Options
What eBay Should Have Done about Coin Grading
Here is the solution I offered ebay.
Have a catagory for PCGS graded coins
Have a catagory for NGC graded coins
Have a catagory for ANACS graded coins
Have a catagory for ICG graded coins
Have a catagory for ABC graded coins
come on its a data base you can create a catagory for what ever you want...........
Now tell me that would not have been more fair to everyone. FLAME away
Al
Have a catagory for PCGS graded coins
Have a catagory for NGC graded coins
Have a catagory for ANACS graded coins
Have a catagory for ICG graded coins
Have a catagory for ABC graded coins
come on its a data base you can create a catagory for what ever you want...........
Now tell me that would not have been more fair to everyone. FLAME away
Al
0

Comments
or would I have to search in each catagory? Might be a bit of a problem without the right search
engines that would cross over to additional catagories. Workable for sure.
bob
President, Racine Numismatic Society 2013-2014; Variety Resource Dimes; See 6/8/12 CDN for my article on Winged Liberty Dimes; Ebay
<< <i>Here is the solution I offered ebay.
Have a catagory for PCGS graded coins
Have a catagory for NGC graded coins
Have a catagory for ANACS graded coins
Have a catagory for ICG graded coins
Have a catagory for ABC graded coins
come on its a data base you can create a catagory for what ever you want...........
Now tell me that would not have been more fair to everyone. FLAME away
Al >>
It's actually not a bad idea. Unfortunately, there is no way to disseminate the value add grading companies such as PCGS with the implementation of these categories and I believe that is what EBAY is trying to do.
Rob
"Those guys weren't Fathers they were...Mothers."
<< <i>It has some merit but most people don't drink one TPG's Kool-Aid to the point that they will ONLY take coins of one TPG. >>
BINGO! some do however, and for those, they can simply type 'PCGS' in the subject line. whatever dreg inventory that dealers are selling off that day on the 'bay will show up for all to see. then the drinkers can click away 'till the cows come home!
<< <i>No, they found a way to get the junk off. Why give them another way to put it back on? >>
Not all coins self slabbed by dealers are junk....
<< <i>
<< <i>No, they found a way to get the junk off. Why give them another way to put it back on? >>
Not all coins self slabbed by dealers are junk.... >>
The chance of reselling any third world crap for the value of the stated grade is about the same as winning the lottery. Dave W
David J Weygant Rare Coins website: www.djwcoin.com
edit to add:
Of course, a lot of big wigs have helped by demeaning the LITTLE collectors, too.
<< <i>
The chance of reselling any third world crap for the value of the stated grade is about the same as winning the lottery. Dave W
David J Weygant Rare Coins website: www.djwcoin.com >>
So, you believe that it is inherently unethical for a coin dealer to grade his own coins and put them into his own slab or sealed flip?
While here is an NGC MS66 Red coin from Teletrade Auction 1912 Lot
1090
It all comes down to..if you DO NOT want to trust your dealer, and
just buy the plastic...well you can find some nice PCGS draped bust
silver dollars from Chinese sellers....
I still cannot see any reason to complain about the current set of rules. How does not listing a grade in the title hurt the sale of a raw coin, especially since you can specifiy VF, AU, BU etc?
Perhaps they should have had categories for each one, and when you are selling junk slabs, Ebay puts a big disclaimer in the listing for you. I am sure that would have gone over well.
It is not hard to see why Teletrade does not allow junk slabs and self assigned grades given the type of people who think they should be allowed.
<< <i> Our "third world slab" MS66 which we called MS64 is here... >>
Frank,
Are you claiming that the coin above is the one you sold in this auction, which I linked from a different thread earlier in the week? I didn't see anywhere in that auction where you said your coin was really a 64. I also noticed the image is no longer showing in the listing - it was there when I linked it a few days ago. The file the listing is looking for is "http://www.frankcoins.com/e3972.jpg", while the coin in your post is named "e4040.jpg", so obviously it can't be the same auction, right?
Maybe you can provide the link to the right auction for me, unless eBay removed it on you. Thanks,
Sean Reynolds
"Keep in mind that most of what passes as numismatic information is no more than tested opinion at best, and marketing blather at worst. However, I try to choose my words carefully, since I know that you guys are always watching." - Joe O'Connor
<< <i>
<< <i> Our "third world slab" MS66 which we called MS64 is here... >>
Frank,
Are you claiming that the coin above is the one you sold in this auction, which I linked from a different thread earlier in the week? I didn't see anywhere in that auction where you said your coin was really a 64. I also noticed the image is no longer showing in the listing - it was there when I linked it a few days ago. The file the listing is looking for is "http://www.frankcoins.com/e3972.jpg", while the coin in your post is named "e4040.jpg", so obviously it can't be the same auction, right?
Maybe you can provide the link to the right auction for me, unless eBay removed it on you. Thanks,
Sean Reynolds >>
That was a different coin, nicer than the one that I am showing above.
It was among these:
eBay Listing Removed: Counterfeit Currency and Stamps (=PS &12363 JM150178638)
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Dear frankcoins,
You recently listed the following listing:
200160392679 - 1930-S Lincoln Cent MS64 Red Retail $75 No Reserve
200160391508 - 1934 Walking Half AU55 Retail $60 No Minimum
200160399854 - 1880 Indian Head Cent EF45 Retail $35 No Minimum
200160257173 - 1864 Confederate $20 Note T-67 CSA VF No Res
200160397273 - 1893 Chicago World's Fair Half Dollar AU58 Retail $30
200160397958 - 1963 Franklin Half MS64 Retail $30 No Minimum
200160395384 - 1853 $2.50 Gold Quarter Eagle AU55 Retail $300 No Min
200160253586 - 1776-1976 Bicentennial Mint Set
200160430852 - 1945 Washington Quarter MS65 Retail $50
200160429909 - 1943 Washington Quarter Choice AU Retail $7
200160255014 - 1917 Large Size $2 Note Tape Repair
200158329559 - 1941 Walking Half PCI MS64 Retail $70 Properly Graded
200160398870 - 1880-O Morgan Dollar AU58 Retail $35 No Reserve
The listing was removed because it violated the eBay Counterfeit Currency and Stamps policy.
WS
<< <i>The listing was removed because it violated the eBay Counterfeit Currency and Stamps policy. >>
No, it was removed because it violated the grade and value in the title policy. This martyr act is lame.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
I still cannot see any reason to complain about the current set of rules. How does not listing a grade in the title hurt the sale of a raw coin, especially since you can specifiy VF, AU, BU etc? >>
There is still a market for people wishing to put sets of raw Peace dollars, Walkers, and Franklins in Danscos or Capital boards, and they prefer MS-63 grade. These usually sell for double MS-60 grade. Terms such as choice and gem have various meanings, and none are official for MS coins in the 6th edition of the ANA guide.
Searching for the auction text gives many false hits, and there is often boilerplate material such as "authorized dealer for PCGS, NGC, ANACS, ICG"
Plus the terms like Select, Choice and Gem BU have been associated with listings in the multi-page ads in the coin papers by dealers who have been expelled from the ANA.
<< <i>
<< <i>The listing was removed because it violated the eBay Counterfeit Currency and Stamps policy. >>
No, it was removed because it violated the grade and value in the title policy. This martyr act is lame.
Russ, NCNE >>
You are a jerk. They send an email claiming it violates counterfeit coin policy, and has links to the United State Code on counterfeits.
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
<< <i><< The listing was removed because it violated the eBay Counterfeit Currency and Stamps policy. >>
No, it was removed because it violated the grade and value in the title policy. This martyr act is lame.
Russ, NCNE >>
You are a jerk. They send an email claiming it violates counterfeit coin policy, and has links to the United State Code on counterfeits. >>
They sent you the standard boiler plate copy/paste eMail that they send any time they end a coin auction.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i> They send an email claiming it violates counterfeit coin policy, and has links to the United State Code on counterfeits. >>
I'd agree that they probably need to update their boilerplate, but that's all this is.
<< <i>
They sent you the standard boiler plate copy/paste eMail that they send any time they end a coin auction.
Russ, NCNE >>
They ended THESE also, for stating that the face value of the mint set and that the torn $2
saddleblanket was "still legal tender for $2, of course" The PCI coins were posted before Oct 1, as was
the gold coin. Their explanation for those was "many complaints" and "hyping, which might have to do with drugs"
Does pointing out bad policy make someone a target, where the anonymous bullies feel justified deliberately trying to end my auctions and cause me economic harm?
200160253586 - 1776-1976 Bicentennial Mint Set
200160255014 - 1917 Large Size $2 Note Tape Repair
They are dead !
<< <i>200160253586 - 1776-1976 Bicentennial Mint Set
200160255014 - 1917 Large Size $2 Note Tape Repair >>
You have a legitimate complaint about those two auctions. The rest is just whining.
Russ, NCNE
"You Suck Award" - February, 2015
Discoverer of 1919 Mercury Dime DDO - FS-101
"If I say something in the woods, and my wife isn't around to hear it. Am I still wrong?"
If everyone would grade the coin, and pay what they are willing to pay for that grade, instead of buying the numbers inside the plastic, the only words in the title that would make any difference would be the date, series, type, variety, and composition......
Which BTW is how I list coins and currency
Education is the answer, not discrimination......
Al