<< <i>I guess I'm not sure why you are so shocked either. I would have a similar reaction as the dealer and I have seen many B&M dealers who treat high end moderns just like this (Though admittedly a "70" coin is scarce). I guess that doesn't excuse my ignorance or his, and as a dealer I suppose he should have known better, but as an advanced collector of moderns so, too, should you. This is a specialty field that does not appeal to some, perhaps many. From my perspective, with thousands of coins slabbed as 69s and with little or no difference between the two grades, I just don't see the value in buying a nice coin in a 70 holder whne I can get one which to my eye is the same, for about $25 in a 69 holder. >>
Lots of mom & pop dealers still believe it's foolish and a scam to have huge prices for very common modern non-circulating coins that almost always come perfect, or close enough to perfect that a $20 coin and a $2000 coin are indistinguishable to them or their customer base. >>
This is very true.
As has been said here many times ... crack that PF-70 Ike out and try and sell it. It's still the same coin, but not attached to the magical label. The slab provides "assurances" for many high-end modern collectors, but not all. Thus the uber-high prices for modern condition rarities is seen by some to be legitimate, but by others to be silly.
Edited to correct MS-70 to PF-70 ... big difference!
Numismatist Ordinaire See http://www.doubledimes.com for a free online reference for US twenty-cent pieces
Well that is interesting because today I asked a price on a rare coin 1871 Proof Seated Dollar in PR64 NGC and was quoted $7,500.........They thought it was a 65 and it was a low 64...... So the kind dealer really over quoted in my opinion.
The court jester does not play, but gently pulls the strings…
If you saw other PCGS MS70 Ikes that they were selling, and for what YOU would consider "reasonable" prices, then you shouldn't be surprised as not all (not most) B&Ms deal with moderns at any high level (from what I have seen). They do moderns, because people want them, but not the MS70/PR70 because that is a much thinner market and one that can't usually be supported by walk-in customers.
To that point, if you B&M doesn't have a web presence, or sell on ebay, and they just use the store, then I really am not surprised and am only surprised that you are surprised.
<< <i>All this defense of this dealer for offering $14.75 is a little too much... if the OP sold the coin to him for $14.75 you all know damn well he wouldn't have just put it in his case for a reasonalbe markup over his cost. Whether he knows the modern market or now, he would have done the minute or two of research and easily figured out it's a 4-figure coin and priced it accordingly. >>
It's all a matter of when the dealer does the research, before or after the rip.
<< <i>Lots of mom & pop dealers still believe it's foolish and a scam to have huge prices for very common modern non-circulating coins that almost always come perfect, or close enough to perfect that a $20 coin and a $2000 coin are indistinguishable to them or their customer base. >>
I think a lot of collectors also feel this way.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>How long did it take me? About 50 years of collecting experience in dealing with different kinds of dealers. >>
Really? That long? Just to be able to make up and then sarcastically comment on an argument nobody else is making? >>
Balderdash.
The most amusing thing about most B&M dealers is how they puff up their coins when selling, and disparage yours when buying. For those who doubt this, please consider doing the following experiment:
Go to your local B&M dealer and buy a PCGS slabbed coin that is typical of the dealer's stock. This may cost you a few hundred dollars at most. Crack the coin out and send it to PCGS for grading. After you receive the newly slabbed coin, wait a couple of months and then take it back to the dealer you bought it from and tell him you want to sell it. Compare what he says about the coin when he is buying it to what he said about the coin when he was selling it to you. It will be like day and night.
I agree with roadrunner's first post in this thread.
When I first saw 1976 PR70DCAM Ike, I thought 'wow, a 70, that is probably worth several hundred bucks.' When the dealer 'said' $1475 I thought to myself 'WOW, that seems like a big price from a local shop on a coin like that, he must have people that trade in that sort of thing come in all the time.' I was still amazed the coin was worth that much money.
When the $6000 figure came out, I realized that I had ABSOLUTELY NO IDEA what '70' coins are worth.
Still though, if someone were offering me one to buy, I'd probably pull up PCGS guide to have a look see.
I'm a car dealer, and occasionally, people come into the store with the random Rolls Royce, AstonMartin, or Ferrari to trade. I don't know the market of these type of cars like the back of my hand, but I KNOW that I don't know......and would tell the customer I need to do at least a modicum of research before I could make an offer. I wouldn't pull up a Blue Book or NADA guide and spit a random figure out. I can imagine some others that WOULD, and picture instances where they are seriously uninformed, and not necessarily thieves.
I'd then call other dealers, get a buy bid, and offer the customer somewhere between 1-5% less than the best REAL buy bid I got from other dealers. I offer less partially because when the other dealer comes to pick it up, they might start to pick at me for a few thousand for tires, dings, etc........and partially so I've got a cushion for error.......and partially for profit.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ That's exactly the point I was trying to make with my original post PutTogether. I wasn't saying the dealers was overtly trying to scam me, or that he should know that market, just that it was a funny conversation to be having with someone who should know better about what he was doing.
<< <i>It's all a matter of when the dealer does the research, before or after the rip. >>
If the seller does some research himself, the issue of a rip never arises. As has been posted numerous times, expecting to get a substantial offer for an esoteric item at a B&M is idealistic, at best.
^^^^^^^^^ Agreed, this wasn't supposed to be a thread about a dealer trying to rip off a collector. It was supposed to be a thread about a dealer not taking a second to check for a true value.
I don't expect anyone and everyone to know about high end Ikes or even be interested in them. But I would at least assume he would do some due dilligence to get an approximation of the coin's value. First, he ought to check the PCGS price guide for a rough estimate. PCGS price guide seems to be pretty close to the mark on PR70DCAM Ikes in my opinion. Then, he could go somewhere like Heritage and check aution history. He would quickly see that these coins regularly sell for $4500-$6500 there, and it is documented as such in their archives. Whether a dealer or collector agrees with modern coins having that value or not, the fact is that is what they sell for at auction. If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum, but my point is that he didn't even try to do some reasonable valuation inquiries that could have taken him only a few minutes and perhaps made him several thousand dollars in the process.
<< <i>BTW, as far as 69s and 70s being virtually the same......I have Ikes in 69DCAM and this coin blows them outa the water!!! It truly is a gorgeous coin with absolutely zero imperfections, and frost and mirrors exactly the way a top coin should be!! I can see the difference, for sure!
Greg >>
Can you post pictures of a 69DCAM and 70DCAM, and point out the significant differences?
The longer I live the more convincing proofs I see of this truth, that God governs in the affairs of men. And if a sparrow cannot fall to the ground without His notice is it possible for an empire to rise without His aid? Benjamin Franklin
I don't expect anyone and everyone to know about high end Ikes or even be interested in them. But I would at least assume he would do some due dilligence to get an approximation of the coin's value. First, he ought to check the PCGS price guide for a rough estimate. PCGS price guide seems to be pretty close to the mark on PR70DCAM Ikes in my opinion. Then, he could go somewhere like Heritage and check aution history. He would quickly see that these coins regularly sell for $4500-$6500 there, and it is documented as such in their archives. If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum, but my point is that he didn't even try to do some reasonable valuation inquiries that could have taken him only a few minutes and perhaps made him several thousand dollars in the process. >>
Which is one of the reasons why he is a local B&M dealer and not more successful.
<< <i>Then he proceeded to proudly tell me that he just took a bath on a PCGS Top Pop coin last week that was in the price guide for $12,000. He ended up selling it for $800 because "the market isn't that strong on top pop PCGS stuff right now". >>
Maybe you should have told him about this site and it's B/S/T forum.
<< <i>... but my point is that he didn't even try to do some reasonable valuation inquiries that could have taken him only a few minutes and perhaps made him several thousand dollars in the process. >>
People are free to run their businesses as they see fit. That you disagree with how they do it is immaterial- you don't get a vote on the matter. The reasoning for not looking the coin up is known only to the dealer. Still trying to figure it out? Unless you're willing to ask him directly, there's no point in worrying about it- that way lies madness.
<< <i>Which is one of the reasons why he is a local B&M dealer and not more successful. >>
How do you know he's not just as successful as he wants to be right now?
<< <i>If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum >>
<< <i>If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum >>
Was this just some type of exercise? >>
I don't think it was - but your question brings up an interesting idea.
What if a group of collectors got together and developed a check list for acceptable and unacceptable B&M dealer behaviors and then ran tests like this? The results could be published and it would help us identify the rotten apples among the B&M dealers. Part of the problem is that everyone has to find out for themselves how a specific dealer operates. It would be useful to have some kind of database of customer experiences and evaluations.
Sort of like Angie's list does for plumbers, electricians and house cleaners.
<< <i>If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum >>
Was this just some type of exercise? >>
Best I can tell from the quote you included, the seller woudn't have accepted what he called a reasonable offer. That only leaves unreasonable offers, and he apparently got one.
<< <i>If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum >>
Was this just some type of exercise? >>
Best I can tell from the quote you included, the seller woudn't have accepted what he called a reasonable offer. That only leaves unreasonable offers, and he apparently got one. >>
If it weren't for misquoting and taking phrases out of context, what would you talk about?
Most, if not all top grade modern coins are not worth anywhere near what the price guides say. If you want top dollar for your high grade moderns you need to find a dealer who specializes in those coins.
To most dealers that coin is worth $10 and anything above that is paying for ephemeral plastic. A PR70DCAM is worth more than $14.75 but not much more than you'd believe.
Follow me on Twitter @wtcgroup Authorized dealer for PCGS, PCGS Currency, NGC, NCS, PMG, CAC. Member of the PNG, ANA. Member dealer of CoinPlex and CCE/FACTS as "CH5"
<< <i>If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum >>
Was this just some type of exercise? >>
Best I can tell from the quote you included, the seller woudn't have accepted what he called a reasonable offer. That only leaves unreasonable offers, and he apparently got one. >>
If it weren't for misquoting and taking phrases out of context, what would you talk about? >>
There is no misquote, those are your words. I cut and pasted and asked a legitimate question.
<< <i>Go to your local B&M dealer and buy a PCGS slabbed coin that is typical of the dealer's stock. This may cost you a few hundred dollars at most. Crack the coin out and send it to PCGS for grading. After you receive the newly slabbed coin, wait a couple of months and then take it back to the dealer you bought it from and tell him you want to sell it. Compare what he says about the coin when he is buying it to what he said about the coin when he was selling it to you. It will be like day and night. >>
My local dealer would say the same thing he said when he sold it, and offer to buy it back at a very reasonable price relative to the original sales price. Subject to market conditions, of course.
<< <i>Go to your local B&M dealer and buy a PCGS slabbed coin that is typical of the dealer's stock. This may cost you a few hundred dollars at most. Crack the coin out and send it to PCGS for grading. After you receive the newly slabbed coin, wait a couple of months and then take it back to the dealer you bought it from and tell him you want to sell it. Compare what he says about the coin when he is buying it to what he said about the coin when he was selling it to you. It will be like day and night. >>
My local dealer would say the same thing he said when he sold it, and offer to buy it back at a very reasonable price relative to the original sales price. Subject to market conditions, of course.
Russ, NCNE >>
Then you have a great local dealer. Since you haven't had the experience, you may find it difficult to believe that all local B&M dealers are not as wonderful as yours.
I would like to try this experiment with 100 dealers across the country. Who wants to play?
<< <i>I was talking to potatoheadd. He seems to thrive on hyperbole. >>
I don't see what the problem is- I copied a copy of your own words, and responded to them. You said you wouldn't accept what you called a reasonable offer:
"If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum."
and I responded that if a reasonable offer wouldn't work for you, all that was left was unreasonable ones. Unless you know of any other options...
If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum, but my point is that he didn't even try to do some reasonable valuation inquiries that could have taken him only a few minutes and perhaps made him several thousand dollars in the process.
It's entirely possible your dealer was down this road before with high grade low pop moderns and found out that Heritage and others don't buy them for anything but a small fraction of PCGS price guide. To complete the loop on this and remove a lot of doubt, why not ship the coin off to Heritage to see what they would offer. They might even give you a number over the phone. It would be a most enlightening exercise.
<< <i> If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum, but my point is that he didn't even try to do some reasonable valuation inquiries that could have taken him only a few minutes and perhaps made him several thousand dollars in the process.
It's entirely possible your dealer was down this road before with high grade low pop moderns and found out that Heritage and others don't buy them for anything but a small fraction of PCGS price guide. To complete the loop on this and remove a lot of doubt, why not ship the coin off to Heritage to see what they would offer. They might even give you a number over the phone. It would be a most enlightening exercise.
roadrunner >>
I believe the suggestion was to put the coin in a Heritage auction, not to SELL it to Heritage. Big difference.
<< <i>Go to your local B&M dealer and buy a PCGS slabbed coin that is typical of the dealer's stock. This may cost you a few hundred dollars at most. Crack the coin out and send it to PCGS for grading. After you receive the newly slabbed coin, wait a couple of months and then take it back to the dealer you bought it from and tell him you want to sell it. Compare what he says about the coin when he is buying it to what he said about the coin when he was selling it to you. It will be like day and night. >>
My local dealer would say the same thing he said when he sold it, and offer to buy it back at a very reasonable price relative to the original sales price. Subject to market conditions, of course.
Russ, NCNE >>
Then you have a great local dealer. Since you haven't had the experience, you may find it difficult to believe that all local B&M dealers are not as wonderful as yours.
I would like to try this experiment with 100 dealers across the country. Who wants to play? >>
I've had experience with plenty of dirtbag dealers. My point is that, contrary to popular mythology, there are honest coin dealers.
I don't see why there is all the negativity over modern pieces. Yeah, they made a bunch more of say a 1976 Ike vs a common date Morgan, and yes, the chances of finding a bunch of said 1976 in high condition vs the Morgan is pretty good. But, a PR70DCAM Ike is still going to be very hard to find ungraded and worth the premium over a 69 imo. Ask someone like Wondercoin who I'm sure has searched through thousands of them.
Positive dealing with oilstates2003, rkfish, Scrapman1077, Weather11am, Guitarwes, Twosides2acoin, Hendrixkat, Sevensteps, CarlWohlforth, DLBack, zug, wildjag, tetradrachm, tydye, NotSure, AgBlox, Seemyauction, Stopmotion, Zubie, Fivecents, Musky1011, Bstat1020, Gsa1fan several times, and Mkman123 LOTS of times
<< <i>^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ That's exactly the point I was trying to make with my original post PutTogether. I wasn't saying the dealers was overtly trying to scam me, or that he should know that market, just that it was a funny conversation to be having with someone who should know better about what he was doing.
Greg >>
Why should a BM dealer know better? I bet you 99 to 1 that of you cracked that coin out and resubmitted it to PCGS it will not get that magical 70 grade again.
Awarded the coveted "You Suck" Award on 22 Oct 2010 for finding a 1942/1 D Dime in silver, and on 7 Feb 2011 Cherrypicking a 1914 MPL Cent on Ebay!
Every dealer has their nitch. When you offer them coins that are not in their area of the market, they will either make a low-ball offer, or they will decline to buy the item.
When it comes to modern Proof coins, I don't fault the dealer one bit. Most modern Proof coins are in high grade and are not rare at all. The only reason why a collector would pay a big price for a PR-70 DCam is for a registry set and the points involved. Otherwise they will be happy with an Ike dollar in a the mint package or a PR-69 DCam that will cost them a lot less money.
I'm in that camp. I bought the six Bicentennial coins (quarter, half dollar and dollar) in clad and silver clad in PCGS PR-69 DCam for $150. That paid the dealer a profit. Sorry guy, but if you think that a modern Proof Bicentennial Ike in PR-70 DCam is worth $6,000, you are not being realistic.
Retired dealer and avid collector of U.S. type coins, 19th century presidential campaign medalets and selected medals. In recent years I have been working on a set of British coins - at least one coin from each king or queen who issued pieces that are collectible. I am also collecting at least one coin for each Roman emperor from Julius Caesar to ... ?
personally I think you should go back there and see if there is a good deal in the case LOL .. check his Top pops and offer him those low prices with the same reasoning he gave you
Just remember; The longer a coin sits in a B/M dealer's inventory, the lower and lower the value of that coin becomes. I'm guessing there are very few walk ins looking for PF70 Ikes.
Need a Barber Half with ANACS photo certificate. If you have one for sale please PM me. Current Ebay auctions
<< <i>Just remember; The longer a coin sits in a B/M dealer's inventory, the lower and lower the value of that coin becomes. I'm guessing there are very few walk ins looking for PF70 Ikes. >>
About the same likelihood as a meteorite hitting the shop.
<< <i>I'm really not sure why I just read this entire thread. I'll probably not read it any further.
I'll just say it's quite amazing what numerical grading has bought about. >>
Just to be compulsive ... numerical grading has been around for over 50 years. It's not the reason for high prices for modern condition-rarity coins. >>
Nuts. I'm still reading it.
Numerical grading most certainly enabled it, and is a necessary, if not a sufficient, condition.
<< <i>^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ That's exactly the point I was trying to make with my original post PutTogether. I wasn't saying the dealers was overtly trying to scam me, or that he should know that market, just that it was a funny conversation to be having with someone who should know better about what he was doing.
Greg >>
Why should a BM dealer know better? I bet you 99 to 1 that of you cracked that coin out and resubmitted it to PCGS it will not get that magical 70 grade again. >>
That is a BOLD declaration Tdec1000. I will take you up on your offer at the odds posted, 99:1.
My $200 against your $19,800. Greg, if you are game, I'll split my profits with you if it regrades a 70. So you'd end up with the same 70 coin, AND $9900 cash.
Is anyone reputable willing to hold both bettors money as an impartial third party / escrow?
Tdec - If Greg (understandably) doesn't want to participate, can we do the same bet with any random PR70DCAM coin I buy? I'd be more than happy to purchase a PCGS PR70DCAM something crack it, and resubmit for the same grade @ 99:1 odds. If I have to go out and buy the coin though, I'd be looking to place a bet a little larger than $200.
Also, bet is only good if a reputable, been around a while, type forum member is willing to hold everyone's money for fairness impartiality sake. (Roadrunner, Bear, TDN, Russ, etc) The 'beyond reproach' type people on these forums.
<< <i>That is a BOLD declaration Tdec1000. I will take you up on your offer at the odds posted, 99:1.
My $200 against your $19,800. Greg, if you are game, I'll split my profits with you if it regrades a 70. So you'd end up with the same 70 coin, AND $9900 cash. >>
What if it doesn't come back as a 70? Are you willing to make the owner whole at PCGS trends?
Comments
<< <i>
<< <i>I guess I'm not sure why you are so shocked either. I would have a similar reaction as the dealer and I have seen many B&M dealers who treat high end moderns just like this (Though admittedly a "70" coin is scarce). I guess that doesn't excuse my ignorance or his, and as a dealer I suppose he should have known better, but as an advanced collector of moderns so, too, should you. This is a specialty field that does not appeal to some, perhaps many. From my perspective, with thousands of coins slabbed as 69s and with little or no difference between the two grades, I just don't see the value in buying a nice coin in a 70 holder whne I can get one which to my eye is the same, for about $25 in a 69 holder. >>
Lots of mom & pop dealers still believe it's foolish and a scam to have huge prices for very common modern non-circulating coins that almost always come perfect, or close enough to perfect that a $20 coin and a $2000 coin are indistinguishable to them or their customer base. >>
This is very true.
As has been said here many times ... crack that PF-70 Ike out and try and sell it. It's still the same coin, but not attached to the magical label. The slab provides "assurances" for many high-end modern collectors, but not all. Thus the uber-high prices for modern condition rarities is seen by some to be legitimate, but by others to be silly.
Edited to correct MS-70 to PF-70 ... big difference!
See http://www.doubledimes.com for a free online reference for US twenty-cent pieces
The court jester does not play, but gently pulls the strings…
To that point, if you B&M doesn't have a web presence, or sell on ebay, and they just use the store, then I really am not surprised and am only surprised that you are surprised.
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
<< <i>All this defense of this dealer for offering $14.75 is a little too much... if the OP sold the coin to him for $14.75 you all know damn well he wouldn't have just put it in his case for a reasonalbe markup over his cost. Whether he knows the modern market or now, he would have done the minute or two of research and easily figured out it's a 4-figure coin and priced it accordingly. >>
It's all a matter of when the dealer does the research, before or after the rip.
<< <i>Lots of mom & pop dealers still believe it's foolish and a scam to have huge prices for very common modern non-circulating coins that almost always come perfect, or close enough to perfect that a $20 coin and a $2000 coin are indistinguishable to them or their customer base. >>
I think a lot of collectors also feel this way.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>
<< <i>How long did it take me? About 50 years of collecting experience in dealing with different kinds of dealers. >>
Really? That long? Just to be able to make up and then sarcastically comment on an argument nobody else is making? >>
Balderdash.
The most amusing thing about most B&M dealers is how they puff up their coins when selling, and disparage yours when buying. For those who doubt this, please consider doing the following experiment:
Go to your local B&M dealer and buy a PCGS slabbed coin that is typical of the dealer's stock. This may cost you a few hundred dollars at most. Crack the coin out and send it to PCGS for grading. After you receive the newly slabbed coin, wait a couple of months and then take it back to the dealer you bought it from and tell him you want to sell it. Compare what he says about the coin when he is buying it to what he said about the coin when he was selling it to you. It will be like day and night.
<< <i>
<< <i>That's like taking a year-old Lambo to a "we buy cars" shack on Van Nuys Blvd.
<< <i>That's like taking a year-old Lambo to a "we buy cars" shack on Van Nuys Blvd.
Now THAT'S FUNNY!!!!!
When I first saw 1976 PR70DCAM Ike, I thought 'wow, a 70, that is probably worth several hundred bucks.' When the dealer 'said' $1475 I thought to myself 'WOW, that seems like a big price from a local shop on a coin like that, he must have people that trade in that sort of thing come in all the time.' I was still amazed the coin was worth that much money.
When the $6000 figure came out, I realized that I had ABSOLUTELY NO IDEA what '70' coins are worth.
Still though, if someone were offering me one to buy, I'd probably pull up PCGS guide to have a look see.
I'm a car dealer, and occasionally, people come into the store with the random Rolls Royce, AstonMartin, or Ferrari to trade. I don't know the market of these type of cars like the back of my hand, but I KNOW that I don't know......and would tell the customer I need to do at least a modicum of research before I could make an offer. I wouldn't pull up a Blue Book or NADA guide and spit a random figure out. I can imagine some others that WOULD, and picture instances where they are seriously uninformed, and not necessarily thieves.
I'd then call other dealers, get a buy bid, and offer the customer somewhere between 1-5% less than the best REAL buy bid I got from other dealers. I offer less partially because when the other dealer comes to pick it up, they might start to pick at me for a few thousand for tires, dings, etc........and partially so I've got a cushion for error.......and partially for profit.
Greg
<< <i>It's all a matter of when the dealer does the research, before or after the rip. >>
If the seller does some research himself, the issue of a rip never arises. As has been posted numerous times, expecting to get a substantial offer for an esoteric item at a B&M is idealistic, at best.
I don't expect anyone and everyone to know about high end Ikes or even be interested in them. But I would at least assume he would do some due dilligence to get an approximation of the coin's value. First, he ought to check the PCGS price guide for a rough estimate. PCGS price guide seems to be pretty close to the mark on PR70DCAM Ikes in my opinion. Then, he could go somewhere like Heritage and check aution history. He would quickly see that these coins regularly sell for $4500-$6500 there, and it is documented as such in their archives. Whether a dealer or collector agrees with modern coins having that value or not, the fact is that is what they sell for at auction. If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum, but my point is that he didn't even try to do some reasonable valuation inquiries that could have taken him only a few minutes and perhaps made him several thousand dollars in the process.
<< <i>BTW, as far as 69s and 70s being virtually the same......I have Ikes in 69DCAM and this coin blows them outa the water!!! It truly is a gorgeous coin with absolutely zero imperfections, and frost and mirrors exactly the way a top coin should be!! I can see the difference, for sure!
Greg >>
Can you post pictures of a 69DCAM and 70DCAM, and point out the significant differences?
<< <i>^^^^^^^^^ Agreed
I don't expect anyone and everyone to know about high end Ikes or even be interested in them. But I would at least assume he would do some due dilligence to get an approximation of the coin's value. First, he ought to check the PCGS price guide for a rough estimate. PCGS price guide seems to be pretty close to the mark on PR70DCAM Ikes in my opinion. Then, he could go somewhere like Heritage and check aution history. He would quickly see that these coins regularly sell for $4500-$6500 there, and it is documented as such in their archives. If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum, but my point is that he didn't even try to do some reasonable valuation inquiries that could have taken him only a few minutes and perhaps made him several thousand dollars in the process. >>
Which is one of the reasons why he is a local B&M dealer and not more successful.
<< <i>Then he proceeded to proudly tell me that he just took a bath on a PCGS Top Pop coin last week that was in the price guide for $12,000. He ended up selling it for $800 because "the market isn't that strong on top pop PCGS stuff right now". >>
Maybe you should have told him about this site and it's B/S/T forum.
<< <i>... but my point is that he didn't even try to do some reasonable valuation inquiries that could have taken him only a few minutes and perhaps made him several thousand dollars in the process. >>
People are free to run their businesses as they see fit. That you disagree with how they do it is immaterial- you don't get a vote on the matter. The reasoning for not looking the coin up is known only to the dealer. Still trying to figure it out? Unless you're willing to ask him directly, there's no point in worrying about it- that way lies madness.
<< <i>Which is one of the reasons why he is a local B&M dealer and not more successful. >>
How do you know he's not just as successful as he wants to be right now?
<< <i>If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum >>
Was this just some type of exercise?
<< <i>
<< <i>If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum >>
Was this just some type of exercise? >>
I don't think it was - but your question brings up an interesting idea.
What if a group of collectors got together and developed a check list for acceptable and unacceptable B&M dealer behaviors and then ran tests like this? The results could be published and it would help us identify the rotten apples among the B&M dealers. Part of the problem is that everyone has to find out for themselves how a specific dealer operates. It would be useful to have some kind of database of customer experiences and evaluations.
Sort of like Angie's list does for plumbers, electricians and house cleaners.
Who wants to take this on?
<< <i>
<< <i>If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum >>
Was this just some type of exercise? >>
Best I can tell from the quote you included, the seller woudn't have accepted what he called a reasonable offer. That only leaves unreasonable offers, and he apparently got one.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum >>
Was this just some type of exercise? >>
Best I can tell from the quote you included, the seller woudn't have accepted what he called a reasonable offer. That only leaves unreasonable offers, and he apparently got one.
If it weren't for misquoting and taking phrases out of context, what would you talk about?
To most dealers that coin is worth $10 and anything above that is paying for ephemeral plastic. A PR70DCAM is worth more than $14.75 but not much more than you'd believe.
Authorized dealer for PCGS, PCGS Currency, NGC, NCS, PMG, CAC. Member of the PNG, ANA. Member dealer of CoinPlex and CCE/FACTS as "CH5"
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum >>
Was this just some type of exercise? >>
Best I can tell from the quote you included, the seller woudn't have accepted what he called a reasonable offer. That only leaves unreasonable offers, and he apparently got one.
If it weren't for misquoting and taking phrases out of context, what would you talk about? >>
There is no misquote, those are your words. I cut and pasted and asked a legitimate question.
<< <i>Go to your local B&M dealer and buy a PCGS slabbed coin that is typical of the dealer's stock. This may cost you a few hundred dollars at most. Crack the coin out and send it to PCGS for grading. After you receive the newly slabbed coin, wait a couple of months and then take it back to the dealer you bought it from and tell him you want to sell it. Compare what he says about the coin when he is buying it to what he said about the coin when he was selling it to you. It will be like day and night. >>
My local dealer would say the same thing he said when he sold it, and offer to buy it back at a very reasonable price relative to the original sales price. Subject to market conditions, of course.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>Go to your local B&M dealer and buy a PCGS slabbed coin that is typical of the dealer's stock. This may cost you a few hundred dollars at most. Crack the coin out and send it to PCGS for grading. After you receive the newly slabbed coin, wait a couple of months and then take it back to the dealer you bought it from and tell him you want to sell it. Compare what he says about the coin when he is buying it to what he said about the coin when he was selling it to you. It will be like day and night. >>
My local dealer would say the same thing he said when he sold it, and offer to buy it back at a very reasonable price relative to the original sales price. Subject to market conditions, of course.
Russ, NCNE >>
Then you have a great local dealer. Since you haven't had the experience, you may find it difficult to believe that all local B&M dealers are not as wonderful as yours.
I would like to try this experiment with 100 dealers across the country. Who wants to play?
<< <i>I was talking to potatoheadd. He seems to thrive on hyperbole. >>
I don't see what the problem is- I copied a copy of your own words, and responded to them. You said you wouldn't accept what you called a reasonable offer:
"If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum."
and I responded that if a reasonable offer wouldn't work for you, all that was left was unreasonable ones. Unless you know of any other options...
edited... hit enter too soon.
It's entirely possible your dealer was down this road before with high grade low pop moderns and found out that Heritage and others don't buy them for anything but a small fraction of
PCGS price guide. To complete the loop on this and remove a lot of doubt, why not ship the coin off to Heritage to see what they would offer. They might even give you a number over
the phone. It would be a most enlightening exercise.
roadrunner
<< <i> If he had made me a reasonable offer of say $2500 and I had accepted, he could simply mail it off to heritage and expect to make a tidy $2000-$4000 for little to no effort. Of course, I wouldn't settle for that low of a sum, but my point is that he didn't even try to do some reasonable valuation inquiries that could have taken him only a few minutes and perhaps made him several thousand dollars in the process.
It's entirely possible your dealer was down this road before with high grade low pop moderns and found out that Heritage and others don't buy them for anything but a small fraction of
PCGS price guide. To complete the loop on this and remove a lot of doubt, why not ship the coin off to Heritage to see what they would offer. They might even give you a number over
the phone. It would be a most enlightening exercise.
roadrunner >>
I believe the suggestion was to put the coin in a Heritage auction, not to SELL it to Heritage. Big difference.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Go to your local B&M dealer and buy a PCGS slabbed coin that is typical of the dealer's stock. This may cost you a few hundred dollars at most. Crack the coin out and send it to PCGS for grading. After you receive the newly slabbed coin, wait a couple of months and then take it back to the dealer you bought it from and tell him you want to sell it. Compare what he says about the coin when he is buying it to what he said about the coin when he was selling it to you. It will be like day and night. >>
My local dealer would say the same thing he said when he sold it, and offer to buy it back at a very reasonable price relative to the original sales price. Subject to market conditions, of course.
Russ, NCNE >>
Then you have a great local dealer. Since you haven't had the experience, you may find it difficult to believe that all local B&M dealers are not as wonderful as yours.
I would like to try this experiment with 100 dealers across the country. Who wants to play? >>
I've had experience with plenty of dirtbag dealers. My point is that, contrary to popular mythology, there are honest coin dealers.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ That's exactly the point I was trying to make with my original post PutTogether. I wasn't saying the dealers was overtly trying to scam me, or that he should know that market, just that it was a funny conversation to be having with someone who should know better about what he was doing.
Greg >>
Why should a BM dealer know better? I bet you 99 to 1 that of you cracked that coin out and resubmitted it to PCGS it will not get that magical 70 grade again.
Successful BST Transactions!SIconbuster, Meltdown, Mission16, slothman2000, RGjohn, braddick, au58lover, allcoinsrule, commemdude, gerard, lablade, PCcoins, greencopper, kaz, tydye, cucamongacoin, mkman123, SeaEaglecoins, Doh!, AnkurJ, Airplanenut, ArizonaJack, JJM,Tee135,LordMarcovan, Swampboy, piecesofme, Ahrensdad,
When it comes to modern Proof coins, I don't fault the dealer one bit. Most modern Proof coins are in high grade and are not rare at all. The only reason why a collector would pay a big price for a PR-70 DCam is for a registry set and the points involved. Otherwise they will be happy with an Ike dollar in a the mint package or a PR-69 DCam that will cost them a lot less money.
I'm in that camp. I bought the six Bicentennial coins (quarter, half dollar and dollar) in clad and silver clad in PCGS PR-69 DCam for $150. That paid the dealer a profit. Sorry guy, but if you think that a modern Proof Bicentennial Ike in PR-70 DCam is worth $6,000, you are not being realistic.
<< <i>Sorry guy, but if you think that modern a Proof Bicentennial Ike in PR-70 DCam is worth $6,000, you are not being realistic. >>
It's worth a lot more than 15 bucks.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>Just remember; The longer a coin sits in a B/M dealer's inventory, the lower and lower the value of that coin becomes. I'm guessing there are very few walk ins looking for PF70 Ikes. >>
About the same likelihood as a meteorite hitting the shop.
<< <i>That's like taking a year-old Lambo to a "we buy cars" shack on Van Nuys Blvd.
Yeah ... even the "we buy cars" guys know to stay away from used Lambos.
See http://www.doubledimes.com for a free online reference for US twenty-cent pieces
I'll just say it's quite amazing what numerical grading has bought about.
Ed. S.
(EJS)
<< <i>I'm really not sure why I just read this entire thread. I'll probably not read it any further.
I'll just say it's quite amazing what numerical grading has bought about. >>
Just to be compulsive ... numerical grading has been around for over 50 years. It's not the reason for high prices for modern condition-rarity coins.
See http://www.doubledimes.com for a free online reference for US twenty-cent pieces
<< <i>
<< <i>I'm really not sure why I just read this entire thread. I'll probably not read it any further.
I'll just say it's quite amazing what numerical grading has bought about. >>
Just to be compulsive ... numerical grading has been around for over 50 years. It's not the reason for high prices for modern condition-rarity coins. >>
Nuts. I'm still reading it.
Numerical grading most certainly enabled it, and is a necessary, if not a sufficient, condition.
Ed. S.
(EJS)
<< <i>
<< <i>^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ That's exactly the point I was trying to make with my original post PutTogether. I wasn't saying the dealers was overtly trying to scam me, or that he should know that market, just that it was a funny conversation to be having with someone who should know better about what he was doing.
Greg >>
Why should a BM dealer know better? I bet you 99 to 1 that of you cracked that coin out and resubmitted it to PCGS it will not get that magical 70 grade again. >>
That is a BOLD declaration Tdec1000. I will take you up on your offer at the odds posted, 99:1.
My $200 against your $19,800. Greg, if you are game, I'll split my profits with you if it regrades a 70. So you'd end up with the same 70 coin, AND $9900 cash.
Is anyone reputable willing to hold both bettors money as an impartial third party / escrow?
Tdec - If Greg (understandably) doesn't want to participate, can we do the same bet with any random PR70DCAM coin I buy? I'd be more than happy to purchase a PCGS PR70DCAM something crack it, and resubmit for the same grade @ 99:1 odds. If I have to go out and buy the coin though, I'd be looking to place a bet a little larger than $200.
Also, bet is only good if a reputable, been around a while, type forum member is willing to hold everyone's money for fairness impartiality sake. (Roadrunner, Bear, TDN, Russ, etc) The 'beyond reproach' type people on these forums.
Let me know,
Eric
<< <i> My $200 against your $19,800. >>
That's a big risk your taking, very bold.
<< <i>That is a BOLD declaration Tdec1000. I will take you up on your offer at the odds posted, 99:1.
My $200 against your $19,800. Greg, if you are game, I'll split my profits with you if it regrades a 70. So you'd end up with the same 70 coin, AND $9900 cash. >>
What if it doesn't come back as a 70? Are you willing to make the owner whole at PCGS trends?
Not betting- just curious...
Cracking out a 70 and hoping to get that grade again is less than 99 to 1.
It might take 3 years to prove it
All that said, it still has some solid value as a 70. Someone will want it for a registry set at some point in time.
Ike Specialist
Finest Toned Ike I've Ever Seen, been looking since 1986
Now, if you had walked into the store with a High Relief $20 in XF40, $6000 would have been a fair offer.
TRUTH