<< <i>Possibly, but I don't see a dealer hosing a collector here so that doesn't matter. What I see is someone operating out of their depth and spending more than they were willing to lose if their own opinion was wrong. (And yes I do feel for the guy, I've been there and done that myself. But it was my fault, I thought I knew more than I did. I lost, but I learned, and I learned from my lesson how not to make that same mistake again.) >>
I see two parties operating out of their depth and one getting the short end of the stick. Guess who? Well, the "tuition" paid by the poor sap collector is going to benefit a lot of people who now think the seller is at the very least inexperienced and unprofessional and at the very worst (feel free to insert your own expletives).
In the real world, when an honest professional makes a mistake, he/she owns up to it and does his/her best to do the right thing for the patient/client/customer/etc. He/she does not duck responsibility (ie. the patient should have known better, the heir should have known estate law better, the small business should have known the tax code better, etc.). >>
RYK's statement above makes an interesting point. I am naturally skeptical of anyone whose interests are not truly aligned with mine. I prefer to make someone prove their "honesty" before I accept it as a given. I think my approach would have worked well in this scenario--call it the coin dealer jam job put.
I am very stressed with this entire situation and have not gotten a firm reply from Coin Superstore. If you were in my position, how would you handle this from this point on?
Ankur
All coins kept in bank vaults. PCGS Registries Box of 20 SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
<< <i>If you were in my position, how would you handle this from this point on? >>
I would take responsibility for my own actions....... and perhaps TTT this thread all the time. Sorry this happened, but even if they do end up making good on this........ it wasn't their first choice that's for sure.
Please... Save The Stories, Just Answer My Questions, And Tell Me How Much!!!!!
I am very stressed with this entire situation and have not gotten a firm reply from Coin Superstore. If you were in my position, how would you handle this from this point on?
Ankur,
I expect that you are stuck with the note. We all make buying mistakes and learn from them (though most are not thrown up to us by the dealer afterward on a public forum). No reason to be stressed out over it. Just move on and forgetaboutit.
I think that the sellers have also leaned a lesson here, too, though they may not care to admit it.
I would take responsibility for my own actions....... and perhaps TTT this thread all the time. Sorry this happened, but even if they do end up making good on this........ it wasn't their first choice that's for sure. >>
I admit, I did buy the note as I was told it was problem free and he "felt" that it was an XF. Again if I knew it was cleaned, I would have passed but that is a moot point now.
RYK: seems like it, but I will wait and here what they have to say.
Ankur
All coins kept in bank vaults. PCGS Registries Box of 20 SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
I sure wasn't trying to be harsh on you. I would just try and learn about what I am spending my hard earned money on....... then adhere to the first part of my SIG line. No matter what anybody and any dealer tells you, make your own judgments. Just my worthless opinion. And don't forget to TTT the thread to spread the word. Since they started the thread to begin with, you're just helping them out is all.
Please... Save The Stories, Just Answer My Questions, And Tell Me How Much!!!!!
<< <i>I am very stressed with this entire situation and have not gotten a firm reply from Coin Superstore. If you were in my position, how would you handle this from this point on? >>
Not sure if there is anythng you can do. Maybe learn from the experience. In terms of action, it is in the dealer's court.
<< <i>I am very stressed with this entire situation and have not gotten a firm reply from Coin Superstore. If you were in my position, how would you handle this from this point on? >>
Legally I think you're stuck. It's up to the dealer to decide whether the hit to their reputation is less costly to them than taking the financial hit of taking the note back.
The good news is that half of the people who have read this thread won't buy from Coin Superstore.
#1 They bring private problems to public forums. Poor play. #2 They can't grade what they sell, or alternatively, #3 They are not honest about what they sell. #4 If something bad happens, they are unwilling to make it right or at least compromise.
Legally I think you're stuck. It's up to the dealer to decide whether the hit to their reputation is less costly to them than taking the financial hit of taking the note back. >>
Id say that this is the million dollar question, or 2000 dollar question if you will.
AJ
All coins kept in bank vaults. PCGS Registries Box of 20 SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
In response to some of the statements. We are not unwilling to comprimise. We offered him one of the coins back that were in the trade. The coin was valued at 250.00. So, yes we were willing to solve this. The offer was not good enough for him. To get back to the original deal. We had told the customer the grade it was. He agreed with the grade. Also, a currency dealer who was at the show also agreed with it. We also stated that there were no returns. He still bought it. I think that we are being very fair. Also PMG graded it VF-25 but never stated it was "cleaned and pressed on the holder". Had it come back an AU-50 we he or anyone come to us and say " here is the difference for the fact it is worth more" I don't think so.
This is not true at all. Everytime I made a purchase from them over the last year, this was NEVER said to me. And yes I was offered the Morgan back, but before I made any decision, I wanted to speak to Alex first, and Vin, you know that.
AJ
Edit to say: even on the website it says there is a 14 day return policy for non-graded coins.
All coins kept in bank vaults. PCGS Registries Box of 20 SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
Regardless of the legality the whole thing stinks imo. If I were the seller, I don't care it if was a month or 12 months later, I'd give the guy his money back if the item was returned unmessed with, as this note appears to be. Some buyers don't get around to figuring out they got a raw deal until months later. Many are too embarassed to even speak out (not a problem at the Coin Forum though).
The dealer is the PRO or is supposed to be. 95% of the public buyers out there don't really know what they are buying, even if they think they do. It all falls on the PRO who is supposed to know his stuff. As soon as I read "nice XF" note becomes "VF" note, I said the dealer has a problem, whether he guaranteed the grade or not. If he can't grade an XF note and he's selling them then it's time for another business venture or be willing to ante up to the customers who find out their purchases were overgraded.
Dealers always have a way out of their bad purchases by dumping them on customers. This goes for the national curcuit retail pros as well. They do make mistakes and they do sell those to their customers. It doesn't matter if they know they screwed up or not. Joe Average Collector does not have this avenue of disposal and he eats it when he sells that item to another dealer. In the sale, the dealer still screwed the client and the still made their profit. If a dealer is good enough to hit on 95+% of their purchases (as most do), the 5% they miss on should not affect their bottom line much. That's part of being a PRO.
Sure, the buyer has all the legal risk in this situation and NO leg to stand on. It's always like that too. Legal or not, give the customer his money or trade back and move along. That's good business. Enough damage has been done already. If one is not willing to stand behind your opinions as a professional dealer then something is wrong. I'd expect no less of my doctor, lawyer, accountant.
When it comes to bad transactions, I err in the favor of the customer. The hobby is too oriented towards dealers making their 10-20% and nothing else. The orientation should be making money for your clients.....then they'll come back. I had the same thing happen to me in my earlier years and those dealers were forever eliminated from future considerations.
Move it along. The whole forum now knows there is a potential weakness in grading currency. You don't need a back up post concerning a coin you sold to show up next week.
<< <i>The good news is that half of the people who have read this thread won't buy from Coin Superstore.
#1 They bring private problems to public forums. Poor play. #2 They can't grade what they sell, or alternatively, #3 They are not honest about what they sell. #4 If something bad happens, they are unwilling to make it right or at least compromise. >>
I get the impression that all Coin Superstore is trying to do is pocket as much money as they can at the expense of collectors.
The entire deal should be reversed. The cash and trade coins returned to the buyer, and the note exchanged for them. Neither party would be out anything, except the buyer for his grading cost. So why not do it? Like I responded earlier........... I won't ever buy anything from CoinSuperstore. No way. There's too many dealers that won't cheat you in the first place, and if a mistake is made will stand behind what they sell. I've been collecting for 50 years.
The thought "wins the legal battle but losses the relations war" comes to my mind when considering this dealer in this transaction and for any in the future...
It occurs to me that since PMG did not note the cleaning and pressing on the holder, we have no real evidence that this is the case. We have only what amounts to hearsay from the buyer of the note. Since this alleged cleaning and pressing isn't noted, this situation really distills down to nothing more than a difference of opinion about the grade.
Sure, a difference of "opinion" of hundreds of dollars between the pro who should know how to grade what they are selling or the newbie who doesn't. If I sell a raw coin to someone as "X" and it comes back less than "X", then I'll take it back, no questions asked. I expect nothing less from a competent dealer. Using the excuse "I don't know much about this but it's an XF" is bunk. Your expertise is implied. If this was the only note that a dealer every owned or bought, I'd cut them some slack. I for one have never bought a note. And I certainly realized the opportunity that could present to a dealer. Too many dealers don't even care what they have. They just know there's an ultimate consumer down the road who will pay them more......because they paid "X" and are listed as a dealer.
I intend to call them about this on Monday Russ. When I asked him if cleaning & pressing significantly effects a grade, he said yes it does. So if that was the case, why didnt they note it?
But in any case, I dont expect to get anything back from the dealer at this point. I know that they are just hoping that all his will go away by itself without them having to take any action. Obviously the hit to their reputation doesnt matter.
Edit to say that him = the head grader at PMG
Ankur
All coins kept in bank vaults. PCGS Registries Box of 20 SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
I hope coinsuperstore isn't counting on doing any business with members of this forum. The amount he's cost himself in potential business probably exceeds the amount he's ripped this buyer for... not to mention the damage to reputation. Some people are just shortsighted... *shakes head*
<< <i>In response to some of the statements. We are not unwilling to comprimise. We offered him one of the coins back that were in the trade. The coin was valued at 250.00. So, yes we were willing to solve this. The offer was not good enough for him. To get back to the original deal. We had told the customer the grade it was. He agreed with the grade. Also, a currency dealer who was at the show also agreed with it. We also stated that there were no returns. He still bought it. I think that we are being very fair. Also PMG graded it VF-25 but never stated it was "cleaned and pressed on the holder". Had it come back an AU-50 we he or anyone come to us and say " here is the difference for the fact it is worth more" I don't think so. >>
Did I calculate the deal correctly? $1000 cash plus an MS-63 Saint plus a $250 toner for an $1850 note? I am not very smart with math and all, but $600 for an MS-63 Saint seems awfully cheap. Off him the Saint back, and see if he takes the deal.
As far as the hit to your reputation on the forum, well, it's probably too late. We all forget about these things, but it usually takes some time.
RYK, he priced the note at 2k. Since I didnt haggle on the price, he took the dough, the saint valued at $750, and the Morgan valued at $250. He later said that the Morgan would sell for around $150, and the Saint at around $700. That is how $1850 came about.
I already asked for the Saint back, it was denied stating that it would be a loss to them.
Ankur
All coins kept in bank vaults. PCGS Registries Box of 20 SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
I would like to buy MS63 Saints at $700. I would imagine the major buyers are offering $725+ for them. $750 is a fair sell price. Because of the high liquidity they are like cash.
<< <i>And collectors hosing dealers is called cherrypicking..... and is acceptable.... >>
Are we really going to deal with this again? >>
No..... I just couldn't resist..........
I think we all accept the fact that the dealer SHOULD know what he has and in addition has factored in HIS acceptable profit into his asking price.... He is (should be) content with his price as it was what he wanted and expected......
I want to let everyone know that the situation has been resolved. An agreed upon cash refund will be given to me. Thank you to Coin Superstore for resolving this.
Ankur
All coins kept in bank vaults. PCGS Registries Box of 20 SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
<< <i>I want to let everyone know that the situation has been resolved. An agreed upon cash refund will be given to me. Thank you to Coin Superstore for resolving this.
Ankur >>
Cool beans. A customer that seems satisfied, some education for almost everyone involved.
<< <i>Another question comes to mind. PMG grades problem notes rather than bodybagging them? >>
At least 50% of the large size notes in existence have been played with in some sort of way. Light wash and press jobs, closed pinholes and margin trimming are routinely "net" graded by TPGs without disclosing the note as such.
I've also seen several people state that buying raw is taking a chance, or to never buy raw. Frankly, the TPGs don't get this right 100% either (alot less that you think). Notes with serious problems / repairs get missed and are gradrd by TPGs. (The neat thing is that paper money has serials. It isn't as hard as you think to track a notes history.) The fact is, if you plan on laying down any significant amount of cash, you had better know what you are doing. Don't rely on the dealer, TPG, friend or anyone else.
FWIW - I'm simply amazed at the amount of "coin" guys entering the paper scene without doing their homework. Just because it's money and uses the same grading scale (BTW- thanks for that one ) don't assume they are the same. Collecting paper is as different from coins as say, collecting anvils.
"Don't talk like an ignarosis."
I specialize in Wisconsin currency! Looking for information on WI national banknotes. Census stands at 12,318 notes.
**"Wisconsin National Bank Notes - 2nd Edition" is out!!!" Only $20PPd!!!
Just got off the phone with the PMG head grader again.about this note again. He told me that people do not like any negative comments on the back, which is why they didnt mention cleaned & pressed on the back of the holder. I was told many dealers asked them to leave it off, but just have it reflected in the grade. He also told me that the note had been pressed for a long time, and that there is NO embossing left at all. Which is why the grade is a 25. I posted this on the paper money board as well, but I want to know..
How does one tell if embossing is still present? When I held the note, it didnt have any groves or bumpiness to it in the ink. Is that what embossing is?
AJ
All coins kept in bank vaults. PCGS Registries Box of 20 SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
<< <i>How does one tell if embossing is still present? When I held the note, it didnt have any groves or bumpiness to it in the ink. Is that what embossing is? >>
Ever look at a crisp, new note and notice that there appears to be a very slight "relief" or 3-D effect on some of the details? That's embossing, basically.
And I don't want to sound critical, really...but if you don't know what "embossing" is on currency, I'm not sure it's a good idea to go out and spend $2000+ on it any more than it's a good idea to spend $2000 on a raw coin if you don't know how to spot a whizzing, recoloring or artificial toning.
I'm 100% on the dealer's side in this hypothetical situation. Tough luck on the buyer.
Edit: after reading the ninth post and seeing this is NOT a hypothetical situation (I had a hunch from all the specifics that it might not be), and that the note might've been "doctored" somehow, that is a little different- I have a bit more sympathy for the buyer. However, I still am of the opinion that it's a done deal.
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.
I just read your post in the currency section and it appears that the consensus graded the notes picture XF before you posted what the actual grade came back as. And I think your photo is a good one too. Shows how little one can really tell from a picture on a web page eh?
Lessons to be learned? Never buy raw unless you know exactly what to look for. Never sell raw unless you know exactly what you are selling, otherwise get it graded by professionals first.
<< <i>Lessons to be learned? Never buy raw unless you know exactly what to look for. Never sell raw unless you know exactly what you are selling, otherwise get it graded by professionals first. >>
And, if you're a dealer never out a customer hoping the crowd will support your position.
<< <i>Lessons to be learned? Never buy raw unless you know exactly what to look for. Never sell raw unless you know exactly what you are selling, otherwise get it graded by professionals first. >>
And, if you're a dealer never out a customer hoping the crowd will support your position.
Russ, NCNE >>
Although if he would not have posted on this forum the pressure would not have been there to do the refund.
1. This was dragged onto a public forum that 100's have viewed. 2. Coin Superstore looks bad for a NUMBER of reasons. 3. Coin Superstore ended up returning at least some of the difference.
Lesson learned?
If you are a dealer, don't use real-life hypotheticals involving customers on the forums. Like it or not, you're bound to lose a lot of business. Dozens of people with big spending habits have been turned off because of this ugly incident.
<< <i>At least 50% of the large size notes in existence have been played with in some sort of way. Light wash and press jobs, closed pinholes and margin trimming are routinely "net" graded by TPGs without disclosing the note as such. >>
Sounds like some harder coin series that are often net graded, instead of BBed, by TPGs. There's a lot of subjectivity in TPG grading to be aware of.
<< <i>When I held the note, it didnt have any groves or bumpiness to it in the ink. Is that what embossing is? >>
That's exactly what it is. Worn notes won't have it and neither will pressed high grade notes.
A scan only gives you a starting point from which to grade a note. You really need to feel for embossing, backlight the note to look for folds and repairs, hold the note and look lengthwise for paper wave & bends/folds and smell the note to detect chemicals. (FWIW- Makes it hard to detect worked on notes in the holder of a TPG.)
"Don't talk like an ignarosis."
I specialize in Wisconsin currency! Looking for information on WI national banknotes. Census stands at 12,318 notes.
**"Wisconsin National Bank Notes - 2nd Edition" is out!!!" Only $20PPd!!!
Though "resolved," this whole transaction continues to give off an unpleasant odor. For a few hundred bucks someone loses a customer for life. No winners in this one.
Glad to see this has been an active topic. Just a little note considering I have not posted for a couple of days, I was out of town for the weekend.
I originally posted this note as a hypothetical to see what everyone felt the correct course of action was in this situation. If I wanted to just stiff the customer I would have just stiffed him, but I wanted to do what was fair to all parties involved so I posted this as a hypothetical. If everyone looks at the last couple of questions I posted in the original thread, it asks for what the industry standard is.
Some people responed that the buyer is out of luck, others responded that we should give a full refund. Even though we had agreed upon terms and there was no recourse for the buyer, and the buyer admittedly stated he would not have contacted us had the note graded an AU50, we decided to refund an undisclosed amount of money back to the buyer.
Just a little side note, after looking at many other certified VF25's both buyer and seller agree that this note is nicer than your typical VF25. Go do some archive searching and compare for yourself. Who knows maybe this note will end up in another services holder graded much higher one day!
Just a little side note, after looking at many other certified VF25's both buyer and seller agree that this note is nicer than your typical VF25. Go do some archive searching and compare for yourself. Who knows maybe this note will end up in another services holder graded much higher one day! >>
It is possible but if the buyer confirms the cleaning, pressing, old folds etc... then if another grading firm gives it a higher grade I would hope that they note the issues that needed a magnified look and knowledge of what to look for.
My question to you just for a better understanding is why not get any note worth more than 1K holdered? I rarely see coins that are not holdered and when a buyer see's a coin in a holder that is very nice for the grade he will often pay a premium which may have happened in this case.
<< <i> My question to you just for a better understanding is why not get any note worth more than 1K holdered? I rarely see coins that are not holdered and when a buyer see's a coin in a holder that is very nice for the grade he will often pay a premium which may have happened in this case. >>
We do not send any notes to get graded. We do not list any notes on our website either. There is a lot of time and money involved to get coins or currency graded. Additionally most of the notes that we deal in are $100 or less. Currently in inventory we might have 2 or 3 notes over $500 and none of them currently over $1000. We feel that we do not deal in enough of it to make it worth it to us. We deal in mainly certified coins (90% of our inventory is certified coins either PCGS, NGC or ANACS). Generally speaking I will send most $500+ coins in to get certified but at the same time would probably never send in one or two or even three coins to get graded, I would wait until I had 10+ coins that needed to be certified.
Comments
<< <i>
<< <i>Possibly, but I don't see a dealer hosing a collector here so that doesn't matter. What I see is someone operating out of their depth and spending more than they were willing to lose if their own opinion was wrong. (And yes I do feel for the guy, I've been there and done that myself. But it was my fault, I thought I knew more than I did. I lost, but I learned, and I learned from my lesson how not to make that same mistake again.) >>
I see two parties operating out of their depth and one getting the short end of the stick. Guess who? Well, the "tuition" paid by the poor sap collector is going to benefit a lot of people who now think the seller is at the very least inexperienced and unprofessional and at the very worst (feel free to insert your own expletives).
In the real world, when an honest professional makes a mistake, he/she owns up to it and does his/her best to do the right thing for the patient/client/customer/etc. He/she does not duck responsibility (ie. the patient should have known better, the heir should have known estate law better, the small business should have known the tax code better, etc.). >>
RYK's statement above makes an interesting point. I am naturally skeptical of anyone whose interests are not truly aligned with mine. I prefer to make someone prove their "honesty" before I accept it as a given. I think my approach would have worked well in this scenario--call it the coin dealer jam job put.
I am very stressed with this entire situation and have not gotten a firm reply from Coin Superstore. If you were in my position, how would you handle this from this point on?
Ankur
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
<< <i>If you were in my position, how would you handle this from this point on? >>
I would take responsibility for my own actions....... and perhaps TTT this thread all the time.
Ankur,
I expect that you are stuck with the note. We all make buying mistakes and learn from them (though most are not thrown up to us by the dealer afterward on a public forum). No reason to be stressed out over it. Just move on and forgetaboutit.
I think that the sellers have also leaned a lesson here, too, though they may not care to admit it.
I admit, I did buy the note as I was told it was problem free and he "felt" that it was an XF. Again if I knew it was cleaned, I would have passed but that is a moot point now.
RYK: seems like it, but I will wait and here what they have to say.
Ankur
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
<< <i>I am very stressed with this entire situation and have not gotten a firm reply from Coin Superstore. If you were in my position, how would you handle this from this point on? >>
Not sure if there is anythng you can do. Maybe learn from the experience. In terms of action, it is in the dealer's court.
Puro's Coins and Jewelry
Rutland, VT
(802)773-3883
Link to my website www.vtcoins.com
Link to my eBay auctions
Buy, sell and trade all coins, US paper money, jewelry, diamonds and anything made of gold, silver or platinum.
<< <i>I am very stressed with this entire situation and have not gotten a firm reply from Coin Superstore. If you were in my position, how would you handle this from this point on? >>
Legally I think you're stuck. It's up to the dealer to decide whether the hit to their reputation is less costly to them than taking the financial hit of taking the note back.
#1 They bring private problems to public forums. Poor play.
#2 They can't grade what they sell, or alternatively,
#3 They are not honest about what they sell.
#4 If something bad happens, they are unwilling to make it right or at least compromise.
Coin's for sale/trade.
Tom Pilitowski
US Rare Coin Investments
800-624-1870
<< <i> >>
Legally I think you're stuck. It's up to the dealer to decide whether the hit to their reputation is less costly to them than taking the financial hit of taking the note back. >>
Id say that this is the million dollar question, or 2000 dollar question if you will.
AJ
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
This is not true at all. Everytime I made a purchase from them over the last year, this was NEVER said to me.
And yes I was offered the Morgan back, but before I made any decision, I wanted to speak to Alex first, and Vin, you know that.
AJ
Edit to say: even on the website it says there is a 14 day return policy for non-graded coins.
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
The dealer is the PRO or is supposed to be. 95% of the public buyers out there don't really know what they are buying, even if they think they do. It all falls on the PRO who is supposed to know his stuff. As soon as I read "nice XF" note becomes "VF" note, I said the dealer has a problem, whether he guaranteed the grade or not. If he can't grade an XF note and he's selling them then it's time for another business venture or be willing to ante up to the customers who find out their purchases were overgraded.
Dealers always have a way out of their bad purchases by dumping them on customers. This goes for the national curcuit retail pros as well. They do make mistakes and they do sell those to their customers. It doesn't matter if they know they screwed up or not.
Joe Average Collector does not have this avenue of disposal and he eats it when he sells that item to another dealer.
In the sale, the dealer still screwed the client and the still made their profit. If a dealer is good enough to hit on 95+% of their purchases (as most do), the 5% they miss on should not affect their bottom line much. That's part of being a PRO.
Sure, the buyer has all the legal risk in this situation and NO leg to stand on. It's always like that too. Legal or not, give the customer his money or trade back and move along. That's good business. Enough damage has been done already. If one is not willing to stand behind your opinions as a professional dealer then something is wrong. I'd expect no less of my doctor, lawyer, accountant.
When it comes to bad transactions, I err in the favor of the customer.
The hobby is too oriented towards dealers making their 10-20% and nothing else. The orientation should be making money for your clients.....then they'll come back. I had the same thing happen to me in my earlier years and those dealers were forever eliminated from future considerations.
Move it along. The whole forum now knows there is a potential weakness in grading currency. You don't need a back up post concerning a coin you sold to show up next week.
roadrunner
<< <i>The good news is that half of the people who have read this thread won't buy from Coin Superstore.
#1 They bring private problems to public forums. Poor play.
#2 They can't grade what they sell, or alternatively,
#3 They are not honest about what they sell.
#4 If something bad happens, they are unwilling to make it right or at least compromise. >>
The cash and trade coins returned to the buyer, and the note exchanged for them.
Neither party would be out anything, except the buyer for his grading cost.
So why not do it?
Like I responded earlier...........
I won't ever buy anything from CoinSuperstore.
No way.
There's too many dealers that won't cheat you in the first place, and if a mistake is made will stand behind what they sell.
I've been collecting for 50 years.
Ray
Doug
Russ, NCNE
I expect nothing less from a competent dealer. Using the excuse "I don't know much about this but it's an XF" is bunk. Your expertise is implied. If this was the only note that a dealer every owned or bought, I'd cut them some slack. I for one have never bought a note. And I certainly realized the opportunity that could present to a dealer. Too many dealers don't even care what they have. They just know there's an ultimate consumer down the road who will pay them more......because they paid "X" and are listed as a dealer.
roadrunner
But in any case, I dont expect to get anything back from the dealer at this point. I know that they are just hoping that all his will go away by itself without them having to take any action. Obviously the hit to their reputation doesnt matter.
Edit to say that him = the head grader at PMG
Ankur
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
1/2 Cents
U.S. Revenue Stamps
<< <i>In response to some of the statements. We are not unwilling to comprimise. We offered him one of the coins back that were in the trade. The coin was valued at 250.00. So, yes we were willing to solve this. The offer was not good enough for him. To get back to the original deal. We had told the customer the grade it was. He agreed with the grade. Also, a currency dealer who was at the show also agreed with it. We also stated that there were no returns. He still bought it. I think that we are being very fair. Also PMG graded it VF-25 but never stated it was "cleaned and pressed on the holder". Had it come back an AU-50 we he or anyone come to us and say " here is the difference for the fact it is worth more" I don't think so. >>
Did I calculate the deal correctly? $1000 cash plus an MS-63 Saint plus a $250 toner for an $1850 note? I am not very smart with math and all, but $600 for an MS-63 Saint seems awfully cheap. Off him the Saint back, and see if he takes the deal.
As far as the hit to your reputation on the forum, well, it's probably too late. We all forget about these things, but it usually takes some time.
I already asked for the Saint back, it was denied stating that it would be a loss to them.
Ankur
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
roadrunner
<< <i> I would like to buy MS63 Saints at $700. >>
Me too.
Puro's Coins and Jewelry
Rutland, VT
(802)773-3883
Link to my website www.vtcoins.com
Link to my eBay auctions
Buy, sell and trade all coins, US paper money, jewelry, diamonds and anything made of gold, silver or platinum.
<< <i>
<< <i> I would like to buy MS63 Saints at $700. >>
Me too. >>
Me three!
Coin's for sale/trade.
Tom Pilitowski
US Rare Coin Investments
800-624-1870
<< <i>Dealers hosing dealers is an acceptable part of the numismatic landscape. Dealers hosing collectors is not. At least not to me. >>
And collectors hosing dealers is called cherrypicking..... and is acceptable....
<< <i>And ollectors hosing dealers is called cherrypicking..... and is acceptable.... >>
Are we really going to deal with this again?
<< <i>
<< <i>And collectors hosing dealers is called cherrypicking..... and is acceptable.... >>
Are we really going to deal with this again? >>
No..... I just couldn't resist..........
I think we all accept the fact that the dealer SHOULD know what he has and in addition has factored in HIS acceptable profit into his asking price.... He is (should be) content with his price as it was what he wanted and expected......
Ankur
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
<< <i>I want to let everyone know that the situation has been resolved. An agreed upon cash refund will be given to me. Thank you to Coin Superstore for resolving this.
Ankur >>
Cool beans. A customer that seems satisfied, some education for almost everyone involved.
<< <i>Another question comes to mind. PMG grades problem notes rather than bodybagging them? >>
At least 50% of the large size notes in existence have been played with in some sort of way. Light wash and press jobs, closed pinholes and margin trimming are routinely "net" graded by TPGs without disclosing the note as such.
I've also seen several people state that buying raw is taking a chance, or to never buy raw. Frankly, the TPGs don't get this right 100% either (alot less that you think). Notes with serious problems / repairs get missed and are gradrd by TPGs. (The neat thing is that paper money has serials. It isn't as hard as you think to track a notes history.) The fact is, if you plan on laying down any significant amount of cash, you had better know what you are doing. Don't rely on the dealer, TPG, friend or anyone else.
FWIW - I'm simply amazed at the amount of "coin" guys entering the paper scene without doing their homework. Just because it's money and uses the same grading scale (BTW- thanks for that one
I specialize in Wisconsin currency! Looking for information on WI national banknotes. Census stands at 12,318 notes.
**"Wisconsin National Bank Notes - 2nd Edition" is out!!!" Only $20PPd!!!
How does one tell if embossing is still present? When I held the note, it didnt have any groves or bumpiness to it in the ink. Is that what embossing is?
AJ
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
<< <i>How does one tell if embossing is still present? When I held the note, it didnt have any groves or bumpiness to it in the ink. Is that what embossing is? >>
Ever look at a crisp, new note and notice that there appears to be a very slight "relief" or 3-D effect on some of the details? That's embossing, basically.
And I don't want to sound critical, really...but if you don't know what "embossing" is on currency, I'm not sure it's a good idea to go out and spend $2000+ on it any more than it's a good idea to spend $2000 on a raw coin if you don't know how to spot a whizzing, recoloring or artificial toning.
Edit: after reading the ninth post and seeing this is NOT a hypothetical situation (I had a hunch from all the specifics that it might not be), and that the note might've been "doctored" somehow, that is a little different- I have a bit more sympathy for the buyer. However, I still am of the opinion that it's a done deal.
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.
Coin's for sale/trade.
Tom Pilitowski
US Rare Coin Investments
800-624-1870
Lessons to be learned? Never buy raw unless you know exactly what to look for. Never sell raw unless you know exactly what you are selling, otherwise get it graded by professionals first.
<< <i>Lessons to be learned? Never buy raw unless you know exactly what to look for. Never sell raw unless you know exactly what you are selling, otherwise get it graded by professionals first. >>
And, if you're a dealer never out a customer hoping the crowd will support your position.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>Lessons to be learned? Never buy raw unless you know exactly what to look for. Never sell raw unless you know exactly what you are selling, otherwise get it graded by professionals first. >>
And, if you're a dealer never out a customer hoping the crowd will support your position.
Russ, NCNE >>
Although if he would not have posted on this forum the pressure would not have been there to do the refund.
1. This was dragged onto a public forum that 100's have viewed.
2. Coin Superstore looks bad for a NUMBER of reasons.
3. Coin Superstore ended up returning at least some of the difference.
Lesson learned?
If you are a dealer, don't use real-life hypotheticals involving customers on the forums. Like it or not, you're bound to lose a lot of business. Dozens of people with big spending habits have been turned off because of this ugly incident.
Or, if you decide to do that, at least be willing to make it right, once you get caught.
This whole deal stunk then, and it still stinks now.
And marcovan, you really think that the buyer only deserves a little sympathy? A big "hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm....................."
I knew it would happen.
<< <i>At least 50% of the large size notes in existence have been played with in some sort of way. Light wash and press jobs, closed pinholes and margin trimming are routinely "net" graded by TPGs without disclosing the note as such. >>
Sounds like some harder coin series that are often net graded, instead of BBed, by TPGs. There's a lot of subjectivity in TPG grading to be aware of.
<< <i>When I held the note, it didnt have any groves or bumpiness to it in the ink. Is that what embossing is? >>
That's exactly what it is. Worn notes won't have it and neither will pressed high grade notes.
A scan only gives you a starting point from which to grade a note. You really need to feel for embossing, backlight the note to look for folds and repairs, hold the note and look lengthwise for paper wave & bends/folds and smell the note to detect chemicals. (FWIW- Makes it hard to detect worked on notes in the holder of a TPG.)
I specialize in Wisconsin currency! Looking for information on WI national banknotes. Census stands at 12,318 notes.
**"Wisconsin National Bank Notes - 2nd Edition" is out!!!" Only $20PPd!!!
roadrunner
I originally posted this note as a hypothetical to see what everyone felt the correct course of action was in this situation. If I wanted to just stiff the customer I would have just stiffed him, but I wanted to do what was fair to all parties involved so I posted this as a hypothetical. If everyone looks at the last couple of questions I posted in the original thread, it asks for what the industry standard is.
Some people responed that the buyer is out of luck, others responded that we should give a full refund. Even though we had agreed upon terms and there was no recourse for the buyer, and the buyer admittedly stated he would not have contacted us had the note graded an AU50, we decided to refund an undisclosed amount of money back to the buyer.
Just a little side note, after looking at many other certified VF25's both buyer and seller agree that this note is nicer than your typical VF25. Go do some archive searching and compare for yourself. Who knows maybe this note will end up in another services holder graded much higher one day!
Personal Ebay Auctions
My Website
---------------------------------------------
ALWAYS LOOKING TO PURCHASE
TOP 100 MORGANS / HOT 50
TOP 50 PEACE VAMS
<< <i>
Just a little side note, after looking at many other certified VF25's both buyer and seller agree that this note is nicer than your typical VF25. Go do some archive searching and compare for yourself. Who knows maybe this note will end up in another services holder graded much higher one day! >>
It is possible but if the buyer confirms the cleaning, pressing, old folds etc... then if another grading firm gives it a higher grade I would hope that they note the issues that needed a magnified look and knowledge of what to look for.
My question to you just for a better understanding is why not get any note worth more than 1K holdered? I rarely see coins that are not holdered and when a buyer see's a coin in a holder that is very nice for the grade he will often pay a premium which may have happened in this case.
<< <i>
My question to you just for a better understanding is why not get any note worth more than 1K holdered? I rarely see coins that are not holdered and when a buyer see's a coin in a holder that is very nice for the grade he will often pay a premium which may have happened in this case. >>
We do not send any notes to get graded. We do not list any notes on our website either. There is a lot of time and money involved to get coins or currency graded. Additionally most of the notes that we deal in are $100 or less. Currently in inventory we might have 2 or 3 notes over $500 and none of them currently over $1000. We feel that we do not deal in enough of it to make it worth it to us. We deal in mainly certified coins (90% of our inventory is certified coins either PCGS, NGC or ANACS). Generally speaking I will send most $500+ coins in to get certified but at the same time would probably never send in one or two or even three coins to get graded, I would wait until I had 10+ coins that needed to be certified.
Personal Ebay Auctions
My Website
---------------------------------------------
ALWAYS LOOKING TO PURCHASE
TOP 100 MORGANS / HOT 50
TOP 50 PEACE VAMS