Options
Feelings on ICG
Hi all,
I have a question on the quality and experience any of you have had with ICG. I am putting collections in both NCG and PCGS. However, I am seeing some great deals on ICG coins. Anyone feel they are solid in their slabbed coins? Also, what experience do you have at crossing them over to PCGS or NGC?
Thanks!
Oh I am a newbie to these boards but I have noticed certain patterns in all my lurking. So for the Russ guy...Go Gold Buffalo!
I have a question on the quality and experience any of you have had with ICG. I am putting collections in both NCG and PCGS. However, I am seeing some great deals on ICG coins. Anyone feel they are solid in their slabbed coins? Also, what experience do you have at crossing them over to PCGS or NGC?
Thanks!
Oh I am a newbie to these boards but I have noticed certain patterns in all my lurking. So for the Russ guy...Go Gold Buffalo!
0
Comments
96eagle
<< <i>However, I am seeing some great deals on ICG coins. >>
There's a reason they sell cheap.
Russ, NCNE
-Amanda
I'm a YN working on a type set!
My Buffalo Nickel Website Home of the Quirky Buffaloes Collection!
Proud member of the CUFYNA
Some of my best buys are circulated classics in ICG plastic. They are often bought at a significant discount they don't deserve.
No scrathes, dings, pings, finger prints, or bag marks, nothing but a pretty ICG MS70 coin.
96eagle
96eagle
<< <i>No scrathes, dings, pings, finger prints, or bag marks, nothing but a pretty ICG MS70 coin. >>
Nice coin, but 99.9% of those are nice.
Russ, NCNE
96eagle
Nice coin to be sure, but MS70? ICG coins in MS70 seem to be the equivalent of NGC or PCGS in MS69. They also price that way.
By the way, ICG MS70 coins are the secret sauce in the blue moon coins $100k retail mystery lots. You get $100,000 of PCGS price guide coins for as little as $2,500, all by a major grading company like PCGS, NGC, and ICG! Guess how many ICG MS70's are mixed in to drive that retail up?
The consumers have voted on ICG MS70 coins, and they simply don't hold value to PCGS, or even NGC. At least one point down, maybe two for PCGS.
But, solid for the most part in lower grades I think.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
They are most accurate on 18th and early 19th century circulated type... they are also the only game in town for ancients... as for moderns, they trade for a deep discount to NGC and PCGS for good reasons
42/92
96eagle
Well, yes!! HSN swears by them!!
But according to HSN, it's "First Day of Issue". There's a difference you know...and I'm sure someone at ICG can explain it...or not....
Chicolini: Mint? No, no, I no like a mint. Uh - what other flavor you got?
I have an MS64 Wide AM or type 2 reverse 2000 Lincoln cent by PCGS up on ebay right now. I saw another MS67 Wide AM 2000 in an ICG holder.
I think ICG has a foothold in the market, just as ANACS
It is difficult to say anything bad against them as I do not use them, but by comparing pictures, I'd say they may not be applying the same standard as NGC or PCGS, for that matter. That brings me to STANDARD
Grading is SUBJECTIVE
oh, sorry.......those were just my feelings. Not necessarily on ICG
Diplomacy is what it takes to get out of what tact would have kept you out of.
Not by me.
<< <i>"They are considered to be an upper level grading service."
Not by me. >>
Nor to many people who largely collect moderns...nor should they be.
But I stand by my earlier statement: For most circulated classics they're as good as anyone.
Whether ICG is a "top tier" TPG or not depends on what you collect. For most of what I collect, they are just fine.
<< <i>... However, I am seeing some great deals on ICG coins... >>
Keep that in mind when (if ever) it gets time to sell... the same (listed) ICG grade will probably bring less than a PCGS/NGC grade... paid less to get it, get paid less when you sell it...
I personally don't have any problems with ICG, one of our members (Cammie) even works there as a grader.
Grading is subjective...
I'd give you the world, just because...
Speak to me of loved ones, favorite places and things, loves lost and gained, tears shed for joy and sorrow, of when I see the sparkle in your eye ...
and the blackness when the dream dies, of lovers, fools, adventurers and kings while I sip my wine and contemplate the Chi.
<< <i>I personally don't have any problems with ICG, one of our members (Cammie) even works there as a grader. >>
Neither do I. But I buy mostly circulated classics, not MS-69 moderns. Those who tend toward buying the latter have a good reason to only consider ICG coins at a substantial discount.
<< <i>Some people here have stated that ICG is far better than even PCGS! >>
midwestcoin13
<< <i>When it comes to the classics, they are superb. >>
Just watch out for the suspicious looking seated dollars in high grade slabs I saw at a known coin doctor's table at a Seattle show.....
<< <i>
<< <i>When it comes to the classics, they are superb. >>
Just watch out for the suspicious looking seated dollars in high grade slabs I saw at a known coin doctor's table at a Seattle show..... >>
...and crap can be found in ALL slabs...even fake stuff. Since this is a PCGS board I'm willing to bet there will be easily more bad ICG coins revealed here than PCGS.
Consistently, you'll find ICG graded classics, on the bourse floor, priced as strongly or nearly as strong as PCGS/NGC slabs. Granted there is a stigma attached, but mainly for their modern grading practices.
[Now, I'm just waiting for Russ to chime in with his proverbial wit about how much he can get for a piece of PCGS plastic and how ICG plastic is worthless.]
<< <i>Consistently, you'll find ICG graded classics, on the bourse floor, priced as strongly or nearly as strong as PCGS/NGC slabs. >>
You think what dealers ask for them actually means something?
Try selling ICG graded coins if you really want to know what they're worth. Those same dealers will either a) Say they're not interested, or b) Offer pennies on the dollar compared to PCGS and NGC.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>Consistently, you'll find ICG graded classics, on the bourse floor, priced as strongly or nearly as strong as PCGS/NGC slabs. >>
You think what dealers ask for them actually means something?
Try selling ICG graded coins if you really want to know what they're worth. Those same dealers will either a) Say they're not interested, or b) Offer pennies on the dollar compared to PCGS and NGC.
Russ, NCNE >>
Russ, I HAVE sold quite a few ICG coins.
This is my experience...On net-graded coins - If it has been net graded more than 2 grade points (such as VF30 to VF20) due to cleaning, those coins are a tougher sell. But, PCGS/NGC will typically bodybag those so there's no real price comparison. I had one case where a coin was severely net graded from a VF/XF to F15 because the coin had evidence of a light cleaning. I sold that coin for VF money to a wholesaler who would probably be able to sell it at full Choice VF+ money.
On other coins, I'm able to receive comparable value to those in other holders.
<< <i>For 1950 to 1970 era proof coins, they overgrade and are far too easy in passing out the cameo and deep cameo designations. Many of their DCAM graded coins from that era wouldn't even grade cameo at PCGS or NGC. >>
I'll add my single data point. I crossed a 1961 ICG 69 dcam quarter to PCGS - it came back 67 cameo. Russ is right - there is a reason why ICG coins are cheaper.
On the positive side, I have one or two of their sample slabs.
“In matters of style, swim with the current; in matters of principle, stand like a rock." - Thomas Jefferson
My digital cameo album 1950-64 Cameos - take a look!
Better still, ignore everyone here and try this.....Take your ICG coins to the next regional or national show and walk the floor offering to sell your ICG slabs. This 1-2 hour exercise will make you a better buyer and collector of coins. I guarantee it!
I have had a couple of sweet crosses and been most happy so if you know what to look for and how to grade there are ICG opportunites out there. Buy yhe coin and not the slab. Caveat emptor.
Website-Americana Rare Coin Inc
<< <i>This is my experience...On net-graded coins - If it has been net graded more than 2 grade points (such as VF30 to VF20) due to cleaning, those coins are a tougher sell. But, PCGS/NGC will typically bodybag those so there's no real price comparison. I had one case where a coin was severely net graded from a VF/XF to F15 because the coin had evidence of a light cleaning. I sold that coin for VF money to a wholesaler who would probably be able to sell it at full Choice VF+ money. >>
I never realized that ICG net-graded coins. Can you show us a pic?
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>
<< <i>This is my experience...On net-graded coins - If it has been net graded more than 2 grade points (such as VF30 to VF20) due to cleaning, those coins are a tougher sell. But, PCGS/NGC will typically bodybag those so there's no real price comparison. I had one case where a coin was severely net graded from a VF/XF to F15 because the coin had evidence of a light cleaning. I sold that coin for VF money to a wholesaler who would probably be able to sell it at full Choice VF+ money. >>
I never realized that ICG net-graded coins. Can you show us a pic? >>
When I say net-graded, it's the same thing PCGS/NGC do. If there's some minor cleaning and they don't have to lower the grade more than one point, they'll put it in a lower point holder. They don't have net graded holders as in the old ANACS days. Below is an example that they graded F15 (before it went into the holder). As you can tell with this 1922 No-D Strong Reverse, the coin has to be graded by the reverse (there's light cleaning evident vertically down the center of Lincoln):
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
ugly slabs.............
.excuse me ----- i just had to puke my guts out ..........
i.c.g. = arghaaahuggggggggggggggg....hheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaagggghoooooooooooo
.....awwwwwwwwwwwwwwaaaaaaaaaahggggggggggggggggghhh
Successful BST transactions with: SilverEagles92; Ahrensdad; Smitty; GregHansen; Lablade; Mercury10c; copperflopper; whatsup; KISHU1; scrapman1077, crispy, canadanz, smallchange, robkool, Mission16, ranshdow, ibzman350, Fallguy, Collectorcoins, SurfinxHI, jwitten, Walkerguy21D, dsessom.
Positive BST as a seller: Namvet69, Lordmarcovan, Bigjpst, Soldi, mustanggt, CoinHoader, moursund, SufinxHi, al410, JWP
p.s. The old adage "buy the coin, not the holder" applies well here. If you don't have an eye experienced enough to tell you if the coin is fairly priced, get help from someone who does, pass on the coin, or be prepared for a rude awakening when you try and sell it.
<< <i>ICG is a relatively respected grading service who are pretty good at grading coins. They are considered to be an upper level grading service. >>
Statistically, CDN ranks them pretty high compared to other services.
I give away money. I collect money.
I don’t love money . I do love the Lord God.