Options
There sure are a lot of naive people around here.
And, it's easy to tell who submits coins regularly, and who doesn't. Come on, is it really that surprising that grading is inconsistent? 
Russ, NCNE

Russ, NCNE
0
Comments
yes, some are just beginning to earn some skill and savvy, others are in the bulge of the middle,
and some (like Russ) have moved to the rarefied right arm of the curve in an aspect of "the coin market"
do you suggest, Russ, that some of these "naive people" will learn more about the consistency of grading, or lack thereof, by more frequent submitting?
Some have transcended even TPGs and are back to the coins themselves. Of course, to maximize Profit tm, one must "work the system", no?
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
When I get a grade back that I do not agree with I will examine the coin to find out what I missed. If I missed nothing then it would go back!
Not because I thought it might go higher but because I know it should go higher!
The name is LEE!
IMHO that is the most important part of submitting. I will confess that many of the times when my returned grades differ from what I anticipated, it is due to my overlooking, or not recognizing, something. That goes for PCGS, NGC, and ANACS. Each of those outfits is contributing to my education (albeit a little pricey, granted).
Edited: PCGS please add a spell-checker to this software!
Is it the amount of time they spend looking at the coin, or just the nature of the beast?
<< <i>I often wonder about the amount of consistency one can expect from a tpg over a long period of time. Were services more consistent back in the late 80's or early 90's, or has the inconsistency always been pretty steady? >>
Do you suppose that a lot of the "inconsistency" that is talked about here is as much a function of the coins being submitted as it is the graders? When submitting an unopened box of 10 2006 ASE sets its pretty likely that most or all of them are of high and comparable quality. When you have a bag of CC Morgans that has been bounced around and stored over 100 years, there can be any number of coins that look quite different but should be graded the same technical grade. Too, the graders do have access to grading sets to help them out in the tougher situations.
Maybe the collecting community has been so innundated with "its gotta be slabbed or it aint shet" mentality in recent years that most won't do anything without the comfort of a TPG as a backup.
All grading is inconsistent. It's just a matter of degree.
Certainly, the TPGs are as consistent as anyone can reasonably expect. I get the warm and fuzzies just thinking about how lucky we are to have them.
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
<< <i>All grading is inconsistent. It's just a matter of degree. >>
Some is consistently inconsistent!!
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
<< <i>What do you mean by "submitting a coin?" >>
Yeah, I thought that they came slabbed from the mint????
I knew it would happen.
<< <i>I only submit a coin if I plan on selling it for more than it's worth. >>
Now that is funny!
My eyes are getting so bad all I can tell is if a coin is circulated or uncirculated. All else is a blur.
TPG's are my seeing eye dogs.
Rookie Joe
I have made a few bad judgement calls and am embarrased,
I started out with Hallmark! Coin Slabs, OUCHIE! CLEANED and
just about everything to imagine, paid a lot of money and flushed it
away, I even spent a few at the local Gas Station the woman was
shocked I said your gain my loss!
as a quarter, I have learned a lot by these boards, and wonderful people,
I know ill still buy some junk! But im a little more cautious and a lot of research now before
i jump into things , I thank Everyone here
Keep up the good work, and ill try to add a few cents when I can .
Bill