Problem with a dealer. I will update you all when I am able to. Thanks!

goose3

what would you do if you bought this ANACS AG3 and you were told it had Absolutely NO scratches or digs and then were refused a refund?

MrEureka

mrearlygold

OffMetal

Hope everything works out for you...



<< <i> >>




<< <i> >>



Wow, you two really had a lot to say

Russ

Russ, NCNE

DennisH

Would somebody please explain to me what Andy and Tom are saying?

coinlieutenant

bum deal Goose. I will make a note however.

J

OffMetal

<< <i>Would somebody please explain to me what Andy and Tom are saying? >>



They are getting dibs on first page

goose3

If anyone is familiar with him and happens to know if he shares a table or anything like that at Baltimore shows.....please let me know.

Petescorner

The guy offers you a refund privilege before you agree to the deal and now he won't honor it? Sounds like someone worth avoiding from now on, to me.

BAJJERFAN

<< <i>...the ones I saw were. I missed another sale on that coin whereby I could have gotten more... >>



Then ask him to take it back and sell it to the other buyer; IF there ever was one.

stman

<< <i>stman canned response >>



Before I comment I need to know if the seller is a "respected" board member. It DOES matter ya know!!

clw54

How could that guy spot the circles and not the scratch?

Barry

Point him to this thread and if he's lucky, he'll realize he was in the wrong and will now do the right thing, before his reputation is shot.

And if that doesn't work, if he's an ANA member, file a grievance.

pontiacinf

ABC123

Negative Feed-back !!!

StrikeOutXXX

Edited per request.

ziggy29

<< <i>Negative Feed-back !!! >>

It didn't sell on eBay. Nevertheless, the feedback and his responses to it would have given me pause to think, most likely.

VamGuy

Doesn't ANACS have some sort of guarantee?

I mean, wouldn't that be the next step since this guy told you to go pound sand?

Msb94

Agree with BAJJERFAN....have him sell the piece to the "other buyer" if there was one

Myqqy

World class dickitry- and why did mr eureka edit out his lame response about just keeping the coin??

majorbigtime

Post the issue here (done), neg him and sue!!

ziggy29

<< <i>Post the issue here (done), neg him and sue!! >>

It was not sold on eBay.

MrEureka

why did mr eureka edit out his lame response about just keeping the coin??

Maybe because it was lame? Nah, that would be too obvious. There must be some sinister plot brewing...

majorbigtime

<< <i>

<< <i>Post the issue here (done), neg him and sue!! >>

It was not sold on eBay. >>



Then go for 2 out of 3

Whizzard

Another dishonest dealer, blocked....

Myqqy

There must be some sinister plot brewing...

Of course!! Damn, I wish I had spotted it earlier.....

Fletcher

Just be happy you received your coin at all ... the last time I bought from a board member I paid for the coin instantly and didn't receive a damn thing

CarlWohlforth

<Before I comment I need to know if the seller is a "respected" board member. It DOES matter ya know!!>

Naw, doesn't matter to me. The guy's negatives seem unprofessional to me. And having below %99 pos is bad. He is going back on a deal so is obviously not a man of his word. I'll call it that way regardless if he is a board member or not.

I sure hope he rethinks his position. Who wants to be known as a guy who can't keep his word? Anyway I'd like to know if he does take a table at show.. Anybody?

greghansen

A return privilige should be honored. That scratch is really nasty IMO. That one should be going back, and if he agreed to an inspection, he shouldn't be giving you a hard time about taking it back. If he thinks it is such a beauty, he should have no trouble moving it.

RYK

Sorry about your experience, John.

This dealer is a jagoff (saw that word here recently for the first time since leaving Pittsburgh at age 18 ) to be avoided by knowledgeable collectors and dealers...unless, of course, he joins our forum.

rec78

I missed another sale on that coin whereby I could have gotten more.
He is a liar. This statement alone says it. Name one dealer (or anyone for that matter) who will not buy a coin back if they can get more for it? My guess is that he had it for some time and deecided to unload it. JMHO. Bob

Petarded

Goose...hunt him down like the dog that he is...take him to the woodshed....meet him on the playground at 3pm after school lets out......you know what I mean...what a POS!

Bryan1315

This guys shop is not too far from me but I have never been in that part of town or seen his shop but I have definately heard about how much of a smart A$$ he is with his customers, so I never even took the time to go there. Glad I now know who he is on ebay so I can avoid him

majorbigtime

<< <i> My guess is that he had it for some time and deecided to unload it. >>



Yeah, it's called sticking it to you.

bigMACnoCheese

How did you pay for it?
Check?
Paypal?
Credit card?

Reverse the charges...
then when he screams, send it back ...

You have choices as long as you did not send cash..

You have emails saying he would honor the return and those can be used to present your position to your credit card company.

Even if you paid by paypal and they won't reverse it, go staright to the bank issuing the card and they will pull the rug out from under paypal, pay pal will then reverse it on their side to get their money back..

This works. I have done it once when paypay wouldn't make a move..

John

goose3

Lustig and Mrearlygold if you have something to say, post it. Or if it's so great, why don't you buy it from me Andy since apparently you initially thought I should keep it.

I forgot.....it's taboo around here to associate a dealer with anything negative. We collectors are supposed to take this sort of crap, right?



Fletcher,
Don't get me started with your BS. I can't believe you are STILL whining.

Fletcher

<< <i>Fletcher,
Don't get me started with your BS. I can't believe you are STILL whining. >>



Isn't that the pot calling the kettle black. Funny how when you complain about a crappy transaction with dealer that isn't a regular here everyone jumps on the bandwagon with you. And, when you complain about a crappy transaction with a dealer that everyone knows, the weak minded masses try to turn it around and make it the buyers fault. I love the hipocrisy.

goose3

. my thread has nothing to do with your whining ass crybaby thread.

I thought you were leaving YET AGAIN. You should have learned the last time you tried to dance with me that I bite.

Now pissoff before you make even more of an ass of yourself.....if that's possible.

Fletcher

Lol ... let's dance

stman

<< <i>I forgot.....it's taboo around here to associate a dealer with anything negative. We collectors are supposed to take this sort of crap, right? >>



I've wondered this myself. Please lemme know what ya find out on this.

Fletcher

<< <i>I forgot.....it's taboo around here to associate a dealer with anything negative. We collectors are supposed to take this sort of crap, right?. >>



Lol ... exactly

MrEureka

Lustig and Mrearlygold if you have something to say, post it. Or if it's so great, why don't you buy it from me Andy since apparently you initially thought I should keep it.

I forgot.....it's taboo around here to associate a dealer with anything negative. We collectors are supposed to take this sort of crap, right?

Goose - I never suggested that you keep the coin. You asked what WE would do. I said that I would back off and take a short loss because it's not worth getting into a pissing contest over a small loss. However, if you had asked what we thought YOU should do, I would have advised you to rage on, since you seem to live for this cra*p.

Shamika

How is it this ass-clown didn't see those stable scratches???

BLOCKED!!!

goose3

Ah yes....

I live for it.

What I live for is to be treated properly in a transaction and to not have someone(whether a dealer or collector) not try and pull stuff like this on me.

I guess it's too much to expect a bit of honesty and for someone's word to actually mean something these days.


I don't take kindly to being treated otherwise.


I guess I should just eliminate coins and start handing out money to people if they wish to lie to me and go back on their word. That'd be simple I'm sure.

ILikeMercs

yep, smart a$$ remarks in feedback means an instant NO DEAL for me.

majorbigtime

<< <i>Ah yes....

I live for it.

What I live for is to be treated properly in a transaction and to not have someone(whether a dealer or collector) not try and pull stuff like this on me.

I guess it's too much to expect a bit of honesty and for someone's word to actually mean something these days.


I don't take kindly to being treated otherwise.


I guess I should just eliminate coins and start handing out money to people if they wish to lie to me and go back on their word. That'd be simple I'm sure. >>







Been there, done that--Like our ex Prez sez " I feel your pain"

MrEureka

What I live for is to be treated properly in a transaction and to not have someone(whether a dealer or collector) not try and pull stuff like this on me.

Then spend your time and energy seeking out people who will treat you properly and stick with them. Every moment spent agonizing over your disappointments will only distract you from "what you live for". Right?

morgannut2

I'd just reverse any credit card or other charges. I wouldn't be that upset about a slide mark on an AG coin, because most of them have them. But if you'all agreed to a return--then he should honor it.

Gemini

"man you are one picky guy! Are you using a 20X loupe or something?"

I guess we all must have super vision.

Numismanic

<< <i>I said that I would back off and take a short loss because it's not worth getting into a pissing contest over a small loss. >>



What constitututes a small loss?, not all of us collectors are millionaires. Ethics doesn't have a price!