POLL: Which of These 58-D Roosie Dimes Do You Like Best? (GIVEAWAY Winner ANNOUNCED)

CoinJunkie

Giveaway has ended. Winner announced at bottom of this post. Anyone may now freely post to this thread.

Hi Folks,

This is a poll combined with a giveaway. You can participate in either, both, or neither.

First, the poll. Below are TrueViews of three 1958-D Roosevelt dimes I own, all graded PCGS MS67FB. I like all of them, although I'm still searching for the ultimate coin to fill that slot in my Registry set. The poll question is simply which of the three you like best: coin A, B, or C. You can choose based on any criteria you want.

Secondly, the giveaway. I will be giving away a different 1958-D Roosie dime, also pictured below. This one is only graded PCGS MS66, but has some pretty toning. Here are the rules for the giveaway:

1. To enter the giveaway, simply post once (and only once) to this thread. If you voted in the poll, you could simply post which coin you voted for and perhaps why, but posting anything here makes you eligible to win the giveaway.
2. The deadline to post and be eligible for the giveaway is 12:00 noon PST (Pacific) on Monday, January 6, 2020.
3. At or shortly after the deadline, I will determine a winner by generating a random number (using random.org) between 2 and the total number of posts as of the deadline. This is post #1. The first response will be post #2, etc. Whoever made the post corresponding to the random number generated wins the coin. Simple as that. NOTE: A second post from a member will be "invisible" for purposes of calculating the winner. A third post from a member will disqualify him/her for the giveaway.

Coin A

Coin B

Coin C

Here's the giveaway coin:

Thanks for your input, and good luck!

The winner was post #11. Congrats to @cecropiamoth ! Please PM me your address to receive the giveaway coin.

Tibor

My pick was Coin A , but my favorite is the giveaway coin.

Kccoin

coin A. thanks for the chance

Rob41281

That’s a tough one but I went with A.

AUandAG

I picked B. I think that President Roosevelt being the main focus just stands out! Beautiful.

bob

ParlousJoe

I like and voted for coin A because of the vibrant colors on the Obverse and Reverse, especially how the color on the MM makes it standout. Nice coins CoinJunkie and thank you for the chance at winning a nice looking coin as well.

Electricity

Voted A

privatecoin

A is a beauty.

Walkerfan

I picked B because I like the color scheme of it the best.

GRANDAM

Coin A looks best to me.

cecropiamoth

Coin A. It just 'pops' more to me than the other two.

Jeff

joeykoins

Like the Fonz would say, " A-A-AYE"! I chose A. Thanks for the chance. I like the circular color on both sides.

SkyMan

Definitely A.

Pretty coins. If I should be lucky enough to win the giveaway, please give it to a YN on these boards.

Mgarmy

A all day. Ty for the poll and contest
Happy New Year

Mdcoincollector2003

I picked coin A because that was my favorite toning. It reminds me of a sunset on a summer day.

Treashunt

All nice, but I had to vote for #1, or A.

bearcave

Coin A. All 3 look like what I had raw at one time. I like the giveaway coin as well. Happy New Year!

shish

Voted for coin A, love the toning. The original mint sets holders and Mother Nature have created many beautiful examples for us to enjoy.

Kliao

Coin A because of the very nice toning

Thanks for the chance

Namvet69

Being contrary, I love Coin C because I think it has the strongest FB. Peace Roy

Oldhoopster

I wanted to vote for coin D, but then realized it was the giveaway coin.

Can you guess that I'm not a heavy toning kind of collector

Thanks for the giveaway opportunity

blitzdude

@Oldhoopster said:
I wanted to vote for coin D, but then realized it was the giveaway coin.

Can you guess that I'm not a heavy toning kind of collector

Thanks for the giveaway opportunity

x2, Coin D

ajaan

B

HiBucky

A ... If buying I would have bought A..

Thanks

ricko

Coin C because it appears to have the best detail definition. Thank you for the chance at the giveaway. Cheers, RickO

Jimnight

My pick is C. Nicely balanced toning!

bushmaster888

All are nice but the great strike on C pushes it to the top for me.

radioman

my pick is B I like the tone.

BLUEJAYWAY

A for me. Like the color.

keets

Coin B for me. what could be better than an relatively tone free obverse portrait encircled by the money color, Green!!!

Smudge

B here. I like peripheral toning especially green.

fiftysevener

I like coin b color. Non full torch giveaway coin looks like best strike though

Bigbuck1975

A and B are Purdy, liked A better, thanks for the opportunity

OldGold

I voted B

JBK

Thx!

I picked C.

They are all nice but I liked the muted colors on the obverse.

JeffersonFrog

C for me.

johnny9434

I picked a

Smudge

Does anyone else think that the giveaway coin deserves FB?

BryceM

I voted A, but prefer the giveaway.

CoinJunkie

.

davids5104

Coin C is my fav

ponderit

I like them all but B wins my vote

ElmerFusterpuck

Leaned A, but liked B also. So A-

U1chicago

B drew my attention the most based on the colors surrounding Roosevelt.

If my post is chosen, I would also like to donate the prize to a YN.

golden

I voted for A.

TurtleCat

Of the three, coin A is the most appealing to me in the pictures. Reminds me of some mint sets I’ve seen over the years. Thanks for the opportunity to win one.

MonsterCoinz

A is the best and I like the early cert #

hchcoin

I like them all but the giveaway coin is actually my favorite look.

Al21

love the colors on A

islemangu

C for me...the details in the face come out best but

AlbumAccumulator

I like coin B.