Options
1858 Seated Half Dime Error
Does anyone have any ideas on what caused this error??? About half of the denticles are missing on both sides.


0
Comments
<< <i>Also, check the edge for reeding. If reeding is present it is not a broadstrike. >>
Definitely something cool going on with this coin...looks like it may be broadstruck (the lack of reeding will prove it)...it's not off center, because the entire design is visible.
--Christian
Ask your question over here on the other side.
Steve Crain lives Seated Half dimes. Let him give you some insight.
Ray
First, as Error Maven and others have pointed out, if there is edge reeding on your coin (as there apparently is from your own observation) then your coin cannot be a broadstrike. A broad-struck coin is one that was struck outside of the collar. The collar, which, along with the obverse and reverse dies defines the 'coining chamber', contains the edge reeding, and it is the collar which imparts the edge reeding to the struck coin as the planchet expands under the pressure of striking. If the coin was struck outside of the collar, there will be no reeding, and the coin will typically be larger in diameter than a normal strike. The mere appearance of blurred or indistinct dentils, as on your coin, does not necessarily indicate a broadstrike.
Again, as others have already pointed out, blurred or indistinct dentils on half dimes of this period are the norm rather than the exception. After the arrows, used to indicate the reduced silver weight of the planchets, were removed in 1856, and continuing until the obverse was completely redesigned in 1859, many examples are seen with indistinct, almost non-existant dentils. This was a characteristic of the hub(s), and is seen on most working dies. The worst year for weak and indistinct dentils is 1856; there is just one hub (and perhaps just one or at the most two working dies) which exhibit complete dentils, particularly on the obverse. Although the hubs were 'touched up', or reworked, in 1857, the dentils were not one of the details that were 'touched up'. Although the 1857 and 1858 half dimes are typically not quite as weak in the dentils as are the 1856 half dimes, your coin should be considered typical for the period, and although instructive to the understanding of the minting process, it is not rare.
As to the precise cause of the weak dentils, the working hub, used to produce the working dies, had all of the devices and details in positive relief, just as seen on the struck coins themselves. Thus, the dentils, and the periphery or circumference of the obverse, which defined the outer edges of the dentils, were vulnerable, and subject to wear from both the pressure of striking the working dies, and from reworking and lapping by the die shop. As these details wore down, the same details on the working dies, and therefore the struck coins, also became weaker. The dates involved (1856 - 1858) are very high mintage years for the series, and the working dies were kept in service until they could no longer be used. Thus, a rare half dime of this period would actually be one with fully struck dentils.