Options
How optomistic am I here with the value of this collection?
DNADave
Posts: 7,350 ✭✭✭✭✭
I don't think for a second I could sell it for the "coin prices" value, but how much above what I paid do you think it may go? if anything?
Certified Coins........................................................................$14,434.00.......$21,449.50
My Number...Date....Issue....... .............3rd Party.... Grade...... Price Paid......Current Value
S1............1893-S.....Morgan Dollar.....ANACS..........VG10........$1,400.00.......$3,600.00
S2............1894........Morgan Dollar.....ANACS...........F12...........$600.00.........$1,360.00
S3............1879-S.....Morgan Dollar.....ANACS...........MS63........$45.00...........$65.00
S4............1880-S.....Morgan Dollar.....ANACS...........MS63........$25.00...........$46.00
S5............1882-CC...Morgan Dollar.....ANACS..........MS62.........$95.00...........$235.00
S6............1903-O.... Morgan Dollar......ANACS..........MS63........$420.00..........$475.00
S8............1922........Peace Dollar........ANACS..........MS63.........$38.00...........$50.00
S9............1922........Peace Dollar........ANACS..........MS62.........$300.00.........$450.00 90 degree rotated dies
S10..........1884-CC...Morgan Dollar......PCGS...........MS63.........$140.00.........$225.00
S11..........1884-O.... Morgan Dollar.......PCGS...........MS65.........$75.00...........$170.00
S12..........1926-S.....Peace Dollar.........PCGS...........MS63.........$60.00...........$85.00
S13..........1935........Peace Dollar.........PCGS...........MS64.........$140.00.........$180.00
S14..........1928-S.....Peace Dollar.........PCGS...........MS63.........$280.00.........$580.00
S15..........1921........Peace Dollar.........PCGS...........MS63.........$315.00.........$415.00
S16..........1922-S.....Peace Dollar.........PCGS...........MS64.........$170.00.........$230.00
S17..........1925........Peace Dollar..........NGC............MS65.........$75.00...........$160.00
S18..........1924........Peace Dollar.........NGC.............MS64.........$35.00...........$52.50
S19..........1923........Peace Dollar.........NGC.............MS66.........$420.00.........$550.00
S20..........1926-D.....Peace Dollar.........NGC.............MS64........$200.00..........$285.00
S21..........1923........Peace Dollar..........NGC............MS65.........$140.00.........$160.00
S23..........1922........Peace Dollar..........NGC............MS66.........$420.00.........$550.00
S24..........1922........Peace Dollar..........NCS............NA.............$35.00............$20.00
S25..........1938-D.....Buffalo Nickel........ANACS........MS64..........$25.00...........$30.00
S27..........1806........Draped Bust Half....ANACS.......VG10..........$155.00.........$175.00
S28..........1806/5.....Draped Bust Half....ANACS.......VG8............$155.00.........$160.00
S29..........1916-D.....Mercury Dime.........PCI............G6..............$700.00.........$900.00
S30..........1943-D.....Mercury Dime........PCGS..........MS66..........$60.00...........$45.00
S31..........1998-S.....Kennedy Half.........PCGS..........MS69..........$430.00.........$400.00
S32..........1974-S.....Kennedy Half.........PCGS..........PR69..........$30.00............$60.00
S33..........1978-S.....Kennedy Half........PCGS...........PR68..........$20.00...........$25.00
S34..........2000-S.....Kennedy Half.........PCGS..........PR69..........$30.00...........$60.00
S35..........2000-S.....Roosevelt Diime.....PCGS..........PR69..........$18.00...........$23.00
S36..........1996-S.....Roosevelt Diime.....ICG............PR70...........$60.00...........$20.00
S37..........1854-O....Seated Liberty Half...ANACS.....AU50..........$125.00.........$270.00
S38..........2001........Silver Eagle.............PCGS.........Unc............$50.00...........$80.00
S41..........2001........Silver Eagle.............PCGS.........Unc............$50.00...........$80.00
S42..........1805........Draped Bust Quarter..ANACS...AG3............$90.00............$120.00
S43..........1833........Capped Bust Half Dime..ANACSVF35..........$40.00............$100.00
S44..........1981-S.....SBA Dollar...............ANACS.......PF67HC......$175.00.........$230.00
S46..........2000-P.....Mass Quarter..........ANACS......MS65..........$10.00...........$35.00 partial collar
S47..........1984-P.....Washington Quarter....ANACS.MS63..........$45.00...........$20.00 off center
S49..........1880-S.....Morgan Dollar............ANACS....MS65.........$110.00..........$165.00
S51..........1921........Morgan Dollar............PCGS......Circ............$26.00............$45.00 sample slab
S52..........1964........Kennedy Half Dollar...PCGS......MS.............$20.00............$20.00 sample slab
S53..........1964-D.....Roosevelt Dime.........PCGS......MS64..........$8.00.............$6.00 sample slab
S54..........1960........Roosevelt Dime..........PCGS......MS64.........$2.00..............$6.00 sample slab
S55..........1889 S.....Morgan Dollar............ANACS ...AU58..........$120.00.........$200.00
S56..........1881-CC...Morgan Dollar...........ANACS ...F12.............$300.00.........$350.00
S57..........1968........Ireland Penny............ICG........BU...............Free...............$0.00 sample slab
S58..........2001........New York Quarter.....PCGS.......BU..............$6.00.............$6.00 sample slab
S60..........1807........Draped bust half.......ANACS.... AG3.............$175.00.........$100.00
S61..........1889-CC..Morgan Dollar............ANACS....F12.............$900.00.........$900.00
S62..........1921........Peace Dollar..............ANACS....MS64...........$73.00...........$850.00
S63..........1922........Peace Dollar..............ANACS....AU55..........$9.00..............$25.00 cracked planchet
S64..........1923........Peace Dollar..............ANACS....MS62..........$9.00..............$30.00 top 50 vam
S65..........1880-CC...Morgan Dollar...........NGC........MS63..........$400.00..........$550.00
S66..........1885-CC...Morgan Dollar...........NGC........MS63..........$520.00..........$700.00
S67..........1886........Morgan Dollar...........ANACS.....MS65..........$150.00..........$165.00
S71..........1943........Walking Liberty Half..NGC........MS65..........$110.00..........$150.00
S72..........1927........Peace Dollar...............NGC.......MS63..........$115.00..........$140.00
S74..........1872........Seated Liberty Dollar..ANACS...VF35...........$350.00..........$350.00
S75..........1909-S.vdbLincoln Cent...............ANACS...F15.............$800.00..........$800.00
S77..........1875-S ....Twenty-cent piece.....ANACS....AU55............$275.00.........$350.00
S78..........1938........Walking Liberty Half...ANACS....MS64...........$30.00............$120.00
S79..........1895-O.....Morgan Dollar............ANACS....F15..............$395.00..........$395.00
S80..........1928........Peace Dollar..............ANACS....MS63............$600.00..........$650.00
S81..........1899........Morgan Dollar............ANACS....AU55............$170.00..........$200.00
S82..........1879-CC...Morgan Dollar...........ANACS.....VF20............$80.00............$100.00
S83..........1883-CC...Morgan Dollar...........ANACS.....EF45............$95.00............$115.00
S84..........1886-S.....Morgan Dollar...........ANACS.....AU53............$135.00..........$200.00
S85..........1888-S.....Morgan Dollar............ANACS....AU55............$180.00..........$250.00
S86..........1921........Peace Dollar..............ANACS....VF35.............$75.00............$120.00
S87..........1921........Peace Dollar...............ANACS...EF45.............$80.00............$140.00
S88..........1921........Peace Dollar..............ANACS....AU53.............$115.00..........$180.00
S89..........1882-CC...Morgan Dollar...........PCGS......MS64PL.........$295.00..........$295.00
Certified Coins........................................................................$14,434.00.......$21,449.50
My Number...Date....Issue....... .............3rd Party.... Grade...... Price Paid......Current Value
S1............1893-S.....Morgan Dollar.....ANACS..........VG10........$1,400.00.......$3,600.00
S2............1894........Morgan Dollar.....ANACS...........F12...........$600.00.........$1,360.00
S3............1879-S.....Morgan Dollar.....ANACS...........MS63........$45.00...........$65.00
S4............1880-S.....Morgan Dollar.....ANACS...........MS63........$25.00...........$46.00
S5............1882-CC...Morgan Dollar.....ANACS..........MS62.........$95.00...........$235.00
S6............1903-O.... Morgan Dollar......ANACS..........MS63........$420.00..........$475.00
S8............1922........Peace Dollar........ANACS..........MS63.........$38.00...........$50.00
S9............1922........Peace Dollar........ANACS..........MS62.........$300.00.........$450.00 90 degree rotated dies
S10..........1884-CC...Morgan Dollar......PCGS...........MS63.........$140.00.........$225.00
S11..........1884-O.... Morgan Dollar.......PCGS...........MS65.........$75.00...........$170.00
S12..........1926-S.....Peace Dollar.........PCGS...........MS63.........$60.00...........$85.00
S13..........1935........Peace Dollar.........PCGS...........MS64.........$140.00.........$180.00
S14..........1928-S.....Peace Dollar.........PCGS...........MS63.........$280.00.........$580.00
S15..........1921........Peace Dollar.........PCGS...........MS63.........$315.00.........$415.00
S16..........1922-S.....Peace Dollar.........PCGS...........MS64.........$170.00.........$230.00
S17..........1925........Peace Dollar..........NGC............MS65.........$75.00...........$160.00
S18..........1924........Peace Dollar.........NGC.............MS64.........$35.00...........$52.50
S19..........1923........Peace Dollar.........NGC.............MS66.........$420.00.........$550.00
S20..........1926-D.....Peace Dollar.........NGC.............MS64........$200.00..........$285.00
S21..........1923........Peace Dollar..........NGC............MS65.........$140.00.........$160.00
S23..........1922........Peace Dollar..........NGC............MS66.........$420.00.........$550.00
S24..........1922........Peace Dollar..........NCS............NA.............$35.00............$20.00
S25..........1938-D.....Buffalo Nickel........ANACS........MS64..........$25.00...........$30.00
S27..........1806........Draped Bust Half....ANACS.......VG10..........$155.00.........$175.00
S28..........1806/5.....Draped Bust Half....ANACS.......VG8............$155.00.........$160.00
S29..........1916-D.....Mercury Dime.........PCI............G6..............$700.00.........$900.00
S30..........1943-D.....Mercury Dime........PCGS..........MS66..........$60.00...........$45.00
S31..........1998-S.....Kennedy Half.........PCGS..........MS69..........$430.00.........$400.00
S32..........1974-S.....Kennedy Half.........PCGS..........PR69..........$30.00............$60.00
S33..........1978-S.....Kennedy Half........PCGS...........PR68..........$20.00...........$25.00
S34..........2000-S.....Kennedy Half.........PCGS..........PR69..........$30.00...........$60.00
S35..........2000-S.....Roosevelt Diime.....PCGS..........PR69..........$18.00...........$23.00
S36..........1996-S.....Roosevelt Diime.....ICG............PR70...........$60.00...........$20.00
S37..........1854-O....Seated Liberty Half...ANACS.....AU50..........$125.00.........$270.00
S38..........2001........Silver Eagle.............PCGS.........Unc............$50.00...........$80.00
S41..........2001........Silver Eagle.............PCGS.........Unc............$50.00...........$80.00
S42..........1805........Draped Bust Quarter..ANACS...AG3............$90.00............$120.00
S43..........1833........Capped Bust Half Dime..ANACSVF35..........$40.00............$100.00
S44..........1981-S.....SBA Dollar...............ANACS.......PF67HC......$175.00.........$230.00
S46..........2000-P.....Mass Quarter..........ANACS......MS65..........$10.00...........$35.00 partial collar
S47..........1984-P.....Washington Quarter....ANACS.MS63..........$45.00...........$20.00 off center
S49..........1880-S.....Morgan Dollar............ANACS....MS65.........$110.00..........$165.00
S51..........1921........Morgan Dollar............PCGS......Circ............$26.00............$45.00 sample slab
S52..........1964........Kennedy Half Dollar...PCGS......MS.............$20.00............$20.00 sample slab
S53..........1964-D.....Roosevelt Dime.........PCGS......MS64..........$8.00.............$6.00 sample slab
S54..........1960........Roosevelt Dime..........PCGS......MS64.........$2.00..............$6.00 sample slab
S55..........1889 S.....Morgan Dollar............ANACS ...AU58..........$120.00.........$200.00
S56..........1881-CC...Morgan Dollar...........ANACS ...F12.............$300.00.........$350.00
S57..........1968........Ireland Penny............ICG........BU...............Free...............$0.00 sample slab
S58..........2001........New York Quarter.....PCGS.......BU..............$6.00.............$6.00 sample slab
S60..........1807........Draped bust half.......ANACS.... AG3.............$175.00.........$100.00
S61..........1889-CC..Morgan Dollar............ANACS....F12.............$900.00.........$900.00
S62..........1921........Peace Dollar..............ANACS....MS64...........$73.00...........$850.00
S63..........1922........Peace Dollar..............ANACS....AU55..........$9.00..............$25.00 cracked planchet
S64..........1923........Peace Dollar..............ANACS....MS62..........$9.00..............$30.00 top 50 vam
S65..........1880-CC...Morgan Dollar...........NGC........MS63..........$400.00..........$550.00
S66..........1885-CC...Morgan Dollar...........NGC........MS63..........$520.00..........$700.00
S67..........1886........Morgan Dollar...........ANACS.....MS65..........$150.00..........$165.00
S71..........1943........Walking Liberty Half..NGC........MS65..........$110.00..........$150.00
S72..........1927........Peace Dollar...............NGC.......MS63..........$115.00..........$140.00
S74..........1872........Seated Liberty Dollar..ANACS...VF35...........$350.00..........$350.00
S75..........1909-S.vdbLincoln Cent...............ANACS...F15.............$800.00..........$800.00
S77..........1875-S ....Twenty-cent piece.....ANACS....AU55............$275.00.........$350.00
S78..........1938........Walking Liberty Half...ANACS....MS64...........$30.00............$120.00
S79..........1895-O.....Morgan Dollar............ANACS....F15..............$395.00..........$395.00
S80..........1928........Peace Dollar..............ANACS....MS63............$600.00..........$650.00
S81..........1899........Morgan Dollar............ANACS....AU55............$170.00..........$200.00
S82..........1879-CC...Morgan Dollar...........ANACS.....VF20............$80.00............$100.00
S83..........1883-CC...Morgan Dollar...........ANACS.....EF45............$95.00............$115.00
S84..........1886-S.....Morgan Dollar...........ANACS.....AU53............$135.00..........$200.00
S85..........1888-S.....Morgan Dollar............ANACS....AU55............$180.00..........$250.00
S86..........1921........Peace Dollar..............ANACS....VF35.............$75.00............$120.00
S87..........1921........Peace Dollar...............ANACS...EF45.............$80.00............$140.00
S88..........1921........Peace Dollar..............ANACS....AU53.............$115.00..........$180.00
S89..........1882-CC...Morgan Dollar...........PCGS......MS64PL.........$295.00..........$295.00
0
Comments
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
Put them up for sale at those prices and see what sells.
I'm not sure that I would expect to get $3600 for a 93-s in vg10 in anacs plastic.
<< <i>S42..........1805........Draped Bust Quarter..ANACS...Unc............$90.00............$120.00 >>
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
Why not just put them all up on ebay or take to a coin show to sell? Why not go to the buy, trade forum here and try to sell them? Are these all slabbed coins that are still in the slabs?
<< <i>Why are you tryig to dump all these anyway? >>
He never implied that he is/was trying to sell these. He is just trying to put a current value on them for whatever reason. Usually they say that if you want to see what something is worth that you should try to sell it. Unless you can reach most of the market you don't really know for sure.
<< <i>You may also want to edit coin S42-
<< <i>S42..........1805........Draped Bust Quarter..ANACS...Unc............$90.00............$120.00 >>
>>
yep, thats an AG3 but I did get a good offer for it already
The reason for this post is that my wife is really on my a$$ for buying the last coin on that list today. I tried to tell her that in the long run my coin purchases were doing pretty good and that I'd likely make money IF I decided to sell. Sometimes I think I might just like to sell 'em all, pay off the car loans, and start again.
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
<< <i>Sometimes I think I might just like to sell 'em all, pay off the car loans, and start again. >>
the problem with that scenario is that unless the market tanks big time you will have a hard time replacing many of them for what you currently have in them.
There in lies the key to the answer ... however, in a slow but not studious run down of your coins, unless you have a lot of dogs and/or just "handed them over" to a buyer, I think you would probably recover all of your cost ... and might even make ~15% depending on how you sold them.
That's my WAG anyway ...
“We are only their care-takers,” he posed, “if we take good care of them, then centuries from now they may still be here … ”
Todd - BHNC #242
S4............1880-S.....Morgan Dollar.....ANACS...........MS63........$25.00...........$46.00
S5............1882-CC...Morgan Dollar.....ANACS..........MS62.........$95.00...........$235.00
>>>
I'll comment on some of the prices that I am most familiar with, prices on widget MS Morgans. These three are optimistically high.
$36 for a 1879-S ANACS 63 and 1880-S ANACS 63 is more like it, unless they are spectacularly toned. On a good day someone can get them for less than that. Most dealers probably would offer about $25 each for these two. If that is a typo and it is an 1878-S (not 79-S), that would be about $10 more in value. For the 1882 CC ANACS 62, $170-$175 is more realistic selling on Ebay, and wholesale would be about 20% less than that. Again, I am thinking about middle of the road coins, no unsightly problems, no spectacular toning.
Buying a set of Greysheet/Bluesheets might give you a better idea of wholesale (bluesheet) and retail (greysheet ask) on your coins. This costs $14 for a current set, and a person can probably can get a three month old set for less from a subscriber on BST. ANACS coins over $500 in value tend to be harder to move. If and when you get a bluesheet, you will see this reflected in the sight unseen values listed.
Someone could go through the entire list and give you a play-by-play. The perceived quality or the lack of quality for the grade can easily swing the price by 50%. This can make or break you, especially on the higher priced items. My guesstimate is that you might be about 10% ahead if you take the trouble to retail the coins via Ebay or the like, and about 15% down if you had to wholesale them to a dealer.
You're going to sell your coins and then buy pretty much the same stuff all over again? Cool! Twice as much profit for us coin dealers!
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
Coin for coin, some might be PQ for the grade and some may not be.
If you sold 'em all........in 1 shot....to one Dealer.....
I'd guess......now it's just a guess.......
........and I ain't that sophisticated.........
You might realize 10 to 15 percent.
Prices are up right now.
Pete