vote on key dates

KUCH

If you had a chance to purchase .... which would you choose?
1928 Peace Silver Dollare MS60
or
1895 O Morgan in Good

BAJJERFAN

I mite be inclined to go with the Peace dollar even tho 60 is a lousy grade. The 95-o in circ is pretty common unless its exceptional for the grade.

PutTogether

Peace Dollar

While the 60 is usually an ugly grade, its not always so. Peace Dollar in general is just a better looking coin, and one I would enjoy owning more than the morgan.

Now if you're asking about future increase.......well, not sure.

mr1931S

I'd most likely go with the 1928, especially if buying for resale. Make sure any raw '28 Peace Dollar offered is authentic.

BillJones

If you twisted my arm, I be inclined to go with the Peace Dollar, but I don't care for either piece. Both of them are in undesirable grades. MS-60 coins are really ugly. The main advantage that the 1928 Peace Dollar has is that the coin’s price does not go down that much in the lower grades. Therefore I could sell that coin for a better price. Some collectors are always looking for lower grade examples of that coin.

Many dealers think that the 1895-O silver dollar is an overrated, overpriced coin in the circulated grades. The coin is a rarity to true Mint State, but there are lots of circulated ones around. Good is a very low grade for that coin or for any Morgan Dollar for that matter. As such I would not have much use for any Morgan in Good except for a REAL 1895-P or an 1893-S
.

fivecents

The Peace Dollar.

coincollector1989

I would have to say niether I'll take a 70-d Ken in 67. On the serious side I would take the peace dollar.

KUCH

Thanks for the responces. All votes were for the Peace Dollar. Interesting. But that was my inclination. I'm going for it.

kieferscoins

Peace dollar. Is it slabbed or raw?

Cameron Kiefer

etexmike

It's late but I'm going to jump in anyway.

Gotta go with the 28 Peace.

I think it will have an upside potential even at that grade.

-----------

etexmike

KUCH

The Peace Dollar is raw

Smittys

I'd go with the Peace dollar

Hedger

Peace man.

mgoodm3

Probably peace.

KollectorKing

Peace, bro

GoYankees

Peace, man.

WACoinGuy

I'm not into either series, but I'd go with the 1895-O Morgan. Why? Because an MS-60 Peace is going to have problems and have poor eye appeal (after all, that's what keeps it to an MS-60), whereas a coin in G-4 can have nice even wear and be very eye appealing.