1924 Buffalo Newp!

23Pairer

Just imaged my newest purchase, a splendidly toned Buffalo. Any thoughts on grade? The scratches are on the plastic tomb. Enjoy. Bob

23Pairer

What, no takers? I thought it was a good lookin' Buff, too.

AskRaq

Well then.... I really like the coin, nice detail & cool toning ~ but, what's up with the rim on the reverse my the tail??

jerryf43

ms 61 nice buffalo

NHSBaseball

Looks like maybe it's the plastic holder- not the rim--

NHSBaseball

Beautiful toning, by the way-nice coin. MS-63?

23Pairer

<< <i>Well then.... I really like the coin, nice detail & cool toning ~ but, what's up with the rim on the reverse my the tail?? >>



PCGS plastic

STONE

I wonder why the guesses are so low-IMO.

I would say this looks like an easy 64.

23Pairer

<< <i> I wonder why the guesses are so low-IMO.

I would say this looks like an easy 64. >>



And the Winner is STONE!

STONE

Well, what can I say, I'm just that good

Taking into account the color, luster, maybe a slightly softer strike, and some minor contact marks, I think it's a great coin for the grade

So what do I win

ad4400

Assuming it is only a change to the color of the toning on the Indian's cheek and the buffalo's hip and not rub I'd say 64. There are a number of smaller dings on the indian's portrait that precludes a higher grade IMO. Seems to have the same die polishing by the EPU that mine has. Nice coin.

ricko

I certainly hope toning is not now part of grading... as some previous posts seem to infer. Cheers, RickO

23Pairer

<< <i>Well, what can I say, I'm just that good

Taking into account the color, luster, maybe a slightly softer strike, and some minor contact marks, I think it's a great coin for the grade

So what do I win >>



Good eye, Stone!