Why are Eagle bullion coins "uncirculated"?
scottgardener
Posts: 1,205 ✭
I know that custom has us referring to non-proof coins fresh from the Mint as "uncirculated," but there is a curious loss of original definition and meaning in this.
Have gold and platinum eagles ever gotten into circulation? I would really love to, say, spend $200 at the grocery store, and instead of the usual paper notes, get back a $25 gold half ounce American Eagle, slightly worn, that ultimately grades AU53 with PCGS. Maybe along with it, two silver Eagles and a Boy Scouts Commemorative.
But, I'm really boggled by the use of "uncirculated" to describe the MMIX Ultra-High Relief Saint Gaudens remake. Why isn't this coin a proof? They had to polish the [oogah!] out of the planchets, and the dies were meticulously engineered and designed to a degree that makes other modern proof strikes look like 1850s branch mint work. They had to strike these coins nine times to get the relief and detail, whereas proofs are generally only struck twice. Why in the world are the modern ultra-high relief coins "uncirculated"? It's not like I'll ever get handed one of these in lieu of a $20 bill anywhere.
Or, am I just in the wrong part of the country? If so, I'm definitely moving to wherever it is that modern gold eagles circulate!
Have gold and platinum eagles ever gotten into circulation? I would really love to, say, spend $200 at the grocery store, and instead of the usual paper notes, get back a $25 gold half ounce American Eagle, slightly worn, that ultimately grades AU53 with PCGS. Maybe along with it, two silver Eagles and a Boy Scouts Commemorative.
But, I'm really boggled by the use of "uncirculated" to describe the MMIX Ultra-High Relief Saint Gaudens remake. Why isn't this coin a proof? They had to polish the [oogah!] out of the planchets, and the dies were meticulously engineered and designed to a degree that makes other modern proof strikes look like 1850s branch mint work. They had to strike these coins nine times to get the relief and detail, whereas proofs are generally only struck twice. Why in the world are the modern ultra-high relief coins "uncirculated"? It's not like I'll ever get handed one of these in lieu of a $20 bill anywhere.
Or, am I just in the wrong part of the country? If so, I'm definitely moving to wherever it is that modern gold eagles circulate!
Improperly Cleaned, Our passion for numismatics is Genuine! Now featuring correct spelling.
0
Comments
<< <i>They're uncirculated because they've never been in circulation. >>
BST Transactions: DonnyJf, MrOrganic, Justanothercoinaddict, Fivecents, Slq, Jdimmick,
Robb, Tee135, Ibzman350, Mercfan, Outhaul, Erickso1, Cugamongacoins, Indiananationals, Wayne Herndon
Negative BST Transactions:
I suppose in numismatic terminology, the un can mean something completely different than how I defined it above. I'm not experienced in neither English nor coins. But I wanted to add my simple opinion. I see nothing wrong with its use to describe any coin or other object that has yet to circulate (even if it never does). *giggle* This is a weird topic. /