<< <i>I cracked out an ms 65 Flying Eagle cent out of a PCGS Secure holder. It came back in a genuine holder (98) because of tooling or altered surfaces. >>
Maybe you shouldn't have carved the eagle into a ... *ahem* ... well, you know what certain 19th century wags would recarve those eagles into.
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.
My guess is, that unless Stewart is under a gag order, if he didn't or doesn't get the situation resolved to his satisfaction, he will be extremely vocal about it. So, unless or until we hear a lot of noise from him, it means that either no decision has been made, or that things have gone his way.
<< <i>My guess is, that unless Stewart is under a gag order, if he didn't or doesn't get the situation resolved to his satisfaction, he will be extremely vocal about it. So, unless or until we hear a lot of noise from him, it means that either no decision has been made, or that things have gone his way. >>
When this thread first started it raised some serious questions relative to the merits of Secure Plus grading. If the answers to those questions hadn't been acknowledged to have been of some sort in the public interest, this whole matter should have been addressed privately. Tell us what happened...it's been three months...geeze!
<< <i>Everyone here knows PCGS can sit in session for a while.
I'd be very careful what you say to the person you are asking to be kind enough to supply info good or bad. >>
Now that's the same person who was "kind" enough to start this thread and make a public spectacle out of this whole matter, right? I'm just trying to understand.
Comments
Buying top quality Seated Dimes in Gem BU and Proof.
Buying great coins - monster eye appeal only.
either the coin had a problem from the start or
the coin had no problem from the start or
the coin did not have a problem but now it does
Where are the pics of this flyer.
Has it been doctored and, if so, by whom?
Who shot JR?
RMR: 'Wer, wenn ich schriee, hörte mich denn aus der Engel Ordnungen?'
CJ: 'No one!' [Ain't no angels in the coin biz]
it could be PCGS bought the coin back and that's the end of the story .........
<< <i>glad another brave soldier brought this back to the top -
it could be PCGS bought the coin back and that's the end of the story ......... >>
why would PCGS ever buy an uncertified coin back??
Michael Kittle Rare Coins --- 1908-S Indian Head Cent Grading Set --- No. 1 1909 Mint Set --- Kittlecoins on Facebook --- Long Beach Table 700
nothing sez they can't buy whatever they want ........
it would be a very fitting way to make the whole issue go away .......
<< <i>I cracked out an ms 65 Flying Eagle cent out of a PCGS Secure holder. It came back in a genuine holder (98) because of tooling or altered surfaces. >>
Maybe you shouldn't have carved the eagle into a ... *ahem* ... well, you know what certain 19th century wags would recarve those eagles into.
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.
<< <i>why would PCGS ever buy an uncertified coin back??
nothing sez they can't buy whatever they want ........
it would be a very fitting way to make the whole issue go away ....... >>
I can crack out some coins that should have 70'd !
I'll just keep posting here until "I'm heard."
I had been WONDERING what transpired here.
I hope that he can at least put this issue to rest after starting this and 400+ comments.
<< <i>My guess is, that unless Stewart is under a gag order, if he didn't or doesn't get the situation resolved to his satisfaction, he will be extremely vocal about it. So, unless or until we hear a lot of noise from him, it means that either no decision has been made, or that things have gone his way.
When this thread first started it raised some serious questions relative to the merits of Secure Plus grading. If the answers to those questions hadn't been acknowledged to have been of some sort in the public interest, this whole matter should have been addressed privately. Tell us what happened...it's been three months...geeze!
I'd be very careful what you say to the person you are asking to be kind enough to supply info good or bad.
<< <i>Everyone here knows PCGS can sit in session for a while.
I'd be very careful what you say to the person you are asking to be kind enough to supply info good or bad. >>
Now that's the same person who was "kind" enough to start this thread and make a public spectacle out of this whole matter, right? I'm just trying to understand.
Low and Behold
I just got a package from PCGS and inside is an 1857 Flying Eagle Cent graded MS 65 DDO S-4 in a Secure Plus holder
No Explanation and no upgrade
Across the country from Boston to Baltimore,New York to Tampa,Back to Newport Beach and presently resting in New York
Do you think I should crack her out again and try for an upgrade ?
Stewart
It was a long road ........
and it would seem to me you were victorious , and vindicated , and right all along ......... and no - I sure would not crack it out !
<< <i>Low and Behold
I just got a package from PCGS and inside is an 1857 Flying Eagle Cent graded MS 65 DDO S-4 in a Secure Plus holder
No Explanation and no upgrade
Across the country from Boston to Baltimore,New York to Tampa,Back to Newport Beach and presently resting in New York
Do you think I should crack her out again and try for an upgrade ?
Stewart >>
So did you ever crack it out and try it again???
Michael Kittle Rare Coins --- 1908-S Indian Head Cent Grading Set --- No. 1 1909 Mint Set --- Kittlecoins on Facebook --- Long Beach Table 700