I would like to get some feedback concerning crossover experiences with NGC. Recently my daughter submitted five (5) PCGS graded coins in error to NGC for crossover due to chipped holders. These included a 1890-S MS65+, 1891-S MS65 CAC,1892-O MS65, 1894-S MS64 and a 1895-S MS64.
All failed to crossover except the 1895-S. Even the 1891-S CAC did not cross. I can assure you these were all solid in their grade. To say the least I was shocked, and it has led me to question whether NCG is currently under-grading and undervaluing coins.
I would have understood if a couple had not made the cross, but the CAC? That would seem to indicate that the standard at NGC is above the CAC standard. Can anyone clarify or share the NGC standard? NGC simply refused to comment and was quite rude in the process.