Options
Most over priced and fairly priced dealers?? TOPIC EXPANDED!!!
majorbigtime
Posts: 2,937 ✭
I could name a few (over priced) that are not on TV, at least one of which posts here (feeling paraniod?), but will leave the designations to all you good folks.
***********************************************************************************************************************
OK, to respond to all the flack in the initial 35 responses, I've expanded the topic to cover the good and the bad (see Russ for the rest of the classic Clint Eastwood spagetti western title).
I'd say JJ Teaparty is fairly priced. What say thee?
***********************************************************************************************************************
OK, to respond to all the flack in the initial 35 responses, I've expanded the topic to cover the good and the bad (see Russ for the rest of the classic Clint Eastwood spagetti western title).
I'd say JJ Teaparty is fairly priced. What say thee?
0
Comments
Personally, I think a thread on overpriced dealers is not in good taste. No one makes anyone pay. (But I differentiate between over priced and rip off the unknowing).
<< <i>How corny.... start a thread on over priced dealers, and then not post any yourself, leaving the dirty work for others.
Personally, I think a thread on overpriced dealers is not in good taste. No one makes anyone pay. (But I differentiate between over priced and rip off the unknowing). >>
I like that thinking... it is wise.... a nice way of saying "don't ask me to jump in the judge's chair
I just know it ain't me !.... I am a roofer who sells some nice coins for cheap.... ( a dealer's dealer, if you will
<< <i>I could name a few that are not on TV, at least one of which posts here (feeling paraniod?), but will leave the designations to all you good folks. >>
Is this dealer a legend in the coin biz?
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>
<< <i>I could name a few that are not on TV, at least one of which posts here (feeling paraniod?), but will leave the designations to all you good folks. >>
Is this dealer a legend in the coin biz?
Yes, an 'ol grump in Northern California.
<< <i>Personally, I think a thread on overpriced dealers is not in good taste. >>
Many threads here are not in the best taste--and they seem to have the most posts too!
These boards have been uninspiring lately. so let's sirr it up a bit!
Thats my take on it anyway
Coin Vault is over priced IMO!
<< <i>I could name a few that are not on TV >>
Isn't Coin Vault on TV? Frankly, I don't know, but if it is, you haven't done that, have you?
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
my vote is for anaconda. over priced so much it is funny to mere
mortals.
<< <i>I could name a few that are not on TV, at least one of which posts here (feeling paraniod?), but will leave the designations to all you good folks. >>
Sorry, Legend did not pay me for this plug - just my own observation.
Member ANA, SPMC, SCNA, FUN, CONECA
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
edited for spelling. Oops.
collections: Maryland related coins & exonumia, 7070 Type set, and Video Arcade Tokens.
The Low Budget Y2K Registry Set
you never know when they are gonna have a coin you want at any price.
if they know who you are its gonna be "Sorry we just sold that " !
<< <i>majorbigtime? As I see it, you're spineless. >>
He's also fat, which - in the absence of a spine - means he's just a big jelly blob.
Russ, NCNE
And just so I am not being hypocritical by doing the same...here is an example of the most over priced dealer I've seen in a while.
Edited to add: I appologize to coinblue1 and fc as they did answer the question.
that is just a silly comment and not even funny.
dealers sell coins in public, so they are fair game to any comments
or criticisms.
example:
just because a dealer like david lawrence sells a few nice coins,
does not mean i cannot say their auctions are a scam setup
to make you think you are really at an auction, but in reality it
is just retail.
am i fat now too?
edited to add: i have a lot of respect for you Russ. so please dont
take that as a personal attack. it just seems a bit out of character
and harsh.
<< <i>Why does everyone keep these rediculous threads on the first page by replying with the obvious jibberish. >>
I'm pretty sure that's spelled with a G.
FC,
You should get an historical clue before commenting.
Russ, NCNE
then bash the bad. Overpriced is a very subjective
term and does not take into account the types of coins
and the premiums the dealer may have to pay to obtain
those coins in those conditions.
Camelot
Find the ones that you "Think" don't read or post on the board and hang them. OK, go get them folks!! Heh
By the way, I very rarely sell what I buy. even if I overpay or get ripped off. I'm man enough to take my lumps along with the good.
paying collector
I think the most overpriced dealers are the ones who sell bargains. What, you say? The guys who sell BU Morgans for AU money and send out polished VF's are the worst over-priced dealers around.
As another out-of-the-blue example, say a dealer advertises a coin for $20,000 which recently sold in auction for $10,000. Is that overpriced? What if everyone was sleeping on that lot in the auction? It may even be underpriced at $20,000, since the buyer got it cheap. (maybe he had marked "go to $25,000" in his catalog).
LOL
that's all I'm gonna say... after that, we shared views... He gave me a piece of advice, he suggested we write Dr Phil and see how that works for us ( I made that part up)
Never take it personal unless you are cheating..........then BEWARE ! that's my take on these guys on the boards here....they only want to keep us safe from harm's way..... Can I get an AMEN ?
Also....... High Priced dealers are usually the most trusted and command a high price because of Reputable Dealings.......so point them out, I'll check out their inventory and end up with some awesome coins
Tbig
The court jester does not play, but gently pulls the strings…
then bash the bad. Overpriced is a very subjective
term and does not take into account the types of coins
and the premiums the dealer may have to pay to obtain
those coins in those conditions.
I agree completely with Bear. It is often better to compliment those that do a good job than to "bash the bad." By inference, you will know who to avoid. Certainly, crooks, frauds, and scamsters need to be exposed.
What is overpriced to you may be underpriced to me...and vice versa. "Overpriced" is subjective. Just because you pay 10% more than the dealer paid, this does not mean that you are not paying too much. Similarly, there are times you can pay a multiple what the dealer paid and still get a great deal. Over time, most dealers who consistently sell overpriced coins either go out of business or need to attract fresh meat (ie. Coin World regulars) to avoid going out of business.
Why he doesnt sell me his classic commems at a little bit over face value is beyond me!
"Senorita HepKitty"
"I want a real cool Kitty from Hepcat City, to stay in step with me" - Bill Carter
<< <i>I think the most overpriced dealers are the ones who sell bargains. What, you say? The guys who sell BU Morgans for AU money and send out polished VF's are the worst over-priced dealers around. >>
I agree. If a dealer chooses to move a MS63 at a higher price than his competitors, as long as he's not representing a 64, that's not unethical. But the ones that deal misrepresented cr@ p are the ones that give everyone a black eye.
If the recurring price for a non toned reasonably white and well struck PCGS certified CC Morgan of those years is say $350 and somebody asks and gets $700 for the same then some questions about that dealer's pricing are justified.
Somebody said that there are dealers that specialize in rarities and others that specialize in relatively common coins. The owner of an MS63 1893-S Morgan dollar does not have that manypeople to go to if he/she wants to get a good price for a true raritiy. The kind of customers that a dealer caters for is very much a determining factor.
While I will respect a dealer that sells medium to low priced coins, I normally would not entrust such dealers with a true rarity. If my goal to to make as much as I can selling my wonder pieces it will be ANR, Superior, L & I Goldberg, Legend, etc. The dealers for such coins are in the same league.
I recall a gentleman named Jay Parrino who bought (and probably still does) all kinds of rarities at very high prices. Since he was cited in the 1933 St Gaudens Gold piece "affaire" along eith Stephen Fenton, you don't hear his named mentioned as much any more. But if his customers buy rarities from him "at any price" who is to say that he overprices? He renders a service and gets paid for that service.
The final question is linked to relativity. What is overpriced for some is a fair and acceptable price for somebody else.
Collecting since the 1980's
Morgan Dollars Circ. Strikes
- Basic Set - Varieties - Prooflike Basic Set - Date Set
- Carson City - Early S Mint Short Set - Mintmark Type Set
Morgan Dollars Proof
- Basic Set - Varieties
Peace Circ.