Options
Hypothetical/Situation - Refund of Raw Material
A buyer purchases a raw note 1899 $5 Chief for approximately $1850. There is no grade written anywhere on the note but before the buyer purchases the note he has a conversation with the dealer about the note. The dealer admits his lack of knowledge in Currency (he deals primarily in coins) but says he believes the note to be a strong XF. The buyer mentions another dealer selling the same note raw as an XF45 and states that the one for $1800 here is actually nicer than the raw one graded by the dealer as an XF45. The buyer buys the note for $1000 cash and $850 in trade (coins).
The buyer later sends the note out to get graded and it comes back a VF25. Buyer contacts seller several weeks after the purchase and after the note has now been out of the buyers possession while being graded. The buyer is not happy with the grade and suggests as a possible solution that the seller gives back the majority of the coins that were originally given in the trade.
What is the seller to do?
The buyer was informed by this seller that there was no guarantee on the grade and there was no returns on raw material.
Also what is the industry standard on raw coin and raw currency returns when coins are purchased at a show with material in hand?
What is the industry standard on certified coin and currency returns when coins/currency are purchased at a show with material in hand?
The buyer later sends the note out to get graded and it comes back a VF25. Buyer contacts seller several weeks after the purchase and after the note has now been out of the buyers possession while being graded. The buyer is not happy with the grade and suggests as a possible solution that the seller gives back the majority of the coins that were originally given in the trade.
What is the seller to do?
The buyer was informed by this seller that there was no guarantee on the grade and there was no returns on raw material.
Also what is the industry standard on raw coin and raw currency returns when coins are purchased at a show with material in hand?
What is the industry standard on certified coin and currency returns when coins/currency are purchased at a show with material in hand?
Coin Superstore's Ebay Auctions
Personal Ebay Auctions
My Website
---------------------------------------------
ALWAYS LOOKING TO PURCHASE
TOP 100 MORGANS / HOT 50
TOP 50 PEACE VAMS
Personal Ebay Auctions
My Website
---------------------------------------------
ALWAYS LOOKING TO PURCHASE
TOP 100 MORGANS / HOT 50
TOP 50 PEACE VAMS
0
Comments
If the buyer had any sense he'd have done more research before buying the bill. He probably wouldn't buy a used car without either knowing how to inspect it under the hood or having someone else who did look at it before money changed hands. I know I took my car to a mechanic to have him "grade" it before I agreed to buy it from the seller. I don't have a lot of pity for people who throw around lots of money without taking any time to learn about what they are buying.
If I could give back for a refund all the coins I have purchased over the years that did not grade the way I thought they would then I would have a lot more cash than I do now.
Authorized dealer for PCGS, PCGS Currency, NGC, NCS, PMG, CAC. Member of the PNG, ANA. Member dealer of CoinPlex and CCE/FACTS as "CH5"
San Diego, CA
<< <i> Can he prove it is the same note? >>
If the seller put the note's serial number on the receipt, it shouldn't be too difficult.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
If:
1. You were clear in your communication to him that you did not know squat about these notes.
2. You would just as soon never have this guy darken your door again.
3. You did not rip him on the note.
then, and only then, tell him to "pound sand".
I am the person who purchased this note from Coin Super Store. It was described to me as a problem free XF. It was purchased exactly 2 weeks and 3 days ago (March 4th) at a local show. I had asked if there were any problems with the note, and I was told no. I agreed to give $1000 cash, a MS 63 common date Saint, and a Toned Morgan valued at approx $250.
I sent the note to PMG, it came back a 25. Thats not the problem though. When I called and spoke to the head grader asking why it was graded so low, I was told the note had been CLEANED AND PRESSED in order to hide creases & folds. I WAS NOT MADE AWARE OF THIS when purchasing the note. And if I WAS told, I would NOT have bought the note under any circumstance. Whether or not Coin Super Store knew about this, I do not know.
Do I know what better grade chiefs look like? Yes. Do I know what a cleaned and pressed note looks like? I do now.
I have said many praises for this dealer in the past, as they have always treated me fairly, but I do feel that I was wronged in this situation.
If a collector sold a dealer something that had been altered, the dealer would stop to no end to get his money back from the collector. What I asked back is the Saint which would value this deal at approx $1250, and that was declined. This will be last dealings with them.
Ankur
Edit to say: YES I can prove it is the exact same note.
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
It's always interesting to hear the other side of the story!
If a collector sold a dealer something that had been altered, the dealer would stop to no end to get his money back from the collector.
I agree with you except the part copied above. Usually, in this case, the dealer is stuck.
I reiterate what I said above
If this is true and was conveyed to you prior to your purchase you have no recourse what so ever- you cannot blame him for something he admitted he knew little about.
<< <i>"The dealer admits his lack of knowledge in Currency "
If this is true you have no recourse what so ever- >>
And then what about this statement:
"I had asked if there were any problems with the note, and I was told no. "
He has a showcase full of graded and ungraded notes at every show. I think its a good excuse to be honest.
If a dealer who had hundreds of coins every month at a show tells you he doesnt know how to grade coins, what would you say?
AJ
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
The plot thickens...
Ankur,
Technically, you are indeed stuck with the note, but many dealers would not stick it to you like this and post about it on a public forum in which you participate. Find these other dealers to work with in the future.
I was saying to myself when buying this note that I should look for a graded one. But the trade made me go ahead with it. But yes, that has taught me not to buy high dollar raw notes, or coins for that matter.
AJ
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
<< <i>"The dealer admits his lack of knowledge in Currency "
He has a showcase full of graded and ungraded notes at every show. I think its a good excuse to be honest.
If a dealer who had hundreds of coins every month at a show tells you he doesnt know how to grade coins, what would you say?
AJ >>
I would say that he is an average dealer as far as knowledge and MUCH more honest than the average dealer at any given show. As for the dealer unknowingly telling you that a "cleaned and pressed" note had no problems that is no different than a dealer unknowingly selling you an AT coin. In either situation as described you would be (and IMO SHOULD BE) stuck with the note/coin.
Buyer contacts seller several weeks after the purchase and after the note has now been out of the buyers possession while being graded,
and the facts are these:
It was purchased exactly 2 weeks and 3 days ago (March 4th) at a local show,
I have a pretty good idea who's on the up and up.
<< <i>He has a showcase full of graded and ungraded notes at every show.
The plot thickens...
Ankur,
Technically, you are indeed stuck with the note, but many dealers would not stick it to you like this and post about it on a public forum in which you participate. Find these other dealers to work with in the future. >>
Legally, and ethically (in terms of right or wrong), the dealer owes nothing and is free to say done deal. However, by golden rule (do unto others as you would have done unto you), a dealer that does this to customers is probably going to get paid back in karma double or triple. A dealer with a case full of currency, show after show, who uses an excuse that he/she doesn't know how to grade the things or spot problem notes is extremely lame. That dealer is going to eventually reap what he/she has sown and it may not be so pleasant or with pleasant people.
suffered some kind of damage during that time. I'm not a dealer. Just sell a few coins now and then.
JT
I collect all 20th century series except gold including those series that ended there.
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
Once the hypothetical became a real situation with some more details, I have even more questions. Did the seller know this was cleaned and pressed? Was it ever submitted for grading but cracked out? If the seller did know it was c/p, what price would he have asked for the note?. The buyer here is basically saying in light of being cleaned and pressed, he would have paid $1250 for it instead of $1850 (by asking for the $600 coin back). If the seller didn't know about the c/p, is he actively pursuing his source of the bill to rip them a new one?
The whole thing sucks for both parties. The closest I can come to putting a real-life spin to this is buying antique glassware. I found a hairline crack that wasn't described at an auction, or even easily seen without maginification on a fenton piece. When I took it back to the next auction (2 weeks later), the purchase price was refunded and an apology given. The auctioneer had no reason to doubt it was there to begin with - no accusation of me doing it (would be hard to anyhow), but that's how he chooses to keep his customers happy and maintain a healthy professional reputation.
I hope the two of you work this out somehow.
"You Suck Award" - February, 2015
Discoverer of 1919 Mercury Dime DDO - FS-101
Okay I made up my mind.
I ain't never buying nothing from CoinSuperStore.
Never.
Ray
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
Although we do sell some currency it is only approximately 5% of our total inventory. I consider myself to be very knowledgeable with coins but not currency. On every raw coin in my inventory I put a grade, but on the currency I do not because I am in no way shape or form an expert on currency. Sometimes currency comes into the shop and I base my prices upon what I pay. I still think this note is very nice and far nicer than your typical VF25. If the buyer would be so kind as to post photos of the note, I think everyone on the boards would agree.
As for posting my post I left out names on purpose so as not to involve anyone involved and purposefully put hypothetical in the title to see what the right thing to do was, not to create a problem.
Personal Ebay Auctions
My Website
---------------------------------------------
ALWAYS LOOKING TO PURCHASE
TOP 100 MORGANS / HOT 50
TOP 50 PEACE VAMS
How did you know not to charge $300 or $3000 for it. By setting a price on the note, you have essentially graded it.
I still think this note is very nice and far nicer than your typical VF25.
Wait! I thought you did not know anything about grading currency. You said so earlier. I would not know a 25 from a wet piece of toilet paper.
AJ
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
<< <i>Technically, you are indeed stuck with the note, but many dealers would not stick it to you like this and post about it on a public forum in which you participate. >>
This is what I don't understand. First, it's very unprofessional for a dealer to call out a collector, (customer), on a public forum for any reason other than to warn other dealers in cases of fraud - and this is not one of those cases. The other problem with this is that any experienced business person should be able to decide the correct course of action without requiring the input of a group of what are essentially strangers. Thus, the logical conclusion is that the real purpose of the post was to seek re-inforcement for a decision already made.
<< <i>As for posting my post I left out names on purpose so as not to involve anyone involved and purposefully put hypothetical in the title to see what the right thing to do was, not to create a problem. >>
That doesn't wash. Anybody who's been here more than a week knows damned well that if the other party is a forum member, they will respond.
Russ, NCNE
Edited to add- Treat me right and I'll tell a few people, treat me wrong and I'll tell everyone I know.
<< <i>I would like a chance now to respond to everyone's comments.
Although we do sell some currency it is only approximately 5% of our total inventory. I consider myself to be very knowledgeable with coins but not currency. On every raw coin in my inventory I put a grade, but on the currency I do not because I am in no way shape or form an expert on currency. Sometimes currency comes into the shop and I base my prices upon what I pay. I still think this note is very nice and far nicer than your typical VF25. If the buyer would be so kind as to post photos of the note, I think everyone on the boards would agree.
As for posting my post I left out names on purpose so as not to involve anyone involved and purposefully put hypothetical in the title to see what the right thing to do was, not to create a problem. >>
This reply is full of it. If a person is a dealer, they'd better know something if they are buying and selling. How do you know if the note is real or a very good fake if you know so very little about it? This is hogwash. What dealer in their right mind would pay close to retail value or even 30% back of retail or even 70% back of retail on something they can't grade, and can't detect what is the equivalent of whizzing on a coin? With one breath the dealer says, I can't grade these things, and in the next breath, he says the note is very nice for the grade on the holder. Is there any objective person that will buy this load of baloney?
This story stinks and airing it on this forum makes the dealer look really, really bad. This is unprofessional behavior, poor customer service, lying (I don't know how to grade, it is nice for the grade), willingness to try and embarrass a customer who trusted the dealer on a public forum, all on a matter that should have been settled privately. I will not consider doing business with this dealer and would tell anyone who asks the same.
That doesn't wash. Anybody who's been here more than a week knows damned well that if the other party is a forum member, they will respond.
What Russ said. It also doesn't wash because a person who's sincere doesn't slant the facts in his favor when soliciting opinions on "the right thing to do."
Edited to add: And what RedTiger said, too.
<< <i>
<< <i>Technically, you are indeed stuck with the note, but many dealers would not stick it to you like this and post about it on a public forum in which you participate. >>
This is what I don't understand. First, it's very unprofessional for a dealer to call out a collector, (customer), on a public forum for any reason other than to warn other dealers in cases of fraud - and this is not one of those cases. The other problem with this is that any experienced business person should be able to decide the correct course of action without requiring the input of a group of what are essentially strangers. Thus, the logical conclusion is that the real purpose of the post was to seek re-inforcement for a decision already made.
<< <i>As for posting my post I left out names on purpose so as not to involve anyone involved and purposefully put hypothetical in the title to see what the right thing to do was, not to create a problem. >>
That doesn't wash. Anybody who's been here more than a week knows damned well that if the other party is a forum member, they will respond.
Russ, NCNE >>
Its impossible not to respond!
2 Cam-Slams!
1 Russ POTD!
Then why not just return his money and coins and he'll return you the GRADED note? You come out ahead, right? You receive, at no cost, a free grading and an education in currency grading.
2 Cam-Slams!
1 Russ POTD!
My icon IS my coin. It is a gem 1949 FBL Franklin.
"I know nothing. Nothing!"
he gave you.. everyone ends up where they started out.
except the collector who is out the grading fees and that's the price of education.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
Would a dealer do the same if he bought a note from a collector as XF and it came back AU? I seriously doubt it. The question here isnt the grade, its the fact that the note was cleaned & pressed.
AJ
PCGS Registries
Box of 20
SeaEagleCoins: 11/14/54-4/5/12. Miss you Larry!
that didn't happen
i'm not saying the return is justified. but sometimes we do things that aren't necessary
just to keep the peace.
<< <i>The question here isnt the grade, its the fact that the note was cleaned & pressed. >>
Another question comes to mind. PMG grades problem notes rather than bodybagging them?
Russ, NCNE
Positive BST: WhiteThunder (x2), Ajaan, onefasttalon, mirabela, Wizard1, cucamongacoin, mccardguy1
Negative BST: NONE!
<< <i>It seems this topic has potentially backfired on the OP.... >>
good thing this was only a hypothetical situation!
<<why not accept a return on the now graded note and give the guy back everything
he gave you.. everyone ends up where they started out.
except the collector who is out the grading fees and that's the price of education. >>
A wise man has spoken........
SM1 calls me a troublemaker....
--------------------------------------------
Sunday August 19, 2007 9:17AM
A mentor awarded " YOU SUCK!!"
<< <i>
<< <i>The question here isnt the grade, its the fact that the note was cleaned & pressed. >>
Another question comes to mind. PMG grades problem notes rather than bodybagging them?
Russ, NCNE >>
Sometimes PCGS does, too.
<< <i>"What if the note came back AU55? What's the chance the customer would contact the dealer and offer to pay him more for the note since it turned out to be undergraded?"
Would a dealer do the same if he bought a note from a collector as XF and it came back AU? I seriously doubt it. The question here isnt the grade, its the fact that the note was cleaned & pressed.
AJ >>
As I posted in my original reply, I only have minor problems with the actual transaction, even if dealer says "done deal" in response to the complaint. If it were a transaction with another dealer, definitely "done deal."
What is extremely unprofessional is posting it here on the forum in such detail, labeling it as hypothetical when the dollar amounts and the merchandise match exactly. The other part that irks me is claiming not knowing how to grade and then saying it is a nice for the grade on the holder. Which is it? One of those statements is garbage.
Again, this should have been resolved privately. If the buyer posted the situation, then the dealer would have every right to respond. If were a case of bad checks or a credit card scam that would be one thing. The posting of the story in such detail to make a trusting customer look bad is where the dealer crossed the line to inexcusable behavior.