Where would you grade this 1879 CC Morgan?

goldrealmoney79

Pics are a bit far out, but seller says toned and prooflike. I see some spots that could be wear or just inconsistent toning. Also wondering if its an old cleaning or just weirdly toned over the years.
More experienced eyes, where would this grade?
https://www.ebay.com/itm/285337697265?

johnny010

Cleaned
Harshly

gumby1234

I grade it ugly. Looks like it was dipped and rinsed improperly then retoned. 19 photos and not a good one in the lot.

nwcoast

I’ll take the handbag with all the lips on it! ;-)
All the incidental stuff in the background adds an interesting touch.

I agree with gumby1234 on the speculative history of this thing. Another dip would be a gamble I wouldn’t sign up for.

Tramp

Take it for melt price only. If it isn't counterfeit.

Other items for sale have somewhat decent pics so somethings up.

lermish

I would grade it in my home office under magnification and lights.

BillJones

One should have better sense than to post a coin photo with a hot spot in the middle of it. The coin has numismatic smallpox. Run away.

Soldi

"Where would you grade this 1879 cc ? " Gee, I think I would grade it about three inches above the tub of AT chemicals it came out of. Artificial toning always puddles and an expert coin doctor with better work can still get caught.

ricko

Terrible photographs... would not consider buying from those pictures. Cheers, RickO

kirkmink

@gumby1234 said:
I grade it ugly. Looks like it was dipped and rinsed improperly then retoned. 19 photos and not a good one in the lot.

^^^ This