Options
Those paying huge premiums for MS/PR 70s should be slapped. Those grading them should be shot.
SeattleSlammer
Posts: 10,130 ✭✭✭✭✭
"Wow, I sure am lucky and ultra fortunate that PCGS/NGC has decided to grade this particular modern coin as a 70! What a score! Sure, nobody can really tell the difference between a 69 and a 70, but since those mighty graders saw fit to bestow a 70 on this one, I'm so excited because I know some 'numismatist' out there will fork over some serious cash for it! Yeah, I really don't know how a coin can be "perfect" either, but who cares! I love PCGS/NGC!"
0
Comments
<< <i>Yeah, I really don't know how a coin can be "perfect" either, but who cares! >>
You also don't know the TPG criteria for the 70 grade. Hint: It isn't "perfect".
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>while you may come across as harsh, your sentiment pretty much sums it up >>
although i'd remove the 'should be shot' part if i were you. that is certainly unnecessary
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
Wondercoin
<< <i>Don't the classic guys need the consortium to tell what ANY grade is? >>
Russ, NCNE
That's why I put perfect in quotations.
<< <i>Don't the classic guys need the consortium to tell what ANY grade is?
Good point. Maybe the consortium can define things well enough to make the modern haters happy.
PS. I usually ignore these threads but I'll go on record here to say that there is a difference between 69 and 70 and collectors of these coins can/should/often do learn to grade them---just like classics collectors.
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
Bring me 100 spouses, I'll bet I can pick out ALL the coins that WILL NOT be a 70 @ PCGS.
<< <i> I was just telling a board member via pm an interesting story of a classic coin which was tried 62x at $100/coin before, finally, upgrading on the 63rd time through the service and increasing in price around $50,000+. And, the coin is lovely for the grade in the holder it is in - it was deserving of the grade it is in now when the submittor started trying his "liner" coin years earlier. >>
Hmmm... so you're saying the TPG in question was wrong 62 out of the 63 times the coin was submitted? Sorry, but based on the fact the submitter clearly wanted the $50,000 upshot as opposed to getting an opinion of the grade, I can only see somebody trying to rip off a future customer with this coin.
<< <i>Bring me 100 spouses, I'll bet I can pick out ALL the coins that WILL NOT be a 70 @ PCGS. >>
<< <i>Bring me 100 spouses, I'll bet I can pick out ALL the coins that WILL NOT be a 70 @ PCGS. >>
But can you pick out the ones that will?
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
Wouldn't you think so - strangely, (3) of the greatest world class graders (2 from one service and 1 from the other service with combined professional grading experience of roughly 65 years) either picked this particular coin over another in the same grade when a collector I know had to chose which coin he wanted to place in his world class collection or described this particular specimen as "hands down" the greatest specimen he had seen in more than 15 years of being a very senior grader at one of the services.
I believe the coin was submitted 63x because someone correctly believed in it and once it got in the holder, it looked very comfortable there.
Which brings us to the main point of this fascinating (but true) tale -1 point jumps are often costly jumps in price whethere they are MS69 to MS70 1 point jumps or MS66 to MS67 1 point jumps and whether they are classic coins or moderns. Makes no difference really.
Wondercoin
<< <i>
<< <i>Bring me 100 spouses, I'll bet I can pick out ALL the coins that WILL NOT be a 70 @ PCGS. >>
my thoughts exactly. here is one (of many) problems i have with the "rare" MS/PF 70 market.
It has been said by Mark Feld and others that are/were graders for the 'big two' that a coin is looked at (graded) for no more than 15 seconds or so. I think i'm not the only one that has purchased a coin, looked at it closely for much longer than than and STILL managed to find a nuance, tick mark or hairline that i never saw before; on the umpteenth time i've looked at it! the fact that you've got graders getting overwhelmed with bulk submissions of bullion and having to grade them when they all look pretty much the same; and then paying tons of money for a "perfect" when they clearly overlooked details on something that is really only intended to be a store of wealth for the very metal contained therein, is silly. People can say the same thing about grading classics, but a classic in a lower grade will still (generally) have a significant value over and above the cost of the metal itself, where a bullion coin that goes for a 70, but comes back with a 68 or 69 is oftentimes worth little more than the bullion itself
<< <i>
<< <i>Yeah, I really don't know how a coin can be "perfect" either, but who cares! >>
You also don't know the TPG criteria for the 70 grade. Hint: It isn't "perfect".
Russ, NCNE >>
But, Russ, wasn't the intention of the 70-point grading system to make 70="Perfect"? I betcha that he creator of the system (I forget his name for the moment) never intended for 70 ever to exist. It was a theoretical grade. In fact, the services also felt this was a theoretical grade up until some point in the '90's. I remember hearing about a comment from Salsburg where he stated that NGC will NEVER grade a coin a 70. Yet that all changed with the heavy submissions of modern coinage in the past 15 years.
<< <i>I think i'm not the only one that has purchased a coin, looked at it closely for much longer than than and STILL managed to find a nuance, tick mark or hairline that i never saw before >>
That may be true, but there are a few points to make here:
1- The more coins you look at, the less often that happens... graders have seen a LOT
2- You don't miss a mark that is prominent. Those that are well concealed affect the grade far less than those that are prominent
3- Even the graders aren't perfect. They do make mistakes.
That said, I usually have an opinion about a coin within a few seconds... sometimes it's the full grade, other times just whether or not I like it. I've found the more I look at the coin, the more I second-guess myself, and then my accuracy goes down. When graders need to look at a coin longer, they do, but often, they don't have to. Of course, if there's a big financial impact between grades, more graders may see the coin, or they'll take a closer look.
That's probably the most telling comment. It's only a pricing game between grades 69-70. PCGS/NGC create their own markets. If you cracked out 100 PCGS 70 coins and resubmitted, it wouldn't be surprising to get half of them back as 69s. Hence, you're a sucker to shell out major money for a 70. Of course there's a market full of suckers perpetuating this so I have no illusions that I'm doing anything here other than spitting in the ocean.
<< <i>
<< <i>I think i'm not the only one that has purchased a coin, looked at it closely for much longer than than and STILL managed to find a nuance, tick mark or hairline that i never saw before >>
That may be true, but there are a few points to make here:
1- The more coins you look at, the less often that happens... graders have seen a LOT
2- You don't miss a mark that is prominent. Those that are well concealed affect the grade far less than those that are prominent
3- Even the graders aren't perfect. They do make mistakes.
That said, I usually have an opinion about a coin within a few seconds... sometimes it's the full grade, other times just whether or not I like it. I've found the more I look at the coin, the more I second-guess myself, and then my accuracy goes down. When graders need to look at a coin longer, they do, but often, they don't have to. Of course, if there's a big financial impact between grades, more graders may see the coin, or they'll take a closer look. >>
i think the biggest thing with the ultra-high grade modern craze is that the buyers (at least a majority of them), think that they are buying a perfect coin! What Russ said about 70 and perfection, or lack therof, is not the first time i've heard this. MS/PF 70 grades opened up a huge new door that the 'big 2' were happy to walk through; "the Mint is churning out tons of NCLT and bullion, and we can make a perverbial mint by grading it. we'll have 'em foaming at the mouth for what they think is 'perfect' ! " This is a huge cash cow for the TPGs and one they know is bringing in tons of money. I can't confirm this for sure, but i'd bet a hefty sum that PCGS/NGC's best graders aren't grading NCLT and bullion full-time for three reasons; misuse of talent, burn-out, but most of all, LIABILITY ! When you grade a classic, and the veteran graders are thinking of upgrading this coin by a point, that jump in price can be huge! If they upgrade it, and it turns out that it didnt' deserve it, they get negative press here on the boards and in the minds of dealers and collectors. Give a coin a '70' when in fact it is not, and the unsuspecting buyer (and let's face it, the majority of these buyers/collectors are coin newbies) probably doesn't find out. Even if they do realize it, and PCGS/NGC agrees with the buyer, they will simply replace their coin with another piece of slabbed NCLT/bullion that came through recently and they weren't out of pocket much and the collector generally won't raise a stink about it.
I'm sure the graders at PCGS/NGC that do moderns are adept at what they do, but can you imagine coming in your office in the morning and finding that you have to grade 1000 or completely identical Spouse gold or ASE/etc. "coins"? The veterans wouldn't be lining up for this job, and the newer graders can't be giving anything more than a cursory examination as they try to plow through bulk order after bulk order from modern coin dealers and trashy TV coin shows. "hey, if we miss a few grades, we'll just replace the bullion with a fresh piece we'll grade tomorrow; plenty of it coming in after all"!
<< <i>
It has been said by Mark Feld and others that are/were graders for the 'big two' that a coin is looked at (graded) for no more than 15 seconds or so. I think i'm not the only one that has purchased a coin, looked at it closely for much longer than than and STILL managed to find a nuance, tick mark or hairline that i never saw before; on the umpteenth time i've looked at it! the fact that you've got graders getting overwhelmed with bulk submissions of bullion and having to grade them when they all look pretty much the same; and then paying tons of money for a "perfect" when they clearly overlooked details on something that is really only intended to be a store of wealth for the very metal contained therein, is silly. People can say the same thing about grading classics, but a classic in a lower grade will still (generally) have a significant value over and above the cost of the metal itself, where a bullion coin that goes for a 70, but comes back with a 68 or 69 is oftentimes worth little more than the bullion itself >>
Grading coins in bulk is actually the best way to spot the best coins. They just pop out at you if you've already looked at hundreds.
I believe that there are many people who focus on high grade moderns that can tell the difference between a 69 and a 70 just as well as others can tell a difference between a 66 and a 67.
Which brings us to the main point of this fascinating (but true) tale -1 point jumps are often costly jumps in price whethere they are MS69 to MS70 1 point jumps or MS66 to MS67 1 point jumps and whether they are classic coins or moderns. Makes no difference really.
I would venture to say that there are more abuses in the 66 to 67 regrade scenario than there are in the 69 to 70 regrade scenario, and that the dollars are usually more when a high grade classic is involved.
they all look pretty much the same; and then paying tons of money for a "perfect" when they clearly overlooked details on something that is really only intended to be a store of wealth for the very metal contained therein, is silly. People can say the same thing about grading classics, but a classic in a lower grade will still (generally) have a significant value over and above the cost of the metal itself
It does depend on your perspective. To me, all MS-62 Saint Gaudens look pretty much the same, because I never really look at them, but I still consider them coins. I've never known or even heard of anyone who has ever spent even a common gold coin in a business transaction in my whole lifetime. For many, many years, low grade common gold has sold with a nominal premium over melt, and they only fell out of favor after the American Gold Eagles came onto the scene, because they were a better deal. Before AGEs came onto the scene, common gold was certainly considered "bullion" and was traded as such. It still is, to an extent.
Don't you find your statement ironic to say that bullion coins are "only intended to be a store of wealth" and then suggest that the grade of the coin should only make a difference if it weren't a bullion coin? This suggests that the classic gold coins such as the St. Gaudens Double Eagles were somehow not a store of wealth and were predominantly used in commerce, which is simply not the case. At the time that St.Gaudens were being made, a $20.00 transaction was not an ordinary everyday transaction amount, and I would assert that they were stashed as a store of value even more than they were spent in daily transactions.
The American Eagle series have been made now for 21 years and have every likelihood of continuing as long as the St.Gaudens Double Eagles and the Morgan Dollars. They were authorized by Congress as "real" coins, and they have a nominal face value, even though their actual values vary with the price of gold, just as low grade common gold coins do. The high quality of these bullion coins is one of the major attractions for me, in addition to the fact that they now form a series with various mintmarks and a few other wrinkles such as special finishes.
a bullion coin that goes for a 70, but comes back with a 68 or 69 is oftentimes worth little more than the bullion itself
And that's a bad thing? It's the nature of the beast - there are so many nice specimens that a premium only starts to develop when attrition takes place, as it surely will over time. In the case of a population with so many high grade specimens, the attrition will become most noticable at the high end of the scale, which is why I would expect that is where the largest premiums will occur. The phenomenon is exactly the same as with any other coin series.
The prejudice towards Moderns just amazes me at times.
I knew it would happen.
<< <i>Of course, if there's a big financial impact between grades, more graders may see the coin, or they'll take a closer look.
That's probably the most telling comment. It's only a pricing game between grades 69-70. PCGS/NGC create their own markets. If you cracked out 100 PCGS 70 coins and resubmitted, it wouldn't be surprising to get half of them back as 69s. Hence, you're a sucker to shell out major money for a 70. Of course there's a market full of suckers perpetuating this so I have no illusions that I'm doing anything here other than spitting in the ocean. >>
You can test your theory by resubmitting a bunch of MS-69's so you stand to gain when half come back MS-70.
<< <i>
I'm sure the graders at PCGS/NGC that do moderns are adept at what they do, but can you imagine coming in your office in the morning and finding that you have to grade 1000 or completely identical Spouse gold or ASE/etc. "coins"? The veterans wouldn't be lining up for this job, and the newer graders can't be giving anything more than a cursory examination as they try to plow through bulk order after bulk order from modern coin dealers and trashy TV coin shows. "hey, if we miss a few grades, we'll just replace the bullion with a fresh piece we'll grade tomorrow; plenty of it coming in after all"! >>
You might be surprised to learn that modern collectors actually derive enjoyment from looking at
coins. If a grader just finds it a "job" then perhaps he'd feel the same way about grading a bag
of 1879-S dollars. It really doesn't matter so long as he consistently labels the coins right.
<< <i>"Wow, I sure am lucky and ultra fortunate that PCGS/NGC has decided to grade this particular modern coin as a 70! What a score! Sure, nobody can really tell the difference between a 69 and a 70, but since those mighty graders saw fit to bestow a 70 on this one, I'm so excited because I know some 'numismatist' out there will fork over some serious cash for it! Yeah, I really don't know how a coin can be "perfect" either, but who cares! I love PCGS/NGC!" >>
Where ya' been?
At least we don't need no damn stickers to identify which coins aren't messed with.
<< <i>
Don't you find your statement ironic to say that bullion coins are "only intended to be a store of wealth" and then suggest that the grade of the coin should only make a difference if it weren't a bullion coin? This suggests that the classic gold coins such as the St. Gaudens Double Eagles were somehow not a store of wealth and were predominantly used in commerce, which is simply not the case. At the time that St.Gaudens were being made, a $20.00 transaction was not an ordinary everyday transaction amount, and I would assert that they were stashed as a store of value even more than they were spent in daily transactions.
The American Eagle series have been made now for 21 years and have every likelihood of continuing as long as the St.Gaudens Double Eagles and the Morgan Dollars. They were authorized by Congress as "real" coins, and they have a nominal face value, even though their actual values vary with the price of gold, just as low grade common gold coins do. The high quality of these bullion coins is one of the major attractions for me, in addition to the fact that they now form a series with various mintmarks and a few other wrinkles such as special finishes.
>>
There have been more than one book written on the Liberty and St. Gaudens coins that have stated that both have circulated among the general public, the latter to a much lesser degree. The St. Gaudens were largely sent overseas to settle debts between the United States and foreign countries. being a high denomination and made of gold, it is hard to argue that these weren't "spent" between countries. compare this with our fiat money we have now, where paper currency and electronic transactions go back and forth between countries. i'd be surprised to hear of ships full of ASE/AGEs steaming across the Atlantic to pay debts, as was the case with the St. Gaudens and other US gold pre-1933.
<< <i>
<< <i>"Wow, I sure am lucky and ultra fortunate that PCGS/NGC has decided to grade this particular modern coin as a 70! What a score! Sure, nobody can really tell the difference between a 69 and a 70, but since those mighty graders saw fit to bestow a 70 on this one, I'm so excited because I know some 'numismatist' out there will fork over some serious cash for it! Yeah, I really don't know how a coin can be "perfect" either, but who cares! I love PCGS/NGC!" >>
Where ya' been?
At least we don't need no damn stickers to identify which coins aren't messed with.
with the number of ASE and other commem pieces turning up to be doctored, and many of them finding their way into top TPG holders, it won't be too far off
<< <i>It is wildly idiotic to go ballistic about the difference in value between 69 and 70, and ignore huge premiums for other one-grade jumps.
Well, except for one major difference. Virtually any other grade jump is due to something other that a single minor tick or some extremely subtle strike issue that would essentially be a non-entity in any other grade. The subtlety between a 69 and 70 is the thing that's the issue here and why the value difference can sometimes be quite laughable.
-------------------------
AnacondaRareCoins.com
Brandon would have been happy to sell my PR-70 $4,920.00 Proof Silver Eagle for me - the one he figured I would net about $3,500.00 on.
I knew it would happen.
<< <i>
<< <i>It is wildly idiotic to go ballistic about the difference in value between 69 and 70, and ignore huge premiums for other one-grade jumps.
Well, except for one major difference. Virtually any other grade jump is due to something other that a single minor tick or some extremely subtle strike issue that would essentially be a non-entity in any other grade. The subtlety between a 69 and 70 is the thing that's the issue here and why the value difference can sometimes be quite laughable. >>
I agree with you to some extent.
But it should be remembered that where these jumps are great the 70 is difficult to
find. It is a good idea for many modern collectors to search the raw coins but if you're
going for the high end and the coin is tough then it can simply be cheaper to pay up for
the slabbed coin. Collectors should really wait until a coin is a couple years old before
putting a lot of effort or money toward it. You'll have to pay a market price but being the
first on the block to have a new coin can be expensive.
Not true for the 1995 W Proof ASE, 2004 Platinum proofs or 2006 MS Plat W's, 2006 AGE or ASE Anniversary Reverse Proofs, Jackie Robinson $5 MS......
If a 70 is not acceptable of what I think a 70 should be, I will return the coin if I could not look at the coin in person. It has nothing to do with the registry for me.
Box of 20
Castle and Reagan did us a huge favor by making bullion coins available to the public. I'd be surprised to hear of such shipments too, but don't think it can't happen.
with the number of ASE and other commem pieces turning up to be doctored, and many of them finding their way into top TPG holders, it won't be too far off
I may be somewhat out of the loop, but I'm not aware of any doctoring of Silver or Gold American Eagles, or Modern Commems, in order to make a higher grade upon submission at a top TPG. Is that really happening?
I knew it would happen.
<< <i>i'd be surprised to hear of ships full of ASE/AGEs steaming across the Atlantic to pay debts, as was the case with the St. Gaudens and other US gold pre-1933.
Castle and Reagan did us a huge favor by making bullion coins available to the public. I'd be surprised to hear of such shipments too, but don't think it can't happen.
with the number of ASE and other commem pieces turning up to be doctored, and many of them finding their way into top TPG holders, it won't be too far off
I may be somewhat out of the loop, but I'm not aware of any doctoring of Silver or Gold American Eagles, or Modern Commems, in order to make a higher grade upon submission at a top TPG. Is that really happening? >>
okay, first let me point something out. I collect a few bullion and NCLT pieces because they are extremely well designed and made, i just prescribe to the grading philosophy of them. It's not the coins and their designs/metal content/etc. i have a problem with.
there have been quite a few "doctored" ASEs turning up the last year or so, and by that i largely mean artifically toned. Many of these have made it into NGC and PCGS holders to the chagrin of many of us. there was a long (300 posts or so) not very long ago that lamented a certain ASE that was WILDLY toned and most certainly AT that went from a MS68 PCI slab that had 'questionable toning' on the slab, to a PCGS MS69. This is one example in one thread, others have been talked about as of late. i guess the coin docs see high return for taking a simple bullion/NCLT coin and doing something to increase it's "value" to the unsuspecting.
<< <i>But a classic in a lower grade will still (generally) have a significant value over and above the cost of the metal itself, where a bullion coin that goes for a 70, but comes back with a 68 or 69 is oftentimes worth little more than the bullion itself
Not true for the 1995 W Proof ASE, 2004 Platinum proofs or 2006 MS Plat W's, 2006 AGE or ASE Anniversary Reverse Proofs, Jackie Robinson $5 MS......
If a 70 is not acceptable of what I think a 70 should be, I will return the coin if I could not look at the coin in person. It has nothing to do with the registry for me. >>
yeah, but you're one of the minority that collect these coins that are hyper-aware of these nuances that seperate the grade. Bullion, Commem. and NCLTs are the 'gateway drug', if you will, to the collecting community. Many/most that collect these are unsuspecting, like the designs, and think they are getting an absolutely "FLAWLESS" coin when they plop down their money for a 70; they have no reason to think otherwise, clever marketing has told 'em so, as does the whole 'first strike' stuff. Those of us on the forum can probably count ourselves in the very, very slim minority of coin buyers out there right now, and most of these collectors are buying up moderns and willing to pay a premium for stuff they can't tell the difference in.
I guess that I wasn't paying attention to the fact that some of those had made it into PCGS and NGC slabs as is. Wasn't there some thought that they had been AT'd after getting into the holders? If not, I agree - it's a massive problem for the TPGs if they "allow" any of this sort of BS to occur. I would almost have to believe that contaminants were introduced after the coin had been encapsulated. Did PCGS offer any comment?
On the other hand, those coins are so blatantly screwed up that it would take a real ignoramous not to see that they have been altered. This is part of the attrition factor that I mentioned in a previous post.
I knew it would happen.
<< <i>there have been quite a few "doctored" ASEs turning up the last year or so, and by that i largely mean artifically toned. Many of these have made it into NGC and PCGS holders to the chagrin of many of us. there was a long (300 posts or so) not very long ago that lamented a certain ASE that was WILDLY toned and most certainly AT that went from a MS68 PCI slab that had 'questionable toning' on the slab, to a PCGS MS69.
I guess that I wasn't paying attention to the fact that some of those had made it into PCGS and NGC slabs as is. Wasn't there some thought that they had been AT'd after getting into the holders? If not, I agree - it's a massive problem for the TPGs if they "allow" any of this sort of BS to occur. I would almost have to believe that contaminants were introduced after the coin had been encapsulated. Did PCGS offer any comment?
On the other hand, those coins are so blatantly screwed up that it would take a real ignoramous not to see that they have been altered. This is part of the attrition factor that I mentioned in a previous post. >>
here you go, interesting reading for sure!
http://forums.collectors.com/messageview.cfm?catid=26&threadid=583037&highlight_key=y&keyword1=PCI
<< <i>There are quite a few very talented crack-out artists who make a ton more money noticing the difference between, for example, a classic ms64 and an ms65, than do those who know the difference between a raw modern ms69 and an ms70. These crack-out artists do not keep in their collection all the classic coins that they upgrade. They sell them to very knowledgable collectors who are happy to pay for the difference as noted on the new slab. These collectors are not gullible, or "falling for" clever marketing, they simply want the best, or the best that they can afford. >>
yeah, a lot of these people are the same type of registry hounds as the collectors that seem to be after the 70s; they don't really care if they coin deserves the grade, only that it says the grade on the tag; they're buying the tag and not the coin
Box of 20
<< <i>I guess I should get slapped since I paid $5600 for a 70 reverse gold proof 20th Anniversary AGE last year. >>
weren't the Mint selling the sets for half of what you paid, just a few months before?
<< <i>
<< <i>I guess I should get slapped since I paid $5600 for a 70 reverse gold proof 20th Anniversary AGE last year. >>
weren't the Mint selling the sets for half of what you paid, just a few months before? >>
Not to mention the fact that it probably looks exactly like just about any 69 you can find. Congrat's on spending over $5K, though!
It's a free country and everyone's collecting preferences are different so what's your whoop.
You collect what you like and let others collect what they like, you don't have to blast someone over it.
Just to clarify, you should be slapped not shot.
<< <i>SS - it isn't the "numismatists" that are paying for the 70, it is the registry hunters
Very true Bochiman
Rob
"Those guys weren't Fathers they were...Mothers."
oops... slap those who pay, and shoot those who apply the stickers.
and what about those sellin' um?
....even forgot the sugar