1901 $10 Newp.
Pedzola
Posts: 1,028 ✭✭✭✭✭
Saw this pop up on ebay and thought it might be a good fit for my 20th century gold type set.


I like it because it is relatively free of major distracting marks, and it has a bit of color modulation to it, which matches the look of other "keepers" in my set.
I have been keeping my eye out for a 65, but they seem to be either totally hideous or out of my price range. Lots of beat up 65s out there. Both my last 64 (which I already sold) and this new 64 both look better (in my humble opinion) than most of the 65's I've seen.
So... The sellers pictures shown above are ok but would prefer trueviews. I thought I might start a trend with OGH CAC coins in my set but I am thinking pro photos matter more to me than green labels. I am strongly considering sending these both back in.
Question is - just reholder so I retain the same cert number and CAC? Or try for a plus with a regrade?

Comments
Leave it like it is
Nice coin
To add to the discussion... can anyone help me understand the intricacies of grading gold between MS64 and MS65? I dont want to trash other peoples coins by posting an ugly 65 for comparison - but what is the threshold between the 2 grade levels? What am I missing that keeps this coin a 64 vs a 65 with many more marks on it?
Instagram
They are nice gold coins... but I am a gold bug and like gold in any form...
If they were mine, I would keep them as is...but I do not sell coins, so grade/stickers/labels do not mean much to me. Cheers, RickO
I recognize the old green holder brings a market premium. Primary reason for reholdering is to get better trueview images for my online registry set. I look at the pictures a heck of a lot more than I look at the coins.
Trying for a plus upgrade would offset value lost of the OGH and maybe bump me up a spot on the registry. Cac doesnt make much difference to me. My $5 indian I got reholdered for a trueview and never sent it back for a new cac sticker.
Instagram
There's nothing rare about an OGH, people act as if it's some travesty reholdering one like you're adding your own finishing touches to a famous painting or something. It's not a big deal lol
Very nice coin as well. You definitely have to be selective because there are so many 64s and 65s for this date and especially the 1901-S so there's no reason not to wait for a great one. No distracting marks and blazing luster are absolute musts for the date and it's hard to find both those at the right grade level. In general coins with blazing luster are too heavily bag marked for the grade and vice versa coins with mark free surfaces usually are dull for the grade in this series.
This is my example. Quite a few scattered hits but nothing distracting and the color and incredible luster more than make up for it in my opinion.
Leave it as-is and send it to someone who can take a nice photo of it in the slab. Better yet, invest a bit of $ in a photo setup, learn to do it, and be set for life when it comes to photos of your own coins.
Here's my humble example, in a holder that is more remarkable than the coin by a considerable margin. Luster is pretty nice though.
.
I would concur with others. Leave it as is. Nice coin
Nice eagles, I'd definitely remove those nasty green stickers though. Takes away from the beauty of the coin and even the slab itself. Congrats!
The whole worlds off its rocker, buy Gold™.
BOOMIN!™
Wooooha! Did someone just say it's officially "TACO™" Tuesday????
Retiring at 55, what day is today?
Great coin you have there, one of the nicer 65's I've seen. Would classify luster on mine as muted, in accordance with your observations. I admit I pay more attention to marks than luster, which can be harder to discern in pictures.
BryceM, I've thought about trying my hand at photography but I've got far too many expensive hobbies already. Cheaper for me to send a couple coins back for trueviews each year than buy a whole photo setup.
Instagram
Understood, but photographing coins is almost as much fun as collecting them to start with. My setup cost me about $1200 with the vast majority of that going to a good macro lens.
Nice coin!
I like your new coin. Congrats!!! As previously stated leave it alone. Unless it upgrades, which probably won’t happen, you are losing value. Even though OGH’s are not that rare there’s a mystique about them when you sell one.
There are many terrific photographers on these boards who can shoot your coins through their current holders. Alternatively, send the coin back to PCGS in the OGH and have PCGS take a TrueView image through the current holder. Simply get in touch with PCGS and get the details on the service where they don't remove the coin and shoot through the plastic (like any other fine photographer might do).
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
Does PCGS perform this service at the big shows where they set up? It would save the cost of round trip shipping if the True View can be performed at a show.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
I hope the original poster is very patient if he’s going to wait for a big show.
Great coin! Congrats.
I will sit on it a while. Could possibly still upgrade if I come across the right 65. @PhilLynott I'll trade you.
Instagram
If you do send them in, submit under reconsideration, that way if you get a + (or more) they won't change the number.
You will get a TrueView if they upgrade & you can have the "CurrentAmateurCollector" signs put back on.
They are very helpful if you want to sell them.
Of course if you re-holder the number/grade stays the same you get a TrueView & a bean voucher.
My Saint Set
Leave it alone and have someone photograph it
Latin American Collection
Green holder and sticker, a winner in my book. Leave it as is...
Here is a 65 for comparison. I had to pay up for this, considering the price jump from 64 to 65. I studied it well before buying it. I believe it’s a solid 65:
My YouTube Channel
Nice coins, leave as is.
Well that was short-lived. Found a nice looking 65 at a price I can live with. So for those of you who love the OGH the coin will be up on the BST shortly!
Will post the replacement once I have it in hand.
Instagram
$10 Newp?
So are you going to ask about $12 for it?
+1 for having it photographed in the current holder.
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
I look forward to seeing it!
What date?
My YouTube Channel
1901-S. Not going to post pics til I have it safely in hand. Should ship tomorrow, hopefully receive it by the end of the week. Biggest difference is the luster - looks like a shiny one. Will share as soon as I have it!
Instagram
Nice! I paid up for mine, but never once regretted it. It’s nice to have gem gold!
👍
My YouTube Channel
Really like the coin and the holder! While OGHs aren't rare per se, many people (myself included) just prefer the aesthetics of them. I do think the OP's coin is strong for a 64 and might even garner a plus if regraded. The luster may have been the limiting factor to 64. Hard to say definitively from photos.
Must really be a keeper if you already have it listed on the BST, and haven't even received it yet.
Lol. I have had it for a couple days. Coin looks better in hand than the pictures.
I have been looking for the right 65 for a long time - well over a year. I keep an eye on weekly auctions and ebay. I have bid on a couple and lost.
When this 64 popped up I looked at it hard and decided it was a great fit for my set and I could live with a 64.
Lo and behold, a few days later the perfect 65 popped up within my comfort level / budget. I just couldnt resist.
Timing was just coincidence. Been looking for a year and all of a sudden 2 decent coins show up within a week of each other.
The only thing that turned me off the 64 discussed here is the dilemma about reholdering it.
Now I can pass it on to someone who collects OGH. New coin has a trueview.
Instagram
.
All great original looking coins. 64 cac never disappoints.
Well the replacement arrived today. It is not CAC but it is a 65+, and I paid a price I can live with. Looks great in hand. Huge luster, nice color. I am going to STOP looking at $10 libs now!
Here is my type set:
https://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/type-sets/era-type-sets/20th-century-gold-major-design-type-set-circulation-strikes-1900-1933/publishedset/174178
I still think the original subject of this thread is a super coin for a 64.
It will be shipped out to a forum member soon.
Instagram
That baby is dripping with luster. Absolutely beautiful!
That new upgraded Saint is off the charts as well. Congratulations on a top ten set!
Wow! Superb upgrade!
My YouTube Channel