Options
Questions about negative feedback on eBay....what to do?
drddm
Posts: 5,477 ✭✭✭✭✭
Does anyone know how long one has before the opportunity to leave feedback (positive or negative) expires on eBay?
Also, does anyone know if a seller can leave negative feedback after he has already posted positive feedback for the buyer?
Finally, does the seller have the opportunity to leave comments after negative feedback is posted by the buyer, IF the seller has already left positive feedback for the buyer?
Thanks
Also, does anyone know if a seller can leave negative feedback after he has already posted positive feedback for the buyer?
Finally, does the seller have the opportunity to leave comments after negative feedback is posted by the buyer, IF the seller has already left positive feedback for the buyer?
Thanks
0
Comments
<< <i>Does anyone know how long one has before the opportunity to leave feedback (positive or negative) expires on eBay?
Also, does anyone know if a seller can leave negative feedback after he has already posted positive feedback for the buyer?
Finally, does the seller have the opportunity to leave comments after negative feedback is posted by the buyer, IF the seller has already left positive feedback for the buyer?
Thanks >>
90 days
No
Yes
<< <i>Does anyone know how long one has before the opportunity to leave feedback (positive or negative) expires on eBay? >>
As long as the auction still appears in the database. Used to be 90 days, but I have some linked auctions that are still showing after much longer than that.
<< <i>Also, does anyone know if a seller can leave negative feedback after he has already posted positive feedback for the buyer? >>
No, they can't. They can post a followup to the positive and say negative things, but it doesn't impact the rating.
<< <i>Finally, does the seller have the opportunity to leave comments after negative feedback is posted by the buyer, IF the seller has already left positive feedback for the buyer? >>
Yes, followup comments are part of the process. Again, though, followups don't impact ratings.
Russ, NCNE
True story: I won an auction and paid for a coin on Sept 29. The coin was mailed to me on Oct 4 with delivery confirmation and I have not received it yet. It was not an expensive coin and therefore I did NOT purchase insurance on it, although looking back I wish I did. The seller has communicated to me that he has no intention of refunding my money because I did not buy insurance and therefore I should take the loss on this one, NOT him. A claim was filed with paypal as I used it to pay for the coin. The seller has ALREADY left me positive feedback long ago after he received my payment. Now it is up to me to wait for the paypal inquiry and outcome and decide what to leave the seller as far as feedback goes. By the way, both the seller and myself have 100% feedback as of now.
What would you do in this case?
To support LordM's European Trip, click here!
You elected not to insure.
Sorry but I see NO cause for either of you to leave negitive feedback.
And sorry but I think you loose on the PayPal claim also, they also have a insurance you could of purchased.
No. That would be extremely unfair under the circumstances.
"The Villain"
Shiba Rescue Organization
A Shiba Inu is a terrible thing to waste!
What is the seller's feedback profile like?
--Jerry
Neutrals don't show up in the FB rating either but it's wise to read those as wells since those often are equivalent to a neg.
A seller could have 10 negs out of 1000 and yet another 40 neutrals.
That's a seller probably worth avoiding.
Comments make a difference, even if not to the FB rating.
roadrunner
The seller didn't scam you or rip you off but mailed you coin & left you feedback in good faith. He doesn't deserve a neg.
You can't leave good feedback because you never got you coin, regardless or whether you declined or accepted insurance. Neutralize him.
If an individual, you are out of luck. If it's a business, UCC regs require the SELLER to guarantee delivery.
<< <i>Final question, would you leave negative feedback for a seller if you bought a coin from him and you never received it because it was LOST by the USPS? >>
No. You created the problem by refusing to purchase insurance. In fact, you're also wrong for filing a PayPal chargeback.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>Final question, would you leave negative feedback for a seller if you bought a coin from him and you never received it because it was LOST by the USPS? >>
No. You created the problem by refusing to purchase insurance. In fact, you're also wrong for filing a PayPal chargeback.
Russ, NCNE >>
I thought it was the sellers responsibility to get the coin to the buyer.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>I thought it was the sellers responsibility to get the coin to the buyer. >>
The seller offered the option of purchasing insurance. The buyer willfully declined that offer. The buyer has no moral foundation for posting negative feedback or for filing a PayPal chargeback. The buyer should take responsibility for his own actions.
Russ, NCNE
"Inspiration exists, but it has to find you working" Pablo Picasso
If he has a tracking number and it's valid, i would side with the seller.
If no tracking number can be produced and verified, then the buyer is in the right.
Ike Specialist
Finest Toned Ike I've Ever Seen, been looking since 1986
<< <i>
<< <i>I thought it was the sellers responsibility to get the coin to the buyer. >>
The seller offered the option of purchasing insurance. The buyer willfully declined that offer. The buyer has no moral foundation for posting negative feedback or for filing a PayPal chargeback. The buyer should take responsibility for his own actions.
Russ, NCNE >>
How does the buyer know the seller even shipped the coin? And why would any seller make insurance optional? I thought insurance was to protect the seller and not the buyer since the buyer can reverse the charges.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
To support LordM's European Trip, click here!
I did purchase Delivery Confirmation and retain both the original USPS receipt and Delivery Confirmation slip. I offered the buyer full insurance at exact USPS rates but he chose not to take it. He gambled and lost and I do not feel that I should pay for it.
"The Villain"
Shiba Rescue Organization
A Shiba Inu is a terrible thing to waste!
<< <i><< I thought it was the sellers responsibility to get the coin to the buyer. >>
The seller offered the option of purchasing insurance. The buyer willfully declined that offer. The buyer has no moral foundation for posting negative feedback or for filing a PayPal chargeback. The buyer should take responsibility for his own actions.
Russ, NCNE >>
How does the buyer know the seller even shipped the coin? >>
Did you read his post?
<< <i>The coin was mailed to me on Oct 4 with delivery confirmation >>
<< <i>And why would any seller make insurance optional? >>
It's not a smart thing to do, but that issue is independent of the buyer's moral responsibility to accept the consequences of his own decision.
<< <i>I thought insurance was to protect the seller and not the buyer since the buyer can reverse the charges. >>
It is, and PayPal will likely grant the chargeback as they are legally entitled to do. But, legality and morality are frequently divergent concepts. While this buyer has the "legal" means to file a chargeback, that does not make his action moral.
Russ, NCNE
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
Ahh you've heard of the FTC mail & telephone order merchandise rule. It gives detailed instructions on shipping, non and delayed shipping, insurance etc.
It does say it's the seller's responsibility to get the merchandise to the buyer.
I think that covers retail sales and not internet auctions.
For all I know he mailed something to someone WITHOUT an address.
Still wondering if I will get anything back from paypal. I feel that I deserve some compensation, even if I decided against purchasing insurance. I believe the seller has an obligation to the buyer to provide goods that were paid for.
"If you accept PayPal as a payment method, YOU are responsible to get the item to the buyer. Insurance doesn't matter. Insurance is designed to protect YOU and not the buyer. If they file a claim, you will LOSE. It's that simple. WHEN you lose the claim, PayPal will charge you an additional $10.00 fee."
Here is another one:
"Doesn't matter "why". "The seller is always responsible" when they use USPS without postal insurance. The risk of loss remains with the sender."
A different thread (I'm still trying to find this policy they speak of)
"The seller is responsible, under eBay policy, to get the item delivered to you as described in the auction."
Everyone here seems to have a different opinion - I'm not 100% sure of the rules on private shipments ala eBay, but Dog97 is right - in retail sales, FOB is when it hits my door, that's when ownership is transfered, not when it's in the mail. When it's in the mail, it's still the sellers item - and their problem if it gets lost.
"You Suck Award" - February, 2015
Discoverer of 1919 Mercury Dime DDO - FS-101
<< <i>For all I know he mailed something to someone WITHOUT an address. >>
I can provide pictures of the receipt and delivery confirmation slip (showing the address the package was sent to).
I will work with you on this, and while I still do not intend to issue a full refund, I will do my best to provide you some sense of compensation for the unfortunate loss. Please contact me if you wish to discuss this.
<< <i>I can understand everyone's point of view on this matter, but the one thing I don't know is if the seller mailed me anything or not. All he provided me was a delivery confirmation number for a package that had NO destination.
For all I know he mailed something to someone WITHOUT an address.
Still wondering if I will get anything back from paypal. I feel that I deserve some compensation, even if I decided against purchasing insurance. I believe the seller has an obligation to the buyer to provide goods that were paid for. >>
why didn't you consider all of these scenarios when you declined the insurance? i'm guessing it's a because it was low
dollar and a gamble you were willing to take. well, it came up deuces... move on. no offence meant toward you.
<< <i>Why would a buyer who declines insurance deserve some kind of compensation at the expense of the seller? >>
Morally, he doesn't.
Russ, NCNE
Let me ask you something; you paid .60¢ for Delivery Confirmation which is useless; why didn't you go ahead and pay .70¢ more for the $50 insurance and avoid this headache? You both could have had your claim settled by now.
Cheap a$$ coin collectors!
<< <i>p8nt, when you punch in the delivery confirm number, what does it say? >>
Status: Acceptance
Your item was accepted at 8:07 pm on October 04, 2006 in PORTLAND, OR 97238. No further information is available for this item.
Unfortunately, this is all the information that it shows. It neither confirms nor denies delivery because DC is not a guaranteed service and packages have been known to be delivered without being scanned.
The 70¢ you speak of would have cost me $1.30 more
I would then need to have delivery confirmation and insurance. Delivery confirmation is required for Paypal and without I would lose a claim in all certainty.
"Congratulations on winning a great coin! I personally think it is NT and does stand a chance of crossing at PCGS. I realize that the PCI aspect of the coin probably hurt the sale value, but the coin was on consignment and the consignor wanted to auction it. If I had the chance, I would have kept it for myself. Its that nice of a coin and if for any reason at all you don't like it, feel free to return it. I will even cover the postage."
Any opinions as to whether he actually mailed this coin to me or not?
<< <i>Any opinions as to whether he actually mailed this coin to me or not? >>
I have no doubt that he did.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
Any opinions as to whether he actually mailed this coin to me or not? >>
Hi,
I have bought quite a few coins from Ben and every purchase was flawless and quick. Very honest person.
Dan
"The Villain"
Shiba Rescue Organization
A Shiba Inu is a terrible thing to waste!
That being said, I agree with Russ, the buyer willingly accepted the risk, and it was not appropriate to file the chargeback or even consider negging the seller.
<< <i>
<< <i>Any opinions as to whether he actually mailed this coin to me or not? >>
I have no doubt that he did.
Russ, NCNE >>
I see no cause, whatsoever, for there to be any reasonable doubt. And frankly, if I were the seller under these circumstances, based upon the buyer's posts, I don't think I could be nearly as polite as he's been.
My statement does display a love for the coin, and had it been available to me, I would have bought it. The point is that the coin was not mine. It was on consignment and I auctioned the coin and mailed it to you. For you to suggest that I am lying to you, the numismatic community, and committing mail fraud is a slap in the face. If that is not bad enough, you are now slandering my reputation through the unrightful posting of private messages.
I spoke to you numerous times and gave you additional pictures and insight of the coin that I did not provide to other potential buyers. I have been understanding to you and tried to work this out multiple times with you, both through email when it first became clear the coin had not arrived, and now. Yet you choose not to PM or email me, and instead post this latest statement:
<< <i>As for the reason I said I don't know if he even mailed me the coin is what he said to me via a PM right after the auction was completed, and I quote....
"Congratulations on winning a great coin! I personally think it is NT and does stand a chance of crossing at PCGS. I realize that the PCI aspect of the coin probably hurt the sale value, but the coin was on consignment and the consignor wanted to auction it. If I had the chance, I would have kept it for myself. Its that nice of a coin and if for any reason at all you don't like it, feel free to return it. I will even cover the postage."
Any opinions as to whether he actually mailed this coin to me or not? >>
I am saddened by this choice of actions, but am still willing to discuss some compensation, assuming that compensation is really what you want.
And I believe you, drddm, are in the wrong here. You neglected to buy insurance, and this is the result. A chargeback is a very low thing to do.
The 70¢ you speak of would have cost me $1.30 more>>>
I would then need to have delivery confirmation and insurance. Delivery confirmation is required for Paypal and without I would lose a claim in all certainty.>>>
Dam, They make it complicated & costly now. I got paid with PP for a bunch of $800 gold coins a while back and didn't use DC when I mail them. Maybe I just didn't want to. But I did use PS Form 3813-P.
<<<<< Any opinions as to whether he actually mailed this coin to me or not? >>
I have no doubt that he did.
Russ, NCNE >>
I see no cause, whatsoever, for there to be any reasonable doubt. And frankly, if I were the seller under these circumstances, based upon the buyer's posts, I don't think I could be nearly as polite as he's been.
-------------------------
Mark Feld>>>
Me too.
<< <i>David,
My statement does display a love for the coin, and had it been available to me, I would have bought it. The point is that the coin was not mine. It was on consignment and I auctioned the coin and mailed it to you. For you to suggest that I am lying to you, the numismatic community, and committing mail fraud is a slap in the face. If that is not bad enough, you are now slandering my reputation through the unrightful posting of private messages.
I spoke to you numerous times and gave you additional pictures and insight of the coin that I did not provide to other potential buyers. I have been understanding to you and tried to work this out multiple times with you, both through email when it first became clear the coin had not arrived, and now. Yet you choose not to PM or email me, and instead post this latest statement:
<< <i>As for the reason I said I don't know if he even mailed me the coin is what he said to me via a PM right after the auction was completed, and I quote....
"Congratulations on winning a great coin! I personally think it is NT and does stand a chance of crossing at PCGS. I realize that the PCI aspect of the coin probably hurt the sale value, but the coin was on consignment and the consignor wanted to auction it. If I had the chance, I would have kept it for myself. Its that nice of a coin and if for any reason at all you don't like it, feel free to return it. I will even cover the postage."
Any opinions as to whether he actually mailed this coin to me or not? >>
I am saddened by this choice of actions, but am still willing to discuss some compensation, assuming that compensation is really what you want. >>
WOW - I would have said screw it by now ....
"The Villain"
Shiba Rescue Organization
A Shiba Inu is a terrible thing to waste!
<< <i>As for the reason I said I don't know if he even mailed me the coin is what he said to me via a PM right after the auction was completed, and I quote....
"Congratulations on winning a great coin! I personally think it is NT and does stand a chance of crossing at PCGS. I realize that the PCI aspect of the coin probably hurt the sale value, but the coin was on consignment and the consignor wanted to auction it. If I had the chance, I would have kept it for myself. Its that nice of a coin and if for any reason at all you don't like it, feel free to return it. I will even cover the postage."
Any opinions as to whether he actually mailed this coin to me or not? >>
That's over the line. Quit while you're behind, or take it to pm as Ben suggested.
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
Let's say I have bought and shipped 2,000 items over the past several years. Maybe 1500 were under $100. Insurance would have cost me over $2,000 for those items.
On the two occasions a customer told me an item did not arrive, I refunded their money including shipping. On the two occasions items I paid for did not arrive, well, it's the cost of doing business.
I think of it as "self-insured".
Items I ship over $100 are insured and over $500 are insured and registered. Although I would perhaps rather not insure under $200, this is not good for customer relations as insurance is customary and expected.
Disclaimer - I live in a small Vermont town and know each of the postal workers and try to make their life a little easier. I think I receive really good service in return. Rob
What worries me is the rare occasion when I have to ship valuable Ikes in trade or for study: errors, varieties, Peg Legs and the like whose true value can not be substantiated. Rob
Questions about Ikes? Go to The IKE GROUP WEB SITE
For all I know he mailed something to someone WITHOUT an address.
Still wondering if I will get anything back from paypal. I feel that I deserve some compensation, even if I decided against purchasing insurance. I believe the seller has an obligation to the buyer to provide goods that were paid for.
You chose not to insure. The seller has a delivery confirmation number on a low dollar item, still "in the mail" somewhere. It will probably appear in 1 week, month or year. You made the mistake of not insuring. The seller sent the item per your instructions. You are now unhappy because you lost the gamble you took. You deserve no compensation whatsoever. You want someone else to pay for your mistake. If I were the seller, I'd be upset. I always pay for insurance in case the USPS loses an item, then both the buyer and seller can leave whole. I suggest next time buying the insurance.
Will’sProoflikes
but theres more proof Ben shipped it then did not. I'm willing to bet my left nut he shipped your coin. I have done a lot of business with him and have never had any problems. He is very talented, and very trustworthy. If he really wanted to start screwing people, Im sure he would wait until a more expensive oppertunity came along anyway. Chalk it up to a learning experience...we've all had them. Opt for insurance from now on.
">"http://www.cashcrate.com/5663377"