NEWP Toned Peace Dollar grade & color opinions
ifthevamzarockin
Posts: 8,902 ✭✭✭✭✭
I picked this one up a few weeks ago, thinking about sending it to our host for grading.
Opinions on grade and color are appreciated. 
3
Comments
Hmmmmm....I think I would go with QT.
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
Questionable toning, possibly cleaned too
The way the colors go right up and over “United” without changing or interruptions makes me suspicious that the toning happened quickly
Mr_Spud
More often a "tell" for Morgans and other coins with higher relief lettering than the Peace reverse. Mind you, I'd expect a Details grade too. Attractive coin though.
It’s attractive and I like it. I haven’t a clue as to the grade.
☺️ Beautiful blushing Peace however not too sure nor knowledgeable enough to call on the reverse 🤔
It’s attractive but I wouldn’t get it graded. IMO high chance it will get body bagged with questionable toning and cleaned details
I don’t necessarily see the reverse as QT, but I think the obverse looks cleaned. I’d say AU details. Nice coin, but probably not worth the sub.
Thanks for all the replies so far.
Not sure why everyone is saying cleaned?
Maybe I need to try another obverse photo.
Another obverse photo for better or worse.
I don't think it's AU, I can't really tell if it's cleaned or not, but I think the color is a bit off. In particular, that purple shade just doesn't seem right. My gut tells me it will get a details grade.
I think it's attractive, though I'd not feel confident in my ability to render an opinion re. OT vs QT.
She is a BEAUTY period! 😘
…. Just look at her hair
I think submittal will get you QT details... Other than that, a nice album coin. Cheers, RickO
I’ll go with 63+.
Martin
That's not a coin I would have bought raw. I did see two nicely toned Peace Dollars at Summer FUN yesterday. They were wicked expensive but they were also in PCGS holders which provides a little more confidence.
Looking for Top Pop Mercury Dime Varieties & High Grade Mercury Dime Toners.
Everything has a price. He didn't say what he paid.
Of course. It's the people that take the risk and buy raw that have the best chance at winning. Just not something I would have likely done in this case. Toned Peace dollars is a tough game to play.
Looking for Top Pop Mercury Dime Varieties & High Grade Mercury Dime Toners.
I'll play the contrarian as I do not find it attractive and think it has a high chance of a details or QT result, but let us know the result if you do submit.
My Collection of Old Holders
Never a slave to one plastic brand will I ever be.
Thanks for all the replies!
@thebeav "He didn't say what he paid."
Too much
@keyman64 "Toned Peace dollars is a tough game to play."
"It's the people that take the risk and buy raw that have the best chance at winning."
Yes, and if you don't play you don't win.
I rolled the dice with this one but I am a gambler and it's only money.
@coinbuf "let us know the result if you do submit."
For sure!
Even though the responses here are not the best there is a good chance I will send it.