Referred to this Forum for Expert Advice
Ra2377ven
Posts: 3 ✭
Good afternoon everyone I am brand new to the website and to the world of coins due to an inheritance earlier this year. (I posted earlier this morning), and a nice member referred me to this Forum and advised that I post a couple of pictures and start there to see what some of you had to say about them. Thank you so much for your time and if you do look at the pictures, any advice given I will appreciate and listen to.
Please note I did not want to go overboard posting pictures I'm not sure what the rules are so here are a couple of examples and two of them you'll see the backs of as well the pictures are a tad bit darker than the actual coins themselves I have not tried cleaning them or doing anything to them except keep them wrapped up and put away until I figure out the next move.
Comments
Spurrious-looking stuff. Morgan 1899 CC! A unique specimen!
Welcome to the forum!
Very sorry to say but all look like replica/counterfeit coins.
Some of the dates like an 1899 CC were never minted.
No genuine 1895-CC dollars were made, either.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Counterfeits.
That's a bad inheritance. Fake.
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
I agree with above that they are all fakes.
Collector
75 Positive BST transactions buying and selling with 45 members and counting!
instagram.com/klnumismatics
I can sort of feel your pain in realizing these coins are counterfeit, but if the Hobby interests you don't get too discouraged.
Definitely, without a doubt, all are poorly made fakes. Sorry...
mbogoman
https://pcgs.com/setregistry/collectors-showcase/classic-issues-colonials-through-1964/zambezi-collection-trade-dollars/7345Asesabi Lutho
That’s tough news to hear for sure 😔. Better days ahead.
Unfortunately someone got taken when they purchased all of these dollars. All are fakes, many have been discussed here extensively (CC's especially by me!).
Here is my advice, take all you inherited to a coin shop and have them all looked at for authenticity. Don't be in a hurry to sell anything until you have a lot more knowledge. Purchasing a RED BOOK OF US COINS has got to be foremost on your agenda. It will give you a lot of information and some pricing as well. The 2021 book just came out, get it.
Your relative got taken or collected modern fake US coins.
Welcome,
bob
https://www.ebay.com/itm/Whitmans-Official-Red-Book-Guide-of-United-States-Coins-2021-Spiral-Catalog/333559141278?hash=item4da9ac939e:g:aCUAAOSwvbZefSQf
Omg I am crushed, but I will do as advised and have an expert in person also look them over... This wasn't done by her on purpose-
believe me if there is a fake it's because her spoiled selfish b*tch sister did a swap out...
Oh man I am just heartbroken
Sorry
Feel free to post other coins here for opinions from the forum.
There are many good experts here.
IG: DeCourcyCoinsEbay: neilrobertson
"Numismatic categorizations, if left unconstrained, will increase spontaneously over time." -me
do not try cleaning them, as with authentic coins that will drop the value from 30-70%
the coins shown seem to be recent counterfeits coming from china, they are not even good.
I am not sure what relative you inherited them from and how long ago they were collecting.
I have no idea if an executor could have done a switch for you.
I believe they are all fakes as mentioned from above posters.
Unfortunately I also agree with the above opinions. Sorry.
They look fake.
Ok, so, you fell off your bike for the first time.
No judgments are made here in the sand box. Oh ya, Welcome to the sand box.
Photos are encouraged to support or just to clairify any questions you may have about your collection. (also no spell check)
No question is a bad question.
As everyone has said, they are all fake.
It's one thing to be fooled by decent fakes. It's another to acquire coins that have never been minted and be shocked they're counterfeit.
I hope you can settle the matter without breaking the family. Remember what matters more.
Lance.
Drop the 1895 CC and 1899 CC coins on a hard floor. These coins are obvious counterfeits. Listen to the ring tone made. If you have a circulated half dollar from the early 1960s, do the same. See if it's the same ring tone. If so, the coin is silver and is worth melt value (am guessing around $22). They are probably cast counterfeits, and if so, the ring tone will be different than that of a real silver coin.
Years ago, I was in Vietnam and I found a well made fake 1875 CC Trade Dollar. It even fooled many dealers. But the ring tone when it hit the floor gave it away, because it was not the same ring tone that you hear when you do this with a silver coin.
A modern skilled counterfeiter could not make this mistake, as if the metallic composition was right, the coin would have fooled many and have been worth at least $200.
@Ra2377ven.... Welcome aboard. Very sorry that you have to receive such bad news. Yes, they are fake coins. Might still be silver, that can be checked, but probably not. Cheers, RickO
Welcome to the forum. Though we did not have good news for you on the coins.... don't give up on the hobby. For sure, post photos of other coins you may have.... this site has experts who will give you great advice. The number of photos you posted this time is probably a good number without overwhelming; also not too many per day (there are no rules as to how many posts per day, but some people start not responding when post after post after post..... start showing up up and crowds everyone else off the page....)
Hopefully other coins you have will be genuine.
Even fakes have some value as fakes
I give away money. I collect money.
I don’t love money . I do love the Lord God.
To who?
Not modern ones, except if made of silver....bullion value.
The question for the OP to ponder is when did the family member obtain these coins?
If it was decades ago, then someone pulled the old switcheroo with these modern Chinese fakes.
If they were obtained more recently then the original buyer likely got ripped off at the time of purchase.