Options
A tough question for any member who knows about bust quarters
Coin Finder
Posts: 7,844 ✭✭✭✭✭
I recently bought a 1828 Quarter Dollar. I bought it off the web, The surfaces are pristine, but when I took it out of the holder, it is slightly bent. I cannot find out how this happened, there are no dents or dings on either side. Scans were good but I was not expecting this.
Question:
How does one bend it back? Any idea?
Thanks
Tbig
Question:
How does one bend it back? Any idea?
Thanks
Tbig
The court jester does not play, but gently pulls the strings…
0
Comments
by the way...Hi Mark!
<< <i>I'd return the coin if you're not happy as it is. >>
Except that he took the coin out of the holder, thus almost certainly voiding any return privilege.
Yeah this is what I need to know, these coins are thin, could it be as struck?
I hate returning coins unless I am sure 100% that I was mis led, in this case the seller is very nice and is being very reasonable.
Anyone? I like the felt idea.
The court jester does not play, but gently pulls the strings…
Edited to add: Check your work often so as not to over do it.
Aside from pieces coined on roller dies or rocker dies, coins aren't struck bent -- the die faces are (nearly) flat and essentially parallel, so it's a physical impossibility. Of course, the thinness of the pieces meant that a lot were slightly torqued in normal commerce. Some pieces that are REALLY bent, as in creased, are from attempts to score the coin before being cut into fractions (which is my personal opinion on what "witch pieces" from Massachusetts really are, but that's a different post).
The old method is to take several thick straps of leather, like belt leather, and to place the coin inside them before coming down on the whole pile with a mallet or small sledge. I've never tried it, but I understand that flipping the coin between strikes evens it out best, and that the results are often undetectable on a worn coin.
If the coin looks nice, and you didn't see it in the holder, perhaps it doesn't matter much? I have owned and/or catalogued coins that I thought were positively choice until I noticed that they rocked slightly on a flat surface. I'd rather have that than a pinscratch or rim bruise, but that's just me.
Enjoy the newp!
Didn't wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
--"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
The court jester does not play, but gently pulls the strings…
<< <i>Its raw and a vf on a good day. It has a rim nick. I think I will keep it raw. No die bulging, not sure what the variety is, how many were there for 1828? >>
If I owned the coin, I think I would try the vise or hammer routine mentioned above. You might even make the rim ding look better.
B-2 (R-5) flat base to 2 in 25
B-3 (R-4) 25/50 denomination
B-4 (R-3) curved base to 2 in 25, scroll ends right base of A
An authorized PCGS dealer, and a contributor to the Red Book.
roadrunner