Any opinion of J.J. Teaparty?

mademan

I saw something of interest but....you guys have me on guard about coin dealer--any info I need to know?---thanks Don

RYK

I AM A SATISFIED CUSTOMER OF GREG THE GREAT

They have ben in business a little bit longer than GTG and have a established a somewhat better reputation over that time.

fivecents

I've heard nothing but good things about JJ teaparty. Go for it!

MrHalfDime

I have been dealing with J. J. Teaparty for almost twenty years, and in my opinon they rank right on top of my favorite dealer list. Liz and Gail are two of the most congenial and pleasant people to deal with, and share an enthusiasm for the hobby that is contagious. I have been on both sides of transactions with JJT, as I have bought from them and sold to them, and find them to be fair and honest in all transactions. While it may be true that you can purchase coins from others at lower prices, at the end of the day, when you take time to sit back and appreciate your collection, the coins you purchased from JJT are the coins you will choose to keep. Some of the finest half dimes that I own came from JJT over the years. I can recommend them highly.

GAT

There have been posts, both pro and con, concerning this dealer. There was a recent thread slamming him over a coin.

PerryHall

Highly reputable firm. You shouldn't have any problems dealing with them.

PerryHall

<< <i>There have been posts, both pro and con, concerning this dealer. There was a recent thread slamming him over a coin. >>



I don't remember this post. Can you find it? Are you sure you're not confusing them with Blue Moon Coins?

Barberman55

Great company, one of my top 3 dealers!

rmoss

Won an item from them on eBay once, no complaints from me. good service, nice item.

RYK

There have been posts, both pro and con, concerning this dealer. There was a recent thread slamming him over a coin.

I cannot recall a single anti-JJ Teaparty thread. Search for JJ Teaparty in the archives and see what you find.

mirabela

Silver type coins seem to be their strong suit. That said, I bought a fantastic $10 Indian from them last summer. Their pictures are not flattering (although they're getting better), but I spoke with Gail by phone and with the coin in hand, she patiently described it down to a micro level, with if anything an overemphasis on its flaws.

I check their inventory often. While I haven't found anything else I need there yet, I would gladly buy from them again.

I've done a search on them here a few times before, and I can't recall a thread slamming them either. About the worst thing that's been said about them is that their pricing is geared toward the retail customer.

AlaBill

When I started back they were one of the companies I did a search of on this forum. I found nothing but good remarks.

dimples

Just bought a proof indian penny from them. Accurate description and a good price would buy again.

LeeG

Have never purchased coins from J.J. Teaparty. I agree with mademan that there was something fairly recently about a coin they listed on eBay I think. Can't remember exactly what the problem was though. Did a search and only found one negative post from back in March of 04.

CoinHusker

<< <i>I have been dealing with J. J. Teaparty for almost twenty years, and in my opinon they rank right on top of my favorite dealer list. Liz and Gail are two of the most congenial and pleasant people to deal with, and share an enthusiasm for the hobby that is contagious. I have been on both sides of transactions with JJT, as I have bought from them and sold to them, and find them to be fair and honest in all transactions. While it may be true that you can purchase coins from others at lower prices, at the end of the day, when you take time to sit back and appreciate your collection, the coins you purchased from JJT are the coins you will choose to keep. I can recommend them highly. >>

morgannut2

I remember the slam on Teaparty. It was an early issue with a very poor strike that looked AU but they were selling raw as mint state. They finally imaged the coin next to a no questions Gem, and it showed that Teaparty was right--this date was struck so poorly it appeared as wear but wasn't. The entire Forum here was wrong and several people posted that they were wrong. Teaparty gets top dollar for top coins, and finds original nice coins among series that are otherwise plagued with problem coins.

DrPete

JJ Teaparty is a very reputable and longstanding coin firm. They cater to collectors and are very easy to deal with. I've bought a number of coins from them over the years, mostly raw Barber half dollars. Only a few coins didn't meet my needs or expectations and returns and refunds were handled promptly and professionally. They get a lot of repeat business and have many loyal customers, rightfully so. I have not sold directly to them, but understand they are reasonable and professional at the buying end, as well.

They are an excellent dealer in it for the long haul and customer satisfaction is obviously important to them. Give them a try and I think you will be happy.

LeeG

Can any provide a link to their website. I've been watching their eBay listings, not much there. Thanks.

mademan

Wow- thanks guys--it is refreshing to here that the Good Guys are still out there. I will buy with confidence--thanks Don

Prethen

I just had my first purchasing experience with them and I was thrilled! Gail was great and very straightforward with me on coins I wanted her to look at for me. I look forward to finding another coin I want from their inventory.

MrHalfDime

J. J. Teaparty's website can be reached as follows:

http://www.jjteaparty.com/

BASEagle

Bought this 1909-S IHC from JJ Teaparty. It's in a PCGS VF35 holder. Price was a tad on the high side, but that's cause they are a retail coin dealer. Good service. No complaints.

Mike

BillJones

JJ Teaparty makes a strong effort to market high quality, properly graded coins at fair retail prices. You won't find any "rips" there, but what you will find are a lot of "keeper coins" that advanced collectors hare proud to have in their collections for a LONG TIME.

I know because some of my best pieces that I prize very highly came from JJ Teaparty.

geb209

Here's the bad thread someone referred to earlier in this thread:

JJTeaparty

I stand behind my one bad experience with the dealer discussed therein -- sold a proof coin as a business strike and, when notified of the mistake (which was, without a doubt, a mistake), relisted the coin as a business strike. Even the expert in the series agreed that it was a proof strike (worth considerably less than a business strike).

Barry

I find their prices to be a bit on the high side.

It's always interesting reading about the "slim margins" dealers work on, then see Teaparty and several others list coins for 30%+ over their purchase price at auction.

BillJones

<< <i>I find their prices to be a bit on the high side.

It's always interesting reading about the "slim margins" dealers work on, then see Teaparty and several others list coins for 30%+ over their purchase price at auction. >>



I know for a fact that Teaparty has a lot of overhead. They have a ground level store in Boston and a pretty good sized staff for a smaller firm.

dthigpen

While I've never purchased from them directly, a lot of nice coins in my collection have gone through their hands at one time or another. I've heard only good things about them.

RYK

I know for a fact that Teaparty has a lot of overhead. They have a ground level store in Boston and a pretty good sized staff for a smaller firm.

Should the overhead of the dealer (single man operation like BillJones vs. mega-operation like JJ Teaparty) influence what I am willing to pay for a coin?

DeepCoin

JJ Teaparty has been good to me. I recommend them highly. As has been stated you will not find their coins cheap, but they will be quality coins. They are one of the very FEW dealers I would even consider buying a raw coin from. This is the highest praise I can give.

BillJones

What people should really remember is that the INITIAL quality of the coin is the most important thing. You might pay a little too much for a coin in the opinion of some people, BUT if the coin is really nice for the grade you will make out in the long run.

BUT if you buy a CRAP coin to start with, it will always be crap.

And for the record, I purchased this coin from JJ Teaparty.

DJC

<< <i>I know for a fact that Teaparty has a lot of overhead. They have a ground level store in Boston and a pretty good sized staff for a smaller firm.

Should the overhead of the dealer (single man operation like BillJones vs. mega-operation like JJ Teaparty) influence what I am willing to pay for a coin? >>



Maybe. Experts don't come cheap, and paying a premium to deal with a firm who employs a very knowledgeable numismatist in your collecting area may not be a bad idea. That aside, though, I don't really want to pay a premium just so a large company can afford to redecorate their offices.


All that aside, I've had few (but always very good) experiences with JJ Teaparty.

Shamika

Yes, J.J.Teaparty are the real deal.

BobSav

You can't go wrong with them IMHO.

LeeG

Added to my list of favorites. I'll keep an eye on their listings. As we all know, prices on coins are all relative. I may buy a coin at X and you would have only bought it at Y. This works both ways. I normally don't buy coins thinking I'm going to sell them.

dorkkarl

teaparty is a jekyll & hyde operation, though mostly the good side is present. deal with liz, you'll find nobody better in the coin biz.

K S

WACoinGuy

<< <i>I AM A SATISFIED CUSTOMER OF GREG THE GREAT

They have ben in business a little bit longer than GTG and have a established a somewhat better reputation over that time. >>



Whatever happened to GTG?

atarian

i dealt with JJ once and i was very happy with the coin i bought , the service was good, they keep me posted on what is coming up, and gail even called after to see if all was good. the customer service is also very good if you have questions. 2 thumbs way up

mozin

Bought a few coins in the past ten years from Teaparty and have always been happy. When attending shows I always stop at their table and feel comfortable with them.

goose3

Can't say enough GOOD about them.

One of VERY few dealers I would never hesitate to buy RAW from.

One of very few dealers that ALWAYS has some nice KILLER key date coins!

Just got an email from Gail a few mins ago. They always put out NEWP emails which are nice to receive.

MFH

As everyone has chimed in with kudos, I'll do the same. You won't meet a better bunch of people than @JJTeaparty.

Aside from the coins they buy for inventory they have maintained my want list for about ten years. If you want to see what they have done for me, check out either my Barber Quarter set or the Barber Half Dollar set (on The PCGS Registry). Most coins were gotten from them, and that's because they always worked hard to fill want lists for their customers. I just can't say enough nice things about them. Both Gail and Liz were originally associated with Q. David Bowers's Wolfeboro, NH company and I knew and worked with Gail there as well. My first dealing with Liz was when I bought Bowers two volume Encyclopedia of US Silver Dollars ( she called me a few days after I received it to ask if I was pleased with it ! - a nice customer service follow-thru. ).

I have bought many coins from them and each purchase was pleasant; I have sold a few things to them as well and have felt fairly treated. Rarely have they been off the mark with their prices.

If you see something you must have and can't afford, they will work with you on a payment schedule; they are very flexible.

All I can say in addition to the other testimonials is ...the more you work with them, the more you'll work with them !

Also, its nice to see that Liz does post here once and awhile ...30 posts in three years ! I surprised she found the time !

I was sorry to hear that they won't be at the ANA this weekend. I can't remember when they missed a major convention.

relayer

orie

Purchased my first slab from them about 15 years ago at a show in Pittsburg.

Cameonut

I give them a thumbs up. I bought a number of raw coins from them over 15 years ago.

I have only slabbed one: a 1972 Doubled Die Lincoln that was sold as a MS63+. Came back from PCGS (5 years ago) as a MS65RD. I wish I would have bought more at 63 money!

fullerfun4

I have purchased from this dealer several times and I have always been satisfied.
Regards
Gary