Options
Banks to Restrict Public Ordering Nickel Cases?
As the melt value approaches 1.5 x face for Jefferson Nickels, there is an interesting article suggesting the FED is starting to limit banks from ordering boxes of nickel rolls. He suggest that if the metal value were to exceed 2 x face, the Mint would stop production all together. Could this situation make for a very low mintage for the 2011 Jefferson Nickels? I remember the last time this occurred back in 2008, BU nickel rolls were selling at a big premium.
Nickels as an inflation hedge
Nickels as an inflation hedge
0
Comments
it's scarce so will hoarde it.
Perhaps it's a rumor put out by the zinc industry to cause massive minting of
mountains of pennies.
It's not only the extra polution and energy required by five pennies but extra handling
and transportation costs. Higher minting costs and total cost as well are factors. Five
pennies require more time to count. Without nickels we'll get as many as nine pennies
back when we buy something. Since mintages will have to increase sharply they'll be
able to utilize the new equipment already installed for pennies at the mint. At least
most of these "coins" will be shiny and new rather than the eroded little slugs usually
seen in circulation. The zinc mine owners make more money and the world gets dirtier.
Of course they might "solve" all these problems by giving us a zinc nickel which will
nearly evaporate in circulation because nickels actually get used a little and zinc can't
stand up to being used. It is the worst of all coinage metals except as a galvanize
for steel then it's only among the worst.
Typical “wing nut” garbage built around one or two facts and aimed at weak thinkers.
<< <i>The internet thrives on garbage information such as this. Cheers, RickO >>
yes it certainly does
Nickels - with the exception of
WarNicks....
<< <i>Typical “wing nut” garbage built around one or two facts and aimed at weak thinkers. >>
I love your candor!
The name is LEE!
<< <i>NICKEL PRODUCTION 2009-2011
2009:
DENVER---- 46.80M
PHILADELPHIA---- 39.84
2010:
DENVER---- 229.92M
PHILADELPHIA---- 260.64M
2011:
DENVER---- 77.28M
PHILADELPHIA---- 15.84M >>
<< <i>Don't forget it's illegal to melt
Nickels - with the exception of
WarNicks.... >>
The expectation of nickel hoarders is that once the composition is changed, the ban on melting nickels will eventually be lifted.
expectation, in my view.
<< <i>I don't think that's a reasonable
expectation, in my view. >>
<< <i>I don't think that's a reasonable
expectation, in my view. >>
The reason for the current melting ban on nickels and cents are the higher production costs for the mint to replace pennies and nickels than the face value of the coins, similar to when silver was removed from quarters and dimes in 1965. It's not illegal to melt 90% or 40% silver coins so, if the composition is changed, why should it be illegal to melt pennies and nickels?
P.S. My wife wanted me to tell you all she still doesn't care and is mad as $%#* that one coat closet floor is filled with BU bags of Lincolns from 1959-1981 (original, sealed mint bags) and even more p%%&##d the other closet is fuller with circulated date bags of nickels from 1935-1959 and BU bags from 1960-1996, BU mint or bank sealed BU bags!
Diplomacy is what it takes to get out of what tact would have kept you out of.
<< <i>There was a brief ban in the late 1960s on melting 90% silver coins. They still traded at a premium at this time, but a bit less than their melt value, if I recall correctly. The ban was lifted once a sufficient quantity of clad coins reached circulation. >>
That would make sense. Anybody know how quickly the silver coins disappeared from circulation once the clad replacements were announced ? I know you can still find 90% and 40% halves today, but halves never circulated much.
It seems crazy to me that a widely hoarded modern nickel with a mintage of 40 million is selling for $30 a roll, while the 1959-P nickel with a mintage of 27 million is selling for $10 or less per uncirculated roll.
Even the 1955-P nickel, with a mintage of about 8 million - one-fifth the mintage of the 2009-P - can be bought for less than $25 per uncirculated roll. What's so special about the 2009 nickels?
<< <i>
<< <i>There was a brief ban in the late 1960s on melting 90% silver coins. They still traded at a premium at this time, but a bit less than their melt value, if I recall correctly. The ban was lifted once a sufficient quantity of clad coins reached circulation. >>
That would make sense. Anybody know how quickly the silver coins disappeared from circulation once the clad replacements were announced ? I know you can still find 90% and 40% halves today, but halves never circulated much. >>
I was still finding a few silver dimes and quarters in each roll through about 1971-72. After that time they would turn up in change very infrequently.
So if they drop nickels and cents it gets more complicated.
New math books will say:
Johny is buying a pack of gum for $1.04 what's the best way to pay?
a) 2 dollar coins and get back 3 quarters and 2 dimes
b) 3 quarters and 3 dimes
c) 1 quarter and 8 dimes
d) 5 quarters and get 2 dimes back.
e) all of the above
f) none of the above
------------------------------------------------
Don't cheat!!!!!
No cheating!!!!!
-----------------------------------------------
Answer:
f) none of the above, a Visa card would be 1 cent cheaper.
<< <i><< 2009-P BU Jefferson bank rolls are selling for $30 or more plus shipping on eBay >>
It seems crazy to me that a widely hoarded modern nickel with a mintage of 40 million is selling for $30 a roll, while the 1959-P nickel with a mintage of 27 million is selling for $10 or less per uncirculated roll.
Even the 1955-P nickel, with a mintage of about 8 million - one-fifth the mintage of the 2009-P - can be bought for less than $25 per uncirculated roll. What's so special about the 2009 nickels? >>
I'm not sure why but perhaps it's because the 2009-P is currently the lowest mintage Jefferson nickel with the new front facing portrait on the obverse? If there is a composition change, all BU nickel roll prices may go up (especially the keys?) from the increased attention. If the 2011-P total remains low, there will be a lot of demand for BU rolls of the last (real) nickel as well.
<< <i>2009-P BU Jefferson bank rolls are selling for $30 or more plus shipping on eBay so one thing is for sure, anyone hoarding boxes of 2011-P Jefferson nickels is potentially setting themselves up for a 1500%+ profit if the current production total stays below the 2009-P. It cost the mint more than 2x face in production costs so there is little incentive for them to crank out millions of nickels at loss for each one produced in addition to the billions of pennies they produce at a loss as well.
<< <i>NICKEL PRODUCTION 2009-2011
2009:
DENVER---- 46.80M
PHILADELPHIA---- 39.84
2010:
DENVER---- 229.92M
PHILADELPHIA---- 260.64M
2011:
DENVER---- 77.28M
PHILADELPHIA---- 15.84M >>
>>
Successful Trades: Swampboy,
<< <i>Even if the composition changes, most people will not even notice or care as the new coins will "look" the same as the old. Most are unaware that the cent is mostly zinc and has been since 1982. So if the nickel is still silver in color, the old ones will continue to circulate. Unlike silver and gold, the media is not talking up the benefits of holding copper. >>
Exactly.
So most people including doctors are not aware of the grave risks faced by small
mammals like dogs and infants who swallow a penny.
I'd like to see them switch the nickel to aluminum and this is something most folks
would notice.
<< <i>People said if they discontinued cents then everything would round to the nearest 5 cents.
So if they drop nickels and cents it gets more complicated.
New math books will say:
Johny is buying a pack of gum for $1.04 what's the best way to pay?
a) 2 dollar coins and get back 3 quarters and 2 dimes
b) 3 quarters and 3 dimes
c) 1 quarter and 8 dimes
d) 5 quarters and get 2 dimes back.
e) all of the above
f) none of the above
------------------------------------------------
Don't cheat!!!!!
No cheating!!!!!
-----------------------------------------------
Answer:
f) none of the above, a Visa card would be 1 cent cheaper. >>
If they dropped nickels and cents, wouldn't this go to a buck?
In the meantime, since the mintage numbers are so low, can anyone spare 4 each 2011 "P" and "D" nickels, so I at least don't get shut out from keeping our now-valuable blue Whitman folder nickel collections up-to-date?
- - Dave
Hoard the keys.
<< <i>...If the metal value of a copper cent ever becomes 3¢... >>
Coinflation has the current value of a copper cent at 2.94 cents and that value has exceeded 3.00 cents in recent weeks.
I'll break even on all those '04, '05, & '06 rolls I bought from the mint ! ! !
HH
1947-P & D; 1948-D; 1949-P & S; 1950-D & S; and 1952-S.
Any help locating any of these OBW rolls would be gratefully appreciated!
2009p buy it now
Ahhh..ok i see the difference now..