Options
what would you do re:08W buff $50 purchase?
drfish
Posts: 955 ✭✭✭✭
Purchased a 08W Buff unc $50 in mint packaging from ebay-here's the buyers description ....
Own this gold. This is the 2008 1 0z. American Buffalo Uncirculated Gold Coin. It is a full oz. of pure .9999 fine gold. All the original government packaging is included. I've looked at this coin under magnification and honestly believe it is mint state 70. 2008 could be the last year of issue for the buffaloes. I hope not. It's such a great design. Own Gold! I tell folks it's going over the 1500.00 mark, and when it reaches this level it's up up and more up. I know what you are thinking. Yes, I'm not getting rid of all my gold. I'm keeping enough hidden (it's called a safety deposit box) for the future. 2008 is going to look like the good old days! Own silver gold and platinum! Don't forget my free shipping. ... Not that I was overly optimistic about the sellers grading skills but I figured I had a 50:50 shot at a 70.Looking at the coin there are a couple very small rim nicks so probably a 69.Heres the aggravating part- as I was putting the coin back in the mint box I noticed a small post it note on the bottom of the wood box with 69 written on it.The seller has no return policy stated in the ad.I paid 1300 delivered.What would you reccomend???
00007
Own this gold. This is the 2008 1 0z. American Buffalo Uncirculated Gold Coin. It is a full oz. of pure .9999 fine gold. All the original government packaging is included. I've looked at this coin under magnification and honestly believe it is mint state 70. 2008 could be the last year of issue for the buffaloes. I hope not. It's such a great design. Own Gold! I tell folks it's going over the 1500.00 mark, and when it reaches this level it's up up and more up. I know what you are thinking. Yes, I'm not getting rid of all my gold. I'm keeping enough hidden (it's called a safety deposit box) for the future. 2008 is going to look like the good old days! Own silver gold and platinum! Don't forget my free shipping. ... Not that I was overly optimistic about the sellers grading skills but I figured I had a 50:50 shot at a 70.Looking at the coin there are a couple very small rim nicks so probably a 69.Heres the aggravating part- as I was putting the coin back in the mint box I noticed a small post it note on the bottom of the wood box with 69 written on it.The seller has no return policy stated in the ad.I paid 1300 delivered.What would you reccomend???
00007
0
Comments
One thing that might have clued you in: Always look at what else the seller has listed and even check his feedback to see what he has sold. I'm leary of a seller that has modern graded AND modern raw coins for sale.
Governments can print currency. Only the people can print faith in it — and they’re running low on ink.
<< <i>Rgcoinguy- so in your opinion nothing overtly deceptive about describing a coin as likely ms70 when you know it isn't?I just expected a fair shot at a 70 not a coin that the buyer misrepresented to hide the fact that it was cherrypicked.There is a chance that he bought it already cherrypicked and didn't see the post it and doesn't know you examine rims when grading but probably he is just dishonest. >>
I think he's baiting you with that MS70 business.
You should only buy graded on eBay, especially expensive gold.
I would be very wary of this transaction.
Please post the link!!
GB
Here's a graded MS69 for $1500 eBay Link
No COA or Mint box.....worth about $25 or so
You go by the picture, you go by rep.
If there is no return policy, you should suck it up and should have asked before buying.
Can you prove that post it note was from the same person who sold it? Not a friend/relative/etc? Someone saying they "believe it is mint state 70" is different from getting a slab with it....I've seen MS70 coins that I didn't think were MS70 and I've seen MS69 that I thought were MS70. Grades are an opinion. Pay for the coin and accept that it is what it is and if you wanted a MS70 then you should have bought one already graded by PCGS/NGC or you should buy raw and submit (and where you have a return policy, though, returning what is likely a MS69 because it isn't MS70 is bogus, imho)
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
go based on the pic and realize that many mint products are not
perfect 70s.
As others have stated, I would consider this a lesson learned, and if you are not happy with the coin, resell it. You will probably make a bit of a profit from what the others are stating these are selling for.
<< <i>I understand you thinking it could have a shot at a 70, but I don't think you overpaid for what it is. You just have to learn that someone saying something is a grade such and such, is the same as saying gold is going over 1500.00, it means nothing.
As others have stated, I would consider this a lesson learned, and if you are not happy with the coin, resell it. You will probably make a bit of a profit from what the others are stating these are selling for. >>
i agree just resell it and be done with it. and than just buy a ms70.
go here , for 1685.00 you would of saved yourself alot of crap.
linky
Ever Onward
<< <i>I personally would never pay that much money for a coin that I couldn't hold in my hand first..IMHO >>
not raw anyway !!!!
but i must say i have if it said PCGS !!!!
Ever Onward