Is he serious????

Options
TripleCrown
TripleCrown Posts: 145
in Trading Cards & Memorabilia Forum
Doesn't this card have to at least have a "grade" to arrive at a value? (especially that one)

LINK

image

I didn't think "authentic" alone would draw the asking price??
image
For the love of the game
And the cards that go with it

Comments

  • phreakydancin
    phreakydancin Posts: 1,691 ✭✭
    Options
    Auction

    He's quoting the Beckett raw prices, which are probably meaningless for a card like this.

    Edited to add: PSA pop is 31 total, compared to 25 for the Wagner. This is a rare card in any condition.
  • fdnyladder7
    fdnyladder7 Posts: 293
    Options
    Seller is a creep... His scans are stolen from t206 museum;
    t206 museum online store
  • Brian48
    Brian48 Posts: 2,624 ✭✭✭
    Options
    Has anyone reported this guy yet?
  • grilloj39
    grilloj39 Posts: 370 ✭✭
    Options
    I look at value as what someone is willing to pay for it...not necessarily the grade. I have no problems with an "Authentic" grade. Even though the card is obviously trimmed, for other trimmed cards it is not as apparent. The "Authentic" grade furthers protects the buyer from unknowingly buying a trimmed card, and yet, still allowing cards to be encapsulated per the customers wishes.

    As to the buyer's reputation and whether or not he/she truly owns the item, that is another story.
    Gold Coins
    Silver Coins

    e-bay ID: grilloj39
    e-mail: grilloj39@gmail.com
  • mudflap02
    mudflap02 Posts: 2,060 ✭✭
    Options
    Has anyone considered the possibility that the seller is the T206 museum? The wording on the auction and the website are almost identical, and the feedback is respectable.
  • fdnyladder7
    fdnyladder7 Posts: 293
    Options
    I reported it in great and CLEAR detail to eBay last week. Two days ago I finally recieve this note from the EIA (eBay Intelijints Aginsee). I think they hear with an accent. I resubmitted a report typing wicked slow this time...

    I have reviewed the email you sent us, but have been unable to determine
    the problem you are trying to report.
    -
    Please reply to this email with the information below:

    1. User ID(s)

    2. Item/Auction number(s)

    3. The issue or Problem you are attempting to report

    4. Any other information you think might be important in our
    investigation.


    Regards,

    Kerrie
    Community Watch Team
    eBay Trust & Safety

    Editted to add pertinent data;

    *Mud; Nope, it's a scammer-T206 museum director fellow had reported the stolen scans as well. Check this;

    VBC forum
  • alinchitown
    alinchitown Posts: 75
    Options
    This guy is stealing scans and trying for a hit check this out he is selling an 1895 N300 Mayo's Cut Plug Arlie Latham

    Auction


    And it looks to me like he stole it from here

    martysportscards link


  • alinchitown
    alinchitown Posts: 75
    Options
    While we're at it look at this one 1909 T206 Ray Demmitt PSA 4



    Auction




    martyspsagradedcards page

    Unless this guy is Marty which I don't think he is
  • fdnyladder7
    fdnyladder7 Posts: 293
    Options
    Finally, a Yankee fan I'm glad to see! Good work as usual Al -reported... Still no reply from the EIA on this Pantyload seller and his stuff ends this AM.

    *In "justizzle3" 's defense, I'm sure the plastic wristband scans are his own.
  • alinchitown
    alinchitown Posts: 75
    Options
    I just sent Marty an email so we will see, we could be wrong on this one but, my gut tells me this is a scam.....

    I guess I should have looked at Marty's home page Marty is located in AZ and the izzle is in OH
  • alinchitown
    alinchitown Posts: 75
    Options
    The auctions were finally removed but the seller remains. You know eBay should have NARUed the jerk. If eBay wanted to send a message out to scammers, they would have NARUed this guy and sought prosecution thru the local authorites. The guy acted with intent to commit fraud and grand larcerny but all that eBay did was remove the auctions.

Categories