CAC Approved Error 10c 1807 But...

lilolme

First nice 1807 dime with an error.

10c 1807 MS66 curved clipped planchet CAC approved
This is from HA Aug. 3, 2012 Cert # 24190649

https://coins.ha.com/itm/early-dimes/1807-10c-curved-clipped-planchet-ms66-pcgs-cac-jr-1-r2/a/1173-5086.s?hdnJumpToLot=1&x=0&y=0

Note: would not let me load the HA slab picture (Role thing is maybe/maybe not) but slab picture is at the link.
Slab label has Mint Error Curved Clipped (cac sticker over word) and MS66 with E4480.

But today the CAC website indicates that the cert #24190649 as 'no matching cert number was found'

PCGS cert verification for 24190649 has it listed as MS66 with no mention of the error.
TV below but no current holder picture however it is indicated as a new holder with chip.
.
https://www.pcgs.com/cert/24190649
.

So it appears that CAC approved the Error but now it is gone.

gumby1234

Odd because back then planchet were cut individually from the metal and filed to the shape if needed. I dont see how a curved clip could happen during the old minting process. I could be wrong here. Maybe somebody could explain it to me.

lilolme

@gumby1234 said:
Odd because back then planchet were cut individually from the metal and filed to the shape if needed. I dont see how a curved clip could happen during the old minting process. I could be wrong here. Maybe somebody could explain it to me.

.
Not an error type but that might explain why it appears to no longer be in an error holder but the same cert #.
It went from an E4480 to 4480 now.
Making more sense to me.
Kept the same grade a MS66 with the 'defect' that I will assume is (still) mint made.

ricko

Interesting... I wonder how they determined it was a mint issue... Cheers, RickO