for them. Well..... waning crescent moon money anyway.
<< <i>WOW.1675.00 Should have put a reserve on that, way too cheap ..Watching one last night and it sold for 2125 + 25 post...but think they are selling around 18-2000 for the most part. >>
To cheap???? Its an open market, multiple bids tells you that was all the market was willing to pay at that time. The mint screwed the flippers on this one. Way too many minted for the true demand. Same thing has been happening to the First Hags.
If you sent it in for grading and you sell it on ebay with paypal, you must get around $2300 just to break even.
<< <i>Man 69 sets are taking a real beating, and somebody got a great deal, overall looks like a $450 loss on a nicely presented listing...link >>
Or perhaps a BIN with a best offer. I know I am a small potatoes wannabe, but I can't see placing items like this on ebay for a straight auction in the current economic environment. You are practically asking to get your lunch handed to you. (Although some persons have done just fine on this very item in a straight auction. Fine being recouping the purchase price, grading fees. You are still losing if it is paid by paypal credit card.) JMHO.
Proud Participant in Operation "Stone Holey" August 7, 2008
<< <i>Man 69 sets are taking a real beating, and somebody got a great deal, overall looks like a $450 loss on a nicely presented listing...link >>
Yep, you win some, you lose some. Here, I lost a lot. Some people set reserves, that's fine, but I don't. Sold one set and am going to keep one set.
<< <i>Man 69 sets are taking a real beating, and somebody got a great deal, overall looks like a $450 loss on a nicely presented listing...link >>
This should be a warning to eBay sellers. The above auction title did not have the year 2007 in it, as such it did not come up in my 2007 10th Anniversary Searches. I'm sure, I'm not alone. The seller has only himself to blame... some one got a great deal
<< <i>Man 69 sets are taking a real beating, and somebody got a great deal, overall looks like a $450 loss on a nicely presented listing...link >>
More than that when you consider e-bay fees, grading and shipping fees etc...
<< <i>
<< <i>Man 69 sets are taking a real beating, and somebody got a great deal, overall looks like a $450 loss on a nicely presented listing...link >>
More than that when you consider e-bay fees, grading and shipping fees etc... >>
I was considering that stuff, how much am I off?
<< <i>Just checked my order...both 70/70!!!
Depends on what you want.
If you want the set in 70 grade then of course keep it.
If you want future appreciation then that is a tough call.
70 First strike label will help.
You could sell that set for around $3.000 and buy a 69 set for around $2000
Or just sell it and be happy with the profit.
I received a PF70 and a RP69. I only wanted the Reverse proof so I sold the PF70.
Joe
<< <i>
<< <i>Man 69 sets are taking a real beating, and somebody got a great deal, overall looks like a $450 loss on a nicely presented listing...link >>
This should be a warning to eBay sellers. The above auction title did not have the year 2007 in it, as such it did not come up in my 2007 10th Anniversary Searches. I'm sure, I'm not alone. The seller has only himself to blame... some one got a great deal
Actually I've been using "Platinum 10th." A realization of 8% over melt might look attractive after a month or two.
I just sold my single 69DCAM/70 set to the local dealer for $2275, and was glad to get it. About half a dozen dealers at the Wilmington DE coin show, from several mid-Atlantic states, had exactly zero interest in any platinum -- 10th anny, 2006-W unc, whatever -- for anything more than 5 or 6% less than melt.
not surprising-- platinum costs a lot, and is a specialty area; many dealers lack sufficient knowledge and/or liquidity.
If you decide to sell any 2006 ws for melt, let me know first!
1 1 11910439 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
2 1 11910440 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR69
Proud recipient of two "You Suck" awards
i am still trying to sell my set to just break even. i just need the cask quick. errr never again will i buy a plat set to sell.
<< <i>About half a dozen dealers at the Wilmington DE coin show, from several mid-Atlantic states, had exactly zero interest in any platinum -- 10th anny, 2006-W unc, whatever -- for anything more than 5 or 6% less than melt
not surprising-- platinum costs a lot, and is a specialty area; many dealers lack sufficient knowledge and/or liquidity.
>>
It seems like it was the latter. Some of the comments were that they already had several sets, or that high melt prices were bringing everybody out of the woodwork selling their stuff; in any case demand was too low.
There was one instance where I finally found a dealer willing to look at a 2006 proof at melt levels -- "now you're speaking my language!" -- and a dealer at the next table piped up, "That's way too high. I dumped all my changing reverses at 10% under melt." After that incredible display of bad etiquette from someone who should know better, my possible buyer instantly put his guide book down and passed.
I do wholeheartedly agree that asking melt for an 06-W unc is too pessimistic.
1 1 11900443 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
1 2 11900444 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
2 1 11900445 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 2 11900446 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
Box of 20
<< <i>my set did not yield a 70
No 70 for me either . Have to stop opening this thread
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 11925663 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
1 2 11925664 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
1 3 11925665 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
1 4 11925666 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
1 5 11925667 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
2 1 11925668 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 2 11925669 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 3 11925670 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 4 11925671 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 5 11925672 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
Total Items: 10
1 1 11904045 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
2 1 11904046 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
Now what do I do??
<< <i>I posted these earlier on another thread.
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 11925663 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
1 2 11925664 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
1 3 11925665 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
1 4 11925666 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
1 5 11925667 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
2 1 11925668 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 2 11925669 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 3 11925670 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 4 11925671 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 5 11925672 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
Total Items: 10
Congrats.....awesome results.
Looks like my 69's are getting scarcer......
<< <i>The results are in for my one set:
1 1 11904045 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
2 1 11904046 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
Now what do I do?? >>
Get on your knees and thank the Lord you got a PR70 RP.
<< <i>
<< <i>The results are in for my one set:
1 1 11904045 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
2 1 11904046 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
Now what do I do?? >>
Get on your knees and thank the Lord you got a PR70 RP.
Seems the PR70 RP are not that hard from what I've seen. My brothers 2 set both came back 70's but the regular proofs are harder to get 70's on his were both 69's.
WOuld it be in my best interests to upgrade the PR69DCAM to a PR70DCAM? I believe there is a dealer that will take the 69 in trade for a 70. If the forum says no, then should I sell the set as is?
<< <i>More grades back today... Guess I got lucky that makes 5 out of 6 to be PR70's out of my two submissions
1 1 11900443 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
1 2 11900444 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
2 1 11900445 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 2 11900446 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70 >>
NICE Scores
Looks 50/50 to me....................
1 1 12789360 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
1 2 12789361 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
1 3 12789362 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
1 4 12789363 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
1 5 12789364 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
1 6 12789365 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
1 7 12789366 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
1 8 12789367 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
1 9 12789368 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
1 10 12789369 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR70DC
1 11 12789370 393054 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty, 10th Anniversary set US PR69DC
2 1 12789371 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 2 12789372 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 3 12789373 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 4 12789374 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR69
2 5 12789375 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 6 12789376 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 7 12789377 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 8 12789378 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 9 12789379 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 10 12789380 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR70
2 11 12789381 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR69
2 12 12789382 393056 2007-W $50 Statue of Liberty 10th Anniversary set, Reverse Proof US PR69
PCGS Link
Successful forum transactions: jessewvu, nankraut, tootawl, levinll, mistercoinman, metalsman, adamlaneus, chuckc, fivecents, kingplatinum, jdimmick, waterzooey, moderncoinmart, bige, steelielee,
<< <i>Why 11 proofs and 12 Rev proofs?????? weird... >>
There was a note inside to the graders. Do a good job, and keep 1 proof for your troubles.
<< <i>
<< <i>Why 11 proofs and 12 Rev proofs?????? weird... >>
There was a note inside to the graders. Do a good job, and keep 1 proof for your troubles.
That is funny. Nice grades.
Yours too Coinmaster 8/10 Sweet.
Joe
the 70DCAMS are tougher.......33.9% pass through rate at 70.