Options
UPDATE: Heads up to Seller's that do not leave feedback first Edited, update
This thread is not intended to open up a debate about who should leave feedback first. There have been plenty of those. I am just letting sellers know that there seems to be several buyers now leaving negs for no other reason than the seller did not leave it first. Ebay does not seem to be willing to remove them Here is an example of one, I am sure there are many more. watch out Sellers!
Under the new policy Seller's are going to have trouble avoiding negs no matter what they do, but waiting to leave feedback seems to be an open invitation.
UPDATE: I just clicked the link to this buyer again. I looks like EBAY has removed most of the negs he left. Maybe there is hope after all!
Under the new policy Seller's are going to have trouble avoiding negs no matter what they do, but waiting to leave feedback seems to be an open invitation.
UPDATE: I just clicked the link to this buyer again. I looks like EBAY has removed most of the negs he left. Maybe there is hope after all!
0
Comments
I have left it when paid for about a month now
<< <i>Aside from the fact that some of these buyers are not very mature, what I don't follow is that the number of negatives is not reflected in the monthly,six months and 12 month running totals. Something I'm missing on how Ebay does it math? >>
The page is a list of all feedback left from user "usnfleet", not received.
<< <i>Aside from the fact that some of these buyers are not very mature, what I don't follow is that the number of negatives is not reflected in the monthly,six months and 12 month running totals. Something I'm missing on how Ebay does it math? >>
You are looking at the f/b from usnfleet left for others ...
<< <i>I've already let my lawyer know ahead of time that this will probably happen to me and I fully intend to file a defamation suit in their home county when it does happen. >>
Good luck with that.
Russ, NCNE
ebay sure knew what they were doing when they changed the policy. Way to go ebay!!!
<< <i>Did you notice that as soon as the new feedback rules went into place he starts neg'ing everyone.... >>
Yeah, he suddenly grew nads.
BTW, if enough of these sellers report him eBay WILL boot his ass. They've done it to a couple other of these turds. And when he's gone the negs also go.
Russ, NCNE
I am a small time buyer and not located in the US. For people to treat sellers like this will only make it more difficult for me to be allowed to even bid on an auction.
I have said it many times, this isn't right to treat a seller like this.
My opinion of course.
1-Dammit Boy Oct 14,2003
International Coins
"A work in progress"
Wayne
eBay registered name:
Hard_ Search (buyer/bidder, a small time seller)
e-mail: wayne.whatley@gmail.com
Reported.
If you block everybody, their won't be anybody left to bid.
If blocking bidders cuts into ebay's profits this will happen.
Very fast pay, Gr8 communications, Super Ebayer! Thanks!! Seller: thunderstruck9 ( 374) May-14-08 17:35
Reply by usnfleet (May-16-08 16:44):
R*12 (the seller below) is a moron. I have spent $20,000 on ebay. No problems!
and
Thanks Seller: getsomess ( 55) May-13-08 21:52
Reply by usnfleet (May-16-08 16:47):
R*12 (the seller above) unfairly retaliated. Check all my feedback. No problems!
<Russ, NCNE
Won't need any luck. There are already several suits filed by sellers since last month, the cases currently pending. It will cost the bidder simply to hire a lawyer, before court costs and damages are considered. And the Shellhorn case was before the new feedback rules went into effect. In that case the buyer only left a neutral and still had to shell out $500 to hire a lawyer. Well worth it for sellers to pursue this type of action.
There is currently a lawsuit filed for millions in damages against a California buyer for negative feedback.
eBay has also been named as a defendant in that case.
Unless the bidder states something that isn't true, you have no case. And, pursuing a case will cost you thousands in attorney fees and expenses. For what? eBay feedback? Any lawyer that would advise you to do that is an idiot.
Like I said, good luck.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i><Good luck with that.
<Russ, NCNE
Won't need any luck. There are already several suits filed by sellers since last month, the cases currently pending. It will cost the bidder simply to hire a lawyer, before court costs and damages are considered. And the Shellhorn case was before the new feedback rules went into effect. In that case the buyer only left a neutral and still had to shell out $500 to hire a lawyer. Well worth it for sellers to pursue this type of action.
There is currently a lawsuit filed for millions in damages against a California buyer for negative feedback.
eBay has also been named as a defendant in that case. >>
Cases filed and winning the case is two very different things. How much you want to bet, that case in Cali will be thrown out or severely reduced? And even IF you win, try collecting. Like Russ said, Good luck with that. And how much is it going to cost you to file and hire an attorney?
But back to the OP topic, thanks for the heads up. BLOCKED!
Incorrect. If the bidder leaves a negative because the seller did not leave one first, the negative itself is defamation since the T & S doesn't mandate who should leave feedback first.
My attorney is on a retainer, so filing suits doesn't cost me a cent.
halfnut X3, Dabigkahuna, Kaelasdad, LALASD4, harvey85422458,
fivecents, Coll3ctor, cucamongacoin, Becoka
I wish every seller out there would block this guy.
Frankly, I don't see myself selling on eBay any more with all these seller-hostile changes, but if I ever do, at least this yahoo is blocked.
<< <i><Unless the bidder states something that isn't true, you have no case.
Incorrect. If the bidder leaves a negative because the seller did not leave one first, the negative itself is defamation since the T & S doesn't mandate who should leave feedback first.
My attorney is on a retainer, so filing suits doesn't cost me a cent. >>
The guy giving negs is apparently in the USN. His attorney is free.
<< <i><Unless the bidder states something that isn't true, you have no case.
Incorrect. If the bidder leaves a negative because the seller did not leave one first, the negative itself is defamation since the T & S doesn't mandate who should leave feedback first. >>
If your "attorney on retainer" told you that he got his law degree through eMail spam.
Russ, NCNE
well wrapped, they receive a good rating from me. This is
whether they respond before or after I do. Since two wrongs
can never make a right, I am willing to go first.
Camelot
<< <i>Incorrect. If the bidder leaves a negative because the seller did not leave one first, the negative itself is defamation since the T & S doesn't mandate who should leave feedback first. >>
Nope.
Feedback is generally simply the opinion of the customer. If the customer doesn't like your service for any reason, they can say so and criticize you for it even if 99% of the people would think it's an irrational reason to be highly dissatisfied.
Defamation only comes into the picture if they called you a "crook" or a "fraud" or some such -- not because they didn't like your policy of not leaving feedback the nanosecond the buyer paid. While I think it shows the buyer has a screw loose, if they consider this such a bad policy that they consider the transaction a bad one, it's their right.
And it's the right of sellers to out loons like this and block them.
Silly comments aren't going to make the "lawsuit boogie men" go away. A negative doesn't even have to be defamatory. If it has the potential to affect one's income, then a lawsuit is also justified. A negative causes you to lose eBay discounts, penalizes you in searches, can force you to accept PayPal and have your funds held for 3 weeks and can cause powersellers to lose their health-care insurance. We're going to be seeing a lot of lawsuits against buyers leaving undeserved malicious feedback in the coming months.
If he is in the USN, then simply contact his commanding officer and let them notify his JAG of misconduct.
<< <i><If your "attorney on retainer" told you that he got his law degree through eMail spam
Silly comments aren't going to make the "lawsuit boogie men" go away. A negative doesn't even have to be defamatory. If it has the potential to affect one's income, then a lawsuit is also justified. A negative causes you to lose eBay discounts, penalizes you in searches, can force you to accept PayPal and have your funds held for 3 weeks and can cause powersellers to lose their health-care insurance. We're going to be seeing a lot of lawsuits against buyers leaving undeserved malicious feedback in the coming months. >>
<< <i>A negative doesn't even have to be defamatory. If it has the potential to affect one's income, then a lawsuit is also justified. >>
Then why don't movie studios sue the crap out of every critic who mercilessly pans the studio's latest flick? That could seem to cost the studios millions of dollars of revenue on each occasion.
it's cheaper that way.
Camelot
Because critics are employed to give their opinion and they usually aren't employed for free. Who pays the bidder to give their opinion?
<< <i>Because critics are employed to give their opinion and they usually aren't employed for free. Who pays the bidder to give their opinion? >>
So opinions are only "protected speech" if the "speaker" is paid to provide them? That's a pretty interesting interpretation of the First Amendment. In almost 43 years on this planet, I'd never heard that one before.
edited: ooops, always should read the whole thread first before posting.
Collector of Early 20th Century U.S. Coinage.
ANA Member R-3147111
The employee is protected. His employer isn't. But the studios would have to prove a conspiracy to lower their revenue by the newspaper or media company employing such critics. This would be nearly impossible. There would have to be a track record of reviews critical of their products when compared to those of other reviewers. How do you prove such a thing?
<< <i><Then why don't movie studios sue the crap out of every critic who mercilessly pans the studio's latest flick? <That could seem to cost the studios millions of dollars of revenue on each occasion.
Because critics are employed to give their opinion and they usually aren't employed for free. Who pays the bidder to give their opinion? >>
Is that you, Iwog???
If your premise actually had any merit then sites like paypalsucks.com would have been sued out of existence. I sure hope your lawyer isn't feeding you this crap.
Russ, NCNE
That's how EBay's figured out and then rigged the system to avoid giving you the discount.
I say screw it, I'm charging what it costs.
It is what it is.
<< <i>I just blocked him for eternity. I'm waiting for a buyer like this one to leave me my first negative. I've already let my lawyer know ahead of time that this will probably happen to me and I fully intend to file a defamation suit in their home county when it does happen. It's going to cost them. >>
PLEASE.....Let me be the first so I can tell you and your attorney where to stick it!
I'd rather have a hippie for a friend than you. It's painful to think I spent all that time in the trenches defending the rights of "real Americans" like yourself.
<< <i><PLEASE.....Let me be the first so I can tell you and your attorney where to stick it
I'd rather have a hippie for a friend than you. It's painful to think I spent all that time in the trenches defending the rights of "real Americans" like yourself. >>
Now you're really talking out of your ass.
https://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/gold/liberty-head-2-1-gold-major-sets/liberty-head-2-1-gold-basic-set-circulation-strikes-1840-1907/publishedset/15628
March of Time - 27 Centuries in Gold
https://coins.www.collectors-society.com/WCM/CoinCustomSetView.aspx?s=36590
<< <i>Gamehunter, If your premise actually had any merit then sites like paypalsucks.com would have been sued out of existence. I sure hope your lawyer isn't feeding you this crap. Russ, NCNE >>
He's never even spoken to an attourney, doen't know what "on retainer" means, and enjoys blowing smoke. Those who think suing is the solution for everything, almost without exception, have never tried it. --Jerry
It's a fixed annual fee I pay him to remain on-call for any and all legal matters I might need assistance with.
"attourney, doen't"
You're a bright bulb aren't you?