Three coins for submission

dsessom

I have had these raw coins in an album for some time. I know they are not rarities, but just for fun, I thought I would post images and let everyone chime in on the grades, and any problems that I might have not seen that would prevent a straight grade. I bought them all at a local coin shop, if memory serves. Anyway, I am leaning toward submitting them to our host for grading. What do you all think?

joeykoins

Nice coins. The 1866 has some variety possibilities. RPD?
Classic coins indeed.
Good Luck!

OAKSTAR

Nice looking coins. Submitting for grading wasn't my first thought. My second thought was, they would be great for a type set.

dsessom

Any opinions on grades? My best guess would be;

1866 w/rays - AU50
1867 no rays - MS62 (or AU58) This one is a tough call.
1858 flying eagle - VF30

Walkerguy21D

Granted, you have the coins in hand, and I have images through cellophane, but I’m at XF40, AU 55, and VF 20.
I also agree that these look to be nice album coins and would leave them as such, but I’m also the same one wasting $ submitting large cents that wind up grading a half grade lower than comparable coins shown in CoinFacts, or worse, winding up in genny holders. So I’m in no position to judge….

MFeld

The obverse of the 1866 looks cleaned (though I don’t know if enough to garner a details-grade) and the 1867 looks AU.

ricko

I would put those coins in an album.... Cheers, RickO

MICHAELDIXON

1866-Cleaned obverse
1867-AU50
Flying Eagle-VF25 (might have reverse environmental damage)

Smudge

I would leave them alone.

pursuitofliberty

I'm at

1866 Shield EF40 shot 45
1867 Shield AU53 shot 55
1858 Flyer VF20 shot 25

Granted, this based on images taken through cellophane and I have no way to see some things, but that would be my WAG.

Great looking 7070 coins. Not sure I'd pay the fees to grade.

coinbuf

1866 - Cleaned
1867 - maybe cleaned, maybe AU55
1858 - VF something

Fine album coins, but I cannot see any reason to spend money on grading coins like this.