Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

1958 PCGS MS65 Franklin : $3800.00 ?

Here is your big chance , to be somebody - to rise to notoriety beyond your wildest dreams in the kingdom of the mighty , mighty Franklin Half Dollar ;

here is the picture when it sold @ Teletrade : MOST INCREADABLE COLOR TONED 1958 IN EXISTANCE !







" 1958-P

EVEREST

Picture


FRANKLIN PCGS MS 65. OFF THE CHARTS! ONLY THE MOST SPCTACULAR COLOR TONED 1958-P I HAVE EVER SEEN!!!!! This is the finest color toned mint state 1958-P Franklin I have ever come across. Both obverse and reverse are decked out in INSANE electric-blue toning. Adding to the beauty is this phenomenal intense bright purple tone that shines through the incredible electric-blue toning. The surfaces are extremely clean and the eye-appeal is top drawer! If I had this coin in my possession just a month earlier I would have this incredible specimen in my new book due out at the end of November. If you want to own the most incredible color toned 1958-p in existence, don't pass this gem up. Amazing! 1-2-4

$ 3800 " - R. Tomaska



would any Franklin collectors like to comment on this coin ?
«1

Comments

  • Options
    mrdqmrdq Posts: 1,186 ✭✭✭
    not with a 10 foot pole.

    --------T O M---------

    -------------------------
  • Options
    JCMhoustonJCMhouston Posts: 5,306 ✭✭✭
    He gets to ask whatever he wants. But he might have to ask it a long time.
  • Options
    coinguy1coinguy1 Posts: 13,484 ✭✭✭
    Hypothetically, if he sells it for that, I wonder what his buy-back price would be, a year later, in an unchanged market?
  • Options


    << <i>Hypothetically, if he sells it for that, I wonder what his buy-back price would be, a year later, in an unchanged market? >>


    I'm guessing $425image
  • Options
    PawPaulPawPaul Posts: 5,845 ✭


    << <i>Hypothetically, if he sells it for that, I wonder what his buy-back price would be, a year later, in an unchanged market? >>




    Having dealt with Mr. Tomaska for nearly twenty years , I have found that if the coin is irreplaceable (as in this coin ) , he will eagerly purchase it back !
  • Options
    BochimanBochiman Posts: 25,783 ✭✭✭✭✭
    To me, that says tons about the "expert" in the field.....ie, use expertise to take advantage of others.

    Yes, he is free to ask what he wants.
    Yes, he may have recognized a "bargain" when he bought it and his bid may have been much higher.
    Yes, people feel HE is THE expert on Franklins.
    Yes, he may not sell it for that price but may cust someone a "deal" and knock off a hundred or two, out of the kindness of his heart.

    I have his book, I have not dealt with him, and I have no desire to deal with him. This isn't the first one like this for him, nor will it likely be his last.

    I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment

  • Options
    PawPaulPawPaul Posts: 5,845 ✭
    Bman - I wish I had your common sense ........


    you see , I am an advanced Franklin collector and I would like nothing more then to own the most incredibly color toned 1958 in existence ,

    offered by a man that D. Hall has stated is the "main man" in the field of Franklin Half Dollars ;

    but I feel the price is just a tad wee bit too high
  • Options
    coinguy1coinguy1 Posts: 13,484 ✭✭✭


    << <i>

    << <i>Hypothetically, if he sells it for that, I wonder what his buy-back price would be, a year later, in an unchanged market? >>




    Having dealt with Mr. Tomaska for nearly twenty years , I have found that if the coin is irreplaceable (as in this coin ) , he will eagerly purchase it back ! >>

    But at what price?
  • Options
    Paw, you no-doubt saw that coin in the TT auction...what did you bid ? (iffin' you don't mind telling us)image
    "Wars are really ugly! They're dirty
    and they're cold.
    I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
    Mary






    Best Franklin Website
  • Options
    PawPaulPawPaul Posts: 5,845 ✭
    But at what price?


    .....what doe's the devil offer for one's soul these days ?
  • Options
    PawPaulPawPaul Posts: 5,845 ✭


    << <i>Paw, you no-doubt saw that coin in the TT auction...what did you bid ? (iffin' you don't mind telling us)image >>




    I think it's safe to assume I bid the same thing you did Bushy : a big fat ZERO !
  • Options


    << <i>

    << <i>Paw, you no-doubt saw that coin in the TT auction...what did you bid ? (iffin' you don't mind telling us)image >>




    I think it's safe to assume I bid the same thing you did Bushy : a big fat ZERO ! >>





    I think you did alright then PP.image
  • Options
    .........but I didn't know it was the most incredibly color toned 1958 in existence until today ! image
  • Options
    "I think you did alright then PP. "


    .........so you don't think I should pay more then 100 X bid for it then ?
  • Options
    BaleyBaley Posts: 22,663 ✭✭✭✭✭
    well, look at that! the third in submission order, right after these two

    wonder how many blue 1958 franklin halves the submitter had?

    Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry

  • Options
    roadrunnerroadrunner Posts: 28,374 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Before the I get to far past the start of the OP's post I was thinking (jokingly) to myself, yeah I'd pay $3800 for a common 1958...as long as it was for sale by R&I. Then I got to the bottom of the post....sure enough. image

    roadrunner
    Barbarous Relic No More, LSCC -GoldSeek--shadow stats--SafeHaven--321gold
  • Options
    This is a rather rare coin in another respect.
    How many TPG graded type 2 eagles have you seen?
  • Options


    << <i>This is a rather rare coin in another respect.
    How many TPG graded type 2 eagles have you seen? >>



    A fair number. They are hardly "rare". Relatively scarce, yes. But still plenty to go around.

    Now if it was designated FBL, and TRULY WAS FBL, a case could be made that the coin is worth R&I's price. But, alas, it is not FBL.
    "Wars are really ugly! They're dirty
    and they're cold.
    I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
    Mary






    Best Franklin Website
  • Options
    I still stand by my original assesment in a previous thread that this coin and the two others that were very similar with consecutive serial numbers are AT. If these three coins were offered raw on Ebay I doubt very few on this board with call them NT.
  • Options
    The 3 coins did always strike me as AT from seeing images of them...not clue how they look in hand. I know the blue is very common on the 1958-P's...matter of fact that are kinda rare without the blue toning when found in mint sets but to date.....I don't remember ever pulling a 1958-P with that color purple mixed in with the blue image


    To add to this discussion.....I have a proof frankie that I experimented with by storing it in a box with matches and then place it under a lamp to add some heat.....the two colors it toned were...you guessed it...the same shades of blue and purple so I know the colors can be duplicated but again...I couldn't tag the coins as 100% AT based soley on some less than stellar teletrade photos. image
  • Options
    AngryTurtleAngryTurtle Posts: 1,612 ✭✭✭


    << <i>... I know the blue is very common on the 1958-P's...matter of fact that are kinda rare without the blue toning when found in mint sets but to date.....I don't remember ever pulling a 1958-P with that color purple mixed in with the blue image
    >>



    image
  • Options
    djdilliodondjdilliodon Posts: 1,938 ✭✭
    I would not buy that coin for more than 40 bux. The color is just off if you ask me.
  • Options
    lcoopielcoopie Posts: 8,875 ✭✭✭✭✭
    I wonder what might happen
    if the holder got damaged
    and was sent in for re-holdering.
    LCoopie = Les
  • Options
    PawPaulPawPaul Posts: 5,845 ✭
    ......as much as I would like to own the the most incredibly toned color 1958 Franklin half in the world

    ........I don't want to pay such an outlandish price, in fact , it's downright insulting to me ...to be priced at such a ridiculous level .

    On top of that , knowledgeable Franklin buffs are suspicious of the originality of the toning - of which I am .

    ..........I will take the advice of KurtDog and move on .........
  • Options
    rainbowroosierainbowroosie Posts: 4,875 ✭✭✭✭
    A year or two ago I think Bear posted a 58 that he owned; I was one of the prvious owners. Now THAT 58 had some claim to fame. Anybody still have the photo?
    "You keep your 1804 dollar and 1822 half eagle -- give me rainbow roosies in MS68."
    rainbowroosie April 1, 2003
  • Options
    PawPaulPawPaul Posts: 5,845 ✭
    .........I will go see if I can dig up that pix ; that coin was off the charts !

    and as I remember , it sold way back when for a really strong price - for more then 2000$ ......I think ..........

    It was a PCGS MS 66 , maybe with FBL ......... and there was some controversy about the origin of the tone on that one too

    but I think the community here gave it their stamp of approval image
  • Options
    PawPaulPawPaul Posts: 5,845 ✭
    o.k. , moving on image


    here is the brother coin , also sold @ T.T in August this year .

    It just sold off eBay for less then 400$ ........maybe not quite the coin of it's peer , but surely we should see it for sale soon for a couple grand image

    image
    image


    and here is the runt of the litter of three ; you know - I sure would like Ronyahski to give his opinion on this triplet
  • Options
    relicsncoinsrelicsncoins Posts: 8,353 ✭✭✭✭✭
    All I know; If I submitted that coin, 91 would surley be the result.
    Need a Barber Half with ANACS photo certificate. If you have one for sale please PM me. Current Ebay auctions
  • Options
    PawPaulPawPaul Posts: 5,845 ✭
    maybe the buyer of coin #2 will send it in for review, have it bagged and then will post it in a genuine holder .......

    ........de-bunking the trio !
  • Options


    << <i>A year or two ago I think Bear posted a 58 that he owned; I was one of the prvious owners. Now THAT 58 had some claim to fame. Anybody still have the photo? >>




    This would be that coin .......sold @ Auction in 2005 for an astounding $5750.00 !!
    imageimage
  • Options
    GrivGriv Posts: 2,804 ✭


    << <i>o.k. , moving on image


    here is the brother coin , also sold @ T.T in August this year .

    It just sold off eBay for less then 400$ ........maybe not quite the coin of it's peer , but surely we should see it for sale soon for a couple grand image

    image
    image


    and here is the runt of the litter of three ; you know - I sure would like Ronyahski to give his opinion on this triplet >>



    NEITHER of those impress me. $300-$400 tops.
  • Options
    SkyManSkyMan Posts: 9,610 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>

    << <i>A year or two ago I think Bear posted a 58 that he owned; I was one of the prvious owners. Now THAT 58 had some claim to fame. Anybody still have the photo? >>




    This would be that coin .......sold @ Auction in 2005 for an astounding $5750.00 !!
    imageimage >>



    Well, that coin is a D, so the color structure (toning for you folks in Rio Linda) would be different. Still, I wouldn't touch that one either (well, I'd buy it if it were going for sheet or maybe $10 - $20 over sheet, but that's about it).

    As to the FINEST 1958 in the world, IF THE IMAGES ARE ACCURATE (and given the fact that 3 coins in a row look the same I suspect the images are reasonably accurate), it is VERY sad to see "the Franklin expert" going down this path. Some poor bugger is gonna' get TOTALLY bent over.
  • Options
    GrivGriv Posts: 2,804 ✭


    << <i>

    << <i>A year or two ago I think Bear posted a 58 that he owned; I was one of the prvious owners. Now THAT 58 had some claim to fame. Anybody still have the photo? >>




    This would be that coin .......sold @ Auction in 2005 for an astounding $5750.00 !!
    imageimage >>



    Now this is a DIFFERENT story, even though I think it would have been better if it would have been sold to me for a WHOLE lot less money. Can you imagine how much HAPPIER the seller AND the buyer would have been if only they knew that this coin could have been in my collection without me having to sell anymore of my kid's PlayStation games? It's dang hard to but I can. But that's just me, giving, giving, giving.

  • Options
    ElcontadorElcontador Posts: 7,743 ✭✭✭✭✭
    The only way I would own a silver coin toned like that is if it was given to me as a gift by a loved one.
    "Vou invadir o Nordeste,
    "Seu cabra da peste,
    "Sou Mangueira......."
  • Options
    PCcoinsPCcoins Posts: 3,354 ✭✭✭
    This "Franklin expert" seems more like an expert of robbing people in exchange for medieoce toned franklins.... hate to say it.
    "It is what it is."
  • Options
    I wouldn't buy that without a solid return policy. Nothing looks right about it, but you need to get it in hand.

    As far as True master Franklin dealers, I wish I could find one.

    I've collected, and dealt in Franklins since the early Seventies.

    The best ever were Erhmantraut, Wooten, Leber, and even Shuch. Wooten was, to me, the very best. No Hype, PQ coins, and accurate and honest descriptions.

    I am truly flabbergasted at the amount of artificial toning that I'm seeing since I decided to become active again.

    Even more disturbing is the amount of self proclaimed experts who fall for, or sling, the hype, who can't recognize problem coins, and who don't seem to know the attributes of a premium Franklin.



    Today's mighty oak is just yesterday's nut that held its ground.
  • Options
    ........that's " Schuch" !

    ...and he's getting up there in years too........., but I sure bought many a nice one from him as well .

    Leber has passed away , Wooten has passed out of existence , Erhmantraut has been long gone ............

    there is only the one left at the top - and if he suspects the tone is false ; he looks the other way

    he doesn't offer a two way market

    and puts prices on many of his coins that strip away his credibility

    the new book coming out is supposed to have pix of many of the top color pieces known ; but he rejected many coins offered to him for inclusion in the book

    as the coins had not passed thru his hands and therefor he wanted no part of them - even though several were better , prettier examples .


    no ,

    It's a whole new world for the Mighty , Mighty Franklin

    .........and the overwhelming multitude of A.T and enhanced toned coins that flood the current market along with it
  • Options
    Yes! Schuch! I thought I was spelling that wrong. Sorry to here Steve finally succombed. He was quite a fellow.

    As far as pictures in books, you're absolutely spot on. I would think that a fan would want to use the very best.

    I think that is part of the problem PP, that too many monsters are tucked away in collections, waiting for the right time to surface.

    A lot of folks simply have no frame of reference.

    I sold most of my 66 and higher material back in 2006. I have not seen one of them, anywhere.

    Even the stuff I have left is better than 98-99% of the stuff I'm seeing. Seriously makes me consider sending in for reviews.




    Today's mighty oak is just yesterday's nut that held its ground.
  • Options


    << <i>

    << <i>... I know the blue is very common on the 1958-P's...matter of fact that are kinda rare without the blue toning when found in mint sets but to date.....I don't remember ever pulling a 1958-P with that color purple mixed in with the blue image
    >>



    image >>



    The one thing about these three coins is that they have a type 2 reverse. The mint sets of 1958 only contained type 1s. If anyone has a 1958 type 2 that without a doubt came from a mint set I'd like to see it.

    This is how 99% of the ones I've seen look like. They're white and sometimes have semi-PL surfaces.

    image
  • Options
    RebelRonRebelRon Posts: 544 ✭✭


    << <i>Here is your big chance , to be somebody - to rise to notoriety beyond your wildest dreams in the kingdom of the mighty , mighty Franklin Half Dollar ;

    here is the picture when it sold @ Teletrade : MOST INCREADABLE COLOR TONED 1958 IN EXISTANCE !







    " 1958-P

    EVEREST

    Picture


    FRANKLIN PCGS MS 65. OFF THE CHARTS! ONLY THE MOST SPCTACULAR COLOR TONED 1958-P I HAVE EVER SEEN!!!!! This is the finest color toned mint state 1958-P Franklin I have ever come across. Both obverse and reverse are decked out in INSANE electric-blue toning. Adding to the beauty is this phenomenal intense bright purple tone that shines through the incredible electric-blue toning. The surfaces are extremely clean and the eye-appeal is top drawer! If I had this coin in my possession just a month earlier I would have this incredible specimen in my new book due out at the end of November. If you want to own the most incredible color toned 1958-p in existence, don't pass this gem up. Amazing! 1-2-4

    $ 3800 " - R. Tomaska



    would any Franklin collectors like to comment on this coin ? >>

    Yup!!! image I wish that I could afford it!
  • Options
    RebelRonRebelRon Posts: 544 ✭✭


    << <i>Bman - I wish I had your common sense ........


    you see , I am an advanced Franklin collector and I would like nothing more then to own the most incredibly color toned 1958 in existence ,

    offered by a man that D. Hall has stated is the "main man" in the field of Franklin Half Dollars ;

    but I feel the price is just a tad wee bit too high >>

    image
  • Options
    lcoopielcoopie Posts: 8,875 ✭✭✭✭✭
    let me stir the cauldron a little more (I had to look up cauldron),
    I am guessing the coin will not be sent in for possible upgrade, or reholdering.
    LCoopie = Les
  • Options
    PawPaulPawPaul Posts: 5,845 ✭
    coopie-

    if your referring to Mr. Tomask's example , I would say if the piece had any shot at upgrade , or a "plus" , or a FBL designation,

    then it would be resubmitted ; I think he can grade Franklin's very , very well , and knows potential when he see's it
  • Options
    Hey PawPaul, just wanted to let you know that I'm still hanging on to those babies of yours from years ago. image
  • Options
    PawPaulPawPaul Posts: 5,845 ✭
    your just teasing me right ?

    you mean the 1950-D with the midnight blue and gold crescent ??


    ....or the 57-D that was emerald green and every other color of the rainbow ?

    .........................or those one's that got put into I.C.G MS 67 holders ??????????


    it is time to sell them back to me image
  • Options
    PawPaulPawPaul Posts: 5,845 ✭


    << <i>Hey PawPaul, just wanted to let you know that I'm still hanging on to those babies of yours from years ago. image >>




    You still got this one Toneluver ? image

    image
  • Options
    PawPaulPawPaul Posts: 5,845 ✭
    ...........I got a look at the middle coin of the trio -

    it's extremely pretty - in fact ; it's one of those " too good to be true coins " , it was basically a MS 66 coin , with the downgrade to MS65 because of the doubt ......
    it had a very odd feature : the lettering and date were not really toned on the high point , hummmmm

    I can tell you this about the coin -

    it's not mint set tone

    it's not album tone

    it's not envelope tone ............


    so what the heck could produce that kind of tone on 3 separate coins ??
  • Options
    Nice work tracking this one; I remember when we first talked about it; now, how about the $9500 58-D and one other (can't remember the date) from Anaconda ?
  • Options
    PawPaulPawPaul Posts: 5,845 ✭
    the 9500$ 58-D , that I offered 6 grand for and the snake later sold for under 4 grand , is now in Ronyahski's collection

    Why do so many people kill snakes ? Bushmaster used to have his basement full of all different kinds of 'um........ .Hognose, Rat , boa's, kingsnakes, fox snakes, etc
  • Options
    sorry but it looks at to me. looks like one that a stink bomp was use on.

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file