GTG: 1884 O Morgan

bearcave

It's in a PCGS old blue holder. Just wondering if it would upgrade. I thought on Ebay it would, now I'm not sure.

coastaljerseyguy

MS62

jcping

AU55

nwcoast

62 seems about right.
Might even be 61, but 62 is my guess if I had to be nailed down.

gumby1234

Looks AU from the photos.

U1chicago

MS 62 ….cheek looks rough from that photo

It’s also a common date that doesn’t make sense to try to upgrade; you would need to get a 65 (if not a 66) to make it worthwhile (cover grading and shipping fees) and I don’t see it approaching 65 levels.

bsshog40

I'm with the 62 crowd. I think the reverse pulls it up from 61.

relicsncoins

62 seems about right.

coinbuf

50/50 shot it would grade as AU or MS62, without knowing the current grade its impossible to speculate on an upgrade. However there would be no financial reason to try this for an upgrade.

NumisOxide

62

fiftysevener

I don't see any rub or wear, just chopped up. I would rather have a nice AU 58 with original skin.

scotty4449

I think it's a 63

airplanenut

While it's chattery in the photos, depending on how strong those marks are I could see a case for a 63 at best, but a 62 seems pretty reasonable. Since even a 63 isn't particularly expensive, whatever holder it's in, I can't imagine sending it in for an upgrade would make financial sense.

CoinJunkie

63

AUandAG

That dog needs to stay in that coffin.

bob

bearcave

Yeah, you are right @AUandAG 😀

bearcave

It is in a 62 holder, I though it might up grade to a 64 but once I got it in hand.....

airplanenut

@bearcave said:
It is in a 62 holder, I though it might up grade to a 64 but once I got it in hand.....

Can we see the photos that made it look like a 64?

ricko

Late to the game... but 62 would also have been my guess... and no upgrade potential. Cheers, RickO

pursuitofliberty

Late to the party ... but when I looked before reading, I had it as a 62 also