Options
Some interesting recent submissions of mine.
<< <i>Order #10343608 / Submission #3245149
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 60215433 9434 1952 50C Washington-Carver US Questionable Color
2 1 60215434 86702 1961 50C US PR67CA
3 1 60215435 86703 1962 50C US PR65CA
4 1 60215436 86800 1964 50C US PR66CA
5 1 60215437 6801 1964 50C Accented Hair US PR68
6 1 60215438 3429 1970-S 1C Large Date US PR66RB
7 1 60215439 86806 1970-S 50C US PR67CA
Total Items: 7
Date Received: 8/8/2005
Date Shipped: 9/9/2005 >>
<< <i>Order #20071986 / Submission #3456626
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 10749290 1576 1814 1C Plain 4 US G04BN
2 1 10749291 1919 1856 1C Upright 5 US Damage or ToolingBN
3 1 10749292 4504 1827 10C US VF25
4 1 10749293 4521 1832 10C US VF25
5 1 10749294 5313 1805 25C US G04
6 1 10749295 6052 1795 50C US G04
7 1 10749296 6071 1806 50C Pointed 6, Stem US VF35
8 1 10749297 7363 1924 $1 US MS63
9 1 10749298 9434 1952 50C Washington-Carver US MS65
Total Items: 9
Date Received: 12/6/2006
Date Shipped: N/A >>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
<< <i>Order #20022591 / Submission #3456621
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 11188684 3583 1865 2C US Questionable ColorRB
2 1 11188685 5336 1825/4/3 25C US VG08
3 1 11188686 5354 1835 25C US XF45
4 1 11188687 5298 1875-S 20C US AU50
5 1 11188688 5616 1897 25C US MS61
6 1 11188689 6143 1826 50C US MS62
7 1 11188690 6275 1853 50C Arrows and Rays US VF25
8 1 11188691 6929 1843 $1 US XF45
9 1 11188692 86801 1964 50C Accented Hair US PR66CA
10 1 11188693 96805 1969-S 50C US PR67DC
Total Items: 10
Date Received: 3/14/2006
Date Shipped: N/A >>
<< <i>Order #20056557 / Submission #3456624
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 10418402 1093 1806 1/2C Small 6, No Stems US VF35BN
2 1 10418403 3583 1865 2C US MS64RB
3 1 10418404 6071 1806 50C Pointed 6, Stem US Cleaned
4 1 10418405 7092 1879-S $1 US MS65
5 1 10418406 7131 1881-S $1 US MS65PL
6 1 10418407 7144 1883-CC $1 US MS64
7 1 10418408 6702 1961 50C US PR66
8 1 10418409 6702 1961 50C US PR67
9 1 10418410 6845 1965 50C SMS US MS66
10 1 10418411 86846 1966 50C SMS US MS66CA
Total Items: 10
Date Received: 9/18/2006
Date Shipped: N/A >>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
<< <i>Order #20056557 / Submission #3456624
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 10418402 1093 1806 1/2C Small 6, No Stems US VF35BN
2 1 10418403 3583 1865 2C US MS64RB
3 1 10418404 6071 1806 50C Pointed 6, Stem US Cleaned
4 1 10418405 7092 1879-S $1 US MS65
5 1 10418406 7131 1881-S $1 US MS65PL
6 1 10418407 7144 1883-CC $1 US MS64
7 1 10418408 6702 1961 50C US PR66
8 1 10418409 6702 1961 50C US PR67
9 1 10418410 6845 1965 50C SMS US MS66
10 1 10418411 86846 1966 50C SMS US MS66CA
Total Items: 10
Date Received: 9/18/2006
Date Shipped: N/A >>
Order #20071986 / Submission #3456626
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 10749290 1576 1814 1C Plain 4 US G04BN
2 1 10749291 1919 1856 1C Upright 5 US Damage or ToolingBN
3 1 10749292 4504 1827 10C US VF25
4 1 10749293 4521 1832 10C US VF25
5 1 10749294 5313 1805 25C US G04
6 1 10749295 6052 1795 50C US G04
7 1 10749296 6071 1806 50C Pointed 6, Stem US VF35
8 1 10749297 7363 1924 $1 US MS63
9 1 10749298 9434 1952 50C Washington-Carver US MS65
Total Items: 9
Date Received: 12/6/2006
Date Shipped: N/A >>

Russ, NCNE
0
Comments
Lincoln set Colorless Set
It's quite obvious from those grading submissions, that each of the coins that were body bagged the first time in really should not have been submitted on those days. It's quite clear that it was your mistake for submitting them for grading on the wrong days. Had you been more patient, or maybe more intuitive, and ony submitted them on the days that PCGS was actually grading coins, you would not have received those 3 bodybagged coins.
And Russ, let me also say, it takes a real man to step up and show us all your submission mistakes.
I certainly hope that you've learned your lesson Russ.
PCGS, ANACS, & NGC Certified Coins on My Website.
Now shut up about them being perfect damn it!
Positive BST: WhiteThunder (x2), Ajaan, onefasttalon, mirabela, Wizard1, cucamongacoin, mccardguy1
Negative BST: NONE!
then they dang well ought to refund someones hard earned money for
that first (or previous) submissions. i.e... their mistake.
That last one had a lot of nice original oldies in there.
<< <i>I guess I need to resubmit my Texas Commem, again >>
If you truly believe in the coin, then by all means do it. I mean TRULY believe. I've had my share of "iffys" that I got back and decided PCGS was likely right about them. Those I didn't try again.
We are all human and subject to mistakes, even graders.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>what amuses me about this thread-----and especially the responses thus far-----is that the supposition is that PCGS was wrong the first time and right the second. isn't it just as plausible that the coins were graded properly the first time and now are nothing more than problem coins in PCGS holders, two which may be AT and one which may have had an old(or new) cleaning?? >>
IMO it's the inconsistency - doesn't matter which coin came first.
<< <i>what amuses me about this thread-----and especially the responses thus far-----is that the supposition is that PCGS was wrong the first time and right the second. isn't it just as plausible that the coins were graded properly the first time and now are nothing more than problem coins in PCGS holders, two which may be AT and one which may have had an old(or new) cleaning?? >>
Except for the fact that all three of them was cracked out of legitimate third party holders; two ANACS and one NGC - and two of them upgraded at PCGS.
Russ, NCNE
Experience the World through Numismatics...it's more than you can imagine.
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
<< <i>how does that change anything?? >>
You're kidding, right? Your argument was that PCGS could just as easily be wrong the second time, and that these are problem coins now in their holder. That argument falls flat in the face of the fact that 80% of the opinions, (mine, the owner of the coins, the original TPG, and now PCGS), rendered say the coins are fine. It's pretty silly to assert that one opinion out of five is likely the correct one.
Russ, NCNE
Fact: they submit and get bodybagged (oops!)
Fact: they are resubmitted and come out smelling like a rose
...so someone was either alseep at the wheel the second time around, or someone was having a bad day the first time.
either way I like this idea.
"If they grade a coin that the owner can prove was a prior bodybag,
then they dang well ought to refund someones hard earned money for that first (or previous) submissions. i.e... their mistake."
so, can you prove it?
---Had you been more patient, or maybe more intuitive, and ony submitted them on the days that PCGS was actually grading coins, you would not have received those 3 bodybagged coins.
---Interesting indeed. Just goes to show that even *gasp* PCGS doesn't get everything right.
---I guess I need to resubmit my Texas Commem, again, that I have has been BB'd twice for questionable color. I just pisses me off that we have to pay high grading fees for this game, over and over.
---If they grade a coin that the owner can prove was a prior bodybag,
then they dang well ought to refund someones hard earned money for
that first (or previous) submissions. i.e... their mistake.
Your argument was that PCGS could just as easily be wrong the second time, and that these are problem coins now in their holder.
not my arguement at all. i'm simply saying that assuming either scenario to be right is akin to drinking koolaid. the replies before mine simply tended to assume that PCGS got it right the second time.
<< <i>7 1 10749296 6071 1806 50C Pointed 6, Stem US VF35 >>
<< <i>"If they grade a coin that the owner can prove was a prior bodybag,
then they dang well ought to refund someones hard earned money for that first (or previous) submissions. i.e... their mistake."
so, can you prove it?
If you paid for photos the first time around, you probably could prove it. Of course, how's that really all that different than repeatedly submitting a coin in order to max out the grade?
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
<< <i>If they grade a coin that the owner can prove was a prior bodybag,
then they dang well ought to refund someones hard earned money for that first (or previous) submissions. i.e... their mistake."
so, can you prove it?
If you paid for photos the first time around, you probably could prove it. Of course, how's that really all that different than repeatedly submitting a coin in order to max out the grade? >>
Good point messydesk, let me ask you this, i don't know the answer because i don't get enough coins graded to know how it all works. But, if a coin is more than maxed out in it's grade (it's overgraded) and it is presented to PCGS for review and they deem that it is in fact, overgraded, don't they offer some sort of guarantee or buyback?
Why not do it in the other direction also. If a coin has had an unwarranted bagging, to the owners financial harm and it is later graded properly, shouldn't the owner of coin be made whole, provided they can prove they were out the bagging fees?
<< <i>grading has a subjective component >>
Exactly! You could take a raw coin to any large show and show it to 4 or 5 very experienced and knowledgeable dealers and easily get several different and varying opinions on its grade, and those opinions may change yet again if shown the exact same coin at a later date.
Check out my current listings: https://ebay.com/sch/khunt/m.html?_ipg=200&_sop=12&_rdc=1
<< <i>Good point messydesk, let me ask you this, i don't know the answer because i don't get enough coins graded to know how it all works. But, if a coin is more than maxed out in it's grade (it's overgraded) and it is presented to PCGS for review and they deem that it is in fact, overgraded, don't they offer some sort of guarantee or buyback?
Why not do it in the other direction also. If a coin has had an unwarranted bagging, to the owners financial harm and it is later graded properly, shouldn't the owner of coin be made whole, provided they can prove they were out the bagging fees? >>
PCGS and others offer a grade guarantee or buyback to prevent sight unseen buyers from being burned on a purchase. A bodybag followed by encapsulation is merely an illustration of the flexibility of the term "market acceptable."
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
I see this one bagged twice as well. I always wonder what they see in 10 seconds when I can't see
it under my scope with endless time to examine the coin.
Free Trial
I guess I should have re-submitted this one
Russ it's nice to see you don't do just Kennedy's
<< <i>Russ it's nice to see you don't do just Kennedy's
Wonder if he has done any Lauras!!!
<< <i>this thread certainly has some educational value, but it also goes a long way towards explaining why grading and resubmission is often referred to as a game. >>
Ah yes, but its a subjective game where the consensus of three different graders must be met.
Could be the same three, could be a different three or could be a combination of the original three and a newb. Still, unless the coin has a specific pedigree and known history, I doubt that it would grade the same on different submissions just because of the subjectivity.
On the plus side, if a submitter absolutely and without a doubt feels that the coin was undergraded, then he/she should resubmit it. Submission choice is up to the submitter. Once its cracked out though, then the submitter is the one playing the game...................er, taking the chance.
The name is LEE!
If the grade don't fit, you must resubmit!!!