Options
Should I pull the plug on an auction?Edted to add:The auction is over and I'm glad I let it ride.
TennesseeDave
Posts: 4,932 ✭✭✭✭✭
1st off let me say that I am not promoting anything and will not post a link to the auction.If you had an item for sale on E-bay that was worth say $400 and you started it at $99 and no reserve and it was down to a few hours left with 4 watchers and no bids would you pull the plug or let it ride?
Edited:Now must be a good time to sell your scrap gold !auction results
Edited:Now must be a good time to sell your scrap gold !auction results
Trade $'s
0
Comments
greg
www.brunkauctions.com
heh.
i would pull the auction if i was worried and especially if no bids.
if there was a bid of any amount i would let it ride!
your choice, but the shilling idea leaves a bad taste in my mouth.
i have never sold a coin on ebay starting at .99 cents and not
get its full value. (pcgs graded half eagles).
<< <i>clad, lol, did you just suggest shilling up the bid? >>
I don't think what I suggested is shilling because there are no current bids and you wouldn't be pumping up someones already placed bid. If there were existing bids I'd not do what I mentioned but in your case I don't have any problems with it. You'd basically just be changing the starting bid.
Russ, NCNE
But next time, if you're that concerned, make the starting bid $400 instead of $99 and you won't have to worry.
If you have done everything correctly including photos, terms , end time, etc., IMHO, eBay is very efficient at pricing items.
If something is wrong with your auction, consider it a good lesson and don't make the same mistake twice.
ah, i did not think of it that way. good point.
but still, i would not do it.
Either way it is a shill.
From E-Bay
Shill Bidding is bidding that artificially increases an item’s price or apparent desirability, or bidding by individuals with a level of access to the seller’s item information not available to the general Community. Shill Bidding is prohibited on eBay.
Bob is a high-volume seller on eBay, who wants to be sure that he never sells at a loss. Rather than use eBay’s “Reserve Price” feature to set his minimum sale prices, Bob has an associate place bids on his auctions... in effect, setting a ‘hidden’ reserve price.
Clearly the friend has inside information, thus shill.
...but what exactly makes the seller think the coin is worth $400? If he started it at $99 and there's zero interest I'd say the coin isn't worth anywhere close to $400
No "ifs, ands, or buts" about it.
If you can't handle selling it for lower, than pay the price for a reserve or set the initial price higher.
I had something I put up for a friend 2 weeks ago. She doesn't have ebay or paypal so I was helping. It sat at the starting bid for all but the last 12 seconds or so, then 4 people sniped. She sold for an acceptable price
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
Hoard the keys.
<< <i>
<< <i>clad, lol, did you just suggest shilling up the bid? >>
I don't think what I suggested is shilling because there are no current bids and you wouldn't be pumping up someones already placed bid. If there were existing bids I'd not do what I mentioned but in your case I don't have any problems with it. You'd basically just be changing the starting bid. >>
.....................................................
no more woories.
end of story....
<< <i>I agree with Russ.
But next time, if you're that concerned, make the starting bid $400 instead of $99 and you won't have to worry. >>
I also agree-end it. I'm guessing your selling a widget and there is a 99.9% chance you will only get your opening bid or close to it. I sell lots of widgets and rarely get what the coin is so called valued. Every coin I sell I set a opening price I consider to be the very least I will accept. It's not any cheaper setting a reserve in your auction as opposed to a higher opening bid. You may have to face the fact that if you couldn't pull a $99 bid-the chances of getting a higher bid are even less.
<< <i>According to ebay, clearly the friend has inside information, thus shill. >>
PUL-leeese..according to ebay's definition, anyone who goes to advance viewing before an auction has
inside information not available to all bidders, and is therefore a shill...
<< <i>I didn't think you could end an auction if it had less than 12 hours remaining.... >>
i think you can if there are no bids. anybody correct me if i`m wrong.
<< <i>
<< <i>I didn't think you could end an auction if it had less than 12 hours remaining.... >>
i think you can if there are no bids. anybody correct me if i`m wrong. >>
If you have bidders or not doesn't matter-you can cancel. I'm not positive about the 12 hour rule. I recently had to cancel a auction just a little over the 12 hours with a bidder and it was no problem at all.
<< <i><< I didn't think you could end an auction if it had less than 12 hours remaining.... >>
i think you can if there are no bids. anybody correct me if i`m wrong. >>
If you have bidders or not doesn't matter-you can cancel. I'm not positive about the 12 hour rule. >>
If the auction is under 12 hours and you have a winning bid or a reserve met bid, you cannot cancel the listing. If it has no bids, or the reserve is not met, you can.
Edited for clarification: In a no reserve auction, any bid is a winning bid.
Russ, NCNE
I don't think it would be considered SHILLING if I bid with the FULL intent to pay for the coin if I win.......
If I listed a $400 coin at 99 cents and had 4 watchers with a few hours left and the high bid was less than $100 I would be tempted to pull the plug. However I would weigh the value of my reputation as being a person who doesn't pull the plug unless I've made an error in listing... but you started at $99...
Naturally one course of action that is not available at the very last minute is to advertise, say on the B/S/T, that you have a $400 coin ending in, say, 1 day, and you would like a mercy bid of $250...
Edited for clarification: In a no reserve auction, any bid is a winning bid.
Russ, NCNE >>
As I understand it though-you may cancel any bid you wish at any time for any reason.
<< <i>Edited for clarification: In a no reserve auction, any bid is a winning bid.
Russ, NCNE >>
As I understand it though-you may cancel any bid you wish at any time for any reason. >>
Yes, you can cancel the bid but even after doing so you still cannot end the auction. The eBay coding is setup in such a way as to prevent sellers from making any changes in the last 12 hours, including ending the listing, even if you cancel all bids.
Russ, NCNE
Same time I started a $50 star note for 99 cents and it sold for $48....
I also sold a JUNK lot of 20 acid date buffalo nickels (all common in POOR condition), $5 face value, started at 1 cent, sold for that same 1 cent ......
it happens, but they were not major losses, AND I was curious to see what would happen........
On items that I can't afford to take a loss upon, I start the bidding at an appropriate price......
NOT !!!!!
Ken
<< <i>1st off let me say that I am not promoting anything and will not post a link to the auction.If you had an item for sale on E-bay that was worth say $400 and you started it at $99 and no reserve and it was down to a few hours left with 4 watchers and no bids would you pull the plug or let it ride? >>
Let it ride. Don't listen to the people trying to push you towards doing somthing that you know is not right. Show some dignaty and character, learn from your mistake and get on with your life.
"I has a bucket." - Minazo.
Minazo the LOLRUS, 1994-2005
<< <i> Who cares how many people are watching. >>
I recently had a auction end with 45 watchers and no bids-just curiousity.
<< <i>Yeah, Clad, what you said is the defintion of shill bidding and is not cool. The seller needs to learn a lesson with this coin. If he wants to remove the auction I guess that's his business...
...but what exactly makes the seller think the coin is worth $400? If he started it at $99 and there's zero interest I'd say the coin isn't worth anywhere close to $400 >>
I never stated it was a $400.00 coin.It is just some 14K gold(33 grams of it)
<< <i>
<< <i> Who cares how many people are watching. >>
I recently had a auction end with 45 watchers and no bids-just curiousity. >>
I've had that happen too........ Certain collectors watch some of my esoteric varieties (darkside) to see what the market is.........
So the best way to avoid doing wrong is to do it right. Avoid eBay. Use the BST.
Blow Meg off and go in the HALLway
eBoy™
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>The auction is over and I'm happy with the results.
<< <i>The auction is over and I'm happy with the results.
Was it a flurry of last second sniping? A few of us told you that may happen
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
<< <i>See? You were sweating for nothing.
Russ, NCNE >>
that's usually the case. I almost always start at 99 cents. I used to sweat em too. The market will dictate the value and you usually get your desired price.