Options
What is the best stategy for submitting a slabbed coin for grading?
Let's say you have a nice NGC slabbed coin and you send it to PCGS for grading? Are you better off cracking the coin out before you send it in for grading or are you better off leaving it in the slab? Is there any bias when a grader sees the coin in a competators slab? Is he influenced by the grade on the slab? What are your experiences and thoughts?
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
0
Comments
I was a Monkey
Either way, good luck
If you do not give a hoot that the coin may downgrade, then crack it out and submit raw.
If you do not want the coin to downgrade then submit it in the slab for crossover.
Are graders influenced by a competitors slab? They are not supposed to be but this is very difficult to prove and it can be very costly!
The name is LEE!
In general, it's not wise imo to crack anything out until you've tried sending it in the holder first. The potential for a downgrade if cracked out or a BB is becoming quite common place, even on coins that you know are 100% orig and untampered with. I am a firm believer that the coin the company keeps on the submission plays a role on how it is individually received. Single coin submissions don't have the benefit of being seen with similar coins (PQ or LQ) and in the same vein, they don't have to contend with the confusion that other coins could add. Someday I'm sure that one of the big boys will write a book on this topic. Some of them have earned PhD's on the subject.
As far as the question to whether the graders are influenced by grading a coin in someone else's holder is VERY easy to answer. Considering that both major TPG's have a 30-40% cross rate on the other guy's stuff, what does that tell you? In a perfect world, with the same quality of graders shouldn't they be in agreement on 60-80% of the coin's out there? The above means that the world's best graders, when separated by a distance of >2000 miles, disagree on regrades 60% of the time (ie agree no more than 40% of the time). Yet on raw coins submitted to each service they typically only disagree on only 10-30% of the coins. My example is more suited towards silver and gold type coins and pre-1916 material. On moderns and most 20th century REG series, the story is different.
roadrunner
<< <i>My thoughts are:
If you do not give a hoot that the coin may downgrade, then crack it out and submit raw.
If you do not want the coin to downgrade then submit it in the slab for crossover.
Are graders influenced by a competitors slab? They are not supposed to be but this is very difficult to prove and it can be very costly! >>
I sent another morgan graded by anacs for crossover and it came back a grade lower.
I think they really do look at the coin and not just the holder and its current marked grade.
I dont think it matters if you crack it out first or leave it in its current slab other than you might damage it.
No more than if you send a raw coin to pcgs 10 different times and might get different results.
Coins where the 3rd side are important I would send raw.
I say sneak up on them in the middle of the night - whisper in their ears- MH2 SEZ 1878 ms69, MH2 SEZ 1878ms69, MH2 SEZ1878 ms69, etc...
and then send them a PO1 for grade.
Camelot
Experience the World through Numismatics...it's more than you can imagine.
If questionable, keep it in the slab.
roadrunner
I think, in some occasions, being in the competitors holder could play a role in affecting judgment, depending on who and what is going on at PCGS. A significant amount of NGC coins will grade a grade lower depending on the series, so I'd expect that to happen, unless of course, it's graded in a way that PCGS should agree (I've sent in enough coins at this point that I can usually predict what will be graded and by whom, just by looking at it).
Raw coins, however, carry a significant risk, even if they are NT and the grade you believe them to be.
I think we just have to realize that these coins are looked at for a very small period of time, and a grade assigned rather quickly. If at first you don't succeed, try try again.
Doesn't this just give the TPGs an incentive to under grade?
1947-P & D; 1948-D; 1949-P & S; 1950-D & S; and 1952-S.
Any help locating any of these OBW rolls would be gratefully appreciated!
There's just too much risk of a BB or downgrade. If you send the coin in it's holder, it's
guaranteed to come back at that grade at a minimum.