Options
What is the best decade for coin collecting?
mcarney1173
Posts: 927 ✭✭✭✭✭
If you could choose one decade between 1800 and 2010 that is the best in terms of collectible coins of all denominations, which would you choose. The 1790s are excluded from this thread. Please explain:
0
Comments
Coins I understand and are passionate about. Good coins in every denomination.
jmho
<< <i>I choose 1860-1870. With a plethora of pattern coins, Civil War tokens, obsolete denominations (2c, 3c silver and nickel), and many rare date Seated and gold coins, plus the historical connection to the Civil War, this colorful decade offers a great amount of numismatic diversity. In addition, one can acquire P, S, O, CC, D, and C mint coins from 1860-1870, if 1870 is included. If you want to say that this is an 11 year span, then I choose 1861-70. What a great decade for coins! >>
I strongly agree!
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>1960's. Handsdown. >>
Followed by 2000-2010. There's been some GREAT STUFF the last few years.
Not that I wouldn't have liked to have a day with a wad of cash in the 1920s!
<< <i>The 1790s are excluded from this thread. Please explain >>
Yes, please explain why the 1790s are excluded.
<< <i>I think there is some confusion in this thread. We are talking about the best decade in terms of coins minted during those years, correct? Someone could misread the original question as the best decade to be living in as a collector. >>
"The best decade for coin collecting" would not preclude collecting coins then in circulation from prior decades.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
The 1850s are full of some really tough dates and minor design changes, the 1860s have all the Civil War dates, and the 1870s have some really neat CC and San Francisco dates.
This post is not biased in any way from the fact that I collect the seated dollar seres which runs through all three of the above decades
Governments can print currency. Only the people can print faith in it — and they’re running low on ink.
And 1960
<< <i>I took it to mean actually being in that time period and could get coins for face.
And 1960
Most of the best coins of the era went straight into circulation and are
still there.
For world coins it's the 1950's.
still there.<<<
What's your point? There are no rarities in the 1960's. Who cares that they went into circulation.
The early 1800's would be great. 1920's would be great Really anything after the 1920's wouldn't be worth the trip.
<< <i>
What's your point? There are no rarities in the 1960's. Who cares that they went into circulation.
The early 1800's would be great. 1920's would be great Really anything after the 1920's wouldn't be worth the trip. >>
In the early 1800's there were collectors who set aside coins. In the 1920's there
were even more collectors setting coins aside. All of these collectors preferentially
set aside the tougher and rare coins as they could.
This simply didn't happen after 1964 when the roll and bag market collapsed. Peo-
ple not only didn't set aside common coins after this they also didn't bother to set
aside any coins.
This same thing happened all over the world after silver was removed from each
country's coinage.
This means a little different things have occured in each place. In New Zealand the
coins are quite scarce in unc but in the US varieties, types, and high grades are scarce.
But the bottom line is the coins in circulation are pretty much random. You can't have
this anywhere that collectors are removing coins.
Which would you rather have an unc roll of 1960 anything or a roll of unc 1921-S halves?????
<< <i>STILL!!! What's your point. It doesn't matter if the 60's were set aside or not!!!
Which would you rather have an unc roll of 1960 anything or a roll of unc 1921-S halves????? >>
I'd rather have almost any scarce or rare coin that's post-1963 than
a '21-S half. It's not only a matter of much lower cost, it's a matter of
being much interesting to me. I don't collect the '21-S half in any grade
and won't find one in circulation there are lots of very rare coins I might
find in circulation.
I can't open up a roll of half dollars from the bank and find a nice unc
'21-S. There are none in circulation and this won't change. I could just
happens to stumble on a roll of gem '82-P half dollars though.
If you're interested only in old coins then the '60's aren't for you. But
if you like scarce coins for low prices or straight from circulation then the
'60's can't be beat. There are few decades in hisatory of any country
that can beat the coins from the '60's.
However, I will vote for "the other" 60's...............The 1860's.................MJ
Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
I believe the OP is asking "If you were going to collect coins from only one ten year period of time, which decade has the most to offer? (i.e. most interesting coins available, biggest variety of types/denominations/mint marks, etc)."
Which decade since 1800 would make the most interesting focused collection?
I agree with the 1860s crowd. My second choice would be the 1830s.
<< <i>I think a few here are misunderstand the meaning of this post.
I believe the OP is asking "If you were going to collect coins from only one ten year period of time, which decade has the most to offer? (i.e. most interesting coins available, biggest variety of types/denominations/mint marks, etc)." >>
1907-1916. (That is a 10 year period of time, right?)
The era of the great transition. It includes the last of the 19th Century designs in all denominations (excepting Morgans), and the introduction of numerous designs that became classics. St. Gaudens $10 and $20 gold in high and low relief. Pratt's innovative sunken relief $2.5 and $5 gold. Panama-Pacific commems, including the first two non-pattern $50 gold coins ever released. The first Lincoln cents (including the famed 1909-S VDB), Buffalo nickels, Mercury dimes (including the key 1916-D), Standing Liberty quarters (including the superkey 1916), Walking Liberty halves.
Several patterns of the new designs. The lowest mintage Indian cent (1909-S). The lowest mintage Barber Quarter (1913-S). The lowest mintage Barber half (1914).
And of course, the famous 1913 Liberty nickel.
Edit: I just noticed that this is my 1907th post. Appropriate, isn't it?
For Error and Variety Collectors
There was a great deal of very strange goings on at the the U.S. Mint during this time
Many errors and varieties that are not very well known even today.
And are just beginning to see the light of day
Leaving the door open for those that do their research to find some amazing discoveries.
Just my 2 Cents
Terry
Since you have forced the issue, I'll go with 1800 to 1810. My reasons are the same as they are for the 1790s. It was the toward the beginning of the country, the dies were hand made and the coins in high grade are very attractive.
since the first decade is arbitrarily out of bounds, I'll choose the following "decade" of dates within your time frame:
1802, 1807, , 1815, 1838, 1867, 1853, 1883, 1907, 1916, 1936.
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
You can't define "best" when there are so many opinions!
<< <i>Based on responses up until now, and those that will come later, ALL COINS are pretty cool.
You can't define "best" when there are so many opinions! >>
LanLord, I think you are missing the point. You can't have a great thread without some bloody knuckles!