The official CU Member "feedback" thread.

Downtown1974

I know there are alot of people who buy and trade with each other on here, so I thought it might be nice to start a thread dedicated to transactions that take place between board members. There are also alot of generous people on here who give cards away to other members, so maybe there good will could be recognized on this thread also. Dont be afraid to post scans too. Please keep it to deals that were made with other members only. I would rather see your great Ebay deals on the "mail call thread".


I had 2 great transactions this week.

Thanks so much to RipMass and leadoff! RipMass sold me some nice 1955 Topps for my set. And leadoff sold me a Mantle and a Koufax from his recent submission. I was very pleased with the cards and how smooth the transaction was.


THANKS AGAIN GUYS!!!

NathanSr

Some time ago, I had a smooth transaction where I purchased a PSA 9 Seau from Lawnmowerman . I am still waiting for him to sell me those 2 other Seau's he is holding,

NathanSr

lawnmowerman

<< <i>Some time ago, I had a smooth transaction where I purchased a PSA 9 Seau from Lawnmowerman . I am still waiting for him to sell me those 2 other Seau's he is holding,

NathanSr >>

I guess I should have told you Nathan. I'm selling off all my Emmitts to start my Seau master set. Im also gonna need that card back

Actually, the real reason is I am gonna crack and resubmit the others. I'll let you know when I get them back

Gonblott

Month ago I bought a 1955 Bowman Hank Aaaron PSA 8 from Wondo through paypal, no problems at all and very nice to talk to!

Bosox1976

I have had great dealings with JVette, Spacktrack, Ron Burgundy, and Kaline Fan this month - each a pleasure to do business with.

Downtown1974

Bosox, I have also bought some great things from you. Excellent items and service!!

MS70Dreams

I have completed several very smooth trades with Bunker & Beef316. Very fast shippers and well packaged! I look forward to future trades with both guys!

I also have several other trades in the works with board members. I will report on these trades as they complete.

Thanks
Mike

jackstraw

I have had people send me free stuff or free stuff for free stuff. The ones I can remember are
You, stone, Matt, con40(one generous person),divecchia(top notch), magellan, downgoesfrazier, vayank(SGC board), njdolphin(SGC board), softparade and I am sure I missed someone.
I have bought and sold right here and never had any problems!

CDsNuts

pandrews farted in a bubble mailer and sent it to me. Pretty good gag.

Lee

lawnmowerman

I have had countless r.a.k.'s sent to me. I like to return the favors as much as possible.

I would be afraid to try and list all the guys that sent stuff to me. I would hate to forget someone.

So, thank you to everyone

MikeyLikesIt

I haven't made many purchases from this board, but the ones I did have were positive. 86nova (Craig) sent me a group of 2006 Topps Heritage SPs that I needed for free - heckuva guy. I also bought a bunch of ArnyVee's leftover Drysdales with no problems.

perkdog

Neil Downey sold me a card and it was a smooth transaction with great communication as well. A +

yankeeno7

I have had sucessful transactions (these are just the ones I remember off the top of my head) with
Bri2327
Gregmo32
Spahnfan
tkd7
Tennesseebanker
Lothar
Those are probably the most recent. Im sorry if I have forgotten anyone else.

williplett

LDFerg and DownGoesFrazier have been good sellers, ah yeah, and Itzagoner has been awesome as well.

pandrews

lots of cool people on here.. id also be afraid i'd miss someone if i started naming people.. ive had many transactions, buying, selling, trading, free stuff, girly pics, etc..

plus i once mailed a fart to CDsNuts..

pandrews

most recently, lawnmowerman sent me a bunch of mint rickey henderson cards..

+1 for lawnmowerman..

itzagoner

thanks williplett, very kind of you....i've had only positive experiences with quite a few board members here, it's been a pleasure to deal with all who support my auctions....and pandrews has never sent me a fart

lawnmowerman

<< <i>most recently, lawnmowerman sent me a bunch of mint rickey henderson cards..

+1 for lawnmowerman.. >>



+1 for pa as well.

He sent me a psa Emmitt that was just added to my set because my request just popped up Its weighted a 3 too

pandrews

<< <i>thanks williplett, very kind of you....i've had only positive experiences with quite a few board members here, it's been a pleasure to deal with all who support my auctions....and pandrews has never sent me a fart >>



itzagoner is a supreme forum member in my opinion also..

may he be blessed with a fart from Christina Aguilera one day..

Robeson

I have many great deals with both David Barkus (BarkusD) and Frank Smith (Late1970sTopps). Both have great prices and Frank sends a very secure package of cards. Hard to ship 140 discs, very heavy. Tedw9 also sent me a free book and refused any paypal from me for shipping. A good bunch of people on this site.

leadoff4

Thanks Downtown1974(Bob) for the good words. No problems with Downtown1974 from the selling end either. Prompt payment and good communication. It's leadoff4 for those that are interested. I'll have many more graded items up when I get the time. Thanks!

beef316

In the last month I have had fair and successful trades w/ the following:

five7teen
rugbymarine
MS70Dreams
Pharber

Carew29

artimus
Hammerman
jhpfunk
SOM
tkd7
softparade
rbdjr1
ArnyVee
RedRomad275
augustaman
Bkritz

And a special thanks to--Carew4me

nightcrawler

Had some good deals, got a free SMR sent by Knuckles then later picked up a (words can't describe and no scan because I'm 1400 miles from home in Winnipeg) Terry Sawchuk Auto stick card, wow. And thanks also to winpitcher??? I think on the SMR.

Bought a nice card from Boopotts, can't remember which one???

And finally... most generously and never to be forgoten, a autographed Reg Leach from gameusedhoops. Still have an express envelope with his address on it in my computor bag. Wonder what's going to land in his box someday soon???

Now with the hockey rip comin up, I feel as though I'll be in debt with renrutmd, but goes around comes around... hear that renrutmd

leftofdial

I think onlypsahockey did a great job on the 80's hockey rip, he shipped fast after payments, boxes were well packed, all packs were sealed with clear roller marks and he also randomly sent participants extra packs since some of the boxes were 48 counts!

ArnyVee

Wow, so many....let's see if I can remember them all....

LostDart58
Carew29
MikeyLikesIt
BarkusD
GregM13
Bkritz
LDFerg
RVC
MCholke
JoeMaggio
Julen23
Bunker
FB
SixDart
5Stat
AlNavMan
BlindFlyer
EagleEyeKid
Archinator
FiveNiner
XanaduNow
Zef204
FabFrank
gseaman25
CDC4
Stingray

....I know there's more, but that's a decent sized list.

samsgirl214

purchased this from marz, 1976 Sweet Williams discs ( Isalys ) PSA 10 YAZ (got card day after i sent money) lightning fast shipping..lol
and 28 or so PSA 8, 9 and 10's packers from wondo fast shipping..always great deals

have bought and sold to greg and james and a few others i don't remember, sorry guys....all the rest are in sig line..most from past years but a few still hang around the boards

larryallen73

I have bought pictures from DowngoesFrazier and sold a few cards to Stingray. Excellente!

djspann

I've had several good trades with shouldabeena10 over the last month or two.


Doug

lawnmowerman

I have had several good trades with Joe Orlando. I send him lots of cards and a bunch of money.

He sends me cards in return but for some reason never any money?

The weirdest part of this whole deal is I keep doing it over and over and over again.

I guess I will never learn.

Tedw9

I've had the good fortune dealing with some awesome people on this board.

One person, whos name I forget (I'm sorry) sent me a free copy of the SMR a few months ago. I still use it, so thank you to whom ever was so kind.

Lawnmowerman sent me a sweet Willie McGinnest autographed card for my Patriots collection. Thanks Matt!

samsgirl sent me a bunch of sweet Patriots cards including some game used cards. And even though she is a Packers fan, she sent some Packers cards for my wife. Very kind lady, thank you samsgirl!

And recently Tennesseebanker sold me a partial set of cards at a great price. He was even so kind as to take payments from me until I could pay it off. Thank you so much Tennesseebanker!

Edited to add: How could I forget Brian48 who sent me a Topps hockey sticker set and album for free! Thank you so much Brian, I love the set!

And Lostdart who was kind enough to give me some advice which was right on the money. He saved me a bunch of hassle and got me on the right path. Your advice was much appreciated, thank you so much.

If I have forgotten anyone, I apologize.



There are alot of great people on this board who help each other out. It's nice to read a positive thread like this, thanks for starting this Downtown.

BigRedMachine

I'll agree that some of the people on these boards have been tremendous.

I've done a lot of trades with guys here, especially while I was doing the Heritage set in '05 and '06. The guys have been fantastic!!

And people like onlyanumber (Paul), TNP777 (Geordie), joestalin (Kevin), archstanton (Jim), and samsgirl (Julie) come to mind as people who have seemingly bent over backwards to help me out or send something nice.

I try to return the favors as often as possible. The trades I've made with some of the heritage guys have all worked out and would be too long to list. So apologies to those I didn't list, but you're certainly not forgotten.

shawn

MS70Dreams

I just had a great trade with "packman". I received the cards quickly and they were packed very well.

He even threw in some extra Reds cards, damn near the whole 76 Reds team including Bench and some other vintage.

David is a great trader and great person!



Thanks
Mike

bigfische

I have had good transactions with the following:

bbne1-sent me cards I needed for a set for free
iamrock-bought cards with no problem
Jeff8877- bought cards with no problem

Stingray

Have had a few dealings with Bkritz, always have been good!!! Also with LarryAllen, good also!!

goose3

I have sold to quite a few people here, mainly when I was selling off my dad's stuff last year.
Morrell
ArnyVee
Blindflyer
1420
Aconte
Fiveniner
Fullerfun
JimQ
ETC...to name a few

Recently I've purchased from a few of you as well with no problems or hassles

Pre1960
incugator
Cmoking

Goodsport40

I just got a great 1977-78 basketball pack from Lee, Cdsnuts. I have dealt with ldferg as well on a deal and it went very well.

Robert

EAsports

I got a great deal on some football and baseball packs from this one guy.... He even offered to get them from Steve Hart and ship them to me....


Seriously, though....

I got a GREAT 1986 Topps FB Set (minus the Rice RC) from Pittsburghese.

TZAHL

Joestalin +1
Magellan +1
Softparade +1
Archstanton +1
Five7teen +1

Zef +1---cuz he's sexy

Lawnmower man-----+1 for the Will Farrell Harry Carey....although you gotta wonder about a guy who collects Emmitt.
Lawnmowermanswife +1 for the reproductive system (congrats!)

1980s collector +1
1980s junkie 0---1 pos. and 1 neg.

Hopefully I'll have more to add when my trades from this weekend get complete! Gotta love it.

renrutmd

Thanks Nightcrawler it was my pleasure.

MS70Dreams

I just completed a couple of great trades with board members!

Great Trade with paleocards - Thanks Andy

Great Trade with five7teen - Jason is a top notch guy!

Thanks to everyone on the board for being so nice. This is the most civil public forum that I have had the priviledge to participate with.

Thanks
Mike

jmbkb4

gosteelers and I have completed several nice trades.

Onlypsahockey

I've had several positive experiences with many members here. My apologies if I forgot anyone.

lawnmowerman
Ezyshooter
Cardbender
Zef
Bkritz
gameusedhoops
RVC
rbeaton
DirtyDog48
EagleEyeKid
NeilDowney
Carew29
jerster
thefootballcardstore

and probably a few I can't remember right now.

Thanks guys! Bob C.

mreuter

Just got some sets from "packman", great deal and fantastic shipping.

kmnorton

Jason (five7teen) shorted me out of a Cobb card, other than that, stand up guy and a real pleasure (joke about the Cobb card).
Geordie (TNP777)
Bryan (Munson15)
Andy (paleocards)
David (BarkusD)
Mark (bbne1)
Kevin (joestalin) he of little faith in Heritage
Nelson (thenarcissus01) for helping me pop my grading cherry

Yankeeefan

I'd like to send out a big THANKS! to -

renrutmd- for organizing and fronting the $$ for the 1978-79 OPC hockey rip. Well done and if he does another, I'm in.

onlypsahockey- was part of the hockey rip and sent my son a big lot of NJ Devils cards ( shipped Priority and better packaged than 75% of the EBAYers I've dealt w/ recently.)

It's a shame that the scammers and rip-off clowns get more bandwidth than the good-guys on these boards.

dpfitzell

I have had a very positive trading with:

artimus
Bkritz
daindrain

Thanks to all of the great traders, Dave

drewsef

I've had excellent success with:

shagrotn77
bigredmachine
joestalin
beach64(really nice vintage FB)
CDsNuts

jradke4

So far I have only dealt and met with GregM13. He is great. We have traded some Favres for Marinos, some HOF autos back and forth as well. I still am working on Marinos for him. I have had the chance to see most of his collection and he has had the chance to see most of mine. Both times we had a great time. In addition Greg does alot to help the guys on the HOF auto group put together group subs. I cant thank him enough for that.

He has hooked me up with another Marino collector who is planning on sending me some Favres. I can wait to complete the deal. When I do I will add him to the list.

MS70Dreams

TZAHL +1
MikeLikesIt +1

Thanks for the trades guys!

Mike

Fabfrank

I've bought and traded with many on this board. If I forget to mention your name, it's purely due to my rapidly deteriorating brian cell count
Gregm13- does a great job in assembling those group subs
jasp24- I wish I had his detailed knowledge of football and HOF RC's, but I'm a "big picture" guy
alohaet- One of the first guys I dealt with on this board. Just a wondeful human being. Hope you are doing well Ed
mantlefan- Knowledgeable, great cards, big help in completing and upgraing my Philly footballsets.
John Brinjiac- I don't know if he is on these boards, but he was very supportive in helping me build ny 52 Bowman Large set
Rick Snyder (Mint State)- The other person who has worked diligently with me on 52 Large. Thanks for all your help Rick
Itzagoner- I believe I was one of his first customers on Ebay. I hate buying from newbie sellers, but he was great and I haven't regretted it since.
Augustaman- Bill knows my sets (especially 71 topps baseball) better than me. Has been a tremendous help in completing and upgrading that set and others.
NearMint- One of the best on the net- nuff saif
Quality Cards- Okay Jay is great too.
shouldabeen- Mike has done a few deals with me and helped tremendously with my 48 Leaf set
sixdart- 85 Topps football wouldn't be where it's at if it wasn't for Marcus
metalking??- Mike always seems to find nice 85's for me
shagroth- I enjoy Andy's IM's and he always gives me a "heads up" when he sees a card I need.
Skinsfan- Art Miller is da man. Great guy with a wonderful sense of humor. Gave my Philly football sets a huge lift over the years.
AllanAlan- Joe was the one who originally "lit the fire" for me to build the "All Time football sets"
There are others such as downgoesfrazier, thefootballcardstore, bkritz, barkusd, that come immediately to mind. I have to say with all the people on these boards, I don't think I've had one bad experience.
Umm... well maybe one