Options
What's Everyone's Thoughts On The 3 Minute Extension Of The End Of DLRC Auctions? Cool? Stressful?
RBinTex
Posts: 4,328 ✭
For those that don't know. If a bid is placed within the last 3 minutes (as defined by the original ending time) the ending time gets extended to 3 minutes from that bid.
e.g. if it ended at 9:30 & someone placed a bid at 9:29, it gets extended to 9:32. I don't know what happens if a bid is then placed at 9:31. Are unlimited extensions possible?
Anyway, I think it's sorta cool on one hand ' cause it give you another chance to up your bid but a little stressful on the other if you already have the high bid.
Any thoughts?
e.g. if it ended at 9:30 & someone placed a bid at 9:29, it gets extended to 9:32. I don't know what happens if a bid is then placed at 9:31. Are unlimited extensions possible?
Anyway, I think it's sorta cool on one hand ' cause it give you another chance to up your bid but a little stressful on the other if you already have the high bid.
Any thoughts?
0
Comments
Of course, you could also argue that if you want the coin badly enough, you could just enter a nuclear snipe.
David
bid is recognized. Real auctions don't stop by a clock, but rather when the bidding stops. Of course,
bidders who are overbid are not happy. I suppose they think they always lose to a shill or an illegal alien
<< <i>That's how the bid board works at my local shop. I don't have a problem with it and actually think it's a good idea. I hate the sniping thing. >>
The bid board at the shop I went to as a child (and eventually managed for ten years -- Causey's in Fort Worth, TX) had
a strict cutoff of 3 pm Saturday. Often several people writing their bids on the card at the same time just as the bell
sounded. A couple of good fistfights over the years. Once a sniper got shoved into a jewelry display tower. Another
got spit on, and another hit with a Coke bottle. An ambulance called once, the police a few times. Gee I miss all that!
<< <i>I wouldn't bid - imagine going to a live auction and, after the hammer falls, they reopen bidding to a late comer with remorse. Bad idea. >>
Actually, with the bid extention they are closer to your live auction example where the hammer does not fall at a particular point in time but when there are no more bidders.
Didn't wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
--"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
Actually this happens all the time. The craziest was Heritage going back 10+ lots and taking a new bid which of course won. The bid was not paying attention when the lot crossed. There have been lots reopened because people had taken pee breaks, got confused, etc. Sometimes they won sometimes they did not. But it does happen with frequency. Good for the house and seller.
For those who think that "nuclear snipe bids" are cool, just think of what might happen to you if another person had the same idea. Once when I was bidding at the last moment on a Lincoln presidential campaign medalet during the closing seconds, I messed up when I was typing and entered $2,600
<< <i>
<< <i>That's how the bid board works at my local shop. I don't have a problem with it and actually think it's a good idea. I hate the sniping thing. >>
The bid board at the shop I went to as a child (and eventually managed for ten years -- Causey's in Fort Worth, TX) had
a strict cutoff of 3 pm Saturday. Often several people writing their bids on the card at the same time just as the bell
sounded. A couple of good fistfights over the years. Once a sniper got shoved into a jewelry display tower. Another
got spit on, and another hit with a Coke bottle. An ambulance called once, the police a few times. Gee I miss all that! >>
Frank,I used to go to Causeys all the time when i lived in Bedford.Isnt it on the way to FT.Worth though?
<< <i>I've seen competing nuclear snipes...not a pretty sight! >>
It is for the seller.
1964 PCGS PR69DCAM Kennedy - $1840
Last Heritage sale - $3623
On eBay, they bring $2500 and up.
1967 PCGS MS67DCAM Kennedy - didn't make reserve of $500.
Last eBay sale - $800.
1964 PCGS PR68CAM Accented Hair - didn't make reserve of $550.
Last Heritage sale - $1840.
Averages about $1200 on eBay.
1953 PCGS MS66 Lincoln - $207.
I just sold one on eBay for $355.
Edit: The Lincoln was a 1953.
Russ, NCNE
ALL Past Heritage Sales Below:
Lot 1910 1946 50C Doubled Die MS63 PCGS Signature June 3, 2006 $920.00
Lot 23205 1946 50C Doubled Die MS63 PCGS Signature January 29, 2005 $853.30
Lot 13389 1946 50C Doubled Die MS63 PCGS Internet Only May 4, 2004 $681.95
Lot 1883 1946 50C Doubled Die MS63 PCGS Online Session August 6, 2003 $529.00
Looks like a few rips last night.
Edited to add:
<< <i>If their goal is to increase realized prices, they are failing - miserably. Examples from last night's auction:
1964 PCGS PR69DCAM Kennedy - $1840
Last Heritage sale - $3623
On eBay, they bring $2500 and up.
1967 PCGS MS67DCAM Kennedy - didn't make reserve of $500.
Last eBay sale - $800.
1964 PCGS PR68CAM Accented Hair - didn't make reserve of $550.
Last Heritage sale - $1840.
Averages about $1200 on eBay.
1955 PCGS MS66 Lincoln - $207.
I just sold one on eBay for $355.
Russ, NCNE >>
Russ--- wouldn't these be buying opportunities? Should I start checking out the DLRC auctions more closely? It seems that items could be bought for a song on DLRC and then flipped for an Obscene Profit™ on Ebay.
Didn't wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
--"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
maybe prices are returning to decent levels....still not there yet, but at least going that way.
At least for moderns
<< <i>Russ--- wouldn't these be buying opportunities? >>
Yes, they would. In this case, though, I didn't get real aggressive. I put in a bid on the Lincoln, but lowballed it because I'm greedy.
Russ, NCNE
I am 100% in favor of the new DLRC auction policy. I commend them for making the change.
I would be equally happy to see ebay start doing three minute extensions. On ebay, prices realized for lots of items would be significantly higher. Auction fever would cause many of us to challenge snipers. Power snipers would have to think twice before releasing super sky high bids. The competition would be much more interesting.
KJ
<< <i>On ebay, prices realized for lots of items would be significantly higher. >>
They aren't on DLRC. Why would eBay be any different?
Russ, NCNE
> Why would eBay be any different?
Your argument re DLRC has more to do with DLRC auctions being followed by a relatively minor number of buyers. Many of those DLRC auctions have little action to begin with.
Many of the ebay items I bid on would definitely go higher if ebay implemented a three minute bid extension. I have no doubt about this.
KJ
Say the owner is watching and sees a "snipe" bid go at the end if his auction, he then shill bids to get that farther up, then another comes in, then another. Too much room for shananigans. I'd never participate in an auction that I couldn't snipe.
<< <i>On a live auction that is one thing to extend until all bidders are done hacking it out. But on a virtual auction that is something else. It opens the door for crooked auctions.
Say the owner is watching and sees a "snipe" bid go at the end if his auction, he then shill bids to get that farther up, then another comes in, then another. Too much room for shananigans. I'd never participate in an auction that I couldn't snipe. >>
Nothing other than the ebay rules against shill bidding keep anyone from doing this now. All it takes is one shill bid with 20 seconds or so left to raise any normal snipes to their max...then a snipe by the shill with 1 or 2 seconds left to max out a nuclear snipe.