Blatantly obvious AT coin for sale locally
Marauderrt10
Posts: 1,097 ✭
Should I buy it? the guy is asking stupid money for it, but I feel trash like that should be taken out of holders. Would PCGS reimburse me for what I paid for it just to get it out of their holder?
0
Comments
<< <i>Should I buy it? the guy is asking stupid money for it, but I feel trash like that should be taken out of holders. Would PCGS reimburse me for what I paid for it just to get it out of their holder? >>
I do not think that this course of action is likely to result in your personal or monetary satisfaction.
<< <i>
<< <i>Should I buy it? the guy is asking stupid money for it, but I feel trash like that should be taken out of holders. Would PCGS reimburse me for what I paid for it just to get it out of their holder? >>
I do not think that this course of action is likely to result in your personal or monetary satisfaction. >>
what do you think i should do then? it is so obvious its sickening that I send in good coins and they come back in genuine holders
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Should I buy it? the guy is asking stupid money for it, but I feel trash like that should be taken out of holders. Would PCGS reimburse me for what I paid for it just to get it out of their holder? >>
I do not think that this course of action is likely to result in your personal or monetary satisfaction. >>
what do you think i should do then? it is so obvious its sickening that I send in good coins and they come back in genuine holders
It appears that you and PCGS don't always see eye to eye. So they might think the coin is perfectly fine, even if you feel it is obviously AT. And they might be right.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Should I buy it? the guy is asking stupid money for it, but I feel trash like that should be taken out of holders. Would PCGS reimburse me for what I paid for it just to get it out of their holder? >>
I do not think that this course of action is likely to result in your personal or monetary satisfaction. >>
what do you think i should do then? it is so obvious its sickening that I send in good coins and they come back in genuine holders
It appears that you and PCGS don't always see eye to eye. So they might think the coin is perfectly fine, even if you feel it is obviously AT. And they might be right. >>
I know the coin is AT, i know who did the coin. it has that holographic toned look to it, just like all of his other coins. His name is Unique n toned on ebay.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Should I buy it? the guy is asking stupid money for it, but I feel trash like that should be taken out of holders. Would PCGS reimburse me for what I paid for it just to get it out of their holder? >>
I do not think that this course of action is likely to result in your personal or monetary satisfaction. >>
what do you think i should do then? it is so obvious its sickening that I send in good coins and they come back in genuine holders
It appears that you and PCGS don't always see eye to eye. So they might think the coin is perfectly fine, even if you feel it is obviously AT. And they might be right. >>
I know the coin is AT, i know who did the coin. it has that holographic toned look to it, just like all of his other coins. His name is Unique n toned on ebay. >>
If that's the case, rather than buying the coin or ignoring the situation entirely, why not PM or email Don Willis and provide him with the pertinent details about the seller you mentioned.
Edited to add: I can't find that seller on Ebay under the name you provided.
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
Unless you are a professional grader, have seen hundreds if not thousands of toned coins and have money to blow, my advice is to just............ fugetaboutit!
The name is LEE!
<< <i>My advice is:
Unless you are a professional grader, have seen hundreds if not thousands of toned coins and have money to blow, my advice is to just............ fugetaboutit! >>
You don't need to be a professional grader to know it's AT. No natural toning is holographic. And I have seen thousands of toned Morgans. I'll PM don about what I should do
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Should I buy it? the guy is asking stupid money for it, but I feel trash like that should be taken out of holders. Would PCGS reimburse me for what I paid for it just to get it out of their holder? >>
I do not think that this course of action is likely to result in your personal or monetary satisfaction. >>
what do you think i should do then? it is so obvious its sickening that I send in good coins and they come back in genuine holders
It appears that you and PCGS don't always see eye to eye. So they might think the coin is perfectly fine, even if you feel it is obviously AT. And they might be right. >>
I know the coin is AT, i know who did the coin. it has that holographic toned look to it, just like all of his other coins. His name is Unique n toned on ebay. >>
If that's the case, rather than buying the coin or ignoring the situation entirely, why not PM or email Don Willis and provide him with the pertinent details about the seller you mentioned.
Edited to add: I can't find that seller on Ebay under the name you provided. >>
Unfortunately he is very well known....and destroys a lot of coins
Ebay Profile Unique_N_Toned
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Should I buy it? the guy is asking stupid money for it, but I feel trash like that should be taken out of holders. Would PCGS reimburse me for what I paid for it just to get it out of their holder? >>
I do not think that this course of action is likely to result in your personal or monetary satisfaction. >>
what do you think i should do then? it is so obvious its sickening that I send in good coins and they come back in genuine holders
It appears that you and PCGS don't always see eye to eye. So they might think the coin is perfectly fine, even if you feel it is obviously AT. And they might be right. >>
I know the coin is AT, i know who did the coin. it has that holographic toned look to it, just like all of his other coins. His name is Unique n toned on ebay. >>
If that's the case, rather than buying the coin or ignoring the situation entirely, why not PM or email Don Willis and provide him with the pertinent details about the seller you mentioned.
Edited to add: I can't find that seller on Ebay under the name you provided. >>
Unfortunately he is very well known....and destroys a lot of coins
Ebay Profile Unique_N_Toned >>
Thanks Shane, I knew you would have his username handy
"Everything is on its way to somewhere. Everything." - George Malley, Phenomenon
http://www.american-legacy-coins.com
<< <i>Just being the
I don't know but it may qualify as altered surfaces.
Edit: Nevermind I see what you're talking about.
<< <i>
<< <i>Just being the
I don't know but it may qualify as altered surfaces.
Edit: Nevermind I see what you're talking about. >>
For those that may not of got my point is that PCGS graded a coin, slabbed it and Guarantied it at one point in time.
Are they liable under their warrantee for the actions of others that alter their product after the fact?
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Just being the
I don't know but it may qualify as altered surfaces.
Edit: Nevermind I see what you're talking about. >>
For those that may not of got my point is that PCGS graded a coin, slabbed it and Guarantied it at one point in time.
Are they liable under their warrantee for the actions of others that alter their product after the fact? >>
If they "GENUINE" any of my coins, with color as a reason, they better guarantee color in their slab (though, I do agree with your "after the fact" that they shouldn't be accountable)
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
"A dog breaks your heart only one time and that is when they pass on". Unknown
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Just being the
I don't know but it may qualify as altered surfaces.
Edit: Nevermind I see what you're talking about. >>
For those that may not of got my point is that PCGS graded a coin, slabbed it and Guarantied it at one point in time.
Are they liable under their warrantee for the actions of others that alter their product after the fact? >>
No, but who said it was done after the fact?
Mark, I think some members are saying that this seller somehow tones the coins after they have been slabbed
<< <i>This seller has his coin sales listed as "private" in his feedback, and the other items can be viewed.-----------BigE
Mark, I think some members are saying that this seller somehow tones the coins after they have been slabbed >>
Thanks.
<< <i>This seller has his coin sales listed as "private" in his feedback, and the other items can be viewed.-----------BigE
Mark, I think some members are saying that this seller somehow tones the coins after they have been slabbed >>
That is incorrect....he AT's the coins and then sends them in to the TPGs. They are very deceptive and I would imagine a half dozen to a dozen of his best stuff initially made it into both NGC and PCGS holder. They quickly caught on and now to my knowledge I haven't seen him sell one of his certified creations in 6 to 12 months. So it's good that the TPGs caught on but it wasn't before he rake in some serious cash with the coins he was able to get holdered.
The Morgan Maruader posted was one of them that he himself bought...I called fowl on the coin and said it wouldn't holder based soley on who he bought it from...afterall the colors and toning progession are quite good. In the end the coin bagged and we all learned just how good some of the doctors had become with banded rainbows. I must say though that the AT coins I have seen in hand with those particular bands of color were easy to label as fake......while luster shows through the color....their is a difference in the quantity and quality of the luster and it does have an affect on the cartwheel effect.
I
<< <i>
<< <i>My advice is:
Unless you are a professional grader, have seen hundreds if not thousands of toned coins and have money to blow, my advice is to just............ fugetaboutit! >>
You don't need to be a professional grader to know it's AT. No natural toning is holographic. And I have seen thousands of toned Morgans. I'll PM don about what I should do >>
Obviously, professional graders DID think it was authentic so as I said either ready to lose your shirt since PCGS just might give it the go ahead.
Am just saying..............
The name is LEE!
<< <i>I didn't see any pcgs or ngc graded coins he is currently selling? I know this seller has had some obvious AT coins in pcgs and ngc holders in the past that he has sold but have only seen raw coins he's selling as of lately.
I >>
Exactly...they caught on.....I am happy about that I just wish we could get the bad apples off the street but this clown is just one of many doctors out their that have successfully gotten their creations into legit holders.
There is a current forum member selling AT coins in third world slabs......somehow that doesn't make me any happier