Guess The Grade: Bust Half Dime - Grade Revealed

Cladiator · September 14, 2006 1:18PM

The pics are big but they are worth it so give it some time. What do you think she grades? Any other comments on the coin and it's condition are welcome of course. MrHalfDime, Barndog and JrGman2004 have all seen this coin I believe so they probably shouldn't put in a grade guess but are more than welcome to see if they can attribute it.

AU58

Barndog · September 14, 2006 1:23PM

quick guess is 1833 LM-3.3 -- clash marks through date, back to the sick baby now!

Leiana · September 14, 2006 1:26PM

AU 58, I think. I see some wear in the high points of the obverse (Liberty's cap and curls) and also (although to a lesser degree) on the tops of the eagle's wings on the reverse.

I like the colours. And the clash is very nice.

-Amanda

JRocco · September 14, 2006 1:32PM

Nice coin clad

This is a WAG without being able to spin her for luster, but I will throw a 53 at her (could go 55 with more luster than I think I am seeing)
Nice coin

SamByrd · September 14, 2006 1:42PM

grade dosent matter with that coin, nice crusty old lady au58 but pq+++++++

LincolnCentMan · September 14, 2006 1:43PM

I guess I'll be the only one that will go XF45... but I'm gonna stick by it.

David

CoinAddict · September 14, 2006 1:44PM

Very nice, Rich.

stman · September 14, 2006 1:44PM

Hey, I can appreciate this one.

NumisOxide · September 14, 2006 2:11PM

AU53. Nice crust.

MikeInFL · September 14, 2006 2:30PM

AU 55 is my grade, although it wouldn't suprirse me if it slipped into 58 or even MS plastic.

rec78 · September 14, 2006 2:36PM

Au50

mercurydimeguy · September 14, 2006 3:01PM

AU58

ms70 · September 14, 2006 3:03PM

53

mikemars · September 14, 2006 3:09PM

I like it alot.

53 is my WAG.

fullerfun4 · September 14, 2006 3:29PM

AU55

RickMilauskas · September 14, 2006 4:16PM

AU 55 for me.

mozin · September 14, 2006 4:19PM

AU58

The toning streak on the reverse bothers me a little. Otherwise, a very pretty coin.

AmericanCopper · September 14, 2006 4:20PM

I grade this drop-dead gorgeous. I want to have her babies.

AmericanCopper · September 14, 2006 4:45PM

Had to come back and look again.

Yep...no doubt... I REALLY want to have her babies.

dorkkarl · September 14, 2006 9:04PM

xf, but i'd boost it to xf-45

K S

Cladiator · September 15, 2006 12:08AM

Wow, the guesses have really run the gambit. Lets let the dayshift guys give it a shot.

Longacre · September 15, 2006 12:10AM

55

jayboxx · September 15, 2006 12:11AM

AU55

HighRelief · September 15, 2006 12:37AM

I like the originality look of this bust half dime, nice pick Cladiator. I would put the grade around AU50.

Cladiator · September 15, 2006 2:10AM

Thanks for playin' everyone

Barndog nailed the attribution as the LM3.3. I was (and still am) a bit confused at the large range of grades given. I'd like to say that anyone who graded this coin in XF, please sell me as many XF half dimes that you can find

This is one instance where I believe the grade on the PCGS label on a Bust half dime is actually accurate. My personal grade and the PCGS grade of this coin is AU58.

Barndog · September 15, 2006 2:11AM

Thanks for the CBHD post, they are always welcome!

JrGMan2004 · September 15, 2006 2:12AM

<< Thanks for playin' everyone

Barndog nailed the attribution as the LM3.3. I was (and still am) a bit confused at the large range of grades given. I'd like to say that anyone who graded this coin in XF, please sell me as many XF half dimes that you can find

This is one instance where I believe the grade on the PCGS label on a Bust half dime is actually accurate. My personal grade and the PCGS grade of this coin is AU58. >>

I don't specifically remember having viewed this coin in hand, but I probally did... my initial thought from the pics had been AU55, but I can see 58

Cladiator · September 15, 2006 2:20AM

ps. I must give credit where it's due. Photos are courtesy of Phil and the PCGS TruView service. Nice pics Phil

Barndog · September 15, 2006 2:21AM

<< ps. I must give credit where it's due. Photos are courtesy of Phil and the PCGS TruView service. Nice pics Phil >>

What is this PCGS you speak of?

dorkkarl · September 15, 2006 2:54AM

au58??? you got ripped

K S

Cladiator · September 15, 2006 2:55AM

<< au58??? you got ripped

K S >>

ledzep87 · September 15, 2006 2:56AM

58!?!

You were ripped off.

I like it. I would have guessed 55.

Regardless of the grade, it is cool!

Barndog · September 15, 2006 2:57AM

anyone familiar with the price difference for a 55 vs. a 58?

ledzep87 · September 15, 2006 2:59AM

<< anyone familiar with the price difference for a 55 vs. a 58? >>

No, but what is the price difference.

Barndog · September 15, 2006 3:01AM

<< No, but what is the proce difference. >>

What's a proce?

ledzep87 · September 15, 2006 3:02AM

<< << No, but what is the proce difference. >>

What's a proce? >>

Sorry, what is the price difference?

dorkkarl · September 15, 2006 3:06AM

<< anyone familiar with the price difference for a 55 vs. a 58? >>

i think you better look at the price difference between xf-45 & au-58! based on THAT digi-pic, that coin is nowhere even remotely close to unc, which is what "58" means

K S

Cladiator · September 15, 2006 3:07AM

dorkkarl,

Like I said before please sell me all of your XF Bust half dimes

dorkkarl · September 15, 2006 3:12AM

if i had some to sell, i wouldn't mind. but you'd be paying me based on my COST, not based on a "grade"

K S

Cladiator · September 15, 2006 3:14AM

<< if i had some to sell, i wouldn't mind. but you'd be paying me based on my COST, not based on a "grade"

K S >>

Oh, bummer. I thought for sure you'd have several Bust half dimes.

Barndog · September 15, 2006 3:16AM

A bust half dime is about the size of a man's thumbnail. Unless I am mistaken, we don't assign grades to a coin based upon viewing a coin under 16x magnification, I thought it was more like 4x-5x. Cladiator's coin is a lock 55 every day of the week, and in my opinion, it would grade 58 three out of four times it was submitted. I've seen his coin and it is very attractive. If his coin were an XF, you would not see the shaft on the arrowheads on the reverse, you would not see the beautiful and generally unmarred wing feathers, talons, and crest of the eagle's head, you would not see a very strong/pronounced drapery line along the bust, you would not see so many high hair details, and you would not see such nice stars on the obverse. 55 all day every day, 58 3/4 of the time in front of a professional grader.

As for price difference, there is virtually none for a 55 vs. a 58 capped bust half dime. I'd expect a common die marriage in a PCGS holder with no notable toning would be a $275-$350 coin in AU-58. Take $10-$25 off that price for a 55. These price levels assume rational sellers and buyers.

JMO

dorkkarl · September 15, 2006 3:20AM

<< Oh, bummer. I thought for sure you'd have several Bust half dimes >>

i have alot more then "several"!!!

of course, the bottom line as always is that if you like it, you really really like it, then the price does not matter

K S

Cladiator · September 15, 2006 3:22AM

<< 

<< Oh, bummer. I thought for sure you'd have several Bust half dimes >>

i have alot more then "several"!!!

of course, the bottom line as always is that if you like it, you really really like it, then the price does not matter

K S >>

Can we see photos of some of yours that you grade XF?

dorkkarl · September 15, 2006 3:22AM

ps: in grades above xf, these coins should be graded based on remaining luster. is it possible your digi-pic does a crappy job of displaying luster? if so, that may be misleading. i'm only seeing less then maybe 10% of remaining luster, which in no way grades au.

K S

seatedcollector · September 15, 2006 3:34AM

i cant find the revealed grade but it has to be higher than an XF looks damn near unc to me. how could anyone think a high grade bust coin could have any "brilliant" luster ?? its not gonna shine like an MS 1921 morgan dollar the luster is there, its just under 150 years of natural tarnish, a beautiful coin no matter what the grade

Cladiator · September 15, 2006 3:38AM

<< i cant find the revealed grade >>

It's AU58.

<< the luster is there, its just under 150 years of natural tarnish >>

Bingo!

AU58WALKERS · September 15, 2006 3:40AM

DAMN...I was just getting ready to say AU58.

Honest I was.

Barndog · September 15, 2006 3:40AM

seatedcollector,

JrGMan2004 · September 15, 2006 5:22AM

<< i cant find the revealed grade but it has to be higher than an XF looks damn near unc to me. how could anyone think a high grade bust coin could have any "brilliant" luster ?? its not gonna shine like an MS 1921 morgan dollar the luster is there, its just under 150 years of natural tarnish, a beautiful coin no matter what the grade >>

Cladiator · September 16, 2006 2:47AM

For the record here are side by side comparison pics. One of the coins is the AU58 from this thread and the other coin is my XF 1832 LM11.2. In my opinion these two photos clearly show what an XF should look like and what an AU should look like.

Guess The Grade: Bust Half Dime - Grade Revealed

Comments

Leave a Comment