1901 barber quarter grade
Matthew17
Posts: 76 ✭
Wanted to see if y'all think this is the correct grade for this coin. I thought it looked ok to me. 
0
Matthew17
Posts: 76 ✭
Comments
For what it is, yes
“We are only their care-takers,” he posed, “if we take good care of them, then centuries from now they may still be here … ”
Todd - BHNC #242
Net Graded from 35 IMHO.
40 was my WAG.....must have been down graded due to cleaning.
bob
Do you think 18 is a good deal? I think its not to bad.
It's not often that ICG gets one right.
18 is ok if that discoloring on the reverse is not environmental damage. Not for me.
For 18, if you are okay with the cleaning, it's not a bad looking coin. The reverse toning will have multiple colors in hand, and does not look cleaned necessarily. It has some meat left, for sure.
I also disagree with what was said about ICG. If you are looking at circulated coins, especially "details" coins, I think ICG has done a pretty good job with their consistency. All bets are off for Choice examples and Uncirculated material. Those require a good eye.
“We are only their care-takers,” he posed, “if we take good care of them, then centuries from now they may still be here … ”
Todd - BHNC #242
Yea I think they do a pretty good job on grading like you said on the ms65 and up I would be Leary especially on morgan dollars.
30 Details looks like a fair assessment for that coin. Not one I would purchase, but the price seems reasonable. Cheers, RickO
Thanks
A coin to be avoided. The obverse has been harshly cleaned. For coins like that the price needs to be more than "reasonable" it needs to be just plain cheap.
I'd pass due to the cleaning. To me it's worth the value of the silver in it is all.
bob
Seems decently graded. I'd pass
I like these kind of coins even though they have been cleaned.