Options
"PCGS: Only TPGS to Survive, All Others Shut Down"
It would seem that many of you would like the above headline to be real. Personally, I think it's sad that two very viable grading services are in upheaval. Yeah, yeah....I don't want to hear how you don't like an ICG 70 (my advice, if you don't like the grade your pocket change gets, don't get it graded). However, they and ANACS, in my opinion, provide an excellent service at rates that are competitive.
So, you guys just want to have NGC and PCGS as the only survivors? How about only PCGS...that would make the Kool-Aid drinkers ecstatic, certainly.
So, you guys just want to have NGC and PCGS as the only survivors? How about only PCGS...that would make the Kool-Aid drinkers ecstatic, certainly.
0
Comments
<< <i>It would seem that many of you would like the above headline to be real. Personally, I think it's sad that two very viable grading services are in upheaval. Yeah, yeah....I don't want to hear how you don't like an ICG 70 (my advice, if you don't like the grade your pocket change gets, don't get it graded). However, they and ANACS, in my opinion, provide an excellent service at rates that are competitive.
So, you guys just want to have NGC and PCGS as the only survivors? How about only PCGS...that would make the Kool-Aid drinkers ecstatic, certainly. >>
Who said any of this? Got links to the threads?
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
Jason
<< <i>Yep ... even though I purchase PCGS graded coins primarily, we need the competition to keep things honest. I remember years back when I joined the collectors club, I got some nice books, an ASE, and submission material. Now you get none of that. A very basic set of materials for submitting, and it's certainly not cheap either. >>
i thought that's what the CAC is for
will use a much stricter standard that would give pcgs/ngc a real run
for their money.
this would be a private affair that is ran by a few dealers and their employees
that would go back to a standard of 15 years ago.
they would not be concerned about making a ton of money off the business,
but more concerned with producing a viable standard of grading that would
make their product (slabbed coins) superior looking to the competition.
obviously they may BB many more coins but the end result would be top notch
coins in their slabs going for good money.
Can you picture their half eagles graded xf45 going for current au53 money? i can.
think of Mr Snows seal of approval sticker, but instead of a sticker his own slabbed product.
EagleEye IHC grading service is open for business ;o) why not have the new tpg specialize
by the dealer. if you want a gold coin graded it should be sent to this person. if you want copper
it goes here. etc...
<< <i>It would seem that many of you would like the above headline to be real. Personally, I think it's sad that two very viable grading services are in upheaval. Yeah, yeah....I don't want to hear how you don't like an ICG 70 (my advice, if you don't like the grade your pocket change gets, don't get it graded). However, they and ANACS, in my opinion, provide an excellent service at rates that are competitive.
So, you guys just want to have NGC and PCGS as the only survivors? How about only PCGS...that would make the Kool-Aid drinkers ecstatic, certainly. >>
LINKS?
You accuse us of wanting "All Other TPGs Shut Down"
Prove it! Show us the great demand on this forum to shut down ANACS and ICG.
Positive BST Transactions (buyers and sellers): wondercoin, blu62vette, BAJJERFAN, privatecoin, blu62vette, AlanLastufka, privatecoin
#1 1951 Bowman Los Angeles Rams Team Set
#2 1980 Topps Los Angeles Rams Team Set
#8 (and climbing) 1972 Topps Los Angeles Rams Team Set
Didn't wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
--"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
<< <i>i feel that there is room right now for a new grading company that
will use a much stricter standard that would give pcgs/ngc a real run
for their money.
this would be a private affair that is ran by a few dealers and their employees
that would go back to a standard of 15 years ago.
they would not be concerned about making a ton of money off the business,
but more concerned with producing a viable standard of grading that would
make their product (slabbed coins) superior looking to the competition.
obviously they may BB many more coins but the end result would be top notch
coins in their slabs going for good money.
Can you picture their half eagles graded xf45 going for current au53 money? i can.
think of Mr Snows seal of approval sticker, but instead of a sticker his own slabbed product.
EagleEye IHC grading service is open for business ;o) why not have the new tpg specialize
by the dealer. if you want a gold coin graded it should be sent to this person. if you want copper
it goes here. etc... >>
<< <i>While I agree that choice is best ...one must look at the auto companies and look at the choices they're are. Who do you think is the best auto manufacturer.?? Although the TPG's don't make the coins.."they make them better"( I heard that on TV
Does this mean there is a Japanese or South Korean TPG coming?
$10 grading fee?
Russ, NCNE
I, personally, don't think it is a good thing to have them in upheaval, but, from the standpoint of their grading and customer service, I had no problems with ANACS or ICG being gone.
The attribution and grading at ANACS went downhill when it came to them moving down to Texas, imho, so why would I want them around?
ICG does so many MS70/PR70 and doesn't seem to do realistic grading on moderns that, again, why should I care if they are around?
It's the people running the company, not the company itself, that I think have the ire of the folks. Until the people running them get their collective heads out of their *****, and stop worrying about the latest $$$$ from coinvault/coin collector, etc, that won't change.
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
only be one TPG. We did have some difference of
opinion as to who was the best TPG, but that was all.
Camelot
Mr. Hall and his PCGS crew are perceived to be the best because they are MARKETING GENUISES !! They took the whole TPG concept, invested the resources, and here they are.
TPGs, after all, are a business. They are not a benevolent organization. In Hall's case, not only does he want to make money for himself and his employees, but he has to keep stockholders happy.
When you look at PCGS, NGC, ANACS, and ICG...on any given day any one is as good as or better than the other. Each has a different "code" of grading. The marketing machine of CLCT and PCGS has successfully marketed the idea that the PCGS standard is THE standard...and has made it stick with today's collectors. Everybody else is swimming against the current because the PCGS juggernaut throws back a strong wake. Why do you think, despite all the complaining, that MicroSoft always wins the software war at the cash register ??
And this is not a sideways slam at PCGS....it's a business, and they are executing a pretty successful business plan. Turmoil is bad for business, and ANACSICG is going to have to overcome that turmoil and win the fight with themselves before they can compete with the big dogs.
This is a ridiculous thread based on a contrived quote and a rhetorical question..
As for drinking KoolAde, I thing you've been at the trough a little too long.
Another case of someone coming into another person's living room and taking a dump on the carpet looking for conversation.
Good luck.
<< <i>Please do not use quote marks in the thread title if it is not a quote, but rather a possible scenario. >>
KoolAde impairs the use of punctuation, Tom.
<< <i>I've seen only a couple members wish ill upon ANACS and ICG. Who are these "many" to which you refer?
Russ, NCNE >>
Russ, yes, there are perhaps only a couple of posters that actually responded to the recent threads regarding the current turmoil that would seem quite pleased with such an outcome. However, over the years, this board in particular, has been extremely hostile to non-PCGS firms. I don't have time to start searching through threads right now. I also know from talking to many, some of only who lurk and don't post, have a similar pro-PCGS-only sentiment.
I find it odd that there are some responders to this thread that are irritated that I made such a statement and it seems preposterous to them. For those in that court, I'd say, One, I wasn't inferring that You explicitly made such a statement; and Two, perhaps you're new to these boards and haven't seen the plethora of threads and responses that do exist in the thread archives.
<< <i>If everyone felt comfortable with grading and authentication, then we wouldn't need any TPGs. >>
I firmly believe in numismatics as the world's greatest hobby, but recognize that this is a luxury and without collectors, we can all spend/melt our collections/inventories.
eBaystore
<< <i>
<< <i>I've seen only a couple members wish ill upon ANACS and ICG. Who are these "many" to which you refer?
Russ, NCNE >>
Russ, yes, there are perhaps only a couple of posters that actually responded to the recent threads regarding the current turmoil that would seem quite pleased with such an outcome. However, over the years, this board in particular, has been extremely hostile to non-PCGS firms. I don't have time to start searching through threads right now. I also know from talking to many, some of only who lurk and don't post, have a similar pro-PCGS-only sentiment.
I find it odd that there are some responders to this thread that are irritated that I made such a statement and it seems preposterous to them. For those in that court, I'd say, One, I wasn't inferring that You explicitly made such a statement; and Two, perhaps you're new to these boards and haven't seen the plethera of threads and responses that do exist in the thread archives. >>
plethora
<< <i>... Although the TPG's don't make the coins.."they make them better"( I heard that on TV
HAHAHA !
"We don't make the coins ... we make them better"
- NCS slogan.
<< <i>If everyone felt comfortable with grading and authentication, then we wouldn't need any TPGs. >>
Yes, we would. It helps decrease the games dealers play with buy/sell grades. It still happens, but not as drastically as with raw coins.
<< <i>People who think it's okay to have only PCGS -- because it's all they use or buy -- need to remember that if submission fees double in the absence of competition. >>
Yes, and then PCGS would be the only one slabbing TV coins.
<< <i>i feel that there is room right now for a new grading company that
will use a much stricter standard that would give pcgs/ngc a real run
for their money.
. >>
I'll design the holder. It will be really cool and compliment the appearance of the coins.
No more coins floating in a boring expanse of milky transluscent silicone rubber !
will use a much stricter standard that would give pcgs/ngc a real run
for their money.
Just so happens that one's for sale! Any takers?
1947-P & D; 1948-D; 1949-P & S; 1950-D & S; and 1952-S.
Any help locating any of these OBW rolls would be gratefully appreciated!
<< <i>i feel that there is room right now for a new grading company that
will use a much stricter standard that would give pcgs/ngc a real run
for their money.
this would be a private affair that is ran by a few dealers and their employees
that would go back to a standard of 15 years ago.
they would not be concerned about making a ton of money off the business,
but more concerned with producing a viable standard of grading that would
make their product (slabbed coins) superior looking to the competition.
obviously they may BB many more coins but the end result would be top notch
coins in their slabs going for good money.
Can you picture their half eagles graded xf45 going for current au53 money? i can.
think of Mr Snows seal of approval sticker, but instead of a sticker his own slabbed product.
EagleEye IHC grading service is open for business ;o) why not have the new tpg specialize
by the dealer. if you want a gold coin graded it should be sent to this person. if you want copper
it goes here. etc... >>
<< <i>I just want grading in accordance with the NAMBLA guidelines... >>
Whaaa???
<< <i>
<< <i>I just want grading in accordance with the NAMBLA guidelines... >>
Whaaa???
He wants to use Walter Breen's grading standards.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
You wouldn't believe how long it took to get him to sit still for this.
Vietnam Vet 1968-1969
<< <i>that would make the Kool-Aid drinkers ecstatic, certainly. >>
Improper grammar.
sainty 2, prethen 1
<< <i>saintguru, My proffer is your wording is not a complete sentence. Score is now 2/2. With Respect, John Curlis >>
Bite me.
Guru 1, charley 0. Shut out in 3 innings.
"The attribution and grading at ANACS went downhill when it came to them moving down to Texas."
So true-especially the attribution. I was very hesitant to use them ever again after they messed up on this big time a year or so ago. I thought I'd try it again, tho, but it looks like my coins will somehow end up at ICG instead. Any future business they (either one) get from me will depend entirely on how their attribution skills are these days. And, of course whether they remain viable.
<< <i>You're an amateur guano-stirrer....take it from a major leaguer.
This is a ridiculous thread based on a contrived quote and a rhetorical question..
As for drinking KoolAde, I thing you've been at the trough a little too long.
Another case of someone coming into another person's living room and taking a dump on the carpet looking for conversation.
Good luck.
I think not I thing. Would you please quit thinking about your thingy all the time.
1/2 Cents
U.S. Revenue Stamps
<< <i>
Hear! Hear!
I don't think NGC is going anywhere!
<< <i><< "PCGS: Only TPGS to Survive, All Others Shut Down" >>
I don't think NGC is going anywhere! >>
Once I believe that I read NGC grades more coins than PCGS, I do not know if they still do.
I wonder how long they can truly last looking at current, and past, auction results on Heritage? At the sampling I looked at PCGS seems to consistently realize 2 and 1/2 to 4 times as much money at auction than NGC. Of course that is still considerably more than the rare ANACS or ICG coin you see there will bring.
If the public is naive to this they cannot remain that way forever and ultimate will have to follow the cash flow.
Even though there are people loyal to NGC sooner or later I believe they will have to follow the money.
Either NGC values have to come up, PCGS values have to go down or I do believe common sense will prevail.
I do not have a horse in this race as I really only own specimen coins with these two services.
From what I read here it seems most coins cross between the two services so grading could be close to equal with everyone having an off day every now and then.
That being said I believe PCGS has a vast marketing superiority. What probably gives PCGS this lead is the lack of reciprocation with NGC on the registry sets.
No offense is meant to anyone here but this is what I think.
Chance favors the prepared mind.
I have had MANY coins cross over to PCGS (only for marketability reasons-mainly for my heirs since I will never sell my collection) that were in SEGS slabs at the same, or even LOWER grades (admittedly a few HIGHER, too-but not many)-but only after they were cracked out of the slab, so as to preclude any preconceived bias. I do admit that PCGS seems to be the most consistent grading service, (though I'm NOT pleased at the lack of attribution exercised by their attributors for some very obvious and well known varieties) and that PCGS coins deserve the top values that they bring in the Numismatic marketplace, but the automatic slamming of any so called "Third Tier" slab seems to me to be only a modern version of the old '50's and '60's trick of "Buy at one grade-sell at a higher grade" mentality that was so prevalent before slabs existed. This is what most coin dealers and the recognized dealer organizations WANT you to believe-after all, it's really only a "money" thing. Wake up!!! Look at the damned coin-not the plastic!