"Sounds like increasingly expensive coins are being sold to fewer collectors who can actually afford them. Wonder when the merry-go-round will stop"
If by "merry-go-round", you're suggesting that these expensive coins are simply being traded round and round in the short term between a bunch of rich guys, you'd be mistaken. Believe me, its one of the signs that we've been keeping watch for (which would suggest a market-top) -- but we're just NOT seeing it.
No one is more impressed (and somewhat amazed) than me by the number of six-figure (and $1mm+) coins being sold these days. All I can tell you is that based on our experience, the vast majority of these coins are being acquired by collector-investors with a healthy, longer-term approach.
Todd L. Imhof Partner / Executive VP Heritage Auctions
Great report. Sounded like a nice show and it bodes well for 2006. Regarding the following comment, how common is it for coins to trade multiple times among dealers? When that happens, doesn't the price of the coin, as it continues to trade hands, approach a retail price, and therefore make that coin a lot less marketable? What is the point of doing that?
Perhaps most impressive, telling and comforting is the absence of multiple-trades among dealers at the show. One of the biggest warning signals that the bull market is ending is when we see the same coins being traded from dealer to dealer to dealer during the same show. From everything we can tell, we think that the vast majority of coins being acquired by dealers are finding collector homes almost immediately. That is healthy.
Always took candy from strangers Didn't wanna get me no trade Never want to be like papa Working for the boss every night and day --"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
I talked with the consignor of the 1909-S IHC in 67R.
All he could say was, "Remember when you guys were laughing at me for buying that coin in Baltimore for over 40K."
Nice profit, if real.
Gone but not forgotten: IGWT, Speedy, Bear, BigE, HokieFore, John Burns, Russ, TahoeDale, Dahlonega, Astrorat, Stewart Blay, Oldhoopster, Ricko, Big Moose, Cardinal, CoinsAreFun.
"New world: old rules don't apply; if you don't get it now, it is never. The new money is the smart money!" Maybe so, but I have heard the language before. It is beginning to sound like the dot coms. Ain't always so. ( Maybe this time is the real time)
I don't know about the rest of you but I agree with the position that we have to evaluate how often a coin will be seen as opposed to a published price in some journal or rag.
The published price on a pop 1 or pop 2 coin is based usually on the last known sale(s). How can that be correct and reasonable if it hasn't been offered in years? If you need it or want it, you will have to pay whatever it takes to procure it when offered or you will be left out in the cold.
At the Morse sale in November I went with a list of 20 coins to buy and ended up buying 10 of them spending well over $1 million dollars to get coins I may never be offered again. There were so many rare coins available that there were some terrific deals. At FUN, the better coins were few and far between. Do you want a 1932 Saint in MS66? You could have bought one at Morse for $125k. You will not find one for under $150k today even if you had the money you may STILL not find one! That is a healthy market.....and why I have been so comfortable buying six figure coins....I suppose this varies depending on the series at issue but I suspect it is pretty accurate across the board as I heard other series were very strong as well....
I also agree with Gold Guy, that the more expensive coins are finding homes with the owners who will put them far away from the auctions and bourse.
A decision to put $100,000 to 500,000 in one coin(much less, over a million) is not just a passing thought. These rarities will be off the market for years, and will not appear again unless through an estate, or total change of monetary needs.
Unless it is an overpriced-non rarity, of which there may be several, and the owner gets nervous about the original buy. Examples of several lincoln cents come to mind.
We don't and won't see 1884 and 1885 Trade dollars sell frequently, or the keys in the Saints, or 1817/4 bust halves. The recent sales will probably be the last for some time.
It was not too long ago that the language in the coin world was much more cautious. We were reminded that coin prices are cyclical and that coins can be a risky investment. Collect for pleasure. Some people even remembered the last downturn in the market. I am not a bear (no offense to the real one) just reflecting on past experiences.
Hard to pick the top (or bottom) of any market. The people that get rich buy when no one else sees the rainbow. Last one in loses big.
I sold a PCGS66RD for 2600 recently. There is no justification for the 98K price. I was shocked at 40K. Guess there was a "greater fool" I think it's a lot of new collectors with a lot of money and no knowledge of historical prices. Gotta check my calendar, I think it says 1989.
Whatever the reason, it's real, for now. I just wonder if the new owners think of these as collectables to keep and cherish or like stocks to "dump" when the prices start to fall.
My thoughts echo Trime's. I'm not saying that people are trading these rare coins like kids traded baseball cards. However, you are seeing fewer and fewer people chasing increasingly expensive coins. Yes, this merry-go-round will stop.
The mentality that "price doesn't matter" sounds exactly like what I heard during the most recent stock market bubble. The pundits were saying that price / earnings ratios of individual stocks didn't matter anymore. Amazon.com was going up and up, and never made any money. Since people kept buying it, the Company was using this money from stock purchases to continue operations. Still, people kept buying it with the belief that it would always keep going up.
The whole mentality was, "better buy **** now because we won't ever see these prices again." I know the financial markets. I saw all of this and made a point of avoiding it. To refresh your memories, the S & P 500 Index dropped from 1527 in March of 2000 to 888 three years later. The NASDAQ -- where most of the tech was -- fared far worse. If I had some expensive very scarce (six figure) coins, I would have sold them by now and taken the money and run.
What I read above is so much like the stock market bubble I described. You don't think it will happen again to the coin market? If you don't, you're going to get an expensive education. "He who does not remember history is doomed to repeat it."
"Vou invadir o Nordeste, "Seu cabra da peste, "Sou Mangueira......."
Elcontador: I agree with much of what you're saying. I certainly agree with the gist. However, your premise is wrong:
"However, you are seeing fewer and fewer people chasing increasingly expensive coins. Yes, this merry-go-round will stop."
I can only speak for Pinnacle. But based on our experience, it is MORE and MORE people chasing expensive coins -- not "fewer". Hence the seemingly strong prices. Moreover, I still don't understand your "merry-go-round" analogy.
"What I read above is so much like the stock market bubble I described"
Notwithstanding the fact that I dislike comparisions between numismatics and stocks, I haven't heard or read anything where someone is suggesting that the coin market is just going to keep going up and up forever. Further, I believe most dealers, collectors and investors DO learn from history. I'm as surprised as anyone, but I'm simply not seeing the kind of scenario or warning signs that suggest a market top. An ultra rare 1885 Trade dollar doubling in value over a couple years is NOT the same thing as if common 1881-S MS65 Morgan dollars all jump from $100 to $350.
(Edited for a couple typo's)
Todd L. Imhof Partner / Executive VP Heritage Auctions
This market is wild. Even in my tiny little world there has been some very strong money jumping on coins, and it seems to be coming from a wide variety of collectors. Case in point:
In the Spring of last year I sold a PCGS graded PR68CAM Accented Hair for $800. The coin just sold on Heritage yesterday for $1840 with the juice. This is happening with increasing frequency.
Edited to add: That comes on the heels of Heritage selling another at $1610.
Heck, I didn't even know PCGS graded that kind of coin! I'm apparently missing something. Please call me for an employment application ASAP. In fact, forget the application. Can you start tomorrow?
Todd L. Imhof Partner / Executive VP Heritage Auctions
I have to bag this law stuff and go into a new profession. Do you know how long I have to work to make that amount of scratch?
Always took candy from strangers Didn't wanna get me no trade Never want to be like papa Working for the boss every night and day --"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
Fortunately or unfortunately, Pinnacle sells plenty of stuff I never see. But the fact you can get $3K for a coin that my firm can only get $500 for means that I need you to start even sooner!
Todd L. Imhof Partner / Executive VP Heritage Auctions
<< <i>But the fact you can get $3K for a coin that my firm can only get $500 for means that I need you to start even sooner! >>
Truth is, that's not a fair comparison. You guys listed it in April of last year when market values were around $800. I'm known for selling this type of material, so I have a bidder base frequenting my auctions that wouldn't necessarily be checking Pinnacle.
In addition, while values have accelerated since then - as evidenced by the two most recent Heritage sales - my sale at $3150 is a fluke. It's a case of two bidders who got caught up in the moment and drove the realized price way beyond what it should have been. I seriously doubt the coin will stick.
A 1909 s VDB sold for $97,750.It was not a 1909 s.This was actually a good deal because it was better than the Mershon example which brought $92,000 in April 2005 and also clearly better than the example that brought $77,000 at the San Francisco ANA.
Stewart, Their show report was referring to Lot #3074 in last week's Heritage Sale. Please correct me if I'm wrong, but my records indicate that this coin was a 1909-S Indian Cent and it realized $97,750.
We're both correct.A 1909 s VDB in ms 67 red AND a 1909 s Indian in ms 67 red sold for $97,750.His 1909s Lincoln in ms 67 red sold at Superior Gallery auctions for $37,000. BTW I was the punter who bought the finest 1901 s dime for $23,000.I was not prepared to stop bidding.
<< <i>Russ showed you that he doesn't need an expensive booth and fancy marketing to get his share of the sucker money that's out there. >>
That's interesting. You said the same thing in the thread I posted about Pinnacle's Accented Hair listing back in April of last year. That was about the time a "sucker" bought one from me for $800. That "sucker" just doubled his money selling it through Heritage.
Todd, I am amazed how Pinnacle has risen to the top tier of dealers in just a few years and I applaud you for the way you do business and the expertise that you and Doug have to offer
pinnacle has been on top more than a few years you just never hear about it nor does pinnacle make a loud noise about it
pinnacle is not a loud talker in the coin game
they sell many huge great coins for BIG money but they usually do not brag or boast about it or advertise it
they have put together some sets of coins thaT are into the $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ of dollars
My primary focus for over a decade has benn Morgan DMPLs. Truly great ones have been drying up in inventories and auction offerings. FUN '06 exhibited a continuation of that. FUN '05 brought a major collection of them out to the auction block, from which I bought two highly important pieces for my own set. Not this year though. DMPL-wise, the bourse was sterile. So, I went on to cherrypick VAMs. Emptied my wallet in the first couple hours of the first day doing that.
Sellers were approachable and accommodating. Didn't have to wait for a seat most of the time for most dealers, though business was still darn good apparently.
Platinum night was packed. Most were probably there for the free food and to watch the neat coins sell, as only a handful of bidders were waving their signs. I could not believe the prices the Lincolns were getting. I know one of the big bidders on them too and he is no dummy newbie at all. Serious prices were coming in for very serious collector coins.
Talked with a handful of currency guys while waiting for lot pickup on Sunday morning. They seemed as hopped up as much as any gold collector has been. Wherever we are in the cycle, a lot of collectors are simply having a lot of fun right now. Dealers are too.
<< <i>I could not believe the prices the Lincolns were getting. I know one of the big bidders on them too and he is no dummy newbie at all. >>
Jack Lee. Stewart was over in the registry forum whining about him.
Even with the wild prices Lincolns have been bringing one would have to think there's still some upside when a sharp cookie like him is grabbing them by the fistful.
Yes, I was referring to Jack Lee. He is known for discriminating quality, but I was scratching my head on a few of those. I sold a number of such pieces on the back channel recently enough for significantly less money (that were unmistakenly full red). Will be interesting to see his final set.
Comments
PLOP!
Wonder when the merry-go-round will stop.
"Seu cabra da peste,
"Sou Mangueira......."
If by "merry-go-round", you're suggesting that these expensive coins are simply being traded round and round in the short term between a bunch of rich guys, you'd be mistaken. Believe me, its one of the signs that we've been keeping watch for (which would suggest a market-top) -- but we're just NOT seeing it.
No one is more impressed (and somewhat amazed) than me by the number of six-figure (and $1mm+) coins being sold these days. All I can tell you is that based on our experience, the vast majority of these coins are being acquired by collector-investors with a healthy, longer-term approach.
Partner / Executive VP
Heritage Auctions
Perhaps most impressive, telling and comforting is the absence of multiple-trades among dealers at the show. One of the biggest warning signals that the bull market is ending is when we see the same coins being traded from dealer to dealer to dealer during the same show. From everything we can tell, we think that the vast majority of coins being acquired by dealers are finding collector homes almost immediately. That is healthy.
Didn't wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
--"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
All he could say was, "Remember when you guys were laughing at me for buying that coin in Baltimore for over 40K."
Nice profit, if real.
"New world: old rules don't apply; if you don't get it now, it is never.
The new money is the smart money!"
Maybe so, but I have heard the language before.
It is beginning to sound like the dot coms.
Ain't always so. ( Maybe this time is the real time)
The published price on a pop 1 or pop 2 coin is based usually on the last known sale(s). How can that be correct and reasonable if it hasn't been offered in years? If you need it or want it, you will have to pay whatever it takes to procure it when offered or you will be left out in the cold.
At the Morse sale in November I went with a list of 20 coins to buy and ended up buying 10 of them spending well over $1 million dollars to get coins I may never be offered again. There were so many rare coins available that there were some terrific deals. At FUN, the better coins were few and far between. Do you want a 1932 Saint in MS66? You could have bought one at Morse for $125k. You will not find one for under $150k today even if you had the money you may STILL not find one! That is a healthy market.....and why I have been so comfortable buying six figure coins....I suppose this varies depending on the series at issue but I suspect it is pretty accurate across the board as I heard other series were very strong as well....
$20 Saint Gaudens Registry Set
A decision to put $100,000 to 500,000 in one coin(much less, over a million) is not just a passing thought. These rarities will be off the market for years, and will not appear again unless through an estate, or total change of monetary needs.
Unless it is an overpriced-non rarity, of which there may be several, and the owner gets nervous about the original buy. Examples of several lincoln cents come to mind.
We don't and won't see 1884 and 1885 Trade dollars sell frequently, or the keys in the Saints, or 1817/4 bust halves. The recent sales will probably be the last for some time.
At least, I hope this will be true.
We were reminded that coin prices are cyclical and that
coins can be a risky investment. Collect for pleasure.
Some people even remembered the last downturn in the market.
I am not a bear (no offense to the real one) just reflecting on past experiences.
Hard to pick the top (or bottom) of any market.
The people that get rich buy when no one else sees the rainbow.
Last one in loses big.
"It's not over until its over!"
thank you
<< <i>$97,750 for a 1909s 67 red IHC >>
I sold a PCGS66RD for 2600 recently. There is no justification for the 98K price. I was shocked at 40K. Guess there was a "greater fool"
I think it's a lot of new collectors with a lot of money and no knowledge of historical prices. Gotta check my calendar, I think it says 1989.
Whatever the reason, it's real, for now. I just wonder if the new owners think of these as collectables to keep and cherish or like stocks to "dump" when the prices start to fall.
The mentality that "price doesn't matter" sounds exactly like what I heard during the most recent stock market bubble. The pundits were saying that price / earnings ratios of individual stocks didn't matter anymore. Amazon.com was going up and up, and never made any money. Since people kept buying it, the Company was using this money from stock purchases to continue operations. Still, people kept buying it with the belief that it would always keep going up.
The whole mentality was, "better buy **** now because we won't ever see these prices again." I know the financial markets. I saw all of this and made a point of avoiding it. To refresh your memories, the S & P 500 Index dropped from 1527 in March of 2000 to 888 three years later. The NASDAQ -- where most of the tech was -- fared far worse. If I had some expensive very scarce (six figure) coins, I would have sold them by now and taken the money and run.
What I read above is so much like the stock market bubble I described. You don't think it will happen again to the coin market? If you don't, you're going to get an expensive education. "He who does not remember history is doomed to repeat it."
"Seu cabra da peste,
"Sou Mangueira......."
"However, you are seeing fewer and fewer people chasing increasingly expensive coins. Yes, this merry-go-round will stop."
I can only speak for Pinnacle. But based on our experience, it is MORE and MORE people chasing expensive coins -- not "fewer". Hence the seemingly strong prices. Moreover, I still don't understand your "merry-go-round" analogy.
"What I read above is so much like the stock market bubble I described"
Notwithstanding the fact that I dislike comparisions between numismatics and stocks, I haven't heard or read anything where someone is suggesting that the coin market is just going to keep going up and up forever. Further, I believe most dealers, collectors and investors DO learn from history. I'm as surprised as anyone, but I'm simply not seeing the kind of scenario or warning signs that suggest a market top. An ultra rare 1885 Trade dollar doubling in value over a couple years is NOT the same thing as if common 1881-S MS65 Morgan dollars all jump from $100 to $350.
(Edited for a couple typo's)
Partner / Executive VP
Heritage Auctions
In the Spring of last year I sold a PCGS graded PR68CAM Accented Hair for $800. The coin just sold on Heritage yesterday for $1840 with the juice. This is happening with increasing frequency.
Edited to add: That comes on the heels of Heritage selling another at $1610.
Russ, NCNE
OK. I take back everything I said previously. Clearly, the coin market has reached a peak that makes the dot-bomb bubble look understandable.
Partner / Executive VP
Heritage Auctions
<< <i>". . . sold a PCGS graded PR68CAM Accented Hair for $800. The coin just sold on Heritage yesterday for $1840 with the juice."
OK. I take back everything I said previously. Clearly, the coin market has reached a peak that makes the dot-bomb bubble look understandable. >>
If you want to really get worried, how about one that closed Sunday at $3150?
Russ, NCNE
Please call me for an employment application ASAP. In fact, forget the application. Can you start tomorrow?
Partner / Executive VP
Heritage Auctions
<< <i>Heck, I didn't even know PCGS graded that kind of coin! >>
Pinnacle listed one on eBay a while back.
(BTW, I think it went for around $500).
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>". . . sold a PCGS graded PR68CAM Accented Hair for $800. The coin just sold on Heritage yesterday for $1840 with the juice."
OK. I take back everything I said previously. Clearly, the coin market has reached a peak that makes the dot-bomb bubble look understandable. >>
If you want to really get worried, how about one that closed Sunday at $3150?
Russ, NCNE >>
I have to bag this law stuff and go into a new profession. Do you know how long I have to work to make that amount of scratch?
Didn't wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
--"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
Russ, NCNE
Russ, NCNE
wont sell me one. She refuses to take my
jellydonuts in payment.
Camelot
But the fact you can get $3K for a coin that my firm can only get $500 for means that I need you to start even sooner!
Partner / Executive VP
Heritage Auctions
<< <i>But the fact you can get $3K for a coin that my firm can only get $500 for means that I need you to start even sooner! >>
Truth is, that's not a fair comparison. You guys listed it in April of last year when market values were around $800. I'm known for selling this type of material, so I have a bidder base frequenting my auctions that wouldn't necessarily be checking Pinnacle.
In addition, while values have accelerated since then - as evidenced by the two most recent Heritage sales - my sale at $3150 is a fluke. It's a case of two bidders who got caught up in the moment and drove the realized price way beyond what it should have been. I seriously doubt the coin will stick.
Russ, NCNE
A 1909 s VDB sold for $97,750.It was not a 1909 s.This was actually a good deal because it was better than the Mershon example which brought $92,000 in April 2005 and also clearly better than the example that brought $77,000 at the San Francisco ANA.
Stewart
Russ, you are hurting your negotiating position. Heretofore, I will act as your agent.
Their show report was referring to Lot #3074 in last week's Heritage Sale. Please correct me if I'm wrong, but my records indicate that this coin was a 1909-S Indian Cent and it realized $97,750.
Thanks for the explanation Russ. You're fired!
Partner / Executive VP
Heritage Auctions
We're both correct.A 1909 s VDB in ms 67 red AND a 1909 s Indian in ms 67 red sold for $97,750.His 1909s Lincoln in ms 67 red sold at Superior Gallery auctions for $37,000.
BTW I was the punter who bought the finest 1901 s dime for $23,000.I was not prepared to stop bidding.
Stewart
Russ showed you that he doesn't need an expensive booth and fancy marketing to get his share of the sucker money that's out there.
<< <i>Russ showed you that he doesn't need an expensive booth and fancy marketing to get his share of the sucker money that's out there. >>
That's interesting. You said the same thing in the thread I posted about Pinnacle's Accented Hair listing back in April of last year. That was about the time a "sucker" bought one from me for $800. That "sucker" just doubled his money selling it through Heritage.
Who's really the sucker here?
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>". . . sold a PCGS graded PR68CAM Accented Hair for $800. The coin just sold on Heritage yesterday for $1840 with the juice."
OK. I take back everything I said previously. Clearly, the coin market has reached a peak that makes the dot-bomb bubble look understandable. >>
If you want to really get worried, how about one that closed Sunday at $3150?
Russ, NCNE >>
Cha-Ching!! Nice Windfall there!
<< <i>Who's really the sucker here? >>
The one left holding when the bottom drops.
This is the PCGS Forum so we can't BOTH be correct. Therefore, I'm right and you're wrong!
Partner / Executive VP
Heritage Auctions
pinnacle has been on top more than a few years you just never hear about it nor does pinnacle make a loud noise about it
pinnacle is not a loud talker in the coin game
they sell many huge great coins for BIG money but they usually do not brag or boast about it or advertise it
they have put together some sets of coins thaT are into the $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ of dollars
again they do not publicise this
pinnacle just does it with little to no fanfair
My primary focus for over a decade has benn Morgan DMPLs. Truly great ones have been drying up in inventories and auction offerings. FUN '06 exhibited a continuation of that. FUN '05 brought a major collection of them out to the auction block, from which I bought two highly important pieces for my own set. Not this year though. DMPL-wise, the bourse was sterile. So, I went on to cherrypick VAMs. Emptied my wallet in the first couple hours of the first day doing that.
Sellers were approachable and accommodating. Didn't have to wait for a seat most of the time for most dealers, though business was still darn good apparently.
Platinum night was packed. Most were probably there for the free food and to watch the neat coins sell, as only a handful of bidders were waving their signs. I could not believe the prices the Lincolns were getting. I know one of the big bidders on them too and he is no dummy newbie at all. Serious prices were coming in for very serious collector coins.
Talked with a handful of currency guys while waiting for lot pickup on Sunday morning. They seemed as hopped up as much as any gold collector has been. Wherever we are in the cycle, a lot of collectors are simply having a lot of fun right now. Dealers are too.
NSDR - Life Member
SSDC - Life Member
ANA - Pay As I Go Member
<< <i>So long as people are buying for the right reasons-to hold long term, they will do well-even if the end of the cycle is near >>
Is that guaranteed?
<< <i>I could not believe the prices the Lincolns were getting. I know one of the big bidders on them too and he is no dummy newbie at all. >>
Jack Lee. Stewart was over in the registry forum whining about him.
Even with the wild prices Lincolns have been bringing one would have to think there's still some upside when a sharp cookie like him is grabbing them by the fistful.
Russ, NCNE
NSDR - Life Member
SSDC - Life Member
ANA - Pay As I Go Member