I'm not sure what he meant, and despite the fact that I think it's silly to say there is no such thing as "market value" I predict that he'll eventually post an answer which is at least thought-provoking.
I'm not sure what he meant, and despite the fact that I think it's silly to say there is no such thing as "market value" I predict that he'll eventually post an answer which is at least thought-provoking.
No he won't; but he'll post some more thought-provoking questions.
IGWT - What is the market value of your house? How do you know?
Before or after the kitchen renovation? There are a few methods of appraisal, including the most common, looking at recent sales prices of three or more comparable properties.
<< <i>I'm not sure what he meant, and despite the fact that I think it's silly to say there is no such thing as "market value" I predict that he'll eventually post an answer which is at least thought-provoking.
No he won't; but he'll post some more thought-provoking questions.
IGWT - What is the market value of your house? How do you know?
Before or after the kitchen renovation? There are a few methods of appraisal, including the most common, looking at recent sales prices of three or more comparable properties. >>
Wait Wait Wait.... You are making way too much sense here IGWT.....just post a silly question and be done with it
<< <i>It's dealer speak for "The coin I'm selling is worth whatever I say it is."
Russ, NCNE >>
And that is the market value (at that time). When you decide to sell, a re-valuation might take place.
I work in an industry where this takes place daily. How do we combat this? We ask "dealers" to make a two-sided market. They often don't or one you could drive a truck through. The bottom line is that coins are very illiquid and you better know how to price/grade b/c opinions on market value differ (depening upon whether you are buying or selling).
<< <i>I'm not sure what he meant, and despite the fact that I think it's silly to say there is no such thing as "market value" I predict that he'll eventually post an answer which is at least thought-provoking. >>
me too!
I manage money. I earn money. I save money . I give away money. I collect money. I don’t love money . I do love the Lord God.
The price that an interested but not desperate buyer would be willing to pay and an interested but not desperate seller would be willing to accept on the open market assuming a reasonable period of time for an agreement to arise
There would be if, as many buyers assume, all coins of the same grade were created equal.
this was a reply by Russ at the original thread and it very plainly explains both what we all know and what Andy was alluding to. for me, market value of a coin equates to what an average dealer will expect from an average seller for an average coin. a better coin will get what we call a "premium" added to the market value and a lesser coin will be what we term "discounted" below the market value.
we all know these things, why in the heck would you start a thread about it?? aren't Numismatists supposed have above average intelligence and be able to infer certain things?
<< <i>There would be if, as many buyers assume, all coins of the same grade were created equal.
this was a reply by Russ at the original thread and it very plainly explains both what we all know and what Andy was alluding to. for me, market value of a coin equates to what an average dealer will expect from an average seller for an average coin. a better coin will get what we call a "premium" added to the market value and a lesser coin will be what we term "discounted" below the market value.
we all know these things, why in the heck would you start a thread about it?? aren't Numismatists supposed have above average intelligence and be able to infer certain things? >>
Well, I can infer from your two questions that you think I have below average intelligence.
First, I wasn't asking what "market value" means, I was asking what Andy meant by saying that he doesn't "believe there is such a thing as a 'market value.'" Second, if Russ had accurately captured Andy's meaning, Andy probably wouldn't have responded, "Not really. . . ." Third, your understanding of market value makes absolutely no sense.
<< <i>There would be if, as many buyers assume, all coins of the same grade were created equal.
this was a reply by Russ at the original thread and it very plainly explains both what we all know and what Andy was alluding to. for me, market value of a coin equates to what an average dealer will expect from an average seller for an average coin. a better coin will get what we call a "premium" added to the market value and a lesser coin will be what we term "discounted" below the market value.
we all know these things, why in the heck would you start a thread about it?? aren't Numismatists supposed have above average intelligence and be able to infer certain things? >>
Well, I can infer from your two questions that you think I have below average intelligence.
First, I wasn't asking what "market value" means, I was asking what Andy meant by saying that he doesn't "believe there is such a thing as a 'market value.'" Second, if Russ had accurately captured Andy's meaning, Andy probably wouldn't have responded, "Not really. . . ." Third, your understanding of market value makes absolutely no sense. >>
The last time I posted something a "dealer" took issue with it; hopefully this time will be different.
In response to MrEureka's statement....
I think he is correct, afterall it is not a "market" that decides to buy a coin. The value of the coin is decided by either the seller who can set a price that is not met but they still value the coin at that level; or a buyer who purchases a coin. There is a seller and a buyer but no "market".
The term is used I believe as a relative level at which we might expect to attract a buyer.
To some people the "market" doesn't start until after $ 1,000,000 apparently .
Ask 20 people what the fair market value of a particular coin is, and you will likely get several different answers. On esoteric items, you might even get 20 different responses. As such, I think he is right - if thre is no way to quantify FMV, how can it exist?
What is now proved was once only imagined. - William Blake
BTW, of course Market Value exists. It's a reasonable estimate based on the information available. But, if no info, then no market value (rare).
If several different people were asked to give Market Value for the same basket of items, I doubt that you would get a the same answer from each person. If knowledgeable people can't come to the same conclusion as to what MV is, does it really exist?
What is now proved was once only imagined. - William Blake
I have often stated that there is no "market" in numismatics. It is a hobby, not a stock swap meet. Buy what floats-your-boat and you will find enjoyment. When it is time to sell, perhaps your coin will float-someone-elses-boat.
"If knowledgeable people can't come to the same conclusion as to what MV is, does it really exist?"
Yes Market value exists even if a group of knowledgeable people give different answers. They can all be wrong. Opinions are like... everybody has them.
You are over thinking this. You must be a Democrat
<< <i>I have often stated that there is no "market" in numismatics. It is a hobby, not a stock swap meet. Buy what floats-your-boat and you will find enjoyment. When it is time to sell, perhaps your coin will float-someone-elses-boat. >>
It is more than a hobby!
I manage money. I earn money. I save money . I give away money. I collect money. I don’t love money . I do love the Lord God.
True from certain perspectives, however I do this for my living and it is still a hobby for me. How can a beautifully toned AR Shilling of Charles I become a commodity? There are NO price guides for that type of coin, nor many countless other historical relics (i.e. special coins).
True from certain perspectives, however I do this for my living and it is still a hobby for me. How can a beautifully toned AR Shilling of Charles I become a commodity? There are NO price guides for that type of coin, nor many countless other historical relics (i.e. special coins). >>
I agree and therefore you must ask the price,.....BTW if it is choice you have a market.
I manage money. I earn money. I save money . I give away money. I collect money. I don’t love money . I do love the Lord God.
Perhaps values (and I propose grades also) should not be thought of having a single acceptable number attached to them but rather have a range, sometimes a small range but othertimes quite broad.
To put value in perspective, take a child of about 6-8 years old. Barely able to grasp the concept of paying more for a coin than the coin is worth at the store.
Then lay out about 20 coins of all types and denominations, tokens, medals, everything... Ask them to pick out the one that they think costs the most money.
Comments
Russ, NCNE
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
No he won't; but he'll post some more thought-provoking questions.
IGWT - What is the market value of your house? How do you know?
Before or after the kitchen renovation?
Coin's for sale/trade.
Tom Pilitowski
US Rare Coin Investments
800-624-1870
<< <i>I'm not sure what he meant, and despite the fact that I think it's silly to say there is no such thing as "market value" I predict that he'll eventually post an answer which is at least thought-provoking.
No he won't; but he'll post some more thought-provoking questions.
IGWT - What is the market value of your house? How do you know?
Before or after the kitchen renovation?
Wait Wait Wait....
You are making way too much sense here IGWT.....just post a silly question and be done with it
<< <i>It's dealer speak for "The coin I'm selling is worth whatever I say it is."
Russ, NCNE >>
And that is the market value (at that time). When you decide to sell, a re-valuation might take place.
I work in an industry where this takes place daily. How do we combat this? We ask "dealers" to make a two-sided market. They often don't or one you could drive a truck through. The bottom line is that coins are very illiquid and you better know how to price/grade b/c opinions on market value differ (depening upon whether you are buying or selling).
I too am interested in hearing a response....
<< <i>IGWT - What is the market value of your house? How do you know? >>
Uh, what about comps?
I give away money. I collect money.
I don’t love money . I do love the Lord God.
<< <i>I'm not sure what he meant, and despite the fact that I think it's silly to say there is no such thing as "market value" I predict that he'll eventually post an answer which is at least thought-provoking. >>
me too!
I give away money. I collect money.
I don’t love money . I do love the Lord God.
The price that an interested but not desperate buyer would be willing to pay and an interested but not desperate seller would be willing to accept on the open market assuming a reasonable period of time for an agreement to arise
this was a reply by Russ at the original thread and it very plainly explains both what we all know and what Andy was alluding to. for me, market value of a coin equates to what an average dealer will expect from an average seller for an average coin. a better coin will get what we call a "premium" added to the market value and a lesser coin will be what we term "discounted" below the market value.
we all know these things, why in the heck would you start a thread about it?? aren't Numismatists supposed have above average intelligence and be able to infer certain things?
<< <i>There would be if, as many buyers assume, all coins of the same grade were created equal.
this was a reply by Russ at the original thread and it very plainly explains both what we all know and what Andy was alluding to. for me, market value of a coin equates to what an average dealer will expect from an average seller for an average coin. a better coin will get what we call a "premium" added to the market value and a lesser coin will be what we term "discounted" below the market value.
we all know these things, why in the heck would you start a thread about it?? aren't Numismatists supposed have above average intelligence and be able to infer certain things? >>
Well, I can infer from your two questions that you think I have below average intelligence.
First, I wasn't asking what "market value" means, I was asking what Andy meant by saying that he doesn't "believe there is such a thing as a 'market value.'" Second, if Russ had accurately captured Andy's meaning, Andy probably wouldn't have responded, "Not really. . . ." Third, your understanding of market value makes absolutely no sense.
<< <i>
<< <i>There would be if, as many buyers assume, all coins of the same grade were created equal.
this was a reply by Russ at the original thread and it very plainly explains both what we all know and what Andy was alluding to. for me, market value of a coin equates to what an average dealer will expect from an average seller for an average coin. a better coin will get what we call a "premium" added to the market value and a lesser coin will be what we term "discounted" below the market value.
we all know these things, why in the heck would you start a thread about it?? aren't Numismatists supposed have above average intelligence and be able to infer certain things? >>
Well, I can infer from your two questions that you think I have below average intelligence.
First, I wasn't asking what "market value" means, I was asking what Andy meant by saying that he doesn't "believe there is such a thing as a 'market value.'" Second, if Russ had accurately captured Andy's meaning, Andy probably wouldn't have responded, "Not really. . . ." Third, your understanding of market value makes absolutely no sense. >>
Now we're making progress.
In response to MrEureka's statement....
I think he is correct, afterall it is not a "market" that decides to buy a coin. The value of the coin is decided by either the seller who can set a price that is not met but they still value the coin at that level; or a buyer who purchases a coin. There is a seller and a buyer but no "market".
The term is used I believe as a relative level at which we might expect to attract a buyer.
To some people the "market" doesn't start until after $ 1,000,000 apparently
What is now proved was once only imagined. - William Blake
Um, what about Numismedia?
with regard to this topic, your inference would be correct. you evidentally don't get it, but that's OK.
BTW, of course Market Value exists. It's a reasonable estimate based on the information available. But, if no info, then no market value (rare).
<< <i>Did Andy get married? >>
Andy told me there is no such thing as marriage.
Nah, he just has a stalker.
BTW, of course Market Value exists. It's a reasonable estimate based on the information available. But, if no info, then no market value (rare).
If several different people were asked to give Market Value for the same basket of items, I doubt that you would get a the same answer from each person. If knowledgeable people can't come to the same conclusion as to what MV is, does it really exist?
What is now proved was once only imagined. - William Blake
<< <i>
<< <i>Did Andy get married? >>
Andy told me there is no such thing as marriage. >>
You just don't get it; but that's OK.
I give away money. I collect money.
I don’t love money . I do love the Lord God.
I have often stated that there is no "market" in numismatics. It is a hobby, not a stock swap meet. Buy what floats-your-boat and you will find enjoyment. When it is time to sell, perhaps your coin will float-someone-elses-boat.
Yes Market value exists even if a group of knowledgeable people give different answers. They can all be wrong. Opinions are like... everybody has them.
You are over thinking this. You must be a Democrat
<< <i>I have often stated that there is no "market" in numismatics. It is a hobby, not a stock swap meet. Buy what floats-your-boat and you will find enjoyment. When it is time to sell, perhaps your coin will float-someone-elses-boat.
It is more than a hobby!
I give away money. I collect money.
I don’t love money . I do love the Lord God.
It is more than a hobby!
True from certain perspectives, however I do this for my living and it is still a hobby for me. How can a beautifully toned AR Shilling of Charles I become a commodity? There are NO price guides for that type of coin, nor many countless other historical relics (i.e. special coins).
<< <i>It is more than a hobby!
True from certain perspectives, however I do this for my living and it is still a hobby for me. How can a beautifully toned AR Shilling of Charles I become a commodity? There are NO price guides for that type of coin, nor many countless other historical relics (i.e. special coins). >>
I agree and therefore you must ask the price,.....BTW if it is choice you have a market.
I give away money. I collect money.
I don’t love money . I do love the Lord God.
Touché
Ed. S.
(EJS)
Apparently not.
"Seu cabra da peste,
"Sou Mangueira......."
of paying more for a coin than the coin is worth at the store.
Then lay out about 20 coins of all types and denominations, tokens, medals, everything...
Ask them to pick out the one that they think costs the most money.
<< <i>The last time I posted something a "dealer" took issue with it >>
Kudos!
Russ, NCNE